More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rita Nakashima Brock, Ph. D.

GET UPDATES FROM Rita Nakashima Brock, Ph. D.
 

The Shooting And The Response At Occupy Oakland

Posted: 11/11/2011 7:15 am

I was driving to San Francisco for a meeting when I got the reporter's call about the shooting last night at Occupy Oakland. He thought that I might be taking a shift at the Interfaith Tent, which is near where the gunshots happened, and that I could tell him what was going down. After I hung up, I started calling people on our Tent team and told them to get down there if they could.

As I headed away from Oakland, I felt two things intensely. First, I wanted desperately to be going the other direction so I could be with the team to help people process the trauma. Second, I feared the city would use the incident as a pretext to evacuate the encampment. It did not immediately occur to me to think someone at Occupy Oakland had done the shooting.

Why? I've been at the camp at all hours of the day and night since we put the Tent up on Nov. 2, and after about 10 pm, camp security patrols come around regularly to check on people. In addition, I've gotten to know folks at the encampment, and I've never ever seen a weapon like a gun or knife in the tents or in people's possession. Occupy Oakland stresses nonviolence and respect. At the Interfaith Tent, we have a Baptist pastor, Preston Williams, who stays at the Tent 24/7. He has fixed it up, greets visitors, and accumulated a small library collection for guests. I enjoy talking to him.

Preston witnessed the shooting from a distance of about 20 feet, but, more important, he saw what preceded it and how the camp responded. I talked to him at length when I got there, and here is what he told me.

Some time before the incident, a heated argument broke out between a small cluster of men, not with Occupy Oakland, in front of a store about 50 feet from the Tent entrance. Camp security came over and calmed the men down. They then asked them to leave the area, which they did. But in a few minutes, they came back arguing in the area of some portable toilets where Preston was standing. One man ran away. Preston saw one of the two men standing near him shoot the man about 100 feet away and very near the entrance to the Tent. As the shooter and his companion ran away, they threw the gun, which went off and narrowly missed hitting Preston.

People in Occupy Oakland came running over, saw the man lying on the pavement, and, after the medical crew at the camp did what they could, the group organized a circle around him to protect him until an ambulance could arrive. They also created a human perimeter to protect the crime scene. When a photographer tried to break through, they told him no pictures. He was roughed up some when he climbed up onto a wall to film and occupiers pulled him down.

My friends with the Interfaith Tent told me that after the police came and did an investigation, the occupiers created an altar with candles where the slain man had lain. We began Wednesday night to hold late night candlelight vigils to protect the camp from evacuation by doing a prayer walk around its entire perimeter. The vigil group held a short service with silence at the altar for the victim. No one knew him, but the group nonetheless grieved that he was dead.

Some of the Interfaith Tent at Oakland team stayed all night to make sure people were OK. I came home to write this article at 1 am because I know this shooting is going to feed the media obsession with the violence of a tiny number of occupiers, which dominated news of our successful General Strike held on Nov. 2, with a few wonderful and notable exceptions, including a full report of our people of faith presence that day.

On Wednesday, I was at the Oakland General Assembly from 6 until 10 pm, fascinated with their lively, well-organized process of direct democracy for the 900 people who attended. I was never bored, and remain very impressed with this young and deeply moral movement. But more about that later. For now, I just want to register that Oakland Occupiers dealt with a serious crisis responsibly and bravely, and they exhibited a kind of decency and care for a stranger we could use a lot more of on Wall Street.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 105
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:01 PM on 11/13/2011
This is interesting because a lot of the time provocateurs will purposefully escalate protests in order for things to get out of hand. The Seattle WTO protests of 1999 had police provocateurs. I don't blame Seattle police they have larger problems on their hands than busting pot smoking protesters.
12:57 AM on 11/13/2011
absolutely love how nothing that happens at ows is ows related. rapes, sex assult, sex assult of minors, arson, thefts, overdoses, deaths, vandalism etc... none of it is ows' fault. just because it happened in their camps and tents doesn't mean anything.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Eris23
Justice is in indefinite detention.
01:28 PM on 11/14/2011
Ever been to Oakland, kid?
07:39 PM on 11/14/2011
yes i have. your point being? no, don't even, its not worth talking about.

these things are happening INSIDE ows encampments. These things are happening to protesters by the protesters. if they are in the camps, they are part of the group.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
missjulz
romneying with scissors always gets someone hurt
03:20 PM on 11/12/2011
"Occupy Oakland stresses nonviolence and respect."

This is not at all true. Just go to the facebook pages: the "bridge group" in particular and you will see a complete bashing of those of us trying to forge the message of nonviolence through proposals we bring to the table.

We have been told that we have been "conditioned" and need to be "re-educated" and to embrace Black Bloc and that they are the "heroes" of the movement and that we are "peace police".

"Some in OO embrace nonviolence" would have been a true statement. But it has not been adopted in any formal proposal and in fact proposals are discouraged and voted down and there has been no statement given by OO on this matter.

The only thing that they have formally embraced is STRAIGHT out of the Anarchists's playbook: "diversity of tactics" and those include vandalism and destruction. that is code for: you are an autonomous individual, anything goes.

AND THAT IS WHY OO IS FALLING APART.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bella Lee
01:29 AM on 11/13/2011
OWS is International because of it's peaceful approach and appealing message. OWS Patriots are non violent
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
missjulz
romneying with scissors always gets someone hurt
12:48 PM on 11/13/2011
I know, which is why I fully support OWS. Unfortunately Occupy Oakland has eschewed any messages of nonviolence and those who speak about nonviolence are booed and jeered off the stage at the General Assembly. It's incredibly heartbreaking. And it will be the demise of the oakland movement.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RevJimIII
Open Carry Oklahoma!!
08:02 PM on 11/14/2011
Weren't there riots at OWS sympathetic gatherings in Europe?
02:16 PM on 11/12/2011
It will be interesting when 200,000 vets return to the USA to find there are no jobs and few safety nets for them. Does the term "Frie Corps" ring a bell?

Just remember: These vets know how to use weapons.
02:10 PM on 11/12/2011
Couldn't agree more. Using this incident to try to disband Occupy Oakland is nothing more than another act of a police state.
08:02 PM on 11/11/2011
It inspires me seeing the range of religious and spiritual leaders engaged in this issue of economic justice. Today's briefing was a timely and powerful statement of their ethics and compassion. I wish all safety and wisdom in these encampments. Recently this clip was posted, "occupy the present: justice & love triumph at Oakland's general strike http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o2CZZ0vhS8U
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stpehennettles com
Shooting Straight about People,News and The World
05:31 PM on 11/11/2011
As far as I can tell (here in Atlanta) the OWS has been a failure. There is a band of 20 - 30 Occupiers who will protest for a day or two then disband. Jesse Jackson jetted in for a few days to pump them up - however when he left the Occupiers petered out yet again.

The Atlanta OWS doesn't have a message that resonates with the people here. For that matter, neither does the OWS as a whole.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bella Lee
01:35 AM on 11/13/2011
OWS has a message that resonates Internationally, no more money in politics, no more lobbying by 1% for a system that ignores the middle-class and poor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RevJimIII
Open Carry Oklahoma!!
07:47 PM on 11/14/2011
I was amused by the OWS member who was tweeting his actions on an iPhone.. talk about anti corporation eh?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tulsey
I was Bill Hicks.
03:23 PM on 11/11/2011
Crime has probably gone down in the area thanks to the occupiers and increased presents.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
02:48 PM on 11/11/2011
Interesting column. I find it funny though that the "interfaith" community is only reacting to a shooting near the OWS camp site. Do they have any idea how many shootings occur in Oakland?

Also I have an issue with the idea of self-appointed security patrols. None of these people have an training in actual security work. The large amount of problems with criminal activity in the OWS camps can be attributed to their lack of training and inability to defuse problems.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:05 PM on 11/11/2011
Wow, you have made a mountain of ASSUMPTIONS about this situation. Most of them are completely wrong.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SlammoFandango
03:19 PM on 11/11/2011
If the use and trafficking in non-government-approved intoxicating substances wasn't such an expensively enforced political crime, the small percentage of people hell-bent on getting stoned and those who take advantage of the profitability associated with the gambling risk of incarceration wouldn't be so realitively careless in resorting to equally felonious gun violence attributed to the trafficking of non-government-approved intoxicating substances, which puts the entire populace at risk due to poor decision making of a small sub-group of the population.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
06:03 PM on 11/11/2011
Who said this crime had anything to do with drugs? It seems like it was an argument that escalated and turned into gun violence.
01:42 PM on 11/11/2011
Gun violence is a horrifyingly common occurrence in Oakland. It is necessary to state this fact so that we remember that what happened last night was representative of the status quo and not of the protest. Last nights shooting is a reason to continue protesting the status quo, it is in no way a reason to cease such protests.
12:41 PM on 11/11/2011
Thank you for your article. Crime and violence happen in Oakland and other big cities. Not related to Occupy. Thanks to the interfaith tent and Preston for being there.
photo
massjim
Dem? Repub? Is there a difference?
12:39 PM on 11/11/2011
The tea party rallys didn't leave so much as a gum wrapper left afterwards. Their organizers had to keep a book of all the permits they had to obtain, and were frequently challenged. And the mayors of the same cities where the tea parties had their peaceful rallies turn over their cities to people who ARE committing crimes and are a threat to public safety and health. I like challenging the bad policies of the government, there is overlap between the Occupy people and tea party, but this is blatantly unfair.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MidwestMomma
Just a Pilgrim on the Mayflower of Life!
01:54 PM on 11/11/2011
And you accomplished nothing but retreat...NO is not an answer to problems it's a surrender.
02:34 PM on 11/11/2011
The tea party movement became relevant enough to place several members into congressional seats in 2010 and spurred the presidental campaign of one Michelle Bachman. Agree with them or not, but the tea party has done anything BUT retreat.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stpehennettles com
Shooting Straight about People,News and The World
05:22 PM on 11/11/2011
Comments of the uninformed are a commentary on you instead of the reader. Are you suggesting the Occupiers will become influential at the ballot box as the Tea Party has?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:10 PM on 11/11/2011
The shooting had NOTHING to do with OWS!!! You didn't bother to read the entire article and that is just silly. The crime was a crime committed by some bad dudes that had NOTHING to do with OWS at all. READING IS FUNDAMENTAL.
12:49 AM on 11/13/2011
is it not funny that anything that happens at ows had nothing to do with ows?

the fights were not ows, just happened in their camps.

the rapes were not ows, just happened in the tents.

the overdoses were not ows, just happened in their camps.

the sexual assult of a minor was not ows, the arson was not ows, the vandalism of private property was not ows, not one thing was ows.

i know, its the shadow government and the black helicopters, they are the ones doing it all.
12:36 PM on 11/11/2011
I also was at the GA on Wednesday night. I am a longtime Oakland resident that is in support of the Occupy movement's goal to change economic inequalities and a government that is run by corporate interests. BUT, I was very disheartened by what I saw and heard at the meeting on Wednesday. My expectation was, as the author notes, that violence is by a tiny number of occupiers. What I found was very different. A sizable segment of the crowd was very disrespectful of anyone supporting non-violence, with loud boos, jeers, and obscenities. It is my impression that the encampment has a dominant segment whose intention is to use violent means to accomplish the goals of the movement. I cannot support this, nor do the majority of Oakland residents.
RTIII
Poster of over 0.0135% of all HufPost comments
11:21 AM on 11/11/2011
I live in Oakland and this article is the first I've heard of it.

THANK YOU, Rita for this informative article - I can only imagine (at this point) how the MSM is spinning this to the negative. I sure hope they don't!

A BIG THANK-YOU also to the Occupiers in Oakland! Keep strong, keep doing the right thing, and keep on making sure that PEACEFUL, Non-Violent protest is EVERYONE'S goal. ...Boot out ANYONE who appears to have any violent streak! We don't need that!
11:13 AM on 11/11/2011
Because the occupy movement has risen organically from the ranks of people in despair the problems associated with that will continue to appear. Vets ARE committing suicide, there IS what appears to be senseless violence happening regularly in Oakland, women are attacked everywhere and all the time. This did not occur as a result of occupy. However, because these things are happening anyway we should expect them in or around the camps, plan for them, and face them as an inherent factor in huge,(and growing) groups of angry and suffering people.