More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Rob Bell

GET UPDATES FROM Rob Bell
 

The Good News Is Better Than That: Reflections On Hell, Salvation and the Power of Love

Posted: 03/25/2011 8:59 am

I never set out to be controversial.

That's not compelling to me. When someone sets out to be controversial or provocative or shocking as an end in itself, I don't think that's a noble goal.

That being said, I spend the past several years writing a book called Love Wins which released last week and, from what I'm told, has generated a fair bit of, well, controversy.

So why did I write the book?

First, as a Christian pastor I believe that for many in our culture the Christian story has lost the plot and a number of other stories have been told that have nothing to with who Jesus is and why he came.

I believe that God loves everybody and that Jesus came to give us and show us and invite us into that love so that we can experience it and then share it with others. As Jesus himself said, he didn't come to condemn but to save.

The first people who heard the announcement that God has not given up on the world but sent Jesus to save us from all of the ways we've made a mess of things, they called this "good news."

Who doesn't need good news?

This leads me to another reason why I wrote the book. Over the years I've interacted with a massive number of people who have questions about the Christian faith.

What about heaven and hell? What about people who have never heard of Jesus? Are billions of people who aren't Christians going to burn in torment forever?

How is that good news?

And then the big question, the one that lurks behind all of the others: "What is God like?"

For many these questions are obstacles; barriers to faith. And so I wrote this book to address these questions. Obviously, I haven't spoken the last word on any of these subjects. My book is part of an ongoing discussion people have been having for thousands of years about the things that matter most.

When we enter in to this discussion, the one about heaven and hell and salvation and God and the future of the world, our questions matter because to ask is to acknowledge our need, which requires tremendous humility. And God can work with that, because God is in the give and take.

"What do you think?" is a question Jesus often asked. We are wise to pause here and remember that Jesus rarely answered someone's question with a direct yes or no or with an even remotely straight forward answer. He tells a story, he spins a parable, he point to flowers and birds.

This isn't because he's avoiding the questions or he's scared to come clean on where he really stands. It's because he understands that some truths can't be crammed into sound-bytes.

And then another reason, which is really an invitation. I recently received an email from a woman who had just finished reading the new book. She said it was ''...Like when you scuba dive and you first breathe in the oxygen. At first it feels a little panicky, like you can't breathe. It doesn't fit. But if you give it a minute and relax, you can breathe. You can breathe in places you've never even tried to breathe before and can see things you couldn't see unless you let that panicky feeling be there for a bit. Then it's underwater...to unseen life."

I love how she uses that word "panicky" because that's how faith is. You stumble into something new, you hear something you haven't heard before, and first it's jarring, strange, even shocking, and yet you know something life giving is lurking in there. And so you keep going.

Jesus said "Repent," which means to "be transformed."

Let the good news grab you, disrupt you, unsettle you and shake you up. Lose your life and find it, die and be reborn, take a breath, open your eyes, and see things you've never seen before.

It's an ancient invitation, a pressing, urgent wake up call to say yes to this Jesus and the love of God he insists is for every single one of us, right now, here, today.

If that invitation, that insistence, that message and that conviction cause controversy, I'll accept that.

Because now, more than ever, good news is what we need.

 
I never set out to be controversial. That's not compelling to me. When someone sets out to be controversial or provocative or shocking as an end in itself, I don't think that's a noble goal. That b...
I never set out to be controversial. That's not compelling to me. When someone sets out to be controversial or provocative or shocking as an end in itself, I don't think that's a noble goal. That b...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 822
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
05:01 PM on 04/07/2011
Same old heresy. Shiny new package.
12:11 PM on 04/04/2011
We are a society that wants affirmation and approval without responsibility or consequences. In a phrase, we want to "feel good." That's OK, but it smacks of the "cheap grace" that Eric Bonhoeffer addressed in his book "The Cost of Discipleship."

I share with Pastor Bell the truth that God is Love, and that Jesus is the ultimate expression of that love to a fallen world. The Bible states that Jesus was full of "grace and truth." Pastor Bell offers a "feel good" message that grace is disconnected from truth. The truth is that God will not be fitted into our box of "fairness" or "grace." He will run the Universe as He pleases, and He will create the principles by which it runs with or without our approval. Particularly, he will not change His nature so that we will "feel good" about Him.

Jesus spoke very directly about a condition and place known as "hell," a place of eternal suffering. There are consequences to rejecting or ignoring God. There are consequences to accepting a diluted and self-serving version of God. These consequences follow from the principles God has set in place: separation from God brings suffering, and dying without accepting the truth of Jesus brings eternal consequences.
Jivan
Leap and the net will appear
09:56 PM on 04/02/2011
When the Europeans "discovered" North America there were millions of people living here. There were huge cities in North and South America that had thousands of inhabitants who lived and died centuries prior to the arrival of the Christians. Are you telling me that all of these people will be put in eternal damnation by God because they did not accept Jesus as their personal savior? How can you believe in a just God who would do that kind of thing? Imagine never knowing about Jesus but ending up in eternal damnation sent there by a God who never gave you the opportunity to know about Jesus but sent you to eternal fire because you did not accept Jesus as your personal savior? Is that just? Is that fair? Think! Don't stop thinking when you enter your church door. Question everything!
Jivan
Leap and the net will appear
10:06 PM on 04/02/2011
To add to my point. Ever hear of the city of Cahokia? Located in Illinois it was inhabited from about A.D. 700 to 1400. Built by ancient peoples known as the Mound Builders, Cahokia's original population was thought to have been only about 1,000 until about the 11th century when it expanded to tens of thousands.

At its peak from 1,100 to 1,200 A.D., the city covered nearly six square miles and boasted a population of as many as 100,000 people.

All those 100,000 people who lived in Cahokia were born and died after Jesus death and resurrection but I'm sure they never heard of Jesus, but God is going to condemn them to hell anyways?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
detroitblkmale30
Wise Men Still Seek Him
12:09 AM on 04/04/2011
No, they get a pass. you cant be condemned of ignoring something you never knew aboutl
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
myth buster
12:57 AM on 04/03/2011
Shall the unrighteous inherit the Kingdom of God? The Grace of God is not something that can be deserved or earned, and further, it is something that no one perishes without if he seeks it. Even now, millions of Muslims come to Christ because they heard the Gospel in a dream. So is it just that reprobate pagans should be condemned? Absolutely, for they are reprobate by their own free will. They wanted nothing to do with God, so God cut them off from wisdom to limit the damage they could do.
Jivan
Leap and the net will appear
10:56 AM on 04/03/2011
If I hear you correctly your answer to an unjust God who condemns people to hell who never heard about Jesus is that God comes to them in a dream? That sounds good but I would respectfully ask you to provide a scriptural reference to this. If that is the case, why did Jesus give the commandment to "go into all the world and preach the gospel?" Why didn't Jesus say don't worry about it, God comes to everyone in a dream and gives them a chance to repent?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
04:45 PM on 04/02/2011
Christians stole a lot from other religions: the buddhists (sermon on the mount), The Zorostrians (demons, praying to a messenger figure), the Jews (OT), the Pagans (walk on water, turning water....wine, necormancy, healing,virgin birth....), and Mithraism. Maybe I should be happy that my beliefs are given back, but just because Rob Bell believes theres no hell, doesnt mean the other 37,999 sects of christianity believe hell doesnt exist either.

Seems to me christians just make it up as they go along, some things never change.
02:38 PM on 04/04/2011
You might want to study you history just a bit more, there are more scrolls and manuscripts from early Christianity than any other religon or book ever produced
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:21 AM on 04/01/2011
God dosen't torture humans after death in a so called hell fire. That's a false teaching. All who are in Hell will be ressurected it tells us in Revelation 20:13 And the sea gave up those dead in it, and death and HADES (Greek word for Hell) Gave up those dead in them, and they were judged individually according to their deeds.
Verse 14 tells us that death and hell (Hades) were hurled into the lake of fire . This means the SECOND DEATH, the lake of fire. The FIRSTdeath is Adamic death . We die because of Adam and Eve. We inherited imperfection. Theres a ressurection from Adamic death which is the first death. But whoever dies the second death will not have a ressurection. Fire in the bible symbolizes destruction. Not torment but instead eternal destruction.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
04:46 PM on 04/02/2011
Pagan greek word mind you. Convenient how christians forget where they stole their beliefs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
myth buster
12:59 AM on 04/03/2011
Sheol or Grave works just fine, too. The words can be used interchangeably.
02:32 PM on 04/04/2011
I believe you may be a little twisted, Jesus Him self preache on hell many times and that it would be a place of tourment. So if any of you want to use scripture to back your outlandish thoughts make sure you know the whole word not just the part you want to throw out there. Hell is very real and very biblical. The only way you will see Heaven according to scipture is to put your faith in Jesus Christ the Son of God and repent of your sins " confess, ask for forgiveness, and go and strive to sin no more". Maybe you all should do a little more home work.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:31 AM on 04/10/2011
Jesus never preached hell was a place of torment. I used a scripture to back up my comment but looks like you didn't read it and if you did you didn't understand it. Some times we have to read scripture over and over to really SEE whats it says. Hell or Hades is the common grave of mankind. One of Gods main attributes is love. God is not sadistic and didn't invent the hellfire teaching. Jesus was in hell for parts of three days before he was ressurected. Hades is the greek word for hell. Sheol is the Hebrew word for hell. The teaching of being tormented in hell fire for eternity is not in the bible.
You really should use scripture to back up your belief in hell fire.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TokyoTea
07:31 PM on 03/31/2011
Thank you, Rob Bell.

Those who believe in eternal damnation sometimes refer to God's "justice" or "holiness" as if they were a needed counterbalance to his love. But there is no "justice" or "holiness" in creating fallible creatures and then damning the majority to hell eternally for non-eternal wrongs--as if he had no idea that it would all turn out that way!

Eternal damnation is incommensurate with short, limited, fallible lives. We are too small to do any harm to God.

God does not tell us to forgive yet find himself incapable of it. He does not tell us to forgive people only if they apologize or later agree with us, nor does he recommend unforgiveness for the sake of "justice". In fact, Jesus tells us to love our enemies and do good to those who hate us. Is he then recommending injustice re wrong-doers or a higher kind of good? Is God incapable of this higher good?

I don't see how anyone can take Jesus and his teachings seriously and NOT question the idea of eternal hell.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
conscioushope
"There is no darkness but ignorance." Shakespeare
07:14 PM on 04/01/2011
Good post, Tokyo!

fanned!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
myth buster
01:02 AM on 04/03/2011
And what do you suppose Heaven would be like if God allowed unrepentant sinners in? It would be as bad as the Earth is now, and worse, we would never be rid of the wicked who torment us night and day here on Earth. Think about all the monsters who have waged war against the Church because they could not attack God directly. Do you think they'd stop oppressing Christians in the next life if they were able?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daleri Rileda
Jungle Jargon
04:29 PM on 03/31/2011
The good news is that there is no good reason for us to want to do someting that will send us to hell.

All we have to do is to tell the truth that is able to sanctify us so that we will want to do all of the right things
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
iLdoRight
Encouraging The Rightest Rightness
07:15 PM on 03/31/2011
It is not as bad as many think, Job, who was considered a right kind of person actually prayed to go there. You can see all the verse locations where there is a word that has been translated to read as "hell" at truechristianityevangelism.org
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daleri Rileda
Jungle Jargon
08:06 PM on 03/31/2011
Just being wrong for all of eternity would be bad enough only there are conseqences for the wrong things that we do.

Whoever approved abortions or approves of them, for example will have to face the 50 million babies that were aborted.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:10 PM on 03/31/2011
I agree that hell is NOT a place of torment. Hades Is the Greek word for Hell and sheol is the Hebrew word for hell, hell is the english word. all three mean the same thing, the common grave of mankind. Job was suffering so much that he wished he could have relief in death knowing that there eventually would be a ressurection from Hell, ( the grave.)
Jesus was in Hell or hades for parts of three days before his ressurection. Acts 2:31 speaking about Jesus ressurection there in verse 31 it says," HE saw beforehand and spoke concerning the ressurection of the Christ, that neither was he forsaken in HADES (Greek word for Hell ) nor did his flesh see corruption. If hell was a place of torment for sinners Jesus wouldn;t have went there. It's clearly NOT a place of torment, but is the grave, death, the opposite of life.
Jesus died and was ressurected on the third day.
All who are in HELL will be RESSURECTED AFTER Armeggedon Which is Gods war againt all unrighteousness. Revelation 20: 13 And the sea gave up those dead in it , and death and HADES ( Hell) GAVE UP THOSE DEAD IN THEM.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
04:52 PM on 04/02/2011
yes and when you die and realize Jesus is a lie, I shall throw your own words back in your face.
02:31 PM on 03/31/2011
The Gospel can be summed up in three words: God loves you.

GOD loves you. The Being by Whom all the universe was made, and in Whom it persists, cares about litte old you, a tiny speck clinging to a rock orbiting a minor sun at the far end of a medium-sized galaxy.

God LOVES you. You are loved and cherished.

God loves YOU. Yes, you. With all your faults. There is nothing you can do that is so bad that God will stop loving you.

This is the Gospel, the Good News.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
iLdoRight
Encouraging The Rightest Rightness
07:23 PM on 03/31/2011
I think He likes people for what He knows they are capable of being if they would only do as He requests, but He actually hates many of them for what they choose to be. This can be seen in the verses where He talks about how he feels about lies and liars, people who swear an oath and (willingly) default on it. If one listens to the Bible all the way through one will find many times that He has become very disliking toward many different people, and not very (what many would think of as loving).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:51 PM on 03/31/2011
Actually the GOOD NEWS is about Gods Kingdom. Matthew 24:14 . Humans need to know what the KIngdom is. . Jesus preached about Gods kingdom for three and a half years before his death and ressurection. Paul was giving a thorough witness concerning the Kingdom of God and by using persuasion with them concerning Jeaus form both the law of Moses and the Prophets, from morning till evening. Verse 24 says some began to believe and others would not believe. Notice in verse 22 It says as regards this sect, speaking about (Jesus and his disciples) it is known to us everywhere it is SPOKEN AGAINST. Its the same today for those that try to tell others about God Kingdom.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bsmithslo
10:16 AM on 03/31/2011
The sentiment that one man's Heaven is another man's Hell is quite correct. Rob Bell's attempt to present God as kinder and more moral seems to fail to recognize this fact.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bsmithslo
10:14 AM on 03/31/2011
Two points. #1. We begin to enter into paradise now, immediately as we choose to enter into a new relationship with God (no lover choosing to remain enemies but rather becoming his friend. Paradise does not come however until everyone enters that same position (i.e. I can't really enter paradise while my neighbor suffers. To think differently is a form of narcissism. #2. In order for free will to exist, "love" cannot always win. If those who consider "God's love winning" a form of manipulation have no alternative other than to eventually submit their criticisms of God are valid. They are mere puppets. Strangely, the concept of Hell gives God's enemies more power and good news not less. If Paradise is a new reality in God's presence and Hell is a new reality devoid of it the descriptors of them are merely subjective (i
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William D Simpson
11:18 PM on 03/30/2011
Accurately did the writers of Scripture foretell of the day when false teachers would be the rave of modern-day culture. Having read/listened to Rob Bell, he offers nothing different than all the other opinions of the false teachers of present-day evangelical emergent/unitarian christianity.

http://wsimpson.wordpress.com/2011/03/16/love-wins-is-rob-bell-at-his-best/
01:31 PM on 03/30/2011
Rob: I will never convince you that you are wrong but I will say this

Genesis 3:4

Viewing the 1769 King James Version. Click to switch to 1611 King James Version of Genesis 3:4

And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die:
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:58 PM on 03/31/2011
Yes, the serpent did tell the woman she could disobey God and she wouldn't die. The serpent lied and continues to lie and mislead humans.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:40 PM on 03/29/2011
It is absolutely necessary to repent from sins if we would like to be accepted by God .,since no sins are acceptable in Heaven .Moreover if we're all going to Heaven anyway then what's the use of the gospel message ?what is the urgency ?

Then the criminals might as well continue to commit their crimes the world might as well continue in sin ,child molesters ,human traffickers ,defrauders ,torturers,thieves , liers ,killers .What happens to the message of redemption at Calvary? I thought we were all supposed to repent ?.Isn't that the biblical message?
11:02 PM on 03/29/2011
I think you should be the one writing the book!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JayMonaco
12:30 PM on 03/30/2011
If punishment and reward is your sole motivation, you have missed the entire point.
02:25 AM on 03/31/2011
How so? Jesus spoke of punishment and reward all the time. He said that we would have "treasures in heaven" if we followed him. He told us to store up treasure in heaven where "moth does not rust and destroy and where thieves do not break in and steal."

Hebrews 11:6 tells us that

"And without faith it is impossible to please God, because anyone who comes to him must believe that he exists and that he rewards those who earnestly seek him."

So, yes, eternal punishment and reward shouldn't be our SOLE motivation for living the Christian life, as love for each other should come naturally as an overflow of our love for God. But according to Jesus, it should be PART of our motivation. Jesus does not condemn us for seeking eternal personal fulfillment-- he promises us that very thing.
photo
Bianca Befana
...Teach your children well...
09:24 PM on 03/28/2011
Repent they preach at mas on Sunday,
But do they practice what was preached on Monday?
They say non-believer's go to Hell and burn,
Only believer's go to Heaven, but what have they learned?
What is needed in this world is Peace, not blame,
For the The Goddess & God are united, no matter Their Name!
Blessed Be!
08:31 PM on 03/28/2011
Rob, I don't know if you know this or not but I think what you are looking for can be found in the Roman Catholic Church's teaching of purgatory-a place in the afterlife where people 'continue to grow in holiness'.

I believe the same thing as you preach in this book, and having just reverted to the RCC, it was ...comforting? to me to realize that God is much more merciful that black and white/heaven and hell that I had been previously taught (which was one of my major sticking points of mainstream Protestantism).