iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sen. Bernie Sanders

GET UPDATES FROM Sen. Bernie Sanders

Stop Oil Speculation Now

Posted: 06/15/11 04:52 PM ET

The increased cost of oil and gasoline is damaging the American economy and is causing severe economic pain to millions of people, especially in rural America, who often have to drive long distances to work. Many workers are already seeing stagnant or declining wages and high gas prices are just taking another bite out of their paychecks.

People in Vermont and across the country are also worried about the high price of heating oil for the coming winter.

The price of oil, while declining somewhat in recent weeks, was still over $95 a barrel today. That's about $30 higher than it was two years ago.

The theory behind the setting of oil prices is that price is determined by the fundamentals of supply and demand. The fact of the matter is that there is more supply and less demand today than there was two years ago when gas prices averaged about $2.44 a gallon.


While we cannot ignore the fact that big oil companies have been gouging consumers at the pump for years and have made almost $1 trillion in profits over the past decade, there is mounting evidence that the increased price of gasoline has nothing to do with supply and demand and everything to do with Wall Street speculators jacking up oil and gas prices in the energy futures market.

Ten years ago, speculators only controlled about 30 percent of the oil futures market. Today, Wall Street speculators control more than 80 percent of this market, even though many of them will never use a drop of this oil. Their only function in this process is to make as much money as they can, as quickly as they can.

Don't just take it from me. Let me quote from a June 2 article in the Wall Street Journal: "Wall Street is tapping a real gusher in 2011, as heightened volatility and higher prices of oil and other raw materials boost banks' profits... by 55 percent in the first quarter."

The CEO of Exxon-Mobil, Rex Tillerson, in response to a question at a Senate hearing, estimated that speculation was driving up the price of a barrel of oil by as much as 40 percent. The general counsel of Delta Airlines, Ben Hirst, and the experts at Goldman Sachs have all said that excessive speculation is causing oil prices to spike by 20-40 percent. Even Saudi Arabia, the largest exporter of oil in the world, told the Bush Administration back in 2008, during the last major spike in oil prices, that speculation was responsible for about $40 of a barrel of oil.

In other words, the same Wall Street speculators that caused the worst financial crisis since the 1930s through their greed, recklessness, and illegal behavior are ripping off the American people again by gambling that the price of oil and gas will continue to go up, and up, and up.

Sadly, the spike in oil and gasoline prices was entirely avoidable. The Wall Street reform Act, Dodd-Frank, required the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to impose strict limits on the amount of oil that Wall Street speculators could trade in the energy futures market by January 17 of this year.

Almost five months later, the CFTC has still not imposed those speculation limits. In other words, the chief regulator on oil speculation is clearly breaking the law and is not doing what it is supposed to be doing.

Last month, six other senators and I held a meeting in my office with Gary Gensler, the Chairman of the CFTC.

Unfortunately, I was very disappointed in both the tone of the meeting and the complete lack of urgency at the CFTC with respect to cracking down on oil speculators as required by law. Therefore, today I introduced legislation with Senators Blumenthal, Merkley, Franken, Whitehouse and Bill Nelson to end excessive oil speculation once and for all. I am also pleased to announce that Congressman Maurice Hinchey will be introducing this legislation in the House.

This legislation mandates that the Chairman of the CFTC take immediate actions to eliminate excessive oil speculation within two weeks.

1) Our bill requires the Chairman of the CFTC to establish speculative oil position limits equal to the position accountability levels that have been in place at the New York Mercantile Exchange since 2001.

2) Our bill requires the Chairman of the CFTC to double the margin requirements on speculative oil trading so that Wall Street investment banks back their bets with real capital.

3) Under our bill, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and other Wall Street investment banks engaged in proprietary oil trading would be classified as speculators, instead of bona-fide hedgers; and

4) The Chairman of the CFTC would be required under this bill to take any other action necessary to eliminate excessive speculation and ensure that the price of oil accurately reflects the fundamentals of supply and demand.

I am pleased to announce that this legislation already has the support of a diverse group of organizations representing small businesses, fuel dealers, consumers, workers, airlines, and farmers including: Americans for Financial Reform; the Consumer Federation of America; Delta Airlines; the Gasoline & Automotive Service Dealers of America; the International Brotherhood of Teamsters; the Main Street Alliance; the National Farmers Union; the New England Fuel Institute; Public Citizen; and the Vermont Fuel Dealers Association, just to name a few.

I want to thank Michael Trunzo the president & CEO of the New England Fuel Institute; Sean Cota the President and Co-Owner of Cota & Cota Oil; Robert Weissman the president of Public Citizen; and Professor Michael Greenberger from the University of Maryland School of Law for their leadership on this issue and for their hard work in building this diverse coalition to end excessive oil speculation.

The American people are hurting, especially in rural states like Vermont. We need action and we need it NOW.

 

Follow Sen. Bernie Sanders on Twitter: www.twitter.com/senatorsanders

 
 
  • Comments
  • 629
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (16 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marthamothra
11:04 PM on 06/22/2011
Thanks for the bill, Bernie -- as usual, you are looking out for the people, and I, for one, thank you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
funkalicious
06:04 PM on 06/20/2011
Bernie Sanders does not understand the function or the nature of the futures markets. One would hope that an individual who is entrusted with the countries well being would be well versed in international oil markets. Oil is a fungible commodity it is traded world wide the price reflects the cost to produce that commodity today and in the future.
With China,India, Pakistan and many of the emergent markets growing demand 25% year over year there is an exponential growth in the demand for oil. Heap on that metric a slide in the dollar because of Bernakes quantitative easing and our vain attempt to pay off our debts in ever cheaper dollars.
Oil will rise. the huge oil wells are being depleted the new wells will be expensive miles deep below the sea. or deep in the Artic wilderness.
When Sanders can regulate markets in Dubai, London, Paris, Frankfurt, Hong Kong, Madrid, Caracas, Rio, Shanghai, Sidney etc, etc... I guess he will be king of the world. However Sanders once again is nothing more than shouting into the wind all his bluff and bluster amounts to nothing.
03:03 PM on 06/25/2011
LOL....they won't get it
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ligligl
feelthy liberal! ...and not just a pretty face!
11:04 PM on 06/19/2011
THE PETRO BOYS THANK YOU FOR PLAYING
It is clear to me that this is a concerted effort to gradually raise the price. We should recognize that it goes in cycles - first there is a rapid rise to astonishing heights, astonishing until the public and our 'representative' take note of the public distress and threaten to take some action, It is only then that the price at the pump inexplicably begins to fall. taking the pressure off the alternative energy buzz and the congressional moves until they go away. What we don't seem to realize is that the prices never seem to fall to where they were before, not quite. The prices end up just a little higher than they were before, and ready for the next round in this game. Thanks for playing...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aonorat
US Navy Veteran; concerned senior citizen.
03:06 PM on 06/20/2011
Sander's bill (good for him) is a good start but odds of passage is very small especially in the Republican dominated House. You are absolutely correct about the game and the politicians play right along. The public starts making noise and the politicians have their public relations hearings, admonish the CEOs; subsequently nothing happens. Biggest con game ever. They all have excuses. The oil companies blame the speculators but no one forces them to sell their oil for $100 a barrel to pad their profits. It's a game the big oil companies can't lose. Your analysis is right on target. I suspect this time the price of gas might go down to about $3.50 - another big win.
03:06 PM on 06/25/2011
So lets say it does pass and becomes law .....and it works in the U.S. and reduces the price per barrel ....in the U.S. .....I wonder what happens if the price per barrel is 20 or 30.00 a barrel more on the open market ....I wonder where I would sell mu oil
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
ruleoflaw66
And I'd opt out of 'fans' too if I could.
10:39 PM on 06/19/2011
In 1968 minimum wage was $1.60 an hour.

A gallon of gas was $.33 cents

One hour of work would have bought you 5 Gallons of Gas.

Today minimum wage is $7.25 and hour.

A gallon of gas is around $4.00.

The same hour of work will get you less than 2 gallons!

THAT IS WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO THE EARNING POWER OF THE MIDDLE CLASS.

That is where all our money goes today. And this administration, like the one before it does nothing to solve either of those problems.
photo
Greyfox01
My shoe knows more than THEY do.
07:11 PM on 06/19/2011
Michel Greenberger, former director of the CFTC testified before a Congressional committee in May of 2008 on the subject of crude prices. In his testimony Greenberger stated that based on the cost of drilling, pumping, and delivering to the refineries the price of crude should be between $25 to $35 per 30 gallon barrel. The committee mandated the CFTC to develop new rules for regulating speculation in the oil, and gold markets, as well as other commodities that can be manipulated to effect world economies. The new regulations were to be presented to the Committee by January 1st of 2010, but on that very day CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler reported to the committee saying the CFTC would not have the new mandated regulations until June of 2012.

Its interesting that on November 8th of 2008, seven month after Greenbergers testimony the bottom drop out of the US economy as fuel prices pushed home owners to their limits, either buy gasoline to get to work, buy food, or pay the mortgage. The next day crude price dropped to $32 a barrel, and the national average for gasoline dropped to $1.60 as speculators ran screaming for the hills.

You can be sure the CFTC there will make compromises that will leave the oil industry and speculators with lots of wiggle room. How does the saying go? Everyone has their price.
photo
Justtheobvious
Res-erected.
09:07 PM on 06/19/2011
The CEO of ExxonMobile testified in front of congress that if it was striclty supply/demand base it would be ~$60/barrel.

Also, T. Boone pickens has made similar statements on Meet the Press.

Oil production is up 18% and drilling is up 11%....there is definately not a supply problem and demand is down.

The really messed up thing is that over Memorial day weekend gas went down. This is contrary to supply/demand reasoning. The week after prices climbed back up.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeffie 3
Don't understand their reasoning .
07:23 AM on 06/20/2011
Just a note. A barrel of oil is measured 1 barrel = 42 gallons. Also it cost from $2.00 to $7.00 total to get a barrel of oil from the ground to a shipping collection point.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dsws
No owning ideas. Limit only commercial use.
06:58 PM on 06/19/2011
Banning speculation shouldn't be the first option. When a speculative market works right, speculators are betting on actual supply and demand in later periods. If they bet opposite from the way actual supply and demand go, they lose. So they can't keep the price far from equilibrium for long.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aonorat
US Navy Veteran; concerned senior citizen.
03:16 PM on 06/20/2011
Just long enough to dramatically pad the oil companies profits until the next round. Big speculators don't lose; they get out before the major declines. Also, while in a purely speculative environment where supply and demand is in fact, the primary influence on profits, you might be correct. But in the oil world, world events and fear seems in control so speculators not only anticipate but also influence prices.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:54 PM on 06/19/2011
Nice going Bernie. This kind of speculating for sheer profit has an adverse effect on the economy and should be banned completely. Until then, these traders should be required to accept delivery of their purchase (at their personal residence) before they can sell it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dennisdelia
Injustice anywhere-Threat to justice everywhere!
04:34 PM on 06/19/2011
Make Elizabeth Warren the new sheriff in town for wall street and we'll see the laws enforced!!!

Thats why the repubs are fighting her so hard!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dennisdelia
Injustice anywhere-Threat to justice everywhere!
04:28 PM on 06/19/2011
at a time that we are in 3 wars, oil speculation hurts our military also and makes everyones expenses go up! These wall street speculators like goldman sachs are war profiteers and traitors to our people in addition to being greedy bast*rds who don't care whom they hurt as long as they can buy another house!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ligligl
feelthy liberal! ...and not just a pretty face!
11:10 PM on 06/19/2011
You seem to think that everyone has a social conscience. Obviously not true, that is why we need a government THAT REPRESENTS US to regulate what can only be classified as a quasi-utility... Too bad we don't have one...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aonorat
US Navy Veteran; concerned senior citizen.
03:23 PM on 06/20/2011
Don't forget, the oil companies play right along to pad their profits. The speculators and the oil companies aid and abet one another and the Congress plays along. Congress sits back and waits until enough public outcry. Hearings are held to admonish the CEOs of the oil companies--big public relations game. Give Bernie Sanders credit but he is probably fighting a losing battle.
maruski
Liberal Lutheran; lean left, save America!
04:05 PM on 06/19/2011
It would be a shoe in for the economy if the speculation can be contained and the price of oil drops.

It's the only game left to Obama IMHO and it is low hanging fruit IMHO. IF-- big "IF"-- he gets out on this talking about how it would help American families he might be seen as leading on this issue. That would be a good thing. None of the R's are talking about it, and he should be the one behind the lower prices when they happen.

I had a revelation the other day--I was watching an R interviewed and he kept at this meme of the President isn't leading. Well, "leading" according to Paul Ryan is talking about your point until you move the polls your way. I thought when we voted him in that Obama's oratory style was so awesome we were in for a real once in a century leader, but he is silent. I'd like to see him change that. he has the skill, he just needs to step up and do it
02:27 PM on 06/19/2011
The fact that the economy has hit a wall, can be explained by the 100 dollar per barrel oil prices. If every American has to shell out 200 to 500 dollars more out of their pocket to feed the speculators greedy pockets, that is 200 to 500 dollars less he can spend on other consumer goods. We have to get a handle on these commodity brokers and their hedge funds of billions who drive up prices, not only just for oil but for other commodities such as corn and wheat and even rice. These people are impoverishing not only Americans but the rest of the world out there.
CactusTom
My New Novel
01:49 PM on 06/19/2011
Bernie is so right in this one particular instance. But there are three things that have done in the American economy, and they are not Medicare or Social Security. First its insiders gaming the system on Wall Street, things that do nothing but fill the pockets of the few at the expense of the many. An example is Bernie's topic about driving up oil prices for insider gain. Second fighting wars in wrong,very expensive ways. And most of all extremely low 1950 tax rates, particularly on the very well off, that's been starving the government, the very institution which issues the contracts that causes business to actually do things and hire folks.

Today, on Meet the Press, Paul Gigot of the Wall Street Journal once again reiterated the myth that every dollar spent by the government takes away money from the "Free Market." This is nuts. Corporate America is sitting on a huge pile of cash.. It's government contracts for research or road building etc.that puts business to work and creates jobs. Business won't lift a figure until someone pays them to do it, and the biggest someone is government. Thus when tax rates become dangerously low economies go into the toilet.
photo
Justtheobvious
Res-erected.
09:13 PM on 06/19/2011
Businesses sell goods and services. They only employ to sell MORE goods and services. It is absolutely egregious that government bailed out the supply side and not the demand side of the equation.

F&F'd
01:49 PM on 06/19/2011
With the continual dramatic profits being made off of oil speculation, it will continue and get much worse until these actions are stopped. It will and has spread to many other commodities, driving the prices of goods higher for no reason other than to make more money for the brokers involved. Thank you Senator for trying to address this problem, and it could be done, but you're fighting lots of big money, but keep up the fight and just maybe enough attention will get you the goal of restriction from these destructive actions on our economy. Good luck.
10:27 AM on 06/19/2011
Part 1: Thanks for your hard work senators. But it is of no avail. Laws already existed and they broke them with impunity. Not only lying to investors but other financial institutes around the globe.

Trillions of dollars of taxpayer dollars later, not much has improved except for the huge profits being made by wall street, the banks and corporate America. All of them scofflaws.

The collapse caused by wall street and the banks, the bailouts, and then more fraud and more fraud. Millions lost their homes, their jobs and their pensions. They lied and cheated and stole, and during the robo-signings they misrepresented material facts to the courts and presented false and forged documents. Fines and or settlements are not enough.

Still no one is being prosecuted. Now we have oil specultion driving up the price of everything, food, material goods and travel. And still no prosecution.

If the laws currently on the books are not being enforced what good are new ones that will also be ignored?

Untill 100s or 1000s of bankers and wall street moguls are behind bars, then passing a new law is just an exercise in futility. Enforce the laws, then add new ones and more regulation.

Until such time as they are in jails, then new laws are a waste of time. Enforce the ones already in place because failing to do so time and time again is a betrayal of our failth in leadership, justice and in this country.
10:24 AM on 06/19/2011
Part 2: Armed robbery is a 30 years sentence. What wall street and the bankers did was just as dangerous, more so in gact because so many have suffered because of their greed, lack of orals, ethics and prProsecute them now, or become as complicit in their crimes as they already are. 1000s went to jail after the Savings & Loan fiasco, now is now different then before except the scale is grander.

All those jailed should have all their properties seized. inciples.

If Eric Holder won't do it, fire him, and get someone who will. All Obama has to do is tell him. So do it because these bandaid solutions are worthless unless enforced.

Go on the record in the house and the senate force to a vote the prosecution of crimes against the nation. Demand prosecution!

Let the American people see congress act on behalf of America instead of corporate America. This is a betrayal of the American people's faith in leadership, fairplay, a level playing field, the law, justice and in the very institutions we rely on for our well being and safety.

Armed robbery has a 30 year sentence. What wall street and the banks did endangered and in millions of cases robbed from the American people. Prosecute them now.

The failure to prosecute only means that not only does our government fail "We the people" but so doe the very laws we rely upon to protect life, limb and property.