More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rev. Barbara Kaufmann

GET UPDATES FROM Rev. Barbara Kaufmann
 

When the Empire Strikes, Will the People Strike Back?

Posted: 07/18/11 11:35 AM ET

If I were keeping score in the epic battle of good versus evil on this planet, I would calculate the events of last week thus: Light- one; Darkness- zero. Everybody senses that there is more at stake in the Murdoch affair than the management of newspapers and a "naughty" media-gone-wild. Everybody is right. It's our humanity that's at stake. Score one last week for human dignity and for treachery -- zero. We intuitively know that pirating someone's private information in order to carve them up on the front page is more than a little wrong.

This epic battle being waged currently on the global modern-day stage is not a new one; what is ironic though, is that it has surfaced within the industry that represents us to us. It's the same media that so often captures that battle in film or brings it into our living rooms courtesy of TV. The archetypal theme is well documented in history, is very familiar and is played out over and over in media itself and cinematically in a theater near you. The modern version of this epic good v. evil keeps returning -- seen in its modern version in Harry Potter, James Cameron's Avatar, Star Wars, Lord of the Rings and poignantly in an eerily clairvoyant film from the seventies called Network about media struggles for ratings and a network that will do anything to get them.

Network is a movie worth renting and revisiting. The heroes are the people (culture) who at the behest of a newsman-turned-evangelist (savior figure) get up from their chairs (complacency) and go the windows (public forum) and yell "I'm as mad as hell and I am not going to take it anymore."

That precise scenario played out over Twitter, Facebook, the Internet and mainstream media with hurricane fury last week. The Twitter storm was a result of a perfect storm of events that came together to create a climate where people felt empowered and motivated to speak out because they are filled up on treachery (anything goes on the airwaves and in print) and apparently want the paradigm to change.

When we watch stories play out, we intuitively know who the villains are and we applaud the heroes that swoop in to sweep the darkness away for us. The same is true in this story. What ultimately happens in this saga and the outcome will be a vote for human dignity, decency and civility -- or it won't. It will end bullying by a media that has grown to become the biggest offender on the global block, or it will by default, invite public bullying to become even more entrenched and more powerful in the culture of the twenty first century. Humanity always writes its own legacy and often its destiny.

The railing was against Rupert Murdoch's News Corp -- a $33 billion industry with a long reach. Holdings are worldwide and include Europe and the U.K with The Times, the Sunday Times, The Sun, e Financial News, The Times Literary Supplement, The Wall Street Journal Europe and the recently sacrificed News of the World; in the U.S. holdings include The Wall Street Journal, New York Post, Barrons, Community News Group, Dow Jones Local Media Group, and Seven News Information Services; Asia claims The Wall Street Journal Asia; and in Australia includes The Australian, The Daily Telegraph, The Herald Sun, The Advertiser and 150 others. And that's just Murdoch's media empire. Other holdings include 10 film companies including Twentieth Century Fox; Fox News, Fox Cable, Fox News and 27 Fox outlets; National Geographic International; from 25 to 39 percent of 3 Satellite TV markets; Harper Collins publishers U.S. and India; News Corp Digital Media which includes My Space and IGN Entertainment.

That's a lot of money, a lot of power, but more importantly, it's a lot of influence. Especially when that influence is used to hack into people's private phone messages, emails and medical records -- to use that private information to write salacious and sensational stories about peoples' lives and troubles. These stories, then, are offered up to the public as fact, not as a public service -- but in the guise of "newsworthy" simply, cynically, and only to sell newspapers. And in tabloid journalism, the truth has never been allowed to interfere with a good story.

Media -- the very venue that could have been a bastion standing for democracy and truth has become its worst offender. Some media, reminiscent of mafia, dominates the culture and cultivates a them-against-us mentality. It could just as easily encourage unity. People sensed the wrongness of hacking, of fostering a society of deceit, and the mercenary splaying of private lives and private information for sport on front. People were as mad as hell and it sounds like they don't want to take it anymore. Score one for humanity.

Murdoch, who inherited his business from his father in his homeland Australia, imported his brand of journalism to Britain beginning the rein of the tabloids. "Fleet Street" boasted about choosing the Prime Minister for the English public and even a wife for Prince Charles by asking in big headlines: "Charles why haven't you popped the question to Diana?" The sardonic and cynical tone and the tactics of tabloid journalism were cultivated and encouraged by Murdoch himself according to former tabloid journalists become biographers in tell all confession books like Yellow Journalism, Tabloid Baby, Tabloid Prodigy and revealed in programs like Frontline.

The financial success of the tabloid press did not go unnoticed by competitors and initial resentment turned to copycat tactics and junk journalism in Britain and then America. It ultimately leaked its way into, and contaminated, mainstream media. This tabloid turn toward making public figures fair game became traditional during the Clinton tenure in the White House. Dirty laundry trumped the news and essentially became the news. News anchor Walter Cronkite, called 'the most trusted man in America,' warned of what he saw as "the loss of journalistic integrity" and the death of an icon came to represent to many, the end of a noble era.

This ancient battle revisited has all the makings of a modern revolution. Will it come to that? It depends on humans and collective human consciousness. It depends on whether the race is ready to evolve. It depends on whether we have had enough of powerful people deliberately and cynically pandering to our darkest impulses rather than our brightest inspirations. It depends on whether the recent incendiary, spontaneous, passionate revulsion and desire for change was just a temporary flash of insight that will die down quickly (some in media are hoping it will) or whether the human race is truly ready to take a step to move the race forward.

Until last week, it seemed that the public might be forever at the mercy of a system that existed only to feed its own machine. The industry serves up information and people to a public it claims is hungry for this kind of information and "entertainment." But which came first -- the chicken or the egg? Allowing the fox to explain chicken to chickens is either stupid or incestuous or both. Is it really human nature for humanity to salivate over its own degradation? Or did the media create and cultivate a climate for darkness and then serve it up to the masses? In a defense for the irresponsible use of the first amendment, we often hear the excuse "but if the public didn't clamor for this stuff, there wouldn't be a market for it! We are only giving the people what they want!"

That's the same argument used by tobacco companies trying to convince a public that it was only providing a product the public wanted all the while researching and employing methods to get consumers addicted to something that their own research showed would kill them. The fact that the product killed their consumers did nothing to raise the standards of the industry; it prompted more seductive marketing strategies in order to replace the self-extinguishing users with new subscribers.

Predictably, Murdoch and media think tanks will hope that this all dies down and goes away or will pray that our attention span is so short that we will all soon get back to business as usual. The American media will try to ignore the story as it grows to engulf more and more of the industry and the world. Some guilty themselves of tabloidization in their work will, of course, try to distance themselves from the scandal. Some will lose interest. Others will hide, cover or disguise themselves to hide the egg conspicuously decorating their face.

But if we all go back to business as usual, our humanity takes a step backward. So who will subdue this looming Goliath of darkness; who will be our hero? Who will demand that we turn toward the Light? Maybe it's us. Maybe we are the ones we have been waiting for? It's our world. It's our minds that are being used as dumpsters. Are you sick of it yet? Retreating to the recliner and the remote is not going to solve the problem. It's not going to push the race forward or make the world a better place. If you're really not going to take it anymore you have to become your own hero -- get up from the chair of complacency and use your voice. Tell them you're 'mad as hell and you're not going to take it anymore.'

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
08:21 AM on 07/26/2011
Rev Kaufman bravo! Wonderful article. I hope the Murdoch shake down starts a new paradigm
we as a society will no longer tolerate tabloid journalism. It isn't okay to carve people up and put it on the front page of a paper for all to read. Journalists need to be professional not sensational. I want to be given facts and the turth, not fiction and garbage. I hope we all wake up and not buy the tabloid papers, don't feed the monster.
05:51 PM on 07/23/2011
Yes! I am "mad as hell" and I will do my part to keep the spurs to the media's flanks.

Thank you, Reverend Kaufmann. I hope people WILL awake from their complacent stupor and RECOGNIZE the importance of this scandal and why it may have implication for governments worldwide, multi-national corporations and any entity and individual that possesses extreme power and influence.

My fear is that the general public will simply cock an ear, worrying more about the economy and what effect it will have on them. In fact, UNTIL each person understands the disastrous consequences such a discovery has to wreak havoc on all of us, stressing constantly about the economy will be akin to worrying about a hangnail. This has every component to be as big or bigger than Watergate. It's just going to take some determined Woodward-Bernstein-esq reporters to work it tenaciously.

Why do people find it so interesting to read outrageous tabloid journalism. When my senses are assaulted at the grocery checkout with rag after rag proclaiming the most scandalous headlines and truly damaging "claims" and photos of not only celebrities, but ordinary folks, too, I just shake my head and ask, "Is this what we've become?" Humanity struggles to evolve. We are a very young species and hopefully, with our “supposed” superior reasoning power, we will...soon! Frankly, after living my life with many members of the animal kingdom, I truly question who the most intelligent species really is.
03:19 PM on 07/23/2011
This is an excellent article. The human propensity to objectify and exploit others has been targeted by media moguls in their never ending quest for the almighty dollar. That it did not concern us that people were having their privacy and rights violated is a result of the bystander effect,mentality that comes from objectifying and depersonalizing celebrities who we use for our own pleasure.

All of this needs to stop. Murdoch would not have been successful in his campaign to create a celebrity culture if people did not buy into gossiping and maligning others for sports, so much so that their privacy no longer mattered.

It's time to ask ourselves: How have I contributed to this celebrity culture? How have I promoted it or turned a blind eye. What can I do to change?
Every human being has the right to have space to be themselves, to have a life. It is very easy to point the finger at Murdoch and say how dare he, (and why not, he is guilty as sin) but it is not as easy to ask ourselves, how have we violated the private space of others?

It's time for us to reclaim our humanity. To begin to treat others with the same respect, care, regard & compassion with which we would want our own selves to be treated, or the members of our family.

No man is an island. What effects you, effects me - effects everyone in the world. I hope this time WE
12:28 PM on 07/23/2011
outstanding synopsis by the Reverend Barbara Kaufmann. Outside of lone voices like hers, there is no such thing as Journalism anymore and hasn't been for quite some time. Its all a great deal of cannibalistic violation of human beings that makes the "news" now, pandering to what is most low in humans. This keeps us distracted from how malevolent corporations who own and control the Mafia-ized Media are destroying the Mother - Earth - and pushing us over the cliff of our own extinction. Will we wise up in time and outlaw corporate control of what used to be an institution dedicated to exposing Corporate Assault on We The People, and the planet we cannot survive without? Does ANYbody give a damn about their children and grandchildren and what we are dooming them to, by allowing these Murdochian Monsters to continue controlling, manipulating and strangling to death TRUTHFUL, WELL-RESEARCHED AND SUBSTANTIATED NEWS, and what is supposed to be a warning, protective voice of and for We The People?
06:57 AM on 07/23/2011
Barbara Kaufmann writes - "It's our minds that are being used as dumpsters. Are you sick of it yet?"

Yes, im sick of it. I'm sick of seeing people being bullied, degraded and disrespected. I want the media to stop walking through my mind with their dirty feet.

I want them to deliver genuine, unbiased and unslanted news. I want to see more humanitarian stories highlighting ordinary people doing extraordinary things. I want to be informed and uplifted, not stepped on and abused.

I want and expect the media not to tell us what they think we want to hear, but to tell us the whole story and let us decide for ourselves.

I want to see the narrative on this planet change for the betterment of all humanity. To continue down the path we are currently on will ultimately prove disastrous in the end.
07:21 PM on 07/22/2011
"Now is the time for consciousness starting to awaken and tabloid business to be shaken."
06:15 PM on 07/22/2011
A well thought out commentary on what is wrong with society today and has been for a long time. As stated, too many people have become complacent in watching people become objects of degradation for sport. While the greedy are lining their pockets with billions on the blood of innocent people, we have sat back and allowed it. Well I say no more. It is time that we stood together and defended our rights to privacy, and decency and truth in repoting. We cannot let them slide when they are breaking laws and destroying lives, and doing it for nothing more than ratings which equal as always to one thing, the almighty dollar. People are not commodities. We are not disposable, to be used and then tossed aside when something better comes along. We have rights to privacy. When those rights are violated with no recourse, it leaves us vulnerable and helpless. No more. I have lost so much respect for the media. However, what has transpired over the last several weeks has given me cause to believe that it will be from this point forward, moving in a new direction. Though it will not change the damage already done to many people over time, it is certainly giving cause for people to re-evaluate their truths. Many lives were forever changed, damaged, and even lost as a direct result of theses malicious, vehement, unethical tactics. These revelations could not have come soon enough. Thank God they are finally here.
04:52 PM on 07/22/2011
Thank you Barbara for an enlightening perspective on the Murdock scandal. Many people could care less about the trashing of celebrities in the news, (as this story was originally characterized). They really don't include them as 'one of us'. It wasn't until innocent victims were violated that the public became outraged. It's like a cancer that was allowed to spread until it infected the vital organs and life itself was threatened. The time has arrived when the most can be accomplished if we all speak out for a new definition of truth, human decency, and morality in the way we research, report, and analyze what information we feel is really relevant to society. Hopefully ours is a society that cherishes the humanity and divine in all of us versus one that wants to use the media to dehumanize and exploit at all costs-even its own.
03:48 PM on 07/22/2011
Already you can see how the main stream media can't handle the real impact of the Murdoch Madness....no, it's more important that we see and hear over and over how his wife helped to prevent a pie from hitting his face....so now we need to learn more about her.... not about the damage done to the institution of ethical journalism and what that means to our democracy and the people's right to know the whole truth and nothing but the truth...
03:37 PM on 07/22/2011
(continued...) So far, most attention has gone to illegal acts and corporate corruption. Let's also seize this opportunity to shine a light on the non-existent ethics of modern journalism. The evidence is ubiquitous. Lazy cut-and-pasting, without any research or checking, of 'facts' off the internet, glibly glossed over with phrases like 'according to sources...'. The vicious 'build em up, knock em down' game, played out all the time. The downright lies to make something boring seem like a story; and important truths omitted, in case they undermine the so-called story. Cheque-book journalism. Journalism needs to sort itself out - it is not a profession any more.

The media are trying every trick in the book. Look how they tried to condition us by pointing out that 'many people' would now feel sympathy for poor old Rupert, since someone threw a pie at him and he is quite old. Look how they're all being so holier-than-though, doubtless ensuring that all the evidence has been deleted or shredded before claiming that all the transgressions and illegalities were limited to the NotW. Don't be fooled, they are all the same. Murdoch's lot are just the first. Let's make sure we finish the job and do not just leave it there. The media themselves will move the agenda on as soon as they can, switching back to celebrity rehab or sports stars having affairs. Let's not let them get away with it.
02:53 PM on 07/22/2011
I do hope that people begin to see how we all suffer when tabloids cause needless suffering in the name of entertainment.
02:38 PM on 07/22/2011
Thank you for this very timely article, Rev. Kaufmann. I hope you will continue to follow up on this story as it continues to unfold.

"If you're really not going to take it anymore you have to become your own hero -- get up from the chair of complacency and use your voice. Tell them you're 'mad as hell and you're not going to take it anymore.'"

This statement is so true, Barbara. It reminds me of the Freedom Riders during the Civil Rights Movement who rode interstate buses from Washington, DC to New Orleans to test the Supreme Court decision, Boynton v. Virginia of 1960. These brave men and women, both black and white, became their own heroes when they decided they weren't going to take it anymore and mounted a non-violent protest by riding into some very dangerous territories in the south.

We do have the power to make a change for the better, including demanding that journalist live by their code of ethics. It is NOT alright to dehumanize a person for profit. We must lift our voices if we want humanity to take a step forward or the next victim may be you.
02:30 PM on 07/22/2011
Thank God, for bringing this industry DOWN, for ending their reign or terror and deceit and canabalism, for awaking your children to the evil they have done and continue to do in this world.
01:23 PM on 07/22/2011
I have to admit to saying that everything has a essence of good versus bad, Just think about it humanity should be against cigarette companies which are holding hands with tobacco companies and the Media companies are holding hands with the smut newspaper companies and the lawyers and doctors in society are holding hands with both the insurance agencies and the pharmacutical companies so think about it. Everyone has a stake in something somewhere!!!
06:43 PM on 07/20/2011
Stop Phone Hacking at source

Make mail boxes secure. At present -

How to hack voice mail

Find someone's mobile phone number
Dial it
As the message is playing key in the hash sign, and put in their personal code
The default setting is often 0000
Otherwise set up a computer dial programme to go through the 9,999 alternatives -
Bingo - you are into their mail box

This is so easy that it is unreal.
Stop hacking at source - make voice mail secure

Why do people hack into peoples' mail box?? because they can - this is time for some real security - Phone companies must set up proper security on phone message boxes

PLEASE PASS THIS INFORMATION ON