People in the capital were thrilled by Twitter's role in 2009's Iranian uprisings. They probably weren't as excited this weekend when a new "hashtag" (topic) suddenly climbed toward the top of Twitter's trend list. It's not printable here, but the first word began with a "F." After that came the words "you" and "Washington."
The frustration's understandable, given Washington's bizarre monomania with applying the wrong solutions to the wrong problems. But there are more constructive ways to spend your day than tweeting four-letter words in the general direction of the Potomac River.
Tweet Dreams
The Twitter trend was started by the seemingly mild-manner media analyst Jeff Jarvis, who explains (warning: not work safe): "I listened to the latest from Washington about negotiations over the debt ceiling ...After dinner, I tweeted: "Hey, Washington *****, it's our country, our economy, our money. Stop f**ing with it."
Somebody responded by tweeting, "Hashtag it: #F***YOUWASHINGTON." Says Jarvis: "So I did ... And then it exploded as I never could have predicted."
It's easy to make too much out of this sort of thing. Twitter users aren't a cross-section of America. Too much can be made of its top trends -- which as of this writing include #Dear Taylor Swift, #Fantasy Football, and #Russell Brand. If hashtags alone can predict our political future, comedians will rule a nation of make-believe athletes who write love letters to teenaged country singers. (Somebody's probably muttering, 'You mean, like right now?')
The revolution will not be twitterized.
Genuine and Widespread Discontent
But there may be a larger phenomenon here, once that can be seen in polling numbers too. People are in despair for their future. Nearly 70 percent of Americans believe we're still in a recession (which, for many people, we are). Consumer confidence has plunged. Almost 40 percent of Americans believe we've entered a state of permanent decline, while nearly half expect another major recession in the next year.
And they don't believe anything's being done to stop it, since unemployment is still high and the views of the American Majority aren't being represented in this week's deficit discussions. More than 60 percent now say that the country's on the wrong track and unfavorable opinions of both parties are nearing record highs.
In other words, "F**k you, Washington."
Oh, no! Her, too?
If you're one of the discouraged ones, congratulations! At least you're keeping up on current events. Who wouldn't be discouraged sometimes? Republican radicalism is reaching near-nihilistic levels. The president has embraced the failed policies of austerity economics, and he clings to them even as they're failing in Great Britain and poll numbers show that the American public hates them. The only ones speaking for the majority have been the Progressive Congressional Caucus and people like Bernie Sanders and Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi.
And we may have lost Pelosi today, when she released a statement that included this sentence: ""It is clear we must enter an era of austerity; to reduce the deficit through shared sacrifice." Rational Americans might be forgiven for thinking they'd somehow been transported into the third act of that 1950's science-fiction classic, Invaders From Mars:
TOMMY: Mom! Dad! Have they gotten you, too??
PARENTS (in robotic voices): Come ... here ... Tommy.
ALIEN OVERLORD: Bring me the boy!
Pelosi hasn't explained her statement publicly, but these words are difficult to square with her past role as a stalwart defender of the middle class. Her admirers can only hope this ends the way Invaders From Mars ended... when we find out it was all just a bad dream.
Deal or No Deal?
But we have more ability to act than Tommy does. If Harry Reid prevails, the "grand bargain" won't include cuts to Medicare and Social Security. If he's successful (the president now supports him) that will mean that public outcries have once again thwarted attempts to cut these programs.
Reid's proposal has its problems, too. Like Boehner's plan, it would create a "supercommission" empowered to recommend drastic cuts, which would be submitted for an up-or-down vote with no modifications. (It's not clear if entitlements would be excluded from Reid's version.) There would be no tax increases under the Reid plan, either, which means the wealthy would continue their easy ride while other Americans bear the brunt of spending cuts. You can't fix our economic problems without increasing taxes, as this chart from economist Menzie Chinn shows:
It's all there. Spending rose sharply and tax revenues declined dramatically when George W. Bush took office. Both trends spiked again after the Great Recession. Why? First came the cost of two major wars, along with the Bush tax cuts. Then came the cost of (partially) repairing the damage left by a deregulated and unsupervised Wall Street, along with lost tax revenue as millions of people lost their jobs.
In the face of all this, here's Washington's plan: Continue the wars, preserve tax cuts for the wealthy, and fight Wall Street regulations. Hey, what was that hashtag called again?
Into Action
But despair not, ye infuriated Americans. As promised, here are three things you can do today (unless it's not Tuesday, July 26, in which case you can only do two of them):
1. Use this link to tell your Senators and Representatives that you oppose any deal that would cut Social Security, Medicare, or Medicaid, and ask them to raise the debt limit without any conditions attached.
2. Call your Senators and/or Members of Congress to tell them the same thing. (The link above should give you their contact information when you're done. It will ask you for a donation, too -- which, if you decide to give, would make four things you can do today.) If the phone numbers don't appear, they're publicly available.
3. If it's before noon on Tuesday, you still have time to find your Representative's local office and go there for a noon demonstration sponsored by a number of groups, including MoveOn and the Campaign for America's Future. You can find the nearest office here and then, as MoveOn says, "tell your Representative that they need to protect the programs working families rely on, and make the richest few pay their share."
The Progressive Change Campaign Committee summarizes the goals of these actions as 1) thanking the 81 Democrats in Congress who signed the Progressive Caucus letter opposing cuts to Social Secial, Medicare, and Medicaid, 2) urging other Democrats to oppose any plans that includes these cuts, and 3) telling Republicans to stop pushing for cuts to these programs. (They could add a few Democrats to that list, too.)
These actions could make a difference. And if these actions continue and grow, we may someday live in a country where the biggest trending hashtag on Twitter is "#thankyouWashington."
Taylor Swift might be disappointed, but the rest of us would be pretty happy.
(For an updated reaction to last night's debt ceiling developments, read Adults Only.)
Richard (RJ) Eskow, a consultant and writer (and former insurance/finance executive), is a Senior Fellow with the Campaign for America's Future. This post was produced as part of the Curbing Wall Street project.
Richard can be reached at "rjeskow@ourfuture.org."
Follow Richard (RJ) Eskow on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rjeskow
"The revolution will not be twitterized."
Dear Mr. Commentator Sir: I don't know what Twitter threads you follow (I'm not sure you do, given you don't know the protocol), or who you follow, or who follows you, but for you to make the comment that Twitter is not a cross-section of America is dead wrong. Facebook serves the same purpose as Twitter where one can talk about painting fingernails or talk about organizing a political movement. I use both Twitter and Facebook to get my political views out and they work. Your comments are insulting. I'm 61, and my husband just turned 65 in July and has just gone on Medicare, and if you don't think for one second we have been contacting our government officials since we first started getting screwed over by the health insurance industry over five years ago, you sadly underestimate the intelligence of the American people. Many of us have been contacting our government officials for years on a number of issues.
Now I suggest you go follow @BritneySpears #EffYou
One pissed off Granny who pays attention and votes.
We will soon discover first hand what our grandparents were talking about when they spoke of the Great Depression.
1. VOTE
2. OBAMA
3. OUT
In other words, do what you can to avert the present nightmare but you have to keep on, because they never stop.
So it's exactly as you said: We fight on. Others have done it before us, and it's our way of thanking them. And of helping those who follow ...
It is true like so many people have pointed out that waging wars and "armed interventions" all over N. Africa and the Mid East are also hugely inefficient financially...and they should be re-evaluated too.
This mess can not be solved by refusing to look at ALL the contributing factors.
See: http://www.twainquotes.com/Congress.html
If the Democrats think we're going to put the same Dems back in office they are wrong. This is not acceptable for America.
We're going to put whole new Democrats in office and hopefully there will be someone with character and a backbone.