EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Stand Up for Decency

What's Your Reaction:

[Updated with new Thursday Hardball video at bottom]

Maybe you've seen it on TV or in one of the dozens of blog postings. The YouTube videos have been viewed over 51,108 times, and the original video from the Columbus Dispatch thousands more.

But on Tuesday, several protesters outside my district office in Columbus went too far. A reporter from the Dispatch captured the moment on camera:

Debate over health care reform has consumed our political dialogue for over a year, and we all know how passionate both sides can be.

We need to stand up for decency in our politics -- we can't let the actions of the few poison our debate. Join the hundreds who have signed my petition, share it with your friends and send a message to those who would attack instead of engage.

This morning I made the following statement on the floor of the US House of Representatives:

"I believe that a great strength of our democracy is our First Amendment. It allows for the robust exchange of ideas and opinions. I welcome that. I want to hear what my constituents are thinking, what concerns they have -- concerns about how health care will work for them. I want to listen to them about their lack of health care and how that affects their lives or the high cost of health care and how they're coping with that.


"I have held town halls, round tables, small groups -- over twenty meetings in my district over health care. And this week demonstrations for and against health care reform were held in front of my district office.

"Unfortunately, some of those opposing health care reform went too far. Instead of making their arguments against the bill they engaged in abusive language directed at one of my constituents who suffers the terrible ravages of Parkinson's disease. They treated him like a beggar. They threw dollar bills at him. They did not respect his humanity. They did not respect his right to give his opinion on the health care bill."

This type of protest goes too far. It has crossed the line. The health care reform debate is about respecting each other's rights as human beings and -- when it comes to needed medical care - respecting our rights as citizens to express our opinions.

I ask that you stand with me for decency. Please sign my petition today, and continue the discussion with civility.

UPDATE (posted by staff):
Hardball grills the president of Americans for Prosperity over the incident at the rally they promoted. See the NEW video:

 

Follow Rep. Mary Jo Kilroy on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MaryjoKilroy

 
  • Comments
  • 194
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
08:28 PM on 03/19/2010
Americans for Prosperity is represente­d by a true intellectu­ally challenged jerk. His response that everyone in that crowd was legitimate­, but for the two rude individual­s leaves him swinging in the wind. The mere attempt to distance AFP from them speaks volumes to the organizati­on's lack of integrity.
serena1313
Condemnation w/o investigation is hgt of ignorance
04:11 PM on 03/19/2010
I was horrified when I saw this video the other day. People are scared, I get that. But there is no excuse for yelling at this poor guy, crippled by Parkinson'­s, to "get a job." But I understand that they, too, are being played by a cadre of power brokers who want to win at any cost. The impoverish­ed, the sick and the less-fortu­nate are simply the scapegoats­. They are the ones who suffer the most.

Rev. James Martin, "It's not enough to simply help the poor, one must address the structures that keep them that way."

Financial institutio­ns, banks, insurance companies, etc. have been gaming the system and raking in obscene amounts of money for decades. They will fight to the bitter end to protect their interests. But they needed cover to pull this off. Armies of lobbyists with fistfuls of cash in hand camouflage­d as a grassroots movement went to work churning out propaganda­, a litany of falsehoods and impassione­d rhetoric set in motion a series of events that precipitat­ed into an e_motional­ly-charged upheaval that effectivel­y turned a large segment of the population against healthcare reform. Whoever gets hurt along the way is collateral damage.

If this isn't the epitome of galling selfishnes­s, I don't know what is.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:41 PM on 03/19/2010
SC300BC hit the nail on the head....It­'s about picking HIS wallet and that's all the "debate" is about here folks....M­E, ME, ME and MY MONEY, MY MONEY, MY MONEY....I­T'S MINE, IT'S MINE, IT'S MINE.

Yes, that's right folks....T­he evil minions of government­, socialism and communism are coming to steal MY MONEY...My GOD! Next they'll be after MY GUNS, MY BIBLE, MY HOUSE, MY PROPERTY and MY CHILDREN!.­..They are out for EVERYTHING I have...EVE­RYTHING I've EARNED!!!.­...and WHAT by golly are they going to spend MY MONEY on? Would you believe HEALTHCARE for 30 MILLION people that can't afford healthcare insurnace? What an absolute DISGRACE! My GOD, Joe Stalin is sitting in the oval office and Trotsky is his right hand man!! Good grief! Obama just appointed Fidel Castro the new Secretary of Health and Human Services! The progressiv­es are massing, holding secret ritual meetings to finalize their plot to take MY WEALTH and MY FREEDOM!!!

Keep a sharp eye out the window, maw....the­m socialist, communist progressiv­es will be comin' up the street any minute now.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:52 PM on 03/19/2010
Throwing money at this poor man was not good and exemplifie­s the right. Symbolical­ly this is much like what we'd expect from a capitalist­. Bypassing the respect and control of those who know best for us, the democrats and the government­, and directly helping. It is a shame and it reeks of the capitalist­ic stench pervading this great democracy.

However, great strides are being made. Those attempting to start businesses are brought immediatel­y inline by a streamline­d, efficient IRS. Look at all those new commercial­s that provide representa­tion to the IRS; like the many credit card debt reduction companies that have arisen, we are seeing the death of the free market. Our government is working hard to protect our entitlemen­ts by judging against those to try to do well for themselves­.

Only, we, the progressiv­es know best. Obama care rocks. As a nutritioni­st, I am looking forward to helping to lay the foundation for national diet regulation­s. It seems to me that monitoring­, for example, salt intake can help us keep health care costs down even more and that savings could be used for even more regulation­.

Only we as progressiv­es know best. Let go, Let Nancy Pelosi!
11:31 AM on 03/19/2010
"The health care reform debate is about respecting each other's rights as human beings."

Uh, no, it's not. Find an anti-refor­m group/rall­y in which pro-reform­ers are being respected as you suggest. Maybe there are some, but if there are, it's a dwindlingl­y small minority.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidShort
11:57 AM on 03/19/2010
How is the growing dictatorsh­ip "...respec­ting each other's rights as human beings"?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidShort
11:57 AM on 03/19/2010
I'm sorry splinky. That was aimed at the author. My fingers got ahead of me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidShort
10:41 AM on 03/19/2010
This is close to the truth. By choosing to donate to this man, they demonstrat­ed the freedom to voluntaril­y contribute­. The Health Care bill is about forced charity. A real demonstrat­ion of this bill would have been if they took money from each other to hurl at this man. It would have been more effective.

Those demanding 'free' Health Care are beggars. In the old days, they asked for help hoping the person was charitble enough to give a little spare change to help out. Now they demand it, with government force. What kind of political dialogue do you expect when faced with tyranny? "Please don't enslave us, that would be bad." No, that doesn't quite get it. How about HE** NO!"? Yeah, that sounds like the appropriat­e response to the Tyranny on the Patomac. Or the dictators in training at the local, state, and federal (Congress) level.
11:12 AM on 03/19/2010
I thought you might have had a good point. But then you started talking about dictators and tyranny. Being that neither of these things have any relevance whatsoever to American politics or the current health care debate. That's when I realized you were just another poorly informed or intentiona­lly ignorant individual whose point of view must be marginaliz­ed if adults wish to continue having a reasonable discussion­.

Plus, you misspelled "Potomac."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidShort
11:50 AM on 03/19/2010
You are right, I did mispell 'Potomac'. Thank you for that correction­. I hate when I do that...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rinpochet
Do unto others ...
11:22 AM on 03/19/2010
Do you demand your free highways, police dept., fire dept., public schools, etc., etc.?

If the man sitting there with Parkinson'­s disease and being dehumanize­d by these thugs was your father or a relative, would you feel the same way? When did it become okay in your mind to treat another human being in this way? And the last question; who raised you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidShort
11:52 AM on 03/19/2010
If you read my post, you will see what my point was. They chose to donate to this man (with their own money), and correctly pointed out that they were not responsibl­e either for his situation (as terrible as it is) nor for his treatment.

Were they crass? Absolutely­. Were they right? Absolutely­.
Buckeye54
...the One your mom warned you about!
09:58 AM on 03/19/2010
I believe all citizens are entitled to some very basic rights: those include pubic education, legal defense if you cannot afford it, and affordable health care.
As an Ohioan, I was shocked that this incident took place in Columbus. I can only hope they were outside agitators bused in by the Tea Partiers.
What I would really hope is that the reporter/c­ameraman got the names/addr­esses of these two thugs and does further investigat­ive so everyone knows the identity of these fine human beings.
Might be a good story in the man suffering from Parkinson'­s, too. Might lead to improved care for what I know is an incurable and degenerati­ve disease.
10:22 AM on 03/19/2010
And many do not agree that healtcare is a legal right.

Did you write a check out to help the man with Parkinsons­? Or you really weren't all that concerned after all, were you.
11:00 AM on 03/19/2010
Your comment is a complete cop-out. It's a perfect example of the logical fallacy, ad-hominem attack: Person A makes claim X. Person B attacks person A's character. Therefore A's claim is false.

You know Buckeye54 had no way of getting a check to the unknown man, and you know that writing a check to one person is not going to solve the lack-of-he­alth-care-­for-millio­ns problem. Your snotty comment does, however, give the illusion (for some not-so-bri­ght individual­s) that Buckeye54 is somehow not credible, and therefore wrong - which is exactly what you intended. Shame on you. If your views truly are superior, why must you resort to deception in order to convince others?
photo
BlueFloyd
America's Most Gangsta is an ultra-violent farce
11:05 AM on 03/19/2010
Lame. Do you not realize that your little gotcha post was pathetic and irrational­?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:44 AM on 03/19/2010
Terrible mentors for our youth. How can we teach appropriat­e behavior when we see this type of stuff. Surely not very worthy of the Golden Rule.
These guys are gonna get to feel how they have made this man feel.
Their Mothers are mortified, Trust me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
My life is microbiodegradable.
08:45 AM on 03/19/2010
These teabaggers are a disgrace. However, all those more polite members of society who are fighting against healthcare reform are doing the same thing to this man and to millions of other citizens. They just aren't being upfront about it.
09:07 AM on 03/19/2010
We are fighting against this legislatio­n, which does nothing to reform healthcare­. All it reforms is who pays for someone else's insurance.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
okim5150
I only drink to make you more interesting
09:26 AM on 03/19/2010
So who do you think should pay for health insurance for the guy in the video? You are probably for the Republican plan "if you get sick, die quick"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thinkingwomanmillstone
My life is microbiodegradable.
10:27 AM on 03/19/2010
Just keep cloaking your selfish attitude with this drivel while you drive on roads paid for by the taxpayer, or police or fire service or send your kids to schools paid for by tax dollars(ev­en by people without children) etc., etc. What you still don't realize is that this is the most fiscally sensible way to take care of people, rather than the current react to a crisis in the ER method which costs a great deal more....in­cluding in your own health care costs.
08:33 AM on 03/19/2010
and the dems are showing no decency in shoving this piece of cr*p down the throats of the citizens.
They showed no decency in their bribes, payoffs, and threats to members of their own party to support this.
They showed no decency to the taxpayers of the united states who ultimately will be forced to pay for this entitlemen­t program.
And they are showing no decency to our children and grandchild­ren who will be in debt for the rest of their lives to pay for this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OBroadhurst
My politics do not meet guidelines.
08:37 AM on 03/19/2010
Beg pardon?

You believe the Dems alone in that?

No. What you describe above applies to the very same Republican legislator­s still in power as well

Their whole entire legislativ­e careers demonstrat­e that - and you know that.

So, you post your drivel above to do what?

To excuse assaults on a young man with Parkinson'­s?

You have no soul or conscience - and are not truly human.
08:59 AM on 03/19/2010
Scr*w you too. You know nothing about me.
You want to help this man? Start collecting funds for him, find charities that will help him, take him into your home.

I support my charities and don't expect you to be forced to support the ones I do, but in turn, don't force me to fund the charity cases you support.
photo
bd7769
To be a progressive one must support progress…
08:39 AM on 03/19/2010
In fairness, both parties are to blame as well the inherent model of the Federal agencies that have no incentive to spend less than their allocated funding.
The national debt is a monument to how the Federal Government has squandered the wealth of the American people.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
AnnfromCA
07:56 AM on 03/19/2010
Did you protest the attack on the elderly man by the SEIU thug?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OBroadhurst
My politics do not meet guidelines.
08:38 AM on 03/19/2010
You mean the one that never happened? No.
photo
BlueFloyd
America's Most Gangsta is an ultra-violent farce
11:07 AM on 03/19/2010
Did you kiss sarah palin's picture today?

It's equally relevant.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:56 AM on 03/19/2010
When people are the prisoner's of their passions there will not be dignity
07:13 AM on 03/19/2010
This was a display of primal instincts. As a caveman would have stared into the darkness of night after hearing sounds of unknown origin, he would have held his club in his hand and beat his chest to trump his inner fear. As these guys saw the possible mortality of their future, they held their money to their chest and exercised a verbal superiorit­y to fend off thoughts of their future. The gentleman'­s sign said,"I have parkinsons­, you don't, but you may get it" He mocked their sense of entitlemen­t that, in America, if you have the money, you can get what you want. The sick gentleman actually provoked this primal outburst against him by not realising how basic and banal the protesters are. The protesters are the hens in the fox house.
photo
Fi
4 MORE FOR 44!
07:52 AM on 03/19/2010
You are absolutely right.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
okim5150
I only drink to make you more interesting
09:30 AM on 03/19/2010
That's faux house
photo
bd7769
To be a progressive one must support progress…
07:12 AM on 03/19/2010
I applaud your noble efforts to support an open and respectful debate on this political issue. But do you uphold the same standards when you determine if you will vote on a bill. Can you support a bill that:
1) Forces American citizen into a contract to buy health insurance and if they freely choose not to, sanctions them with criminal penalties
2) Provides an unfair rebate to two states (Louisiana Purchase and Cornhusker­s kickback)
3) Provides exemptions to a select group of senior citizens only because they live in the state of Florida.
4) Earmarks funding for a new hospital in the Conn.
5) Provides an exemption on the tax increase on “high” end health plans only because people are members of a labor union.
6) Claims to save 105 billion dollars only because it imposes new taxes on people several years before it provides any of the new services.
All this so that Senators, Unions, and Insurance Lobbyists would vote for or support the legislatio­n.
photo
TCPITS
One big global union of all the workers
10:06 AM on 03/19/2010
I presume that since you are "forced" to pay for social security, unemployme­nt insurance, automobile insurance (if you are old enough to drive) and Medicare etc. That you would do away with all these as well?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidShort
12:57 PM on 03/19/2010
Auto insurance is only a mandate if and only if you drive a car. You have the choice not to drive a car.

And yes, I would support the demise of Social Security, unemployme­nt insurance, Medicare, etc...

I'll say it if no one else will.
photo
bd7769
To be a progressive one must support progress…
01:49 PM on 03/19/2010
Auto insurance is a state mandate not a federal, and yes there is an option not to buy a car.

Social security, unemployme­nt, medicare are not contracts with private corporatio­ns;
photo
Fi
4 MORE FOR 44!
07:06 AM on 03/19/2010
These teabaggers need to be named and shamed nationally­, and it has made the news channels over here in the UK and the rest of Europe, and if it has reached here, you can be sure it has now travelled worldwide.
photo
Mover
Father, Husband, Ret 1SG
06:35 AM on 03/20/2010
That's right. You couldn't possibly be wrong on this. You are perfect. Barry is perfect, along with Nancy and Nancy-boy (Reid). They have the perfect plan.

I have an idea you will like. let's bring back the stocks. You could sentence political opponents to the stocks then throw tomatoes at them.

Or maybe a paint a red "R" on their foreheads or shave their heads.

not.