iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rev. Jennifer Butler

GET UPDATES FROM Rev. Jennifer Butler
 

The Golden Calf and Occupy Wall Street

Posted: 10/13/11 11:03 PM ET

As the #OccupyWallStreet movement continues to flourish as a national symbol of outrage at economic injustice and inequality, faith leaders are bringing a new dimension to the demonstrations in New York. I'm an ordained Presbyterian (PCUSA) minister, and I traveled to Wall Street last weekend with a lay Catholic friend dedicated to fighting for economic justice. Our other passenger was an inanimate object that spoke volumes -- a statue of a golden calf -- a powerful symbol of idolatry in Jewish, Christian and Muslim traditions.

On Sunday, we joined hundreds of people for an interfaith worship service at Judson Memorial Church and march to reflect on the condemnation of greed throughout Scripture. The calf was displayed in the sanctuary during worship and carried at the front of our procession through Lower Manhattan. In church and in the streets, the cheers and prayers were overwhelming. Photographers and TV crews flocked to us. Apparently you don't need to know your Exodus to understand a symbol of idolatry.

People know deep down that greed has been idolized for too long in our nation, with disastrous economic and spiritual consequences, and our effort struck that chord. Americans have wised up to the fact that bad actors on Wall Street -- and their servants in Washington -- have segregated a grossly unjust concentration of our nation's wealth in the hands of the people whose recklessness and greed caused our economic collapse. And we know from experience that working hard and playing by the rules doesn't bring the security that it used to. And we're outraged. We recognize a great sin and injustice in our midst.

This awakening has scared the hell out of the defenders of the status quo, and they're going on the attack. Karl Rove calls us "left-wing crazies," and House Majority Leader Eric Cantor described us as a "growing mob" at a recent religious right conference. Turn on Fox News at any time of day and you'll see pundits throwing around terms like "anti-American" and "class warfare."

What they may not realize is that there's no turning back. Not when the nation has realized an unjust truth. Not when the inspiring and sustaining power of faith is directed toward building a more just economic order. We're not going to forget what we've seen and go back to our homes and our churches like none of this ever happened. We finally, truly understand that greed really is a pervasive sinful force that must be confronted, not a necessary thing that leads to prosperity.

The faith community's movement for economic justice didn't start in Zuccotti Park in September. In addition to overcoming Jim Crow, Martin Luther King Jr. worked to end poverty for people of all races in all places. Since the Tea Party has taken over Washington, we've organized to protect the poor and the vulnerable from immoral budget cuts and confronted politicians who pay lip service to the Gospel but pursue an economic agenda inspired by Ayn Rand. We're working to hold predatory banks accountable, not only on Wall Street, but in cities across the country.

Scripture is replete with examples of people backsliding into sin after progressing toward righteousness. It would be foolish to believe that we are ushering in a golden age free of greed. But the occupiers are helping to end the era in which it is celebrated and rewarded with obscene wealth and power. And it's fitting that the faith community is part of it.

 
As the #OccupyWallStreet movement continues to flourish as a national symbol of outrage at economic injustice and inequality, faith leaders are bringing a new dimension to the demonstrations in New Yo...
As the #OccupyWallStreet movement continues to flourish as a national symbol of outrage at economic injustice and inequality, faith leaders are bringing a new dimension to the demonstrations in New Yo...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Juanne Michaud
Proud Canadian, loony lefty
07:49 AM on 10/17/2011
I am no fan of organized religion (I bolted years ago and have not been back since). However, I think spirituality is massively important to individuals and society as a whole. (No, I do not advocate a theocracy -- I have read history).

My belief is that we are more than a collection of atoms; life is more than linear and the material world is not all there is. Most people recognize this in one form or another; there is a yearning to fill the void that the lack of spirituality creates.

When you try to fill that hole with stuff, you are inevitably not satisfied, and you need more and more. Also, you look about you and see what others have, and decide if you can keep up with your co-workers or rivals, that will make you happy.

But really, how much stuff do you need? How many houses, cars, $10,000 purses and $25,000 sunglasses must you have to be happy?
researcher
researcher
01:08 AM on 10/17/2011
"To be content with little is hard; to be content with much, impossible". Marie von Ebner-Eschenbach

americans are as much responsible for the greed on wall street as those that are on wall street doing their scams and they have have taken on greed as their god and savior.

greed knows no boundaries and deregulated capitalism allows individual and corp greed to be on steroids.

americans love their capitalism more than their bibles and when it does it thing like we see on wall street, we blame the individuals. without regulations some humans will go nuts with greed even think they are doing god's work as they scam americans and their pension funds.

if you think it is bad now wait until wall street gets their greedy hands on education and social security. you aint seen nothing yet in greed; wait until they scam the kids and seniors like they have the medical insurance for the sick and needy.

really the evangels consider america a christian nation. really. interesting perception of a christian nation.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JewishPhysician
fraternity, trust, discourse
01:05 AM on 10/16/2011
Occupy movements as we have thus are sheer Anarchy movements. True they may have some injustice and wickedness on their list of complaints, but shooting at the stars and asking God to forgive you for getting his attention by destroying his Creation is not a very likely scenario for someone to find reform and true betterment in their lives and their whole universe. So guess what HP users, I being a liberal support their message that they may have, but their means at distributing this message is a cause I will NOT support. I believe they would be better off protesting in a political venue such as a state capital rather than in the middle of our commerce sections of Prosperous America. Thanks!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:30 PM on 10/14/2011
I want Mooby's burger :3
06:26 PM on 10/14/2011
What is greed and how does it grow? It is like a virus and can kills many. It would seem it would have to stop in ones heart and mind but that is very hard to break.
05:11 PM on 10/14/2011
It will be very hard to determine where this protest will end. It will only get bigger and bigger with no place to go. As stated above, people know deep down that greed has been idolized for too long in our nation, with disastrous economic and spiritual consequences, and our effort struck that chord.
10:08 AM on 10/14/2011
Here's a little personal note to the politicians. It's not just about wall street. It's about you.

I've had email exchanges with lots of family and friends lately about what's wrong with America. The common thread? Our politician don't represent us anymore. They're bought and paid for by big money special interests.

If you're a Washington politician, I'd suggest you start thinking about about how to fix this. It's clear this hasn't been in your interest, since big money put you into power, but it's going to be very soon. This movement is only going to grow, since millions of us are quietly thinking the same thoughts.
05:14 PM on 10/14/2011
It will only grow stronger and stronger as the people of America move deeper and deeper into proverty.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carmen Slade
5150 Or Fight!
01:26 PM on 10/15/2011
Agreed. After visiting #Occupy San Diego the other day, the scene was mostly hippies and homeless people. Well, they're at the trailing edge of a declining economy anyway, so you'd expect that. It was kind of stupid, with arguments about music being lumped in with public cannabis and alcohol consumption. (hint: they either make the movement look bad, or keep everyone up all night as hippies play their fail guitars while mindlessly ignoring the people around them trying to sleep.)

So, I was not impressed. It's going to take a lot more hardship before the people who need to be out there are motivated to join the societal fringes in the parks today.

It will happen, I have no doubt. But that isn't going to occur until people can no longer afford a cell phone and cable plan after monthly expenses are paid.
03:00 AM on 10/14/2011
“we know from experience that working hard and playing by the rules doesn't bring the security that it used to”

Would these be the old rules about not borrowing money that you cannot repay; making a substantial down payment when you buy a house; not spending the house equity that you have accumulated on consumer goods; not buying consumer goods on credit?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jhm1953
03:39 PM on 10/14/2011
This sounds akin to blaming the victim. Yes, it's true there were some who got in over their heads in chasing the "American dream," but quite often those people were manipulated by those who knew better and ended up paying the price for it. The real villians in this case are very much the large insitutions who foisted this fraud on us.
04:33 AM on 10/15/2011
The author claimed the “playing by the rules doesn't bring the security that it used to”. People stopped playing by the rules - down payments, equity, avoiding credit debt. If they had continued to play by the rules; they would still be secure.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cye
03:11 AM on 10/16/2011
People in need will usually take money when it is offered. Similarly, people wanting to get ahead will usually take money when it is offered. This is hardly a surprise. The real question is why were were offered these loans in the first place. Who offers money to people who can't afford to pay it back?

In my country, the banks are either prohibited from doing this or simply don't do because it doesn't make sense to lend money to risky people!!

What happened in the American system that allowed these types of loans to be made, and then on-sold and securitized until they became ticking time bombs?
01:42 PM on 10/16/2011
“Who offers money to people who can't afford to pay it back?”

Your local pawn shop for one - they don’t care if you never come back for the Rolex you put up for the loan, they just sell it to recoup their money. Houses were supposed to be the same; hence the old expression: “Safe as houses”. If someone defaulted on the mortgage; then the lender could just foreclose and sell to recoup. Usually, they didn’t even have to go to that much trouble since the person unable to repay would sell the house first to avoid the hit to their credit rating. This is why mortgage interest is a third of credit card interest.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
whirlybird
Time's a-wastin'!
12:57 AM on 10/14/2011
RIGHT ON, Ms. Butler! You've managed to strike the heart of the beast. THIS is the unifying theme!
12:40 AM on 10/14/2011
Yea! It is heartwarming and very inspiring to know that there are people of true faith, true understanding of compassion and that have courage. May Grace shower upon us; and give us the strength to stand up for what our reason and our hearts know is true. Wall Street is meant to work FOR us. We, the people, in pursuit of life, liberty and happiness.
12:37 AM on 10/14/2011
The more people who join the Occupy Wall Street movement, the more powerful it will become. Hopefully our nation's leaders will take notice of the message, and some modicum of change will ensue. Hopefully it will give Obama the courage to fight for what is right.

I applaud people of all walks of faith and life who support this incredibly important effort because, you're right, Rev., "we recognize a great sin and injustice in our midst." And something has to be done about it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:58 PM on 10/13/2011
Excellent article, Reverend.

Being one of the richest people in America hasn't brought peace to Sam Walton's daughter:

http://www.katv.com/story/15688273/alice-walton-arrested-for-dui-in-texas
Alice Walton Arrested for DUI in Texas - KATV Channel 7 - The Spirit of Arkansas

The judge should sentence her to help those who are suffering because of greed.