iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rachel Havrelock

GET UPDATES FROM Rachel Havrelock
 

Where Exactly Is Biblical Israel?

Posted: 01/14/2012 5:07 pm

The phrase "Biblical Israel" often passes on the lips of Republican presidential contenders, representatives of the Netanyahu government, and Israeli settlers. But where exactly is this Israel of the Bible to be found?

Not in the Bible itself. The Hebrew Bible (known to Christians as the Old Testament and to Jews as the Torah or Tanakh) contains five different "maps." These "maps" aren't pictures, but lists of boundaries that define the Promised Land. None of them resemble the modern-day "Biblical Israel." One map -- surprisingly found in the book of Joshua, which describes an all-out holy war -- suggests a regional federation in which the tribes of Israel overlap and coexist with local inhabitants. Joshua chapter 15, verse 63 even states: "the Jebusites (local inhabitants of Jerusalem) and the People of Judah dwell together in Jerusalem until today." This not only sounds like contemporary Jerusalem -- a mixed city of Palestinians and Israelis -- but also like a prophecy of how the division of Jerusalem might give way to dwelling together.

The closest we get to "Biblical Israel" in the Bible is a map buried in the book of Numbers in which the land spans from the Mediterranean Sea in the west to the Jordan River in the east. The northern and southern boundaries don't correspond to "Biblical Israel" at all.

If not the Bible, then where does "Biblical Israel" come from? It results from a series of decisions made by the British when they asserted their power and later controlled the Middle East. With increasing awareness of the rich oil fields paralleling the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers and dreams of transporting this oil to Europe via the Mediterranean Sea, the British War Office began funding the efforts of the biblically driven Palestine Exploration Fund (PEF). The PEF aimed to prove the legitimacy of the Bible through scientific endeavors like archeology and mapping. In 1879, the British War Office published maps that became widely available in 1880. The 26 sheets of hand-drawn maps present a Palestine conforming to the biblical formulae "from Dan to Beersheba" for the north-south axis and "from the Jordan to the Sea" for the east-west axis. Thus the Holy Land as a potential holding of a Protestant empire was born.

In 1922, the League of Nations approved the British map of Mandate Palestine that reintroduced the idea of the Jordan River as a border. 1922 marks the first time that Protestants ruled the Holy Land as well as the birthday of "Biblical Israel." The Jews and Arabs who wanted this land for their own countries adopted the British map. Where the British saw the birthplace of Jesus and an excellent port for the shipment of Iraqi oil to Europe, Jews envisioned Israel and Palestinians imagined an independent Palestine.

From 1922 on, most Jewish nationalists recognized the Jordan as the ancient border that would one day define their state. This aspiration found fulfillment when Israel conquered the West Bank and reached the Jordan River in the 1967 war. The British map had a parallel impact on Palestinian nationalists. Although the Palestinian Arab Congresses held in the early 1920s rejected the British Mandate as well as the 1922 map, striking and rioting against both, the borders of the desired Palestine were constituted by the Mandate. The 1968 Palestinian National Charter makes the case most clearly: "Palestine, with the boundaries it had during the British Mandate, is an indivisible territorial unit." The "biblical" land doubly claimed by Palestinians and Israelis results from the British administration of the Middle East.

Since the 1920s -- indeed since the 1960s -- there is much water under the bridge. In the symbolic lexicon of Israelis, the Jordan River, as in the Bible, represents the line between homeland and exile. In the very real experiences of Palestinians exiled across the Jordan as a result of the 1948 and 1967 wars, the Jordan River marks the difference between exile and homeland. Battles have been fought and, ultimately, a peace treaty signed between Israel and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan that recognizes a span of the river as the border between them.

Right-wing religious groups, whether Israeli or Palestinian, aspire to rule all of "Biblical Israel" or "Historic Palestine." In truth, these maps result from British colonialism and not from religious tradition. Religious ideas about this land are, in fact, more fluid, more flexible, and more accepting of the different peoples who live within its uncertain borders.

 
 
 
The phrase "Biblical Israel" often passes on the lips of Republican presidential contenders, representatives of the Netanyahu government, and Israeli settlers. But where exactly is this Israel of the ...
The phrase "Biblical Israel" often passes on the lips of Republican presidential contenders, representatives of the Netanyahu government, and Israeli settlers. But where exactly is this Israel of the ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 444
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
06:00 AM on 01/21/2012
The Judeo Christian Bible said that Isreal was supposed to be a City. Now someone made a country out of it. I dont care how many times revisionist historians say that Isreal was an actual country long ago, If I choose to believe Isreal is a bigger myth than Atlantis, then to my way of thinking, Isreal is a fictional place.
04:35 PM on 01/19/2012
This article stinks. Read the books of Samuel and Kings for the boundaries of Biblical israel. And by the way, the Torah is not the Tanak. it's only 1/3 of Tanach, which includes prophets (Naviim) and Writings (Katibin). Perhaps your misunderstanding on that point caused you to ignore the books of the Prophets where the information is.
11:36 AM on 01/19/2012
'Biblical Israel' does not, in fact arise from a series of decision by the British, only 'political (and Zionist) Israel. As the article indicates in the Torah Israel is variously defined broadly speaking within what was 'Mandate Palestine'. But for Christians 'Biblical Israel' is something very different; see i.e. Galatians 6; Ephesians 6; Romans - all of it!; not to mention John 4:1-26 (oh, I just did). The Church, when it behaves as it should is Biblical Israel. Even in the Old Testament Biblical Israel was never every single Israelite, It was Abrahams faith not his blood that was 'counted for righteousness'.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mick Frodsham
04:39 PM on 01/18/2012
Borders a created by men, not God's, just like the Bible was. The thing is that the men who created the Bible weren't nearly as successful militarily as a most of their contemporaries were. That's why ancient Israel was a province more often than a nation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Forester
Overeducated woods worker.
01:33 PM on 01/17/2012
Sorry, no clear title to the land in that document.
I do title searches all the time, and that is not good enough for any legal claims.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:05 PM on 01/19/2012
Did someone claim that it was?
08:00 AM on 01/21/2012
Who does have "clear title" and where did they get it?
08:27 AM on 01/17/2012
thank you for this information . . .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AndyGra
Autodidact
09:47 PM on 01/16/2012
" Religious ideas about this land are, in fact, more fluid, more flexible, and more accepting of the different peoples who live within its uncertain borders." (last sentence)

This is how I think that the Ottoman Empire kept the peace, in general, for centuries. Except for the Crusades.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
H P
Citizen
09:01 PM on 01/16/2012
So this has been all about oil all along. and we can thank the british military and their cartographers for the current 'lines in the sand'. I bet those maps in the backs of bibles, showing the 'holy land' are derived or come directly from those british maps
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Galilee
I boycott products from Syria & Gaza dictatorships
04:45 AM on 01/17/2012
I haven't seen a bible with a map, however, the geography and borders are described in the text.
03:48 PM on 01/17/2012
Many bibles with maps New American Bible for one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
H P
Citizen
10:58 PM on 01/17/2012
I suggest just going to any bookstore in the US and look in the back of any bible. you will see the maps there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Galilee
I boycott products from Syria & Gaza dictatorships
03:11 PM on 01/17/2012
My bibles are in Hebrew, with no drawings.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
06:33 PM on 01/16/2012
One may as well ask how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. The borders of the "Promised Land" or ancient Israel or Judea are relevant only culturally if at all. The modern state of Israel is based on the human right of self-determination, its borders are defined by treaty, just like every other state on the planet.
08:29 AM on 01/17/2012
really . . .israel has no borders at the moment and has known for decades that it has to return to its pre-war 1967 boundaries . . . . yet it keeps stealing Palestinian land
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:08 PM on 01/19/2012
Of course Israel has borders. The border with Lebanon in the north is well defined, as is the border with Gaza and Egypt. The border between the West Bank (or "Judea" and Sumeria" as it is called in Arabic), is not, but the line separating that area from Jordan is.

BTW, you seem unaware that the treaty that created the Green Line (what you call the 67 borders) explicitly states that it was not to be regarded as a political boundary, and this statement was included at the insistence of the Arab parties, who felt that making it a border would be tantamount to recognizing Israel.
03:52 PM on 01/17/2012
Treaties made after the fact of wars and those who conquered? The stronger Nations that conquered the weak Nations around them also moved and created new border lines?, renamed? and added to their own Nations to enlarge their own? Like Ethiopia ( now called Africa) and Atlantic Ocean was once called Ethiopic Ocean in Ancient History Maps that still exist and can be found. Egypt also was not once its name, but was also part of Ethiopia (now Africa) Interesting.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:09 PM on 01/19/2012
I can see that you have some issue with how countries define their borders. Fair enough, but that is how it is done.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
speedy evans
05:31 PM on 01/16/2012
let me help you with that word...Is ra el ..ra is el or maybe el is ra.... maybe this will help... gods sun is in the sky...the sun of god is in the sky...R U confused yet..you are a good christain
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WESmith
Energy Conservation can save you M-O-N-E-Y!!!!!!!!
07:39 PM on 01/16/2012
Politicians and political activists have always used religion as rhetoric.
02:34 PM on 01/17/2012
Huh????????
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yvonne Serocki
wellness is inspired
03:53 PM on 01/16/2012
Biblical Israel is located in the heart of human beings, the location of the new jerusalem, zion, the new heaven on earth where God descends from heaven to live in the midst of humanity. There is no temple in the new heaven on earth and light radiates from the Light emanating from the innermost spiritual heart. We are all unified in the One Spirit in the bond of peace when we are all able to descend from our head-focused, ego-focused, external locus of control-focus; and move into a heart-focused, internal locus of control; with the eyes of our heart enlightened, our spiritual eye opened, and being guided by the immanent, indwelling Spirit of God within each open heart.www.newheavenonearth.wordpress.com "For he is not a real Jew who is one outwardly, nor is true circumcision something external and physical. He is a Jew who is one inwardly, and real circumcision is a matter of the HEART, spiritual and NOT LITERAL" (Romans 2:28-29 RSV)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:11 PM on 01/19/2012
Actually, Biblical Israel is located in the Middle East.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eddy joe
welcome to the machine
03:42 PM on 01/16/2012
If you are not gloing to accept the bible as history, then you cannot accept other text as history.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tylerious
My mom thinks I'm awesome
04:28 PM on 01/16/2012
I recently listened to a book about the history of Carthage. The author described the lack of unbiased accounts of Carthage and Carthaginians, since the city itself was burned to a pulp and the only surviving accounts of the culture was from their greatest enemy the Romans. Given the obvious bias in all of these accounts, historians have to tread carefully to put together a truthful picture of actual events. I think the same goes for the Bible, since it contains stories regarding a lot of real places and real events. Yet, the authors (of the Torah in particular) wanted to reinforce a strong national identity coupled with and reinforced by constant interventions by their primary deity. Thus, the Bible has to be understood from the perspective of the writers, so that you can discern why they emphasize certain things and exclude others.
07:29 PM on 01/16/2012
If you are not going to accept my pronouncements as law then you don't have my permission to breathe.
You have until the Sabbath's close to choose.
04:38 PM on 01/19/2012
That's exactly the kind of persecution we suffered in Christian Europe for 500 years. I know you mean it as a joke, but in the past it resulted in our deaths.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Craig Koebelin
Gut feelings are usually gas
02:47 PM on 01/16/2012
The political and ethnic boundaries varied through the centuries, but when the "rediscovered" Law was presented to the people by Ezra and Nehemiah, Biblical Israel was a province of Persia.
02:32 PM on 01/16/2012
The Middle East is a hateful pile of rocks and sand. STOP wasting US Tax Dollars and lives on this miserable piece of land that should be spent on US education, healthcare and infrastructure. The future will be in Asia. Get us out of the Middle East and save our tax dollars!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WESmith
Energy Conservation can save you M-O-N-E-Y!!!!!!!!
07:59 PM on 01/16/2012
We The People (via the government) own the vast majority of oil in the US. You and I are BIG OIL. We make more money from petroleum than all 13,000 American oil companies combined.
The value of the US Dollar in directly connected to the price of oil (inversely proportional).

It is in our best interest to control these areas. We The People of the US demand cheap gasoline so that we can continue to purchase inefficient, intimidating vehicles that maximize the amount of pollution entering the environment. We also kill 32,000 of our fellow Americans in avoidable car crashes. We also spend billions of dollars of healthcare money as a result of (again) avoidable car crashes. We demand this. There are costs.
Oh? We are going green? We said that in the 1970s. We were going to be foreign oil free by the end of the century; free of gasoline vehicles soon after that. We had solar and wind generators. We had electric cars, alternative energy vehicles, hybrids, and even Gasohol (10%) for those addicted to gasoline. What did we decide? We overwelmingly choose coal and oil.
The bottom line is always money. But we can't have it both ways.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
OneFish
Various and assorted mutualistic microbial buddies
01:47 PM on 01/16/2012
Where exactly is Biblical Israel?

Oh, I suspect somewhere between the Crystal Cathedral and Joel Osteen's bedroom.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eddy joe
welcome to the machine
03:33 PM on 01/16/2012
As an atheist your statement is of no use. But since no one responded to you, I thought I would take a poke.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
OneFish
Various and assorted mutualistic microbial buddies
04:51 PM on 01/16/2012
You could be right. Likewise, the religious crap that I hear about God this and God that and Jesus is coming back is of even less use.