More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rabbi Yonah Bookstein

GET UPDATES FROM Rabbi Yonah Bookstein
 

The Murder of Kelly Thomas and the Effort to Bring his Murderers to Justice

Posted: 10/29/11 06:03 PM ET

The facts are horrific. Video capture the brutal attack on the side of a busy street. Onlookers and passerby don't come to the victims aid. Eventually, the bruised, bleeding, half-dead body is attended to by medical personal, but it is too late. The victim dies.

No, I am not talking about the tragic hit and run of a two year-old Chinese girl -- I am writing about the death of Kelly Thomas of Fullerton, California.

Kelly Thomas, a 37-year-old mentally ill homeless man, was brutally beaten by six Fullerton police officers on July 5. Yes, on-duty police. They then tried to cover up the murder. Thomas was beloved, not abandoned, but mental illness kept him on the streets.

2011-10-25-kellythomas.jpg

Kelly's beating at a bus stop was done in public. No one came to his aid. Cars and passersby watched. The investigators interviewed 151 witnesses -- yes, that is 151 people stared, watched and did nothing -- viewed seven surveillance videos and two videos recorded by witnesses on their cellphones. In addition, a recording device attached to the leader of the assualt, which all Fullerton officers wear, recorded the murder in vivid detail. Two officers are being charged with his death, four others that took part have not.

Ron Thomas, Kelly's father, is waging a relentless battle to raise awareness about Kelly's murder, the police cover-up and ultimately about the fate of the mentally ill on our streets. And it's working. Residents of Fullerton are taking their city council to task and the FBI is now investigating the crime. Fullerton just set up a task force in the wake of the murder to look for ways to improve the plight of the homeless in Fullerton.

Paul Orloff, a Fullerton resident, has launched a Change.org campaign to bring the four Fullerton police officers who have yet to be charged in the Kelly Thomas murder case to justice. In just a few days, more that 14,000 people signed a petition for justice in the murder of Kelly Thomas.

While the world gasped in horror at the death of the Chinese girl, in America we walk by the legions of homeless who lie motionless on the side of the street every day.

We are numb to the facts: hundreds of thousands of them call the streets their home every night. They sleep over subway grates, in alleyways and doorways. As the economy worsens, the numbers on the streets are increasing.

Those who call the street home are mostly ignored as if they do not exist. From time to time a passerby will show compassion, offering food, money, a kind word. Yet, most of us find ways to harden our hearts to their plight. We dismiss them as junkies, bums, beggars, or mentally-ill. Cities create laws to banish them from our sight. Yet, each homeless person, no matter their mental, physical or hygienic condition, is a human being endowed with the same soul as anyone else.

In addition to their plight living on the streets of America, literally under our feet, the homeless are also targets of random murders across the country. Kelly Thomas's murder is just the latest to make the papers. Just in the last week, these cases made the news:

On October 23rd, Allen Harrell Hunter, from West Palm Beach man was arrested for the 2008 murder of a homeless man David Roland Ulmer.

On October 19th, in Butte, Montanta, Shane Hans, 35, was charged with deliberate homicide in the killing of a homeless man, Teddy James Hildebrant.

On October 13th, Casey Daniel Brown was sentenced by Sacramento County Superior Court for the second-degree murder of 68-year-old Bernice Nickson, a homeless woman who approached him at a bus stop.

Why are homeless people targeted for such random killing? Often because they are regarded them as less than human, murderers wrongly believed no one would miss these creatures of the streets. Some of the murderers have ready admitted that they calculated that no one would miss these people.

Kelly Thomas's tragic life and death are causing one city to move forward and continue the soul-searching needed to work on the issue of homeless on their streets. Hopefully it will not take more grizzly videos of a homless person being bludgeoned, run-over, or stabbed and left to die by the side of the road for America to start taking notice.

 

Follow Rabbi Yonah Bookstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RabbiYonah

 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:45 PM on 12/27/2011
My condolences to the Thomas family. I am truly sorry for your lost, for I was almost murdered in the same fashion, in the same Orange County California; just four months prior.

On March 9, 2011 several Police brutally ordered a K-9 to attack an unarmed, California Registered (RN). The California Highway Patrol (CHP) in Orange County then attempted to cover up the incident.

Malik King, a reportedly Licensed Vocational Nurse (LVN) since nineteen and RN since twenty three, is said to have initially attempted to steal a car. Later, it was found he was the owner of that Mercedes. What ensued next on the part of several officers goes well beyond the bounds of simply trying to subdue their suspect.

The several police officers ordered a police K-9 to attack him while he was still fastened in his seat-belt; tasered multiple times while the K-9 attacked for over one minute and thirty seconds, then hand cuffed, slammed to the concrete, hog tied, beat and kicked in the head until unconscious. He was then taken to jail, accused of multiple felonies, and had to pay $50,000 for bail.

The beating of Mr. King is sickening and disturbing. The police involved in the beating and cover up must be brought to justice. Tell Orange County District Attorney Tony Rackauckas to thoroughly investigate and prosecute the officers involved in the brutality of Malik A. King,LVN,RN.

http://www.thepetitionsite.com/takeaction/196/722/705/

Respectfully,
Malik King,LVN,RN
09:56 AM on 11/24/2011
But, in the video clip I saw, one brave young man's voice could be heard telling the police to stop many times. Instead, an officer forcefully ordered he and his friends to go away or go to jail.
09:11 PM on 11/23/2011
As a resident of Fullerton, I too was "gobsmacked" at how many citizen's stood back and watched this atrocity. I have walked up and offered aid to people, as a human it is my duty to help protect and assist those who are in need. The entire city needs to be put right and we citizens need to think about others and their needs and become better people. Those fair-weather religious types that are good one day a week then turn a blind eye the rest of the time need to be accountable as well. If you see someone needing help, if you see an animal being abused it is your duty to aid them, stop being so selfish and righteous. Moral and ethical living isn't always church based but it would help if the hypocrites would MAN-UP.
06:01 PM on 11/16/2011
After about the tenth time that the cops try to kill you, you kind of get over being afraid of them. I wrote a book about Kelly Thomas, The Borogroves, you can see it for free by going to my site freetibetbooks.wordpress.com, scroll down and click on the blurb.com icon. No one profits from the sale, but I did offer it to Ron Thomas, to do with as he sees fit, hope he will claim it and make lots of money, but it won't bring Kelly back. -Carolyn
05:54 PM on 11/16/2011
I wrote a book about Kelly Thomas: The Jabberwocky, preview it for free at: freetibetbooks.wordpress.com Scroll down to the blurb.com widget and click on the book cover.
THE JABBERWOCK... Radical Reconstruct... By Illustrated by Ca... Book Preview
03:49 PM on 11/08/2011
The Plight of the homeless is real. I have experience going thru this myself. I had some tough times economically and lost my home and had to go to a shelter as a last resort. What I found when I went thru the experience is that a lot of the people who were at the shelter had some sort of mental health condition that obviously was not being treated properly. Of course there are some there who have ability but just wont do anything. It took effort to work my way out and get a new home, but some there dont have that ability and do not get the help they need and get stuck in that awful cycle
06:50 PM on 11/03/2011
Bystanders who watch cops murder a citizen with brutal , vicious strike after strike with clubs until he was smashed to death should hang their heads in shame. They had every right to use force to stop the murder, including deadly force. Had that been my son laying there begging for help and being beaten over and over while not resisting I would have used any force necessary to stop it, including opening fire on the cops.

Why should a uniform or a stinking badge allow cops to do anything they want, including murder while the citizenry stand by horrified but afraid to act? Where are the guts qanymore? Where is the willingness to step in and stop a moral outrage? If the cops took a knife and began stabbing someone would the public ignore it? What CAN'T a cop do anymore ? Dear God people, cops are just people, granted most are amoral and violent, but they are not above justice on the spot if they shock the conscience...if the public CAN stop police murder and brutality we should...someday I swear if this crap doesn't stop the people are going to have to rise up and take care of these killer cops ourselves...I promise you that would get their attention.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Susan Shaffer
tell me from the beginning
04:45 AM on 11/02/2011
Too many stories about mentally ill patients on the streets. Sorry, I think it was a bad idea to empty the psych wards. Even a clear thinking person can be bamboozled. What hope has someone got that has mental illness? At least in a facility the caretakers can be scrutinised. A few posters have commented about their kids on the street and they can do nothing about it. If the adult child was in an institution the parent can at least visit and should anything untoward happen to their kid they can alert someone superior.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
My life is microbiodegradable.
10:47 PM on 11/03/2011
The theory of getting rid of the large psychiatric hospitals was to move the patients into smaller community based treatment venues so that the patient would have friends and family and possibly work close by. The actuality is that they closed the hospitals without any of these programs in place and no concrete plans to ever develop them. Boarding houses, streets, shelters and prisons are where a great many of the mentally ill now end up. Private health insurance limits coverage. Medicaid is being cut back drastically. The mentally ill in rural homes and many small town homes have no psychiatrists for treatment of these citizens. It's a national disgrace.
04:53 AM on 11/26/2011
YES!!!
photo
SevenUPtheUNCOOLA
give me reproductive freedom or give me death
01:45 AM on 11/02/2011
we cant remain numb to his situation. 150 people ignored kelly being beaten to death. that makes me so sad. police are supposed to 'protect and serve'. if private citizens try to intervene, its our right to do that. but to videotape it with a cell phone? you have a cell phone in your hand CALL FOR HELP and i would suggest everyone have the ACLU on speed dial, just like 911.

RIP kelly.
09:05 PM on 10/31/2011
I agree that stepping in when police officers are doing the beating is a bit intimidating to say the least, being a police officer 20 years ago I can tell you they most likely would have told you to mind your business or you will be arrested for obstructing .However stepping in and getting arrested would have been the right thing to do no matter what. I think most people think that police officers know what they are doing and would not do something like this in the first place and most police officers would not.
But like every group of people there are some bad apples in every bunch and they need to be removed before they ruin the whole bunch!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Claude Hosch
A single bracelet does not jingle
03:07 PM on 10/31/2011
It is a sad truth, made sadder by public servants. I have a brother mentally challenged, and have learned that they are mistreated in the facilities designed to protect them Probably the most frequent offense is dismissing ones ability to state fact, because of their fragile emotions.
01:35 AM on 11/01/2011
Which facilities have been mistreating their patients? This cannot be true of all mental facilities. I know someone whose son improved immensely after one year of living in a locked psychiatric hospital in Pomona, California.
02:00 PM on 10/31/2011
This article is SO TRUE unfortunately.
01:28 AM on 10/31/2011
The laws for homeless mentally ill people need to be changed. It is currently almost impossible to place a severely mentally ill person in a locked facility, which is where that person should be. I know because my 29-year-old son is on the streets by choice and every effort I have made to commit him has failed.
02:27 PM on 10/31/2011
I sympathize..I have a 20 yr old son who has chosen to live on the streets for the last 2 years, in a city an hour away fro me, refusing any and all offers of real help and only wanting enabling.BUT, being mentally ill and locked in a cage with violent people is worse than tolerating them, why?Because they are not criminals unless they break the law and being ill is not illegal. Imagine it from their viewpoint: Suffering every day and living on the edge of survival and then being thrown in a cage, not comprehending why and being forced to take meds against their will...what kind of people are WE willing to be to " protect" them from themselves?

Hard issues, difficult questions, no good answers...tragic.
02:26 AM on 11/18/2011
Thank you! It does not seem to be within some parents with adult children with psychiatric diagnoses are willing and/or able to, "Imagine it from their viewpoint" or acknowledge the serious violation of Human Rights that placing, "a severely mentally ill person in a locked facility" is. and think that it "is where that person should be" is justifiable because it makes the parent feel better. Treatment is to make the patient feel better, and while there are those who have this done and are later grateful...there are also many who are grievously permanently harmed by such experiences. It is not humane, or therapeutic to force people to take dangerous drugs which cause cognitive, metabolic and neurological dysfunction so that other people feel better.
"Of all tyrannies, a tyranny exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It may be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end, for they do so with the approval of their own conscience." C.S. Lewis
involuntarytransformation.blogspot.com
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:04 AM on 10/30/2011
In all fairness, intervening when it is police officers committing the murder, does up the ante. It does not surprise me that even potential Good Samaritans might think twice.