Why Israel Should Reject American Economic Aid

Over the weekend I read Startup Nation, the new book about why Israel has emerged as an unlikely global leader in high-tech. Even if its authors Dan Senor and Saul Singer were not my friends and, in the case of Saul, my editor at the post I would still say that it's the best advertisement for Israel to come out in recent memory. Foregoing the usual discussion of Israel as an embattled nation whom everyone hates and seeks to destroy, it focuses instead on the ingenuity and invincibility of the Israeli people and their vast technological contribution to the global economy. Where the Israeli army is discussed its focus is not on soldiers chasing down terrorists but on how the Israeli military serves as a future commercial networking tool for soldiers who served in the same unit. You can see why the book both informs and inspires.

Am I the only one is just plain tired of only hearing bad news about Jews and Israel? Remember the old joke of the Jewish guy who loves reading anti-Semitic magazines. When asked why he says, "When I read Jewish newspapers all I come across is that we're hated and attacked. When I read the anti-Semitic alternatives they tell me we run the world and have all the money."

Israel is not a victim. Less so is it a tragic nation. Rather, as Startup Nation makes clear Israel today is one of the most highly educated and technologically-advanced nations on earth with one of its fastest growing economies. And it's time that Jewish newspapers and periodicals stopped the sad, tired, worn story that Israel is about to draw its last breath.

True, Israel has implacable, terrorist enemies that surround it, and yes, Iran is building a bomb which is an existential threat to the Jewish state. That's all mighty serious stuff. These threats should and must be discussed, confronted, and ultimately neutralized, by force if necessary. But is that all there is to the modern Jewish story? Is there not also a story of tremendous success? Just imagine what a downer it is for the rest of the world to hear that the Jews only see themselves as perennial victims who are about to be murdered. And propagating only that bad news means that people learn to tune Israel out. Whenever they see the country coming up on the news - which is all the time - they naturally assume it's some tragic, depressing story. So they either turn the channel or worse, they watch it and conclude that Israel is a place of guns, bombs, and bullets. If only they could hear about Israeli universities ranking in the top ten worldwide, of the growing number of Nobel Prize winners, of Andy Grove, Warren Buffet, and Bill Gates rushing to invest in Israel, and how a crazy percentage of all the world's computer chips are manufactured in the Jewish state.

The time has come for world Jewry to no longer look at the Jewish state only as the refuge for a persecuted people and instead focus on Israel as the place where the limitless potential of the Jewish people is finally being manifest. All we needed was for people to get out of our way, to rid ourselves of countries that shoved us into ghettoes or gave quotas as to how many Jews could attend University, and just look at how much we now thrive. And we prosper not as a self-absorbed nation but as a people who make vast contributions to the welfare of all mankind.

It is time for Israel to begin seriously considering forgoing American economic aid. I understand the military aid. Israel has an insane number of crazies who wish to attack and destroy it. But the economic aid creates an unnecessary dependency, undermines the perception of Israel as a prosperous country, and gives the United States undo influence over Israeli policy. And surely we all believe that decisions governing Israel's right to defend itself should be taken by the Israeli Prime Minister rather than the American President.

There is more.

Many a Jew has wondered aloud why the Arabs got all the oil and Israel got none. What could G-d have been thinking in making despots and dictators like the Saudis and Kaddafi so insanely rich while Israel has to struggle for every shekel it earns. Only now to do we see the truth. Oil is the greatest curse ever to befall the Arabs. By digging a hole and having money flow from the ground, the Arab states had little incentive to build world-class Universities and a thriving high-tech industry. And when the day finally comes -- and it will come -- when the world is wise enough to finally find an alternative energy source to oil, these despotic regimes will completely collapse.

This isn't rocket science. All of us, I'm sure, know at least one rich friend whose kids had to work for very little and who consequently became spoiled and indolent. Israel has had to work for every thing it has. No country in world history has ever been more unjustly reviled or more ferociously and continuously attacked. Conversely, no country better inspires the world to ponder the infinite capacity of humans to rise from the ashes -- and in the case of the holocaust, quite literally -- and build a shining state on a hill.

Israel still has a lot of problems and a lot of enemies who seek to destroy it. It must be hyper vigilant and forever strong. But it is time for the other side of the story to be highlighted as well. And I hope that more books like Start Up Nation will begin to focus on Israel's colossal achievements rather than merely its insurmountable threats.

Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, founder of This World: The Values Network, has just published 'The Blessing of Enough' and 'The Michael Jackson Tapes.' www.shmuley.com.

 

 

Comments

[shotei]

Israel has a brilliant present and future despite being surrounded by enemies who seek its destruction and fragile allies who have to bear incredible pressure to maintain a cold peace within their own constituencies (even though neither Jordan or Egypt are democracies).
Israel thrives in the middle of nothing and being the only country in the world that has its very existence challenged both physically and morally.
Israel does not need America's economic aid. No Israeli critic here has stopped to think that it's in America's interest to aid Israel militarily. And also that it's a two way road, since Israel gives a significant contribution to America's military edge through its technological advances.

[Garioch]

In what manner is it the only nation whose existence has been challenged both physically and morally?
Many nations have been challenged morally and many have faced significantly larger threats to their existence physically. Israel have barely been around for any time in the general historical scale, there are nations who have been occupied and invaded dozens of times and still survive.
Mythmongering as usual.

[shotei]

CURRENTLY, it is the only nation that suffers existential threats from neighboring countries (Iran) and other state-funded groups (Hamas, Hezbollah). Of course other countries in the PAST, have also received very physical existential threats, but the modern-day war does not imply total anihilation of the enemy. The only case it is still so is with Israel.

[arvay]

Great news. let's suspend all aid, particularly miitary aid, to this nation of supermen and let them fight their fight.

[joeinvt]

I agree. And while we are at it let's also cut off all aid to Egypt and other Arab/Muslim countries, which exceeds what we give to Israel. What we save can be put to better use in the industrial Midwest than in the Mideast.

[SpoonieLuv]

I agree. Both the Jewish state and the Muslim states of the Middle East are dangerously rife with religious fundamentalists. It is antithetical to the American spirit to endorse (not to mention ARM) any regime that is marked by such extremism.

[duxguts]

They should also reject US political aid.

[DC]

The end of cultivating victimology and dependency will make Israel strong.

[StCuthbert]

I think the point of this article is that Israel has become strong despite being a victim. How come the Palestinians aren't strong since they receive a lot more aid and are a lot more dependent then Israel is?

[Garioch]

They do not receive more aid or even a significant fraction of the aid that the Israeli state has, they also do not have a nation. They have however managed to survive decades of intense Israeli aggression and become a significant world political player which indicates a fair amount of strength. It is however good to see that your anti Palestinian racism is still coming through loud and clear though.

[Fireslayer]

The U S payoff for aid has been a mixed blessing. Those of us who like some Israelis more than others should be disappointed in the lack of benefits for our bucks.

Israel could have a great future if they would do justice by the Palestinians. And don't give me that "we offered them the moon" crap about previous peace discussions.

Basic human rights, control of their own real estate and equal treatment by authorities should not be items of negotiation. They should be firm points of departure for discussions towards a region where all can thrive.

[shelby35]

Hey if an orthodox rabbi can say it there is a shot.

[jollyelle]

The victim status should be shelved as is allowing Israel to be non participants in the rules that govern other independent states such as International law and nuclear inspections.

[S1m0n]

They'd be able to stop biting the hand that feeds them, too.

[jeanrenoir]

It is absurd for American tax-payers to be subsidizing a state as rich per capita as Israel. We need our tax dollars right here. So it's great to see a rabbi advocating that Israel cut the aid umbilical cord with the United States. Hope Bibi's listening.

[devadasi]

Good point jeanrenoir! We have our hands full right here in the U.S. and need to deal with our own problems. Plus the Israeli government continues to their neighbors like second class citizens.

[lbsaltzman]

But let's make sure that we cut all aid to Israel particularly the military aid.

[Macready]

definitely lb . . . all aid military, financial and the use of the veto in the UN to protect israel . . . all aid of any kind