iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Obama Should Have Thanked India

What's Your Reaction:

Speaking of the American-Indian relationship, President Obama predicted it would be "one of the defining partnerships of the twenty-first century." No doubt it will be. But in fact, our two nations have been trading partners of sorts for more than two centuries, and Americans have derived far more from the arrangement than they realize.

As the land of material discovery and innovation, the U.S. has given India advantages from electric lighting to computer technology, not to mention the inventions that made Bollywood a larger producer of movies than Hollywood. What we've imported in return is far more subtle, but perhaps even more profound. Ages ago, the vast subcontinent birthed explorers and innovators who focused on the inner realm. Those geniuses -- spiritual sages or scientists of consciousness, depending on your perspective -- gave us, through a series of modern translators and adapters, insights that have profoundly influenced religion, healthcare, psychology, the arts and other areas of life. The way we understand ourselves and the universe has been shaped by India more than we can readily appreciate.

It began when early translations of Hindu and Buddhist texts, along with scholarly commentaries, arrived from Europe and found their way to Ralph Waldo Emerson. The philosopher who has been called our "founding thinker" absorbed Indian philosophy with the gusto of a gourmand sampling savory curries for the first time. It helped to shape the Emersonian world-view, which gave rise to process philosophy and American pragmatism, as well as to a literary tradition so pervasive that Yale's Harold Bloom called the Sage of Concord "the mind of America." Anyone who reads Emerson, whether a high school student for an assignment or an adult for illumination, gets a dose of Indian philosophy, whether or not he or she realizes it.

The same can be said of anyone who reads Henry David Thoreau or Walt Whitman. The Bhagavad Gita that Thoreau borrowed from his mentor, Emerson, was his constant companion on Walden Pond. When Obama noted the debt that America owes to Mahatma Gandhi for his immense influence on Martin Luther King, he left out the initial phase of that great U.S.-India volley: Thoreau, who called the Vedas "the royal road for the attainment of Great Knowledge," was one of Gandhi's inspirations. Whitman too was touched by India's "deep diving bibles and legends" and "far-darting beams of the spirit," and poets from Emily Dickinson to Bob Dylan were all touched by our national bard.

That was just the beginning. The pioneers of the so-called New Thought movement drank deeply of Eastern ideas, giving rise to Theosophy, Unity Church, Science of Mind and other institutions that became spiritual homes to an army of seekers. Later, the swamis of the Vedanta Society tutored men whose collective impact on the culture has been incalculable: the British expatriates Gerald Heard, Christopher Isherwood and Aldous Huxley; the comparative mythologist Joseph Campbell; Huston Smith, the most influential religious scholar of the past fifty years; and J.D. Salinger, whose later works taught Eastern Philosophy 101 in fictional form.

Come 1968, the Indian tsunami triggered by the Beatles' now-legendary visit to the ashram of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi gave us far more than The White Album (as if that weren't enough). Over a million people learned Transcendental Meditation, while scientists began the enterprise that has since produced over a thousand experiments on meditative practices. Seminal books like Autobiography of a Yogi by Paramahansa Yogananda and Be Here Now by Ram Dass (nee Richard Alpert) were devoured. Youngsters who studied with gurus went on to become scholars who taught religion in a new way, enlarged the study of psychology to encompass the spiritual dimension, introduced new methods to psychotherapy and began to rethink the nature of consciousness. Self-help authors like John Gray of Men Are from Mars fame adapted Eastern ideas to books and seminars. Popular thinkers like Deepak Chopra and Ken Wilber integrated them into books that appeal as much to secular types as to spiritual seekers. Medical experts like Dean Ornish incorporated yogic teachings into mainstream health practices. And the trickle of Americans going to yoga classes became a mighty river that's now fifteen to twenty million strong.

If you think these are minor phenomena compared to the economic and geopolitical issues discussed by Obama and Indian leaders, consider how many healthcare dollars are saved when people practice meditation and yoga instead of buying drugs and undergoing surgery. More important, India's philosophy of Vedanta and the methodologies of Yoga gave the land of the free a rational, pragmatic, individuated way to conceive of spirituality. And more important still, consider what India's ancient pluralism -- embodied in the Vedic maxim, "Truth is one, the wise call it by different names" -- offers a modern world torn by religious and ethnic tension. Half a century ago, the great historian Arnold Toynbee wrote that India's spiritual legacy offers us "the attitude and the spirit that can make it possible for the human race to grow together into a single family -- and, in the Atomic Age, this is the only alternative to destroying ourselves." For all these gifts, both manifest and yet to be realized, Obama should have offered his partner a sincere "Namaste."

 
 
 
Speaking of the American-Indian relationship, President Obama predicted it would be "one of the defining partnerships of the twenty-first century." No doubt it will be. But in fact, our two nations ...
Speaking of the American-Indian relationship, President Obama predicted it would be "one of the defining partnerships of the twenty-first century." No doubt it will be. But in fact, our two nations ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:00 PM on 12/20/2010
Great article!! I would like to add...

decimal numbers - 0123456789 - !! zero and infinity !!
mathematics - algebra, infinite series etc

These contributions are never mentioned in our textbooks and our children are deliberately kept in the dark and grow up with prejudice "West is rational and East is not" etc.
07:48 PM on 11/11/2010
It has been said that over the last couple of thousand years the incredible things that humans have acheived in terms of Conciousness in India is mindboggling. The incredible experiences, could never be taught to everyone, but only experienced by yogis.

I hope the world can learn from India that humans have to come out of this religious ideologies, and start looking within themselves - Know Thyself! Namaskar!
photo
Keith DeBoer
Meditation Teacher
02:11 PM on 11/11/2010
We owe a great debt to India. All nations do. Its heritage is great and India has positively influenced many cultures, more than we even know. For example the ancient Vedic tradition of India is the oldest continuous tradition of knowledge on earth and in 2003 it was recognized by UNESCO as a masterpiece of heritage to humanity. Good article.
11:31 AM on 11/13/2010
Perhaps President Obama had this in mind as well, the great spiritual heritage of India and that may explain why he was caught off guard when the Indian students asked him very tough and pointed questions about Pakistan and Jihad. That seems to be what's on the mind of India today, as they are very aware of it's extremely hostile borders and working very hard to compete on the world stage after so many years of being behind due to failed govt policies. This new India has only been around for 15 years, and look what they have accomplished in such a short time.
11:14 AM on 11/10/2010
http://www.globalgoodnews.com/government-news-a.html?art=12893246351327328

of the > 1000 studies about benefits from meditation > 600 studies [ 358 published in peeer reviewed journals ] are specifically using the unique an d uniquely effective Transcendental Meditation(TM)

in December 2008 ,that glorious month of transsition, i wrote to whitehouse.gov " fund a group of 8 000 yogic flyers with an endowment fund of $ 1 000 000 000 which will measurbaly result in world peace , world health world harmony "

[Emerson ,Thoreau , Whitman , Einstein {unified field}, Mahatma Gandhi + TAO] actualized in every brain]

[the 2.3 TRILLION dollar sickness bil would be reduced by ~$ 1000 000 000 000 , the $ 400 000 000 000 crime bill would be reduced by 23% , provable realities]

while Obama and ChingTao are the 2 most powerful men on the planet; Professor John Hagelin is th emost important man on the planet

power has not and cannot create peace ;only just releif from stress , liberation from bondage to ignorance , results in peace [[[ and ignorance does not just mean uneducated it also means educated ]]

http://www.dlfprojects.org/met/

its important to emphasize that meditation (TM) is spirituality ; drugs are not ; Meditation improves the brain ,;drugs are disaster for the brain

religion is halfway between

His Holiness Maharishi Mahesh Yogi ,a year before 1968, made the Beatles promise to stop using drugs

see top 100 studies at tm.org
09:41 AM on 11/10/2010
Gee, while it'a all groovy and swell that we take an aging boomers trip down spiritual memory lane with Gurus, Gita, and Indian Spiritualy, but what gets lost each and every time are the true reasons why Obama or for that matter all Americans should thank India and that is her immigrants who come to live and stay in America. Their contributions to our society on all levels are quite substantial and reach out throughout the culture not just from a western seekers perspective. Why this always alludes the Mantra crowd is beyond me. Thank you for living and thriving here, you have made this country richer, yes spiritually but also as good and gracious citizens.
11:40 AM on 11/10/2010
this is all true, stevemax, from the most superficial perspective only. why do you say your thoughts elude the "mantra crowd?" what you say is most obvious to everyone. what goldberg is saying is just way more subtle.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Philip Goldberg
Philip Goldberg is a writer, public speaker and in
02:30 PM on 11/10/2010
You're very right about the presence of Indian Americans who have enriched our country tremendously. But why you express it in a critical way is beyond me. It hasn't eluded Americans who value India's spiritual heritage at all. Anyway, it's a different topic from the one I chose to write about, and you can't say everything in one blog.
07:26 PM on 11/10/2010
Fair enough Philip, I look forward to perhaps a future blog or post on Indian Americans. Are you familiar with TiE? The Indus Entrepreneurs org - http://sv.tie.org/homepage? They are the largest not for profit org. for entrepreneurs and their largest US chapter is in the Silicon Valley. They have transformed Silicon Valley and the IT world with it's pool of talent and innovation (mostly from India), please make special note of famed venture capitalist ,Vinod Kholsa. He was a co -founder of Sun Microsystems and is on th leading (bleeding) edge of the clean energy venture movement. He would make a great interview and I believe he came here from India when he was 19.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanneyogini
07:24 AM on 11/10/2010
Great article Phil! It reminds of the first time I stumbled upon the Bhagavad Gita and Upanishads as at teenager and how it opened up a whole new world of insight and answers to deep probing questions I had about life and spirituality—questions that western philosophy and religions had not satisfied. I think Americans have embraced aspects of India's traditions because they recognize the universal truth contained in them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:20 AM on 11/10/2010
really great article, phil. you're making a valuable contribution yourself. keep it up! very important work. jai guru dev.
10:01 PM on 11/09/2010
This article should have mentioned Swami Vivekananda, The greatest Indian ever to visit the United States. He came to Chicago in 1893 as a poor wandering monk with no credentials to attend the World Parliament of Religions. He became an instant celebrity. He is the first person to bring the ancient wisdom of the Vedas and deliver it to the people of The United States in English. He is also the founder of the Vedanta Society. His work is no doubt great. But even greater is the ease with which America embraced him and his eastern philosophy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:19 AM on 11/10/2010
"Swami Vivekananda, The greatest Indian ever..."

Vivekanada made a cherished contribution. to claim that he was the greatest Indian to visit the US is certainly a personal perception worthy of respect, but it implies a comparison with Yogananda and Maharishi. V helped pave the way for Yogananda, whose influence was arguably greater than V's, and Maharishi's influence far greater than his predecessors. who was the greatest is a subjective assessment. Maharishi himself always attributed all glory not to himself but to the tradition of Vedic masters.

James Clarke Maxwell formulated the electromagnetic field, a great achievement. subsequent generations of physicists (Wheeler et al) worked to unify the electromagnetic field with the other fundamental forces, and Nobel prizes were in physics were awarded for this further unification. now physicists are working to unite all these forces with gravity. none of it could have been done without Maxwell, but more significant unification would come later. would one say Maxwell was the greatest physicist? someone might, but...

V played his indispensable role, and perhaps he's had more of an influence on your life personally and that's why you say he was the greatest. many others would say the same about Y or M.

i think Maharishi will be recognized, among other things, for reviving the technique of effortless transcending (TM) and systematizing the teaching of it to preserve its effectiveness for future generations — and for establishing meditation and enlightenment on the ground of objectively verifiable knowledge.
12:17 PM on 11/10/2010
Swami Vivekananda was a God realized soul. He is considered to be one of the seven sages. He was manifested by his Guru Paramahamsa Ramakrishna who is considered an incarnation of God. I do not know much about Yogananda or Maharishi of TM fame. So I cannot compare their lives. V's work on Raja Yoga is considered a classic and perhaps laid the foundation for later day monks and gurus to learn and teach meditation. James Maxwell unified electricity and magnetism. Einstein used Maxwell's field theory and applied to gravitation. So Maxwell is the original pioneer for all of physics that we now know. Unified field theory, quantum mechanics, entanglement and consciousness have all their foundations in non-dualism, the principle of Advaita.
08:48 AM on 11/10/2010
I think Monkey's comparison to physicists is apt.

Vedic knowledge is all about unification. The word Yoga itself means 'union' or the state of unified awareness.

Interesting that during Maharishi's lifetime, while he was about in the world speaking of the ultimate unity of existence -- the underlying, transcendental field that unites all diversity -- progress in theoretical physics took unprecedented strides toward unification of the 4 forces.

One of the physicists on the Nobel team that accomplished grand unification was John Hagelin, who worked with Maharishi for decades. Hagelin developed a highly successful superstring theory that's still a major element in the architecture of superunification in quantum field theory.

Under Maharishi's guidance, Hagelin took unified field theory much further than his colleagues by declaring that the fundamental force underlying all matter, now glimpsed by modern physics, is actually the field of transcendental consciousness. This blew the minds of many physicists but the concept is graining more ground. Even Nobel physics Laureate Brian Josephson is suggesting that the unified field is actually consciousness.

My point: historically these great Vedic masters came along and increasingly enlivened unity in the collective consciousness of the West by drawing more and more attention to the Transcendent. Coinciding with that subtle shift toward unity in collective consciousness, the scientific model of nature was also becoming increasingly unified.

Experientially awakening the Transcendent in the consciousness of the West maybe the only way to unite the world in peace. That will be India's greatest gift.
04:25 PM on 11/09/2010
Wow - what a great article. Intelligent, coherent and completely right on the mark. Thank you Mr. Goldberg. Thank you India. I'm one the the millions who've learned TM (and I love it and it's completely bettered my life in many, many ways), I've read the Gita, Emerson, Thoreau and Whitman and really hadn't 'seen' the connection until his article pulled it all together (with a big "DUH") - perfectly in much the same way the holistic, pragmatic way that the Vedic maxim, "Truth is one, the wise call it by different names" does. Again, thank you, thank you India! There's hope... ;)
03:51 PM on 11/09/2010
A very nice article.

:) Vakibs
"The Bhagavad Gita that Thoreau borrowed from his mentor, Emerson, was his constant companion on Walden Pond."

One should thank and respect each other without an ego. Indian constitution is not based on a particular country. It was taken from many countries and Indians thank each of them. Indian even thank any guest for visiting the country with a happy smile and true heart.
01:07 PM on 11/09/2010
It is true that Thoreau was one of the most important influences of Gandhi. Sad that Obama has let an opportunity slip by to make that reference. The very words "civil disobedience" were coined by Thoreau. Without him, there would be no Indian independence movement as we know it.

Obama however made the connection between Indian and American constitutions. Dr. Ambedkar who penned the Indian constitution has spent considerable amount of time in the USA and was greatly influenced by the US constitution.

So India owes the USA a lot too - not just in the materialistic front but also in the realm of spirituality and ideas.