More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rob Asghar

Rob Asghar

GET UPDATES FROM Rob Asghar

The Uniquely Bostonian Form of Sports Arrogance

Posted: 06/18/10 04:24 PM ET

Let me kick Boston Celtics fans now that they're down.

All sports fans are arrogant and hypocritical, perhaps because all human beings are arrogant hypocritical, never more so than when they break themselves up in groups. But Boston Celtics fans and watchers offer a unique kind of hubris.

As a fan of USC and the Lakers, I'm hardly one to judge others for smugness. And I realize the Celtics are a tremendous bunch of competitors. But we can all still learn something from looking at the mentality of Celtics watchers, reflected best in this pre-Game 7 swipe by Boston Globe columnist Dan Shaughnessy:

What Game 6 failed to establish was any measure of the Lakers' mental toughness. Historically, the Lakers are the premier frontrunners in all of sports. As it was in 1984, it is today: no team looks better than the gold-clad Lakers running up and down the floor, dunking and making threes.

But there wasn't any competition for the home team last night. The Celtics simply failed to show up.

This suggests so much. The Lakers can score more points than the Celtics in 48 minutes, but they still can't "win" in Celtic eyes. If, with their backs against the wall the Lakers clobber the Celtics in Game 6, it's simply because the Celtics weren't informed that they needed to "show up" to claim their championship.

Shaughnessy reluctantly went on to concede the Lakers' "mental toughness" after Game 7, but only after eulogizing the Celtics for having supreme character.

What's mentally tough for Bostonians, generally, is recognizing that the Lakers have maintained strength longer and better than the Celtics have.

If the Lakers have won more championships in the modern era, Celtics fans say it's merely because the Lakers have greater physical talent -- as though no franchise should get credit for assembling better talent than others, within in a sport where you have to use savvy as much as dollars to assemble effective talent.

In the Celtics' world, it's no sign of toughness if Kobe Bryant plays through a broken finger and tweaked knee and a gimpy ankle for most of the season, or if young Andrew Bynum postpones surgery to hobble along on a torn knee -- but it's Shakespearean tragedy, nay, a Virgilian epic, if the Celtics are forced to soldier on minus an injured Kendrick Perkins.

This is all quintessentially Bostonian. It mainly uses a narrative derived from two Laker Game 7 losses to the Celtics in 1969 and 1984 -- in other words, before NBA players were born or before they began playing basketball. Rather than saying that the Celtics had a fine run in that prehistoric era, and rather than pointing out that Magic Johnson soon destroyed the Celtics' aura of invulnerability, and rather than noting that Andrew Bynum was injured in 2008, the Celtics fans and watchers revel in gloating about how Celtics teams are superior in character.

Bostonians ultimately see the NBA as a morality play. If Phil Jackson won more titles than Red Auerbach, it was because he exploited pre-assembled superstars rather than building a team from the ground up. If Boston beat the Lakers in 2008 using a pre-assembled cast of mercenaries, it's because, well, who cares? And even though those mercenaries enjoyed a league-best 66-16 wins that season and even though the Lakers lacked Bynum in those playoffs, Celtics again manage to see their six-game series win as a sign of heroism against "front-runners."

With two championships in the past 25 years, The Celtics have been largely irrelevant in the modern era, which has been dominated by Los Angeles, Chicago and San Antonio. And their team is again likely to fall apart soon.

But that will not stop Bostonians from their bloviating. Fair enough, it may be what carries them through those long winters. Now I'll stop smugly kicking them while they're down, long enough to celebrate my "front-running" Lakers' latest triumph. See you next June, Bostonians... if you can ever get back.

 

Follow Rob Asghar on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rasghar

 
 
  • Comments
  • 53
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:35 PM on 06/21/2010
I'm still trying to wrap my brain about someone who is literally working *AT USC* who decides they want to write a story on arrogance and hubris and... hmm, what's that 3,000 miles away? A sportswriter writing a story from his own side's perspective?

Dude, turn your mastermind, genius powers of observation toward Heritage Hall. The year's greatest tale of "we'll never get caught. We're too awesome." was right across campus.
07:57 PM on 06/21/2010
So you write an article accusing all Celtics fans of being arrogant by citing one Boston sportswriter and arrogantly talking about all of the Lakers triumphs? Um, OK.
01:13 PM on 06/21/2010
There's also a uniquely Angeleno form of smugness...............that can choose sports, culture, or even a Boston Globe article as its jumping-off point........but ulitimately ends up in the same place.....

And so the rest of us are left to endure another version of the stock lecture
In which everywhere (and everyONE) outside of "Rome" as I call it ...
is either... provincial and hick.....or old & tired...
and in any event..... just not as hip, slick, and cool as the Romans and their gladiators are.

I actually like the LA sports teams...and even some of their fans......... For the record:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/17/lakers-win-nba-championship_n_616779.html?page=15&show_comment_id=50841373#comment_50841373

Mr. Asghar seems to have forgotten.that sportsmanship requires one to also be a "good winner" also.
Perhaps he has no interest in such things at the Center For Public Dimplomacy (Imagine!)

Just across the USC campus from Asghar's office......
scientists engaged in primate behavioral studies there must carefully weed out apes raised in Southern California........
they won't tear themselves away from the mirror long enough to generate usable data.

TM
12:03 PM on 06/21/2010
A majority of Boston fans can't stand Shaughnessy, so using one of his lame columns to stereotype all Boston fans is pretty disingenuous. It says a lot more about the kind of fan YOU are than anything else.
photo
sasidechick
Math, science, history..unraveling the mystery tha
10:03 AM on 06/21/2010
I take immense joy when a sporting team from Boston loses. Believe me, I hate the Flyers more than the Bruins but I LOVED it that the Bruins blew a 3-0 series lead and was up 3-0 in game 7 before losing. I had the same joy when the Celtics blew it and lost the last two games and blew the championship.

Now if Tom Brady decides not to renew his contract, my summer will be complete.
01:25 PM on 06/21/2010
God will get you for that
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NatTurner1
Knowledge is the key that unlocks all the doors.
09:18 AM on 06/21/2010
I told several of my friends before the start of this season, if Doc Rivers and the Celtics starters including Davis and Wallace, played for any other city than Boston...I would be their biggest fan. I hate the arrogance of the people that call Boston home....nevermind I can never get a cab out of Logan!
08:44 AM on 06/21/2010
as a detroit fan, i remember hearing the same type of comments coming out of l.a. when the pistons beat them back in 04.
06:59 AM on 06/21/2010
It's so annoying when sportswriters resort to literary metaphors like Shakespeare and Virgil, et al. It further confirms my conviction that those who do so are failed journalists who couldn't hack-it in the real media world and are trying to impress their readers to make up for their feelings of inadequacy.
I'm probably way off base, but, it gives me great satisfaction to say it...LOL...it's been in my quiver a long time.
01:31 PM on 06/21/2010
MUA-ha-haa!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rob Asghar
06:55 PM on 06/22/2010
Hilarious. But I'm not a sportswriter. Thanks for your quiver.
11:04 PM on 06/20/2010
I am not a basketball fan at all, but as a die-hard Sox fan living in New England, allow me to say that Dan Shaughnessy is a tool. Entertaining, but a major tool.

Curt Schilling dubbing him CHB (the "curly-haired boyfriend") pretty much sums his inanity up quite well.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:52 PM on 06/20/2010
Wow. Lakers fan calling out other fans for assholishness. Talk about your freaking hubris.

Seriously, given the last two weeks of sports news, if you want to have a meaningful article about hubris, there's USC staring you right in your plastic surgery altered faces.
05:20 PM on 06/20/2010
Wow! For a fellow in a center for diplomacy you are not very diplomatic. How do you have a column on here? Might want to look in the mirror. All fans are passionate about their teams which annoys non-fans of the team. Everything you said about Celtic fans can be reflected right back on Lakers fans. Maybe you need to go study more on how to be diplomatic?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
48thGuy
01:50 PM on 06/20/2010
You want HUBRIS, I'll give you HUBRIS.........CHICAGO BLACKHAWKS, STANLEY CUP CHAMPIONS....Nobody gives a crap about LA or Boston.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StevieTheK
On n'oublie rien, rien du tout
01:10 PM on 06/20/2010
Let's face it. This whole article was a glorified troll, designed to create pseudo-controversy in the comments section.

Can't we just stick with celebrity nipple slips when no one has anything to write about?
09:23 AM on 06/20/2010
i have always followed sports and i'm hardly a fan of any boston teams, but you're nitpicking here. what shaughnessy said was rather innocuous and is something said by the fans of all teams that are in that position. it is certainly nothing unique to boston fans.
01:44 AM on 06/20/2010
as a celtics fan, i cannot be totally upset with the outcome of this series. we got outplayed in the final game, did not make key shots when they mattered, and were sloppy on the boards. most of this was because of the perkins injury, which is fine. if perkins had been healthy, it would have been a different ball game. alas.

that said, i feel like its unfair to single out shaughnessy for calling the lakers frontrunners, especially when certain members of the LA media do things like make fun of paul pierce for being stabbed 11 times in a nightclub. but then again, this is the same fan base that appears at dodger games in the third, only to leave in the seventh.

not to mention: the only thing better than USC destroying its football playing future for the next 8 years is pete carroll running from the scene covered in blood. oh well! at least you have your pro football team to watch...oh wait.