iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rabbi Shmuley Boteach

GET UPDATES FROM Rabbi Shmuley Boteach
 

The Republican Primary Trifecta of Abortion, Contraception and Gay Marriage

Posted: 02/23/2012 8:32 am

The Republican party has been dominated of late by a discussion of the sexual trifecta of gay marriage, abortion, and contraception. But are these the only values that matter?

America lives with the profound contradiction of a nation that is at once incredibly religious but increasingly decadent. In the United States 92% of Americans believe in G-d. But given the deep spiritual orientation of the American people, how are we to understand the even deeper materialistic impulses that had us spending $52.4 billion on Black Friday weekend shopping alone? And given the American people's strong disposition to family, what could account for the inability of approximately one in two couples to stay married?

Every four years the presidential election cycle lends a glimpse as to the answer, and we saw it the past few weeks especially. It lies with the American religious obsession with gay marriage and abortion to the exclusion of all other values. Yes, America is a religious nation but it is one whose religious convictions have been hijacked by sexual morality issues that have dominated the political landscape for decades.

While approximately seven percent of the American population is gay, more than fifty percent of all marriages end in divorce. And this was happening years before gays came out in significant number, let alone demanded the right to marry. In fact, gays seem to be the only men in America who are still passionate about marriage. While 74% of heterosexual couples choose to live together before marriage and a Pew Research poll recently found that the average age for an American straight man to marry has climbed to 30 from 23 in the 1950's, homosexual men are marching in the streets and petitioning the United States Supreme Court for the right to tie the knot.

Straight people don't need help from gays to destroy the institution of marriage, having a done a mighty fine job of it ourselves, thank you very much. And rather than pastors pushing real policies that might stem the tide of divorce -- like making marital counseling tax-deductible so that couples can afford the help they need -- we have instead chosen a repeated distraction.

In 1999 I published Kosher Sex which, although it became a best-seller, was instantly pilloried by Jewish and Christian clerics for the explicit erotic advice offered as to how to make the marital bedroom passionate again. Yet the number one cause of divorce in America is erotic disinterest and sexual boredom, with the Washington Post reporting that one out of three American couples is entirely platonic. Were pastors more willing to teach, say, the Song of Solomon, with its deep erotic secrets, rather than obsessing over gay marriage, millions of American children might not end up as yo-yos shuffling between parents' homes on weekends.

In 2008 the American economy nearly collapsed due to avaricious bankers and insatiable consumers whose homes were never big enough and cars never new enough. If ever there was a time where American religious and political leaders could engage in a national conversation about materialism, gluttony, and greed, it was then. But my Evangelical brothers responded not with a conversation about filling one's inner void with spiritual purpose but with Proposition 8, a national campaign to overturn gay marriage in California.

Abortion has also become a major distraction ignoring the values that underlie it. Ninety-nine percent of all abortions are single women who have been impregnated by men in an out-of-wedlock relationships. Yet where is the national conversation on the part of pastors about a culture that degrades woman and portrays them as the libidinous man's plaything, which is responsible for the high rate of abortion in the first place?

Tim Tebow is pilloried for the unseemly act of prayer in the secular cathedral of the stadium. But women jumping up and down in lycra to the accompaniment of pompoms and cleavage creates no offense. From the 4.2 million porn websites in the United States, to the female recording industry becoming soft porn itself, to wafer-thin models on magazine covers indirectly affecting 7 percent of all American girls with eating disorders, the dream of women being appreciated as much for the their brains as for their bust is being strongly undermined. Yet we see no push to mandate school uniforms that would inculcate the value of modesty and respect for the body among teenagers at America's public schools. In the African-American community nearly seventy percent of all marriages are out-of-wedlock births resulting in single mothers raising children on their own. But aside from Bill Cosby's courageous speeches on the subject, pastors largely ignore men's obligations to their children in favor of the Supreme Court's obligation to the unborn.

Then there is our growing narcissism. While two percent of the American population protect our freedom in the military, the remainder do scant public service. In a recent survey, when asked what they wished to do when they grew up seventy-eight percent of high school students responded, "Be famous." Yet even as our self-centeredness grows, pastors have yet to advocate a year of national service, prior to college, the discussion of life-at-conception all but muting any discussion about life-with-purpose.

Shmuley Boteach, 'America's Rabbi,' was the London Times Preacher of the Year at the Millennium and received the American Jewish Press Association's Highest Award for Excellence in Commentary. The international best-selling author of 27 books and award-winning TV host, he has just published "Kosher Jesus." Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley. His website is www.shmuley.com.

 
 
 

Follow Rabbi Shmuley Boteach on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RabbiShmuley

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 71
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
07:24 PM on 02/23/2012
Not all of American society is Catholic, so we cannot impose our view on all of society. I think maybe they should have a Catholic Option when the Exchanges are in place. Each individual, based on their religious views may select the option that best meets their needs and views. This will take place in 2014.

Govt has right to allow Secretary of HHS to implement these rules as they apply to preventative medicine. Self insured Catholic Organizations will have to let Insurers who fall under rule oversee their insurance policies to prevent Material Cooperation. This will give church plausible deniability in the face of Proportionate Reasoning.
07:13 PM on 02/23/2012
I like the word Decadent. It describes the issue perfectly. Society wants sex without responsibility. Contraception provides that. That is what church is railing against. Sex is holy and should be between a married man and woman. Possibility of life should be left open to the providence of G-d is the teaching. It is our small participation in creation in as much as G-d allows us to participate....
04:27 AM on 02/27/2012
Sex is NOT holy. It's one of the most important functions of a living being.

The fact that some people try to make it a "religious" issue is abnormal and wrong. As I look at the persons who try to "institutionalize" or "regularize" a NORMAL bodily function, I cannot help but noticing that they are the ones who, by their own choice, know (or should know) nothing whatsoever about it.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ronald B. Robinson
Keeping the Jesuit Tradition Alive
06:49 PM on 02/23/2012
Sounds more like a trifecta made up of a "sodomy obsession" combined with a "fertilized egg and fetus fetish."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
gutenmorgen
a.k.a. crowsnest
06:07 PM on 02/23/2012
When the Ueber-Calvinist Stuyvesant became the Governor of the outpost of the Dutch West-Indies Company known as New Amsterdam he soon wrote to his employer that about one half of the homes in New Amsterdam were brothels or pubs or both. He asked for permission to close them. The Company said no because we don't want trouble. The problem for the future USA began when the Ueber-Religious witch-hunters of New England defeated the more rational New Netherlanders and established their Holy Land in the New World. It has been all down-hill since. Our political predecessors closed all brothels for good and the pubs transiently with the help of so-called "Progressives". Rabbi, I understand you but it is absolutely hopeless. The Republicans are not the problem. Religious zealots are as it was at the time of Stuyvesant.
Zip Zinzel
If a Nation expects to be both Ignorant & Free . .
05:13 PM on 02/23/2012
CONTRACEPTION= Santorum recently came out saying that the use of contraceptives is interfering with God's natural order of things

BACK IN THE TIME OF THOMAS JEFFERSON, the 8th President of Yale, Timothy Dwight also said the very same thing about vaccination against Smallpox
itolduso
lateral thinker
02:47 PM on 02/23/2012
"Yet the number one cause of divorce in America is erotic disinterest and sexual boredom, with the Washington Post reporting that one out of three American couples is entirely platonic." **************** I'm sorry Rabbi- but it's not a lack of 'nooky' driving marriages apart. American families are stressed - it's not just the fact that it takes two and a half full time jobs for most families just to cover the basics of food, shelter, clothing, transportation and healthcare - there is a real lack of respect for those who hold those jobs. And now that so many of those jobs have disappeared- it's the workers themselves who are blamed for not 'makling it' - who are labeled 'losers'. Since the 1980's, working families have been under attack - blamed for forcing factories to move overseas simply for wanting a living wage and decent retirement. Half of all bankruptcies are due to medical bills, yet the debate rages over BC pills. One in four women will be sexually assaulted in her lifetime- and we lecture women on their dress and behavior without ever demanding that men stop assaulting them. In this country, corporations are granted rights, while individuals are imprisoned. Institutions are granted freedoms, individuals are denied access. Political leaders celebrate ignorance, divisiveness, selfishness, and greed, and families are driven apart. And our spiritual leaders talk about sex.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:39 PM on 02/23/2012
You have a point, families are stressed, ambition, work, take stage before the familial union, it has become that to provide a better future for your child is to not see your child. Their job begins to take up all of their lifeforce and then the family which at this point has become a chore, drains whatever is left. As American's I believe we are so busy trying to obtain the American dream that we forget the beautiful dream we're already in.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yankeeairpirate
an Analog Man in a Digital World
02:43 PM on 02/23/2012
A wise old guy once told me that "faith is your own set of beliefs that you believe in your heart of hearts is the right one for you. Religion, on the other hand is when a group of people who share roughly the same internal faith want to start a social club and start asking everybody for money."

That wise old guy was my dad, and even though I've outlived him, I keep my own faith and not give it to a fundraising social club.
02:42 PM on 02/23/2012
Contraception has only come to dominate public discourse since HHS decided to put a gun to the churches head and demand they pay for something they believe antithetical to their beliefs. The discussion has been falsely turned by Progressives into whether the GOP will ALLOW contraception, rather than the true discussion of who will pay for it.
iridium53
Semper Fi
02:32 PM on 02/23/2012
Politically active conservative White Christians conspire and seek influence or control over secular civil government through political action with the goal of either a nation governed by White Christians, or a nation governed by their particular ultra-conservative White Christian "understanding" of biblical law.

They even seek in Virginia and other places to shame and bully women through state-sponsored sexual assault.

They illogically conflate paying for women's healthcare with religious freedom - instead of relating it to how those women actually exercise their choice.

Time to TAX all religious organizations for what they are - businesses.

They no longer serve as religious organizations. They serve to enrich the organizations and to serve as anti-American political organizations.

"The separation of Church and State is not meant to hinder religion, or to deny the role of religion in society or in our history. Many of the founders were Christians, even James Madison was a Christian, but what they established was a government that was non-religious - a secular government. That does not mean that they rejected religion; their purpose was to establish a government whose sole function was to administer earthy matters, while matters of religion were left purely to ecclesiastical institutions. The founders, by and large, were very much supportive of the role of religion in society, but they separated the ideas of society and government, leaving religion to play a role in society, not government."
http://rationalrevolution.net/articles/history_of_the_separation_of_chu.htm
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:31 PM on 02/23/2012
Bravo.

www.offthegridmpls.blogspot.com
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frano
‘Plausible Deniability’: NOT A FAMILY_VALUE!!
02:20 PM on 02/23/2012
Re: "The Republican party has been dominated of late by a discussion of the sexual trifecta of gay marriage, abortion, and contraception. But are these the only values that matter?..." {Rabbi Boteach}

Correct me if I 'm wrong, but...
Doesn’t 'trifecta' usually refer to a 'winning' triple-issue?
Although they'll all deny it, morality, (particularly 'sexual' morality) as a ‘2012-republican-election’ issue is a LOSING issue...
Isn't it?
Would America, (or, It's sociopathic alter-ego, 'AmeriKa', that country which invaded Iraq, etc. for the hell of it, while allowing multi-billion weapons contracts with Saudi.Arabia, the country from whence arrived the 9-11 plane jackers…), really elect a Santorum, (with his 310+ million sexual obsessions)...
or a Gingrich, (with his ‘marriage as olympic decathlon’ & ‘lunar’ obsessions)...
and/or a Romney...
A man poised to treat his fellow 'mericans, (to borrow from the language-challenged former Texan-president), like he treats dogs during long-distance-driving-vacations??

…Really?
I DON’T think so!

With headlines like “85-95% of woman, (including catholic & republican woman) use birth control at some point”, I would imagine that President & Mrs. O’Bama are probably beseeching the Deity/Deities to have Rick Santorum, Newt Gingrich & M. Romney, (in that order), as republican opponents…
02:19 PM on 02/23/2012
If we want to decrease sexually related divorces, we need to encourage more pre-marital sex, and de-stigmatize the wide range of practices of things that people do in private, but don't talk about.

Personal compatibility and attraction are not the only factors in sexual compatibility, and preying won't make it so.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:47 PM on 02/23/2012
That's the thing, marriages are dying just because of that. Because instead of getting to know their fiance/fiancee, they rap themselves up in the idea of their relationship, the ideals society sets up for them, in the sweat, lust, and pheromones of their one to two year infatuation, instead of celebrating their relationship, their partner they end up celebrating the "fulfillment" of their destinies in society.
And after this storm, and climax of marriage finally settles and they are finally left to themselves and themselves alone, they find that they do not know this person, they're trapped in a obligation they never really honored, and if they want to keep up the public's spotlight, their own "self-fulfillment" they have to advance on, go further, further root each other irrevocably and uselessly into one another's lives with babies, and houses until the whole sham falls apart.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dancingstu
Christian, liberal lawyer
01:41 PM on 02/23/2012
Thank you for this thought-provoking article. I do disagree with you, however, on your description of the Untied States as a "religious nation" Simply because a majority of citizens may believe in a higher power or be a member of one religion or another, that does not make this a "religious nation". In fact, given the diversity of religious affiliations and even the differences between demoninations of each religion, I think it's difficult to say what our shared "religious convictions" really are. I think what your article points out really well is how easily we can be misled by leaders claiming to be guided by their "religious convictions".
01:28 PM on 02/23/2012
Excellent! The "religous" people the rabbi is talking about our exactly why i don't go to a church of any sorts. I find these so called religous people to be so hypocritical and judgemental and with no basis in reality. Thank you for being a thoughtful and logical religous man!
jhNY
Mercy.
01:26 PM on 02/23/2012
Nice read, Rabbi Boteach. There are points within it about which would argue, but I recognize the scale and scope of what you are attempting to describe and address, and I respect your effort.

Misdirection of the impulse to righteous action, in defense of a ruinous status quo is a sad business for any religious group to squander itself and our attentions on. Hypocrisy need not stand any longer than we accept it.