Why Great Men like John Edwards Cheat

The outrage over John Edward's admitted affair with a film-maker transcends what we have seen with most recent sex scandals. This partly results from his repeated denials of the affair. Much more important, of course, is the fact that the affair took place while his wife was battling cancer. The two of them had already dealt with the unspeakable tragedy of losing a teenage son, and the public is furious that Edwards caused his devoted wife, who agreed to campaign for him even after being diagnosed with incurable bone cancer, more pain than any woman should be asked to deal with.

Why, people want to know, do men like John Edwards who have it all throw away their blessings? Why, when they have wives who will do everything for them is it still never enough?

The answer is that men who cheat do not do so because they don't love their wives but because they hate themselves, not because their wives are not caring but because their perforated sense-of-self is immune to affection. Were their wives to shower them with all the love in the world, it would simply seep through the broken shards of their shattered egos. When asked about the affair last year by the media, Edwards denied it by saying, "It's completely untrue, ridiculous. I've been in love with the same woman for 30-plus years and, as anybody who's been around us knows, she's an extraordinary human being, warm, loving, beautiful, sexy and as good a person as I have ever known. So the story's just false." The form of his denial should have been a red flag. Men do not refrain from cheating because they have special wives but because they have a commitment to moral behavior and righteous action.

My purpose is not to kick a good man when is down but to understand his actions so that the rest of us can learn from his tragic fall.

Men today feel like failures. Immersed as they are in a hyper-competitive culture that makes them feel like they are valuable only through external achievement, they nurse a life-long feeling of anonymity and insignificance. Their gnawing insecurity becomes the very engine of their success. Thus, they reason to themselves, if I become a rich trial lawyer and get invited into high society, I'll be important. Oh wait. That happened and I still feel like a failure. Time to become a senator. OK, I did that, and I still don't feel fulfilled. Let's go for the gold, President. But all that attention and power will never make these men feel like they matter because it's being pumped straight into a black hole. There is not bottom to their low self-esteem.

Once you make a man's ego dependent not on the love he gets from his family but on the adoration he gets from crowds, he transfers the locus of his self-esteem away from his intimate circle and on to a fickle public. His need for public validation becomes an addiction. The wife who loves him cannot make him feel good about himself because, he reasons to himself, if he is a great big nothing then the woman dumb enough to marry him, however virtuous and accomplished in her own right, is an even bigger loser than he is. The wife is unwittingly punished for her devotion.

And that's where you see great men becoming susceptible to affairs. It is specifically the woman to whom they are not married, the one that has not been devalued through a merger with a failure, that can make him feel consequential.

Edwards practically admitted as much in the statement he released admitting to the affair: "In the course of several campaigns, I started to believe that I was special and became increasingly egocentric and narcissistic. If you want to beat me up -- feel free. You cannot beat me up more than I have already beaten up myself."

The egocentrism and narcissism to which he courageously confesses is always the hallmark of the Broken American male who mistakenly believes that ephemeral attention is an adequate substitute for intimate love. Fractured males always beat themselves up, whether they succeed or fail. The irony, of course, is that he was always special. He always had a wife and children who loved him. But like so many successful men, it still wasn't enough to make him feel unique. No, it took the adoration of the crowds and the compliments of complete strangers, to make him feel unique. Why not his family? Because men who feel like nothing see their families as impoverished extensions of their own nothingness. They requite external validation to become a somebody.

Our nation witnessed the same tragic error with Bill Clinton. The most powerful man in the world needed the ego boost of feeling desirable to a twenty-something intern. External accoutrements, however grand, are always a poor substitute for authentic self-regard. Elliot Spitzer followed suit by throwing his career away with a high-class call girl. A woman who is so desirable that a night with her can set you back a thousand dollars can make a guy feel like a million bucks.

Far from judging John Edwards, my heart goes out to him. His is an American tragedy. Every day hundreds of millions of Americans go out to work believing that what they do in the office will be more central to determining success than what they do at home. That impressing the boss is more important than keeping your wife off Prozac and your kids off the streets. But are you a success in life if the people who mean the most to you think the least of you?

When John Edwards announced in a press conference that he would continue seeking the nomination of the Democratic party for President despite his wife's metastasizing cancer, Elizabeth Edwards, who is universally admired by Americans, announced that she supported the decision because she did not want her children to believe that they had to give up their lives when faced with difficult battles.

True enough.

But perhaps an even more important lesson to the convey to our children is that what will truly make them special in life is not becoming President but being committed and loving family members who always put each other first.

Rabbi Shmuley Boteach is the host of a daily national radio show on 'Oprah and Friends.' He recently published 'The Broken American Male and How to Fix Him.' www.shmuley.com

Comments

[dreadpiraterobert]

Hmm... Rabbi Boteach, this is what you wrote 4 years ago...

Granted, you were writing a smear job/hit piece on John Kerry, so you may have been a tad excited, but may I remind you. You'll notice that I've substituted the McCains for the Kerry's, and I haven't amended the "eight" to the correct number (12? How can I tell?) but other than that, this is what you wrote:

"Now, having a wife who provides you with a private jet and eight multimillion-dollar vacation homes provides for a comfortable life. But is this the right preparation for becoming president? . . . Alas, there is yet one other important consideration that should get us all thinking. Before they married, [Cindy McCain] made [John McCain] sign a prenuptial agreement. Which begs the question: If his own wife doesn't trust him with her money, why should we trust him with ours?"

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=38643

Why indeed?

[dadshouse]

I agree that people suffering from narcissism seek out validation and love from others, but never feel fulfilled because they hate themselves. And those people may very well be addicted to things they think will bring fulfillment, but which never can because of the self-loathing. That is solid psychology.

But even non-narcissistic men cheat. And not all men in power are narcissistic. The male sex drive is a powerful thing that has led many men to find comfort outside their marriage. I'm not saying that's a good thing, just that it happens, and it's not always due to narcissism.

[neworleanslady68]

Shatterered ego? Men today? Hyper competition? Really?

Okay, my husband has cheated. My sister's husband got another woman pregnant.

My father cheated.

My maternal grandfather cheated (even brought his mistress to the hospital to "see the new baby" when my mother was born). That was 1948.

My great-grandfather, who grew up on a relic Creole plantation, had a mistress in the French Quarter all of his adult life. That began in the early 1900s and continued through the 1970s.

In fact, throughout most of New Orleans' history, male adultery was an open and expected part of life. There were balls - known as quadroon balls - at which young white men could form lifelong alliances with mixed race women. There were social events for men and their mistresses, separate from the ones for those same men and their wives.

And back during slaves days, there were mixed race children with my family's surname being born up and down the River Road. That was 1724 to 1865.

Seriously, spare me the psychobabble about how it's some uniquely modern angst that leads to this behavior.

It's no such thing.

Get some historical context here, man.

[sophiej]

it's the testosterone, rabbi.

[sherbug]

Men cheat because the lower brain has the final say.

[BCubedReg]

Excatly. This is not a complicated issue. Men cheat because they think they can get away with it. Men are basically neanderthals when it comes to sex.

[Jazzcomedian]

"Great men" cheat for the same reason that average and below average men cheat--they're horny, they want a bit of strange, and they think they can get away with it. And it's the same for the many married women who cheat--of which there are many. It's no deeper than that, and it happens in every profession--high or low profile. Fidelity is not for everyone, and in fact is unnatural for most. I'm sure that there are very decent people people on this site who have cheated on their mates--unless Huffpo is a suburb of heaven.

[justobserve]

". Men do not refrain from cheating because they have special wives but because they have a commitment to moral behavior and righteous action."
Exactly!
Any person, man or woman, has to fight all sorts of temptations, whether it is about sex or gambling or alcohol,..., and only their own moral standards would keep them from falling to the traps.

[WorkingClass]

Men cheat because they hate themselves? Hahahaha! Come back and tell us why women cheat.

[Sumocat]

"Why, people want to know, do men like John Edwards who have it all throw away their blessings?" -- It's unfortunate you had to follow this question with so many words when the answer is so clear in your opening paragraph. Edwards is specifically NOT one of those men who "have it all". He lost his son. His wife is dying of cancer. I wouldn't trade places with him if I was on fire. The man didn't throw away his blessings. They have been and are being taken from him. Would I have been stronger in that situation? I don't know, and I hope I never have to find out.

[MsEngineer]

What a bunch of BS.

[aubrey8]

I don't think Edwards deserves that "great man" tag yet. he's a one term senator with no great accomplishments to date.

you may like the guy and want to defend him but he's a long ways from a great man.

[Pupadup4oBama]

Rabbi, thank you so much for such an insightful article.

[PumaAnn]

Any personality type which pours out personal energy is susceptible to numbing out. That goes for salesmen, politicians, and would suggest the best husbands and lovers are probably accountants and bankers.

[BCubedReg]

Accountants maybe, not bankers.

[BehindTheScenes]

A wonderful analysis. This post, and Beth Arnold's, are the best I've seen. You don't deny that Edwards made a tragic mistake, with consequences, but you see the humanity behind it, a humanity common to all of us, unlike those who delight in demonizing the fallen hero. Thank you.

[Gma11]

Excellent assessment!