03/27/2009 05:12 am ET | Updated May 25, 2011

Obama Admin. On Detention Policy: "What He Said"

by Christopher Weaver, ProPublica

This Court's Order of January 22, 2009 invited the Government to inform the Court by February 20, 2009, whether it intends to refine its position on whether the Court has jurisdiction over habeas petitions filed by detainees held at the United States military base in Bagram, Afghanistan. Having considered the matter, the Government adheres to its previously articulated position.

The stance

The decision also reaffirms the fears of human rights activists and civil rights lawyers who worry that the new administration's review of terrorism policies will lead to changes only in rhetoric.

Obama signed two executive orders on his second day in office, pledging to close Gitmo's prison within a year and banning torture. But the orders didn't address the broader questions of detention policy that have left the four Bagram prisoners behind bars for years, without due process.

The men are

Observers weren't surprised that the Obama administration hasn't developed a sweeping new policy on combating terrorism in the brief period allotted by the court. Jack Balkin, a Yale law professor, told
the New York Times
, "It may take some time before we see exactly what is going on -- whether this is just a transitory policy or whether this is really their policy."

However, compared to the tone set by Obama during his campaign, others found room for disappointment. "At a minimum, we were expecting that the Obama administration would say that they are still considering their position and whether or not to change course,"
Tina Foster, a lawyer for the Bagram detainees, told us.

"It's one thing to say that we're going to close Guantanamo in a year," said Foster. "It's another to say that we're going to close Guantanamo, but we're not going to change any of our policies on holding people without charges and denying them access to courts."

ProPublica is America's largest investigative newsroom.

Subscribe to the Politics email.
How will Trump’s administration impact you?