More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Richard M. Benjamin

Richard M. Benjamin

Posted: April 2, 2010 06:30 PM

Karamel Sutra Obama Causes a Stir

What's Your Reaction:

The White House confirmed today that Obama checked only the "Black, African Am., or Negro" box on his 2010 Census form.

He could have checked "white." Or even "some other race." He could have even written in "multiracial."

Like Obama's extended clan, my family members have complexions like a Ben and Jerry's menu, ranging from Karamel Sutra to Chocolate Fudge Brownie.

2010-04-02-obamabeach.jpg

More than a few multi-racial and white people I know are venting: They hate having to "wedge" themselves into a racial "box," one that doesn't seem to categorize them properly. How can the Census capture the rich complexions, cultures, or ancestry coursing through their veins? Through Obama's?

Too boot, many Americans express irritation that their race is being counted in the first place. Given our growing racial diversity and intermixed populations, led by a mutt-style President, why bother to consider race at all? Isn't race an anachronism?

Well, no. Not quite.

The 2010 Census allegedly puts America into a racial Double Bind. "The Census contains a message to the American people, and like any message it educates to some end: It tells them that the government thinks the most important thing about them is their race and ethnicity," Nathan Glazer, the renowned Harvard professor, complained in Public Interest.

Chief Justice John Roberts denounced the "sordid business" of "divvying us up by race" in a landmark 2007 school de-segregation majority ruling. "The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race," the chief judge scolded.

Enter Glenn Beck and a cabal of conservative firebrands who are egging Americans on to ignore the census race question.

America's rapid social changes -- seen directly in Obama's face -- pique raw tensions over political, social, and economic power. Anger seethes across America's conservative landscape -- against government bailouts, unemployment, immigration, perceived high taxes, and the social shift of racial minorities one day becoming the majority.

But these census projections--and their eventual realization--need not bring unrest. Confronted with honesty, integrity, and communitarian values-- e pluribus unum-- our changing social composition can be rendered more an asset than an albatross.

Legal authorities use census data to monitor discrimination and to enforce civil rights laws. And without census data, we could not know whether qualified Latino buyers face discrimination in the housing market (yes) or whether rural, working-class white kids are disproportionately fighting in the Middle East (yes).

Some on the left suspiciously question the timing of the colorblind mania sweeping the nation.

"At the precise historical moment when race has become a tool for undoing racism and when the non-white population seems finally poised to surpass the white group, color blindness has emerged as a new racial ideology," observes Ian Haney Lopez, the John H. Boalt Professor of Law at the University of California.

A provocation: Should the US stop tracking its inhabitants' race, as the colorblind movement would have? Or should we endeavor to track race more comprehensively and nimbly?

Put bluntly, the 2010 and future census efforts need to count race more accurately and nimbly. This is not just an academic question for pointy-headed social scientists or for Oatmeal Chunk flavors like Obama. Rather, that question rouses our national self-awareness and safeguards our democratic integrity, by forcing us to face our demographic future with eyes wide open.

The breadth of census data helps us to uncover incredibly useful lessons about ourselves.


 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:19 AM on 04/03/2010
The President is African-American. He is clearly Black in hue. And, American would encompass his White and or "other" ethnicity. Our President is confident and self assured. I think that anyone that reads so much into this personally should probably self examine. How can some feel that his preference diminishes them in any way? They probably have personal issues that they need to address. Live and let let live.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hontas Farmer
Stargazer
04:29 AM on 04/03/2010
As a very multiracial, from a family that has been triracial since before there was a US I must say I am disappointed in this. We are a group that has inspired both disdain and wonder (at what might have been if we had been a more intermixed people). We have been described as tragic, for everything from the fact that our existence did not prevent racism (as in the case of Thomas Rolfe, my namesakes's son), or for not fitting in the boxes of our time.

It only disheartens me that our president by choosing black alone has reinforced the negative view of the history of multiracial americans. Are my people to be remembered only as tools of the master just for being who we are?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
listentome
Remember, no matter where you go, there you are !
11:04 AM on 04/03/2010
You are kidding me. It is a personal choice that each individual must make. No matter what you are mixed with and black is one of those ingredients, when the world looks at you, the first and main thing that they are trying to figure out is if you are black. Ask the president as well as Halle, Prince, Lenny, Shemar, Mariah, and others, not to mention some folks who have no black roots who look like they do. Is it really reinforcing the negative view of the history of multiracial Americans by checking the black box? And the truth of the matter is that most black Americans are multi-racial.
If the bigotry was not still so prevalent in this country checking a black/white/Latin/Asian/other box wouldn't be necessary because the truth is that their is absolutely only one race and that is human..
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:03 PM on 04/03/2010
fanned!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
listentome
Remember, no matter where you go, there you are !
12:26 PM on 04/03/2010
Correction: .......the truth is that there is........
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:08 PM on 04/03/2010
Where do you live? I think you don't live in the USA. I have seen some mulatos in the Third World acting as if they are white, until they come to the USA and get threated as black.

Learn the USA history and the "One drop" rule. Pres. Obama is a student of history, but I doubt about you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hontas Farmer
Stargazer
08:36 AM on 04/05/2010
Google "The Family history of the Farmer-Sissons". I assembled the genealogy of my family into an essay and sent it to the National Museum of African American History and culture (which is part of the Smithsonian). I know my history. I can name every ancestor back to the first black, first white, and first native in my family line. I know how they were treated in detail. Can you say the same? Or do you get your info from movies and hip hop video's.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
propitiousmoment
the journey is the destination....
10:05 PM on 04/02/2010
Excellent article. But if that picture at the end had been real (ewww!), Obama would not be prez. He's just fine the way he is. We all need to just accept and celebrate ourselves and each other the way we are. It would be a pretty boring world if everyone were one color.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:00 PM on 04/02/2010
Love reading you. Thanks.