iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Randi Weingarten

Randi Weingarten

Posted: March 12, 2011 11:55 AM

History and Voters Will Not Be Kind


Over the last three weeks, Gov. Scott Walker and his allies in the Wisconsin Legislature made a mockery of representative government. Rather than listen to the citizens of Wisconsin, who are strongly opposed to stripping teachers, nurses and other workers of their rights, Walker rammed through a bill that was a blatant political payback to his out-of-state major campaign donors and cronies, who have sought for years to crush the aspirations of workers who dare to demand a voice in the workplace. This charade culminated when Walker shredded 50 years of labor peace, built through bipartisanship and a democratic process, and signed a bill into law against the wishes of a majority of the voters in Wisconsin.

The governor may have won a short-term political victory, but history and Wisconsin voters won't be so kind. Power exercised without discretion and prudence is corrupting. And based on Gov. Walker's actions -- his underhanded maneuvering to get the bill passed, his misrepresentations that the bill was part of reducing the budget deficit, and his manipulation of the process so the bill could be brought to a vote -- it is clear that the process was indeed corrupting. The people of Wisconsin watched this sorry spectacle and took to the streets to protest it. It was deeply unpopular, and record numbers of Wisconsinites are signing recall petitions to force Republican state senators to stand for election again to defend why they stripped workers of their rights. As brazen as Walker was by stripping workers of their rights in the workplace, he can't strip their democratic right to check his abuse of power at the ballot box.

Walker's unpopularity was in further evidence when, during the past three weeks, faculty at the University of Wisconsin at the Stout and La Crosse campuses ignored his threats and insults, and voted to unionize and be represented by AFT-Wisconsin. Hundreds of employees expressed their desire to have their voices heard in the workplace.

Many champions have emerged from these fights, including the 14 Democratic Wisconsin state senators whose principled stand provided the time and space for Walker's true intentions to be revealed. The champions also include the tens of thousands of workers in Wisconsin who agreed to help address the state's fiscal problems -- which were not of their making -- but would not hand over their rights. That sentiment of shared sacrifice was echoed, day in and day out, by Wisconsinites of every stripe, who raised their voices and even slept on floors in the Capitol.

Our challenge now is to take this moment and turn it into a movement. And the way to do so is by renewing America's labor movement, which is the only institution able to fight for working people at both the ballot box and the bargaining table. What happened in Wisconsin is a blow to anyone who values democracy and fairness. But it is also a clarion call to defend these principles, and the call is being answered by thousands from across Wisconsin and beyond, who will not be cowed or silenced by this act. They are emboldened and determined to right this wrong. And Gov. Walker probably never imagined that his disregard for fairness and justice would inspire people to stand up for the very values for which he has shown such disdain.

 

Follow Randi Weingarten on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rweingarten

Over the last three weeks, Gov. Scott Walker and his allies in the Wisconsin Legislature made a mockery of representative government. Rather than listen to the citizens of Wisconsin, who are strongly ...
Over the last three weeks, Gov. Scott Walker and his allies in the Wisconsin Legislature made a mockery of representative government. Rather than listen to the citizens of Wisconsin, who are strongly ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 408
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
06:46 AM on 03/15/2011
Unions have NO place in the PUBLIC sector... The union's job is to get more money for the employees and in the PRIVATE sector this desire is balanced by the corporation and the bottom line. IF the unions demand too much, the employer can simply say - "We can't afford it and here's why...."

That relationship does NOT exist in the public sector. There is no BALANCE. The elected officials have NO stake in standing up to a union demand that it too big. All that happens is the debt or taxes increase (see CA and NY).... The Gov has acted as the boss for the TAXPAYERS.... You know, the people who pay the public employees...

OK, you may attack the messenger - as all good libs do - since you can't attack the message..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jerryengelbach
Working class heritage
10:42 PM on 03/15/2011
The union's job is to represent the workers at the bargaining table. It's included in the Constitution's right of assembly. What right has an employer, be it the state or a private company, to dictate all the terms?

Attacking the working class for the state of the economy is as low as you can go. And taxes have actually never been lower.
rogergoldkin
If you think education is expensive, try ignorance
12:28 PM on 03/16/2011
Public sector unions can and do negotiate lower wages and benefits when required. The WI unions did just that right at the beginning. What you must understand, this about union busting and nothing more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
catalyst1219
I'm a liberal, sports loving, movie geek.
10:11 PM on 03/14/2011
I'm a liberal democrat that is against pretty much everything that Walker is doing but in my opinion the Democratic state senators made a mockery of representative democracy. The PEOPLE of Wisconsin (collectively) voted a Republican governor and a state senate that was a majority Republican then the Democrats knew they would lose a vote so they left and tried to prevent the vote. If people don't want this crap to happen they shouldn't vote Republican. Vote in a Republican and I have very little sympathy for you when you have to deal with Republican policies.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jerryengelbach
Working class heritage
10:38 PM on 03/15/2011
Just because the GOP wanted something did not make it right. Read the article. If people don't want "this crap to happen" they have a right under the Constitution to assemble and petition the government for a redress of grievances. Elections are not the bottom line.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:00 PM on 03/14/2011
Hopefully a movement of the teachers back to their classrooms. No more sick days.
06:47 AM on 03/15/2011
Every teacher with a 'sick note' who is on camera at the demonstration should be fired...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jerryengelbach
Working class heritage
10:43 PM on 03/15/2011
Let's see ... you either are not a worker, or you're a backbiting one, or your kids are home-schooled, or you just like to be mean and vindictive.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spriddler
10:18 AM on 03/14/2011
Mitch Daniels in Indiana did the same thing six years ago. He watched his popularity plummet to 30% and then has steadily seen it rise; allowing him to get handily reelected. Wisonsin may well be different but obviously Mr Walker does not think so. Obama did the same thing with healthcare. Ultimately he probably will not be punished for it either. People have short memories. It will be the climate in the state come 2014 that will decide whether Mr. Walker gets reelected or not.
rogergoldkin
If you think education is expensive, try ignorance
12:29 PM on 03/16/2011
Sorry, Walker won't last that long.
photo
alongst
too often denied to speak
09:31 AM on 03/14/2011
The voters were not kind to the Dems in November. The real question is how will the voters treat the unions and run away Dems in 2012?
06:48 AM on 03/15/2011
Now that union tribute (dues) are no longer stolen from the employees automatically (they actually have to send them in - IF they want), I think you will see the unions back down.... It simply isn't profitable to be a union boss when you can't use the law to force members to pay (protection)..
Pauline Jaing
Artist, worker, mother
07:41 AM on 03/14/2011
I think the Republican Party has made it awfully clear that they intend to destroy collective bargaining everywhere they can.

This is also the lesson of Wisconsin! Its not only immigrant labor they hate, its American labor as well, all labor I suppose.
joefoss
They'll never take my panache!
05:22 AM on 03/14/2011
The lesson of Wisconsin is "think local."
=President Obama is, obviously, hopeless when it comes to defending the rights of American workers--imagine what he'll be like when he doesn't even have to pretend to care about the middle class if he manages a second term!
=So, the goal of organized labor should be to reverse the gains Republicans won in the last election in state legislatures. After all, that's where the collective bargaining-stripping laws are initiated, that's where the governors are refusing to fund their states' pension & health care plans, and that's
where, just like in the White House, tax cuts for millionaires are the order of the day.
=Some progressives think it's a sign of the strength of organized labor that two out of three "union households" in Wisconsin voted Democratic in 2010; I say it's a sign that there's more work to be done: the goal should be three out of three!
04:26 AM on 03/14/2011
Scott Walker doesn't care about getting re-elected. He was sent by the Koch Brothers and their ilk to do a job. When Walker's done he'll simply declare "Mission Accomplished", cash the Koch's checks and retire to the ranch.

Remind you of another Republican in a higher office?
photo
budanatr
US Expat in EU
01:31 AM on 03/14/2011
History will not even remember Scott Walker, although Google will.
01:12 AM on 03/14/2011
Way out here in Wisconsin we have a name for wind, rain and pariah,
The rain is Bess, the wind is Blessed,
But we call the pariah Walker.

couldn't help myself ...
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dcoverley
Fan of open windows, minds, hearts
07:59 AM on 03/14/2011
Loved that song! Good job :)
01:01 AM on 03/14/2011
Miss Weingarten and her fellow colleagues get paid just fine, plus benefits and a pension for life ... all while performing at a D+ Level. I don't understand the need for a 'Movement' when Teachers are doing just fine, in fact far better economically than the average American Family.

Time for Weingarten and the Teachers out there to do a learn a little .. learn about the hard realities of a budget and economics .. just like the rest of us, who are not net recipients of taxes, have been forced to do these past few years.
photo
maninal2
Without knowledge action is useless
07:11 AM on 03/14/2011
"Teachers are doing just fine"

Only in the context of working America being crushed by corporations and banks are the teachers doing just fine. What country are you rooting for?
06:01 AM on 03/15/2011
I'm rooting for the Taxpayers of the United States.... ie: those who subsidize Big Government and Big Education and Big Unions with their lifesblood $$. Who are you rooting for?? Big Special interests like the NEA, SEIU, higher taxes and huge Public Unions?? How do they benefit those who pay their salaries?

I'll agree the Banks laid waste to America along with horrible Government Policies pushed by Fannie / Freddie then bet on by such hacks as AIG, the Goldman Sachs, and Lehman Bros. But now that virtually every Government Entity is far in the Red .. it's time to reduce some of the massive unearned FAT sucked down by Public Employees. Enough is enough.

Teachers and Public Unions need to get some "skin in the game" and stop "getting in people's faces" .. rather than rob the kids of their future .. help ensure they have one but considering the 'Public' in so-called Public Service ... not just your own Collectively Bargained stuffed pocketbook.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dcoverley
Fan of open windows, minds, hearts
08:26 AM on 03/14/2011
Thirty years ago my father worked for Grumman. There was no union because they provided competitive wages and benefits. The strength of the union movement back then benefited all workers. That allowed my high school graduate father to provide his family with a middle class life, very similar to the life of a Wisconsin teacher today, who I guarantee has a post graduate college degree. Maninal is right. The corporations and banks have crushed our American dream. Do you want to help to pull teachers down to wallow with you, or do you want today's American Family to return to living that dream? If we are going to get the dream back we need to take it back from those who stole it.
06:40 PM on 03/14/2011
Fifty years ago we had a trade SURPLUS of $3.5 billion. Thirty years ago, when your father worked at Grumman, we had a trade DEFICIT of -$19.5 billion. Last year, we had a trade DEFICIT of $-497 billion....In 1955, we were a bona fide Super Power...not only did we have energy independence, but we provided half of the rest of the world's oil. The cash flowed in to our shores. Now we import 66% of our own oil. EVERY DAY we send $1 billion offshore to countries that don't like us very much, some of whom recycle our dollars to terrorists who kill us. The American Dream is definitely gone, and the people, the politicians, the banks, the corporations and the unions all had their greedy part. We went from The Land of Opportunity to The Land of You Owe Me. The problem is HUGE, and all the bickering and finger-pointing and crying about "rights" is not going to solve it. We need energy independence, so we are beholden to no one, and our foreign policy decisions are not based on our need for foreign oil; and we need products to sell to the world, to bring cash to our shores again. Otherwise, it's just a matter of time before the dollars we are counterfeiting become valueless.
06:06 AM on 03/15/2011
How does a post grad college degree benefit the students? Sure, it gets the Teacher an extra 10k per year, plus our taxes pay 100% of the Grad Degree .. but I just don't understand how a Masters in Math helps teach basic algebra.

maybe YOU can explain?

We aren't pulling the teachers down. Teachers and overpriced Public Employees are bringing the US Taxpayers down with their bloated costs.

Nobody on here has countered my original assertion at the top. Rather, you've all provided sideline or tangential arguments which don't address the points stated.
12:19 AM on 03/14/2011
This exact same column could have been written about Obamacare a year ago.
This American
An end to all this nonsense
03:08 AM on 03/14/2011
Rashnak, you stole my thought. There is however one fundumental difference. Obamacare steals freedom. Walker et al are returning stolen freedom to its rightful owners. The passage of Obamacare may be the high water mark for collectivism in the U.S.
photo
maninal2
Without knowledge action is useless
07:12 AM on 03/14/2011
You're wrong... HCR gives people access to health care... Walker took people's rights.
Pauline Jaing
Artist, worker, mother
07:32 AM on 03/14/2011
No. The mandate takes a huge sum of money a month from working people to pay for their adult children or thoe children face a tax penalty and the mney is for FIANNCING, for INSURANCE, which they may never use but have no choice about. Statistically, young adults rarely need health care services, so this is just a trick to make working class people pay the entire cost of insuring indigent and very poor adults.

What Walker did is about breaking the very right of workers to sit down and negotiate with ther employers over the PRICE of the sale of their labor to that employer. You say there is to be no give and take, no negotiation, no discussion, you say the employer has all the power, and none of the responsilbity, yet labor does all the real work.

You, therefore, are a thief. If you were consistent, you'd oppoe the AMA as well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveVoice
02:06 AM on 03/15/2011
I agree with you about Walker but you are dead wrong about insurance. What the mandate does is increase the size and diversity of the risk pool. If you have employer-paid health care, the insurance company calculates your premiums based on a risk pool consisting of your fellow co-workers. This means that, in a small company, a costly injury or disease to one employee can cause a huge increase in premiums, because the "risk" increases. It is more complicated than I've described but basically, the insurance company is calculating what they will have to pay out to the risk group plus expenses and profit over the next year and divides it by the number of employees - that's your premium. The larger the risk pool, the lower the costs for everyone.
photo
sixchair
Always left, usually right
11:02 PM on 03/13/2011
I suspect Walker knew he'd be recalled. He'll no doubt receive a 7-figure martyr's job in a Koch subsidiary for "getting the anti-union ball rolling". Where they miscalculated was the continuing protests and REAL grassroots mobilization against the oligarchs and their now-obvious plans.

I hope this signals the demise of the GOP in WI, not just a few short-purposed recalls. Hopefully WI can be the incubator for a national purging of the GOP as well, just as they intended it to be the template for eradicating unions. In my estimation, they are a scourge on this nation.
photo
mlaiuppa
Pres. Sarcasm Society. Like we need your approval.
11:42 PM on 03/13/2011
That job may not be realized if Koch, the Republicans and the 'baggers realize that what Walker started opened up a whole can of worms that impacted them negatively not only in 2012 and not only in Wisconsin. If it results in the mobilization of the middle class against them and the increase in unions, rather than their destruction they'll need a goat to take the blame. That will be Walker.

The poor deluded fool probably thought he'd be rewarded with a nomination to the GOP ticket in 2012. Instead he'll be a pariah.
01:04 AM on 03/14/2011
Yes, the same way Obamacare impacted Barak and the Democrats negatively in 2010 ...

George Soros has been impacting the Media, Elections, and whole economies for Decades ... he is a huge Socialist / Progressive ... I don't understand the outrage here regarding the Koch Bros given that you guys have Soros ... Hypocrisy?
photo
sixchair
Always left, usually right
12:35 PM on 03/14/2011
Could go that way too. That would be best, but then who would answer "the call" from the Koch Birch Society next time they need a rube if they throw their grunt Walker under the bus?
rogergoldkin
If you think education is expensive, try ignorance
12:45 PM on 03/16/2011
Wait until the Repubs destroy Social Security, Medicare, Medicade, public safety (FDA, NOAA, USGS), and the poor & sick. Wait until they privatize all public assets of any value. They've already teaed off the Muslims, women, gays and college kids. Now they are going after Federal workers as well. They are legislating themselves out of existence. The push back is already at a fever pitch. They are doing this while giving the very wealthy tax cuts.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thisboy
06:39 PM on 03/13/2011
Leave it to Republicans to blame School Teachers, Firefighters, and other working Americans for this country's economic mess. Their Solution? Use money saved by denying Americans benefits and social programs and give it to their wealthy Corporate overlords that caused and actually benefitted during this recession. They actually beleive that Americans that found themselves out of work since the recession hit just decided to become lazy with no "Personal Responsibility" because a bad economy seemed like a good time to become mooching hanger ons.The Right's adoration and worship for those with more wealth then themselves id sickening. They seriously think they must regularly pay tribute to these Corporate Volcanoes by sacrificing innocent Americans and their families on a regular basis. The bonuses of a few Wall Street CEO's could surpass the cost of benefits for all of WI union workers put together...
01:06 AM on 03/14/2011
I agree, and why are BOTH Democrats and GOP'ers talking about reduced Social Security benefits, increased SS taxes, and raising the SS age limit ... how is this broken promise any different?
photo
HopeLiesBleeding
Still holding out for a macro-bio
01:53 AM on 03/14/2011
Well said.
02:16 PM on 03/13/2011
Randi is covering her tracks. She has been appeasing and working with big corporations and Bill Gates on education deform. Oops, the opposition is not playing nice. Her appeasement and cozy relationships with corporations have brought us to this level. This is a nice little article but she is still making back rooms deals rather than going after the deformers. Guess she wants a job with Bill Gates. I am happy some strong union leaders are out there in DC, LA, and Chicago. I see more emerging as now the true intent of the deformers and union busters on on stage for all the world to see.
03:39 PM on 03/13/2011
Amen! I hope she actually shows up tomorrow in Texas, I've got a few things I want to say to her.