More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Richard (RJ) Eskow

Richard (RJ) Eskow

Posted: July 15, 2010 09:24 AM

Drill, Gamble, Loot, Starve: The Chamber of Commerce, the GOP, and the Politics of Plunder

What's Your Reaction:

The United States Chamber of Commerce has released an "open letter" to the President, Congress, and the American people which contains its blueprint for our political future. It lays out the current Republican playbook in stark terms, and it reads like the battle plan for those alien spaceships from Independence Day: Drain the resources, take everything from the population, strip the land to a husk... and then presumably sail away in mile-long spaceships toward the next targeted planet.

What we're seeing is the Politics of Plunder, revealed in all its nakedness. There will be another example of this corporate-driven mindset this week, possibly even today, when all but a handful of Republican Senators vote against a moderate set of curbs on Wall Street excesses. The Democratic Party may disappoint its supporters from time to time, but it seems that Republicans never do -- once you accept the fact that its real "supporters" are the mega-businesses represented by the Chamber of Commerce. Some of the delegates who chanted "drill, baby, drill" at the GOP Convention are staring out their windows at oil-soaked beaches, while others have gone broke in an economy ruined by Wall Street gambling. That won't stop the Politics of Plunder. (Come to think of it, "drill, baby, drill" would have been a perfect motto for those spaceships.)

To be clear, the Chamber of Commerce isn't the political lobbying arm of "business," as it sometimes claims. It specifically serves the interests of massive businesses, which are often at odds with the needs of small and medium enterprises. Any CEO of a smaller company who's pressured by one of the Chamber's sales representatives to join, as I was in my business life, is being asked to subsidize policies that will benefit the Chamber's mega-donors -- often at her or his own expense. The Chamber's letter serves those mega-interests well, and we can expect most Republicans to follow it in lockstep, no doubt with cheering crowds pumped up for the same old chants and a few new ones.

"Drill, baby, drill." The lessons of BP are lost on this crowd -- or, to be more accurate, they don't matter. The Chamber's letter says that "there are numerous oil, gas, and shale leases on our lands and off our shores that are currently inactive. Some estimates show that they could generate as much as $1.7 trillion worth of royalties over the next 10 years. (Note: We heard that using 10-year timelines to create impressive-sounding numbers was "cheating" when the Administration did it.) Tapping these reserves would create direct federal revenues and hundreds of thousands of jobs."

The devastation of our Southern coastlines has not dimmed the Chamber/GOP crowd's thirst for drilling in costly, inaccessible, and dangerous areas. This letter, purportedly about "jobs," ignores the many jobs that have been lost because of the spill, and the thousands of small businesses devastated by the loss of fishing and tourism. It doesn't matter: The Politics of Plunder demands revenue for the largest businesses -- most of which would be generated by foreign sales of these resources, and very little of which would be returned to the US economy.

"Gamble, baby, gamble." Millions of American jobs were lost because of Wall Street's reckless, runaway gambling binge. The Chamber/Republican response is to whine about the Dodd/Frank bill, which is nothing more than a simple first step on the road toward comprehensive financial reform. "The soon-to-be-finalized financial regulatory reform legislation creates over 350 regulatory rulemakings, 47 studies, and 74 reports," the letter reads, "dwarfing anything in Sarbanes-Oxley."

The use of these kinds of numbers is a common rhetorical trick for the megabusiness/GOP crowd. Somehow we're expected to believe that the leaders of major corporations are overwhelmed by the complexity of "350 regulatory rulemakings" -- as if they don't have people who handle that sort of thing. Remember, we're talking about Wall Street here: banks and hedge funds, here not Norman Rockwell small-town grocers who will be overwhelmed by paperwork. The real purpose of this complaint is to provide cover for all those "no" votes we will see this week - each of which is a vote to continue the enrichment of wealthy financiers at the expense of the American economy.

"Loot, baby, loot." The GOP and its Democratic Blue Dog sympathizers don't want to vote for unemployment benefits or stimulus programs because, we're told, they're so concerned about the deficit. But when it comes to preserving tax cuts for the wealthy it's "deficits be damned." Sen. Jon Kyl's recent comments on the subject expose the inconsistency.

Here, too, the Chamber slavishly serves the mega-wealthy at the expense of other businesses and the American people. "(J)ust six months from now," their letter reads, "Americans will be hit with the largest tax increase in history in precisely those areas that would have the greatest negative impact on investment and jobs -- individual tax rates, dividends and capital gains taxes, the death tax, and the alternative minimum tax." It's economic nonsense to say that these are the areas that most impact investment and jobs. What's more, these taxes on the wealthy have been artificially low in recent years, adding to the deficit while doing very little to stimulate the economy.

The Chamber's use of the ideological phrase "death tax" to describe the estate tax masks the fact that they're talking about a 2009 law that allows wealthy heirs to inherit up to $10 million while paying no taxes at all, while people who work for their money pay at the usual rates. (If you want to amuse yourself, do a Google search of right-wing "tax justice" websites that rail against lifting this exemption and try to find one that mentions the actual numbers involved. They don't want you to know who's actually getting this tax break. It should be called the "Poodles for Paris Hilton Act.")

"Starve, baby, starve." The letter says that "The Chamber looks forward to the report due later this year from the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform." (Yeah, you bet it does.) "However, we already know that mandatory spending, especially in entitlements, is the primary culprit." Now that its clients have devastated the economy, robbing people of jobs and much of their savings, the Chamber is targeting an "aging population" in order to slash Social Security and other entitlement programs. Social Security is solvent for many more years and minor adjustments would make it completely viable indefinitely. But the mega-wealthy Chamber/GOP agenda demands that Social Security payroll taxes be redirected toward other government programs so they can fund further tax cuts for the rich.

Voters care more about helping the unemployed and getting Americans back to work than they do about cutting the deficit. Budget-slashing is a Washington fixation only, fueled by the think tanks and lobbyists that the Chamber/GOP crowd funds and promotes. But Chamber-driven Republicans hope that the public won't understand what they're doing, counting on "fatigue" and confusion to provide a smokescreen for the Politics of Plunder.

Those shadows over the nation's cities aren't spaceships. They're the very real threats that continue to loom over us: Continued unemployment. A damaged environment in risk of even greater devastation. Generations of older Americans who might be left without financial security. Republicans and the Chamber of Commerce want to use our economic crisis as a "shock doctrine" moment to pass measures that will continue a massive transfer of wealth to the upper one percent, while mortgaging the country's future to the economic interests that have already served it so poorly.

As the vote on financial reform will once again illustrate, this is not a movie.

_______________________________________________________________

Richard (RJ) Eskow, a consultant and writer (and former insurance/finance executive), is a Senior Fellow with the Campaign for America's Future. This post was produced as part of the Curbing Wall Street project. Richard also blogs at A Night Light.

He can be reached at "rjeskow@ourfuture.org."

Website: Eskow and Associates

 

Follow Richard (RJ) Eskow on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rjeskow

 
 
  • Comments
  • 413
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
photo
KOSMOCITIZEN
time is truth
05:21 PM on 07/16/2010
i sense, from a lot posters here, the LOVE for their big bisiness favorites
let me explain something
Big business are like the D/R/U/G Dealers who give you your first fix for free and then you follow
them for the rest of your life and you pay their lunch too.
03:53 PM on 07/16/2010
Keep bashing those Awful Big Corporations (ABC). But those are the employers who are most likely to provide employees with high wages/salaries, benefits such as health care, gay partner benefits, etc. As a parent I'd be happy to have my son or daughter working for a Boeing, Chevron, Bechtel, Ford, Verizon, Apple or other A.B.C. And as a citizen I'd love to have one of them build a facility in our city.
04:54 PM on 07/16/2010
It doesn't have to be that way, and there's nothing wrong with sensible regulation and promoting/enforcing corporate responsibility, fair treatment for workers and equitable wealth distribution.
09:30 PM on 07/17/2010
I think most people who say "big corp" don't mean any of the above companies - unless of course, they have most of their holdings "supposedly" off shore so that they don't have to pay taxes in this Country like the majority of us who live here.

When I say "big greedy corp.", I mean those companies - the banks, the health insurance companies, the big oil companies who #1 make billions/trillions but either take advantage of people they are supposed to be helping and/or find loopholes in the tax code and do not pay their share of the taxes here - to help support the Nation.
12:54 PM on 07/16/2010
I'm tired of people overusing certain words in such a derogatory way until the word is viewed as something negative. For example, the word "calories" is said with disdain: "Omg there are soooo many calories in that bagel." But really calories is just a measurement for energy. In Europe they measure energy in Joules. Can you imagine anyone in America saying, "I can't eat that, it has way to much energy!" Same goes with the word socialism. People just quote Fox news and have no idea what socialism really is. Whenever someone tries to bring up socialism in a negative way, I always ask them if they are referring to Leninism or Marxist theory? Gets 'em every time!

Ok so I rambled . . . but what I'm getting at is the way people talk about "big corporations" and how terrible and greedy they are. While I agree that yes, it is ridiculous the amount some CEOs are making, people have to understand that the fact that these corporations are "big" means that they have a lot of employees (aka jobs, the lack of which everyone is complaining about in the first place). So for people to take cheap shots at big corporations, even saying we should let them be bankrupt, is ludicrous. How do you think they would pay their employees? That's a lot of people to be jobless . . .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Silverpegasus
06:01 PM on 07/16/2010
There's a lot of people jobless now and small companies out of business, because of them.
12:22 PM on 07/16/2010
Oh daddybill... At what point did you and your rich friends all lose touch with what is right and fair for the greatest good? Whatever happened to "One nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."?

And where do any of you get off thinking that everyone else has the same opportunities as you? Really? So tell me... did you have to shut your business down in order to care for a terminally ill parent with no health insurance? Did you lose everything in a house fire with no one to help you recover? Did you come from extreme poverty in which your education was sacrificed in order to feed your siblings? Did you have to raise four children, single-handedly, without pay for twenty years? Are you paid less than a woman (as women are to men?). Do you suffer from a mental or physical disability?

If not, I'm very happy for you. You are quite fortunate. If you did experience these types of hardships however, I am surprised that you don't seem to have any understanding or compassion for those who are still struggling.

Instead, you are flaunting your "success" and the rewards you reap, while telling horrifically disadvantaged people to shut up, get to work and stop whining? Really? And you think corporations should be allowed to throw a mother out into the streets and pollute our oceans so they can sip cocktails on their yachts? Sounds pretty greedy and evil to me.
09:31 PM on 07/17/2010
Thank you for sharing ! If more people who just speak up, I think we could shut some of these selfish greedy people up!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dave Thinkster Paulson
A concerned American moderate
11:54 AM on 07/16/2010
The US Chamber is a major force in the movement to exploit the people of our nation and destroy the American middle class. Year after year, they spend more to buy the favors of government than any other lobby. They poured in $236 million between 08 and 09, and already $31 million in 2010. Even conservative voters might be interested to hear how far the Chamber will go to bring about American Feudalism.

Americans need to understand these sharks will stop at nothing to feed the wealthy and sacrifice everyone else. Their strategy is to cut taxes for the rich and force the cutting of social programs to pay for it. As Mr. Eskow stated, Social Security can remain solvent indefinitely with only small adjustments, yet it’s centered in the Chamber’s sights. Here, the Chamber is just pushing the conservative agenda.

Republicans, the Chamber, Big Business . . . they’re all the same people, and they’ve all suddenly become budget conscious. The deficit that they created is now the only path to economic recovery. Even though history has proven that spending reduction at this juncture will further cripple the economy, this is exactly the poison they prescribe.

Make no mistake about it, this is government by sabotage. If given control in November, the Republicans will re-launch their guerilla attack to privatize Social Security. It’s the crown jewel of the New Deal -- if they can turn it over to business, it will be their coup de grace — game over!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
haimchaim
11:48 AM on 07/16/2010
the little mistakes we have made in the past have been forgotten by almost anyone that matters ..
10:16 AM on 07/16/2010
Evil corporations. Greedy elitists. Plunderers. Cut the crap and face the facts. All this whining is absurd. We are prosperous when wealth is created. Your attitude would change I'm sure if you were on the other side. I have worked hard to build mt business and by God I deserve to enjoy the rewards. You'd have the same attitude if you were successful, too. But for some reason, some people just want everything given to them because they deserve - not because they earned it or worked hard for it. Because of my efforts, my investing my life savings and sheer hard work, I have created 40 jobs for people. How many have you created? Shut up, set your goals, don't quit, work hard and please, stop whining and get to work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
babaann
If I had known I would live this long.........
10:21 AM on 07/16/2010
Are the people who work in those 40 jobs also "successful"? Are they also hard workers?
10:24 AM on 07/16/2010
Yes they are - and they have the same opportunity I had.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
RJ Eskow
10:35 AM on 07/16/2010
Great question. I went back over my business career, and all told I've created about 1,500 jobs. And I've never told a stranger to "shut up," either.

Thanks for asking.
11:03 AM on 07/16/2010
Good for you! Thanks for making a positive contribution to building wealth by creating jobs. We need more of that and less of the poor me mentality. Whining and complaining never got anybody anywhere. Hard work and determination does.
guilatty
Something has got to make sense eventually
09:28 AM on 07/16/2010
You cannot blame your dog for not using the toilet. It is your job to teach him to go outside and to take him outside. It is the same for corporations. They can't help themselves for being what they are. It is our duty to teach them and to take them outside. It is hard to do when the Republicans insist on laying down with them.
10:20 AM on 07/16/2010
Problem is...the big Corps (dogs) have the rolled up paper in their mouth and we can't catch them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
Give peace a chance
06:53 AM on 07/16/2010
The greedy are never satisfied. That's why we need regulations, regulators, courts and prisons. The concept of fair play in our capitalist society has gotten lost. Win (profit) by all means is the the difference between mom and pop shops and megacorps. The chamber of commerce has lost it's moral compass and needs to be dismantled.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TooLooze
Someone should do something about all the problems
07:38 AM on 07/16/2010
Well said. Win by all means is not the only difference, but it is one of the most glaring. The corporate paradigm of continual growth promotes the same short term thinking and policies that got us into this economic mess.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Cantor
I am a human being descended from an exclusive gro
03:49 AM on 07/16/2010
TY, Richard, for this post
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
aligatorhardt
Cut on the bias
02:12 AM on 07/16/2010
The Chamber of Commerce is the enemy of the working people. Their policies have created the problems we now deal with. They do not deserve our support.
01:36 AM on 07/16/2010
Politics of plunder indeed. What we need to understand, though, is that this politics of plunder is not just a scheme cooked up by greedy evil corporations and Republicans to enrich themselves beyond obscene levels (even though it certainly is that too). Plunder is in the very nature of capitalism. The players in a capitalist system MUST plunder any and all resources they can get their hands on. It's in the "grow or die" commandment which is fundamental to capitalism. The fact that the "politics of plunder" has now surfaced in all its repugnance is a function of both the desperation of the capitalist/imperialist class, given the inevitable anarchy of "the market," and the arrogance of the capitalist/imperialist class, in that they seem to think that they no longer need to disguise their program. They apparently think that they now have the power to simply do whatever in the hell they want to, and everyone else can just be damned. Expect construction of the giant luxury escape yachts to hasten--unlike "Independence Day," the ruling class expects only to escape into the middle of the ocean, not into space (at least not yet)..
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:58 AM on 07/16/2010
I've never understood the "grow or die" imperative. Why is it necessary to keep growing?
photo
Welib
Peace on Earth!
02:37 AM on 07/16/2010
I own my own business and so does my husband and we wonder what the big thing is about growing or die thing as well. It's nonsense.

We keep our business small and managable so we have flexibility. My brother in law told me that when I was a teenager. When you have a lot of employees you have a lot of problems. We enjoy our lives and we have money and time to come and go as we please. We aren't loaded but we are comfortable.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
JScott
John Galt's last name is McGuffin-Smithee
11:36 AM on 07/16/2010
Yup on a finite planet it's not possible but in all of human history up till recently we never even thought about it, recent mag articles seemed daring to even discuss it (for fear of being labled socialist or anarchist)
photo
maserati2
Finally an honest politician! ELIZABETH WARREN!
12:30 AM on 07/16/2010
So they've thrown down the gauntlet as they state their demands, dressed up the language a little perhaps. No more playing nice. One carefully planned step at a time, our future independence and well-being is slowly being sucked away.

Unless our diverse public can find common ground to regain power to unite & fight back, It appears that decisions have been made and one version of our futures is not far away.
photo
maserati2
Finally an honest politician! ELIZABETH WARREN!
12:25 AM on 07/16/2010
I'd like to see a new discussion called "Pending Comments". What a goldmine of thought-provoking reading that would be.
11:57 PM on 07/15/2010
Speaking of plunder, will somebody finally answer the question, "Once you progressives (what a ludicrous term) plunder the 'rich' and 'big business', where's the money going to come from then?"
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
awake108
12:14 AM on 07/16/2010
The rich and big corporations are paying the least amount of taxes in our history in spite of making huge profit snd CEO making 600x that of the average worker. As far where is the money going to come from. There will always be the rich because as always their greed will motivate them
12:14 AM on 07/16/2010
"We are not here in this world to find elegant solutions, pregnant with initiative, or to serve the ways and modes of profitable progress. No, we are here to provide for all those who are weaker and hungrier, more battered and crippled than ourselves. That is our only certain good and great purpose on earth, and if you ask me about those insoluble economic problems that may arise if the top is deprived of their initiative, I would answer 'To hell with them.' The top is greedy and mean and will always find a way to take care of themselves. They always do." MICHAEL FOOT, Labour Party leader, UK, 1983. The most important words here "They always do". Don't worry about the rich, they can take care of themselves.