iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rob Densen

GET UPDATES FROM Rob Densen
 

Lung Cancer Kills, So Does Indifference

Posted: 11/19/2010 4:11 pm

By the time you finish this post, two more Americans will receive the life-rending diagnosis of lung cancer. Sadly, given the current state of lung cancer research, diagnosis and treatment, they -- like most of the 225,000 other Americans who will receive a lung cancer diagnosis in 2010 -- are likely to be dead within five years.

There will be an estimated 160,000 lung cancer deaths in 2010. It is a staggering number and more than the total for breast, colon, ovarian, melanoma, brain and leukemia combined.

Here's another sad reality: 71,000 women will die of lung cancer this year -- almost twice as many as will die from breast cancer. And in this era of gender equality, lung cancer is an unfortunate area of catch-up: women are now being diagnosed with lung cancer at almost the same rate as men.

Those are just some of the facts of this dreadful disease. Here is another: my wife has lung cancer.

A Club We Would Rather Not Be a Part of

My wife Barb is a member of a rapidly growing club -- the Women-Who've-Never-Smoked-With-Loving-Families-Who-Get-Lung-Cancer-Anyway Club. Indeed, cancer incidence among women who've never smoked is one of the fastest growing of all cancers. No one really knows why. And from where we sit, it feels like the accompanying question is, does anyone really care?

Lung cancer sucks, but the thing that sucks the most is that by the time you're symptomatic, the disease has usually spread beyond medical science's ability to cure it. As Barb says of her illness, "We all have limited time; I'm just a little more aware of that fact."

As a family, we don't question why lung cancer happens and why it happened to ours. What we don't understand is why we are not much further along in the fight against this awful disease. And therein lies the tale.

Race for a Cure? More Like a Slow Crawl

A child who developed cancer in the 1960s had about a 20 percent five-year survival rate; a child with cancer in 2010 has about an 80 percent rate (closer to 90 percent at the nation's top pediatric cancer centers).

Similar breath-taking progress has been made in the fight against breast cancer, where the five-year survival rate for Stage I is now 96 percent, up from 80 percent in the 1950s.

But the numbers on lung cancer are hardly encouraging. For example, only half of all people diagnosed with Stage I lung cancer will be alive five years later. If you're diagnosed with Stage IV lung cancer, the survival rate is four percent. Those numbers have not changed much over the years.

So while huge gains have been made in treating most cancers, progress is grudging in the fight against lung cancer. There has been some progress -- indeed, my wife is the beneficiary of a diagnostic protocol and a drug that didn't exist 10 years ago -- but not nearly enough. A large part of the problem is that the disease has not received public attention or research dollars proportionate to its prevalence or virulence. It is as if there is a serial killer loose in our community and everyone is looking the other way.

$$$$ Are the Secret Sauce

Basically, here's the way the fight against cancer works. No dollars for research, no progress. Some dollars for research, some progress. A lot of dollars, a lot of progress.

To use the killer-on-the-loose analogy, in the fight against lung cancer, the more money, the more cops on the street and the better equipped they are.

Unfortunately, private fundraising for lung cancer research badly lags the efforts in support of other cancers -- and the story repeats itself in terms of federal dollars. As reported by the Orlando Sentinel last month, "federal funding for other common cancers still dwarfs that for lung cancer -- which receives just $1,200 for every death compared to $27,000 per death for breast cancer, $14,000 for prostate cancer and $6,500 for colon cancer."

There are, I think, two reasons the fight against lung cancer has more often than not resembled a thumb wrestle. One, it's not a particularly "media-genic" disease. It's hard to depict lung cancer in a way that tugs at the heart strings and opens checkbooks. Nothing very compelling about a 70-year-old tethered to an oxygen tank.

But there is a more insidious and dangerous reason dollars for lung cancer research lag. We blame the victim. Jane Brody's article in the New York Times earlier this year, "Blame's Net Catches Lung Cancer Patients," brilliantly articulated this point.

When it comes to lung cancer, there is this nasty syllogism at work: smoking causes lung cancer, people who smoke have a choice in the matter (apparently, the heroin-like vice grip of nicotine notwithstanding), so why fund cancer research? Why? Because lung cancer is the most prevalent and lethal of all cancers. Why? Because 30,000 Americans will die this year who never puffed a cigarette, many of them in their 30s, 40s and 50s. Why? Because many of those who die of lung cancer will have stopped smoking 20 years ago or more. Why? Because right now, millions of Americans are struggling mightily to stop smoking. Why? Because cigarette companies -- the 800-pound gorillas sitting on our loved ones' chests -- are cunning, deep-pocketed, and lethally effective marketers making sure there are another 200,000 Americans in place next year to receive the dread diagnosis.

To Oppose Something Is to Maintain It

Clearly, the issue of lung cancer research and treatment could use the right, high-profile attention. It would be swell if the White House were bathed for a night in a colored light that flickered on and off to simulate respiration or if the NFL floated a giant inflatable lung balloon over every stadium or allowed lung cancer survivors to inflate the game balls. But, frankly, given lung cancer's prevalence -- who among us does not have a friend, co-worker, family member or neighbor who has succumbed to this despicable disease -- the biggest ssue isn't awareness; it's forgiveness.

It is time to forgive lung cancer patients and their families. We love and need our moms and dads, husbands and wives, sisters and brothers, grandpas and grandmas. I must admit, for years I ignored this disease and was secretly disdainful of smokers. But since my wife's diagnosis, I've listened, learned and reflected. The men, women and families we've met in hospital waiting rooms have come from all walks of life. Some have never smoked, some stopped decades ago, some still smoke today, struggling desperately with their nicotine addiction just as some of us struggle with a desire for sugar, alcohol or one more hand at the poker table. I have come to understand this simple, elemental truth: "Forgiveness," as author-educator Christina Baldwin once wrote, "is the act of admitting we are like other people."

But there is one group I am not prepared to forgive: Congress. Our elected officials have dawdled -- dangerously and inexplicably -- to pass the bi-partisan Lung Cancer Mortality Reduction Act, which requires the federal government to make fighting lung cancer a higher priority. Its goal: to cut in half the number of lung cancer deaths in the next five years.

You can help. In the amount of time it takes to breathe in and out a couple of dozen times, you can click here to sign a petition to encourage the President and the Congress to act or here to contact your Congressional representatives and voice your support of this legislation. You may just help to save tens of thousands of lives.

Finally, if you are looking for more information on lung cancer, the following sites are terrific resources: www.lungcanceralliance.org, www.nationallungcancerpartnership.org, www.lungevity.org, www.lungcancerfoundation.org and www.unitingagainstlungcancer.org.

 
FOLLOW IMPACT
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:46 PM on 12/01/2010
Mr. Denson,
Perhaps the ONLY good thing about your wifes' diagnosis is your new awareness and this article.
It is the best and most truthful I've seen published anywhere. I admire your admission of secret disdain for smokers.
Diagnosed with stage 4 myself eleven years ago, I've been blessed!

Stage4Survivor
10:20 PM on 11/24/2010
I am so sorry to hear about your wife's diagnosis, and I hope she is doing well. I too was diagnosed with stage four lung cancer in June 09, I am doing well, but it is a rough road. I had no idea what a killer LC was, how poor the funding was, and what a stigma it has until I found myself in this position. Thank you for this article and for increasing the knowledge and awareness of this disease. I signed both petitions, I sure hope many do also. Wishing you and your wife health and many happy years together.
All the best
Lia
10:31 PM on 11/23/2010
Rob, I cannot begin to tell you how hopeful it makes me to read this. I lost my Father just 4 months ago to lung cancer. He was 61 years old and a smoker. From March to July I watched him go from a vivacious, athletic man to a weak, helpless shell of himself. His lung cancer was found in a routine check-up with no symptoms. I also lost an Aunt this past January to lung cancer. She was 47, had never smoked a day in her life, and was thought to have had pneumonia. I have learned from my experience that until we can convey to Americans the severity of this disease, it will continue to be brushed aside and carry a stigma that causes many to turn a blind eye. Your article was candid, poignant, and completely heartfelt; qualities that are hard to muster watching a loved one battle lung cancer. Thank you for writing this and for sharing your deeply personal experience with your readers; from a young woman about to spend her first holidays without her Father, please know that it's people like you that give me hope that my family's pain will one day not be so many others' as well. May your Thanksgiving this year give you much to be thankful for, especially your wife Barb who will be in my prayers this holiday season.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rob Densen
11:02 AM on 11/24/2010
Molly:

Barb and I are so sorry for your recent losses, but so most appreciative of your support and prayers. Thank you, too, for sharing your story. As you suggest, it is hard to "go public" with lung cancer given all the stigma attached to the issue. The problem is that the longer lung cancer is allowed to hide in plain sight, the more lives it will take. We need to move lung cancer -- and the appalling lack of research funding and public advocacy -- into the spotlight. It will take courageous people like you who are willing to share their stories and their emotions and expose lung cancer for what it is -- a dreadful disease that is stealing tens of thousands of loving and beautiful people from us each and every year. Anything you can do to share the article and encourage your friends to sign the petition and, in turn, share it with their friends, will be important. Finally, Molly, know this: among the many things the Densens are so appreciative of this Thanksgiving is your sharing, support and eloquence. May g-d bless you and your family.
05:26 PM on 11/22/2010
I urge your readers to test their homes for Radon gas the leading cause of lung cancer in nonsmokers and the leading environmental cause of cancer mortality.
01:51 PM on 11/22/2010
Many people also forget that lung cancer is not exclusively caused by smoking. Toxic chemicals such as radon gas and asbestos fibers can also cause this devastating disease. I agree with the theme of this post though. Lung cancer is one of the most deadly forms of cancer, yet among the least funded. It’s not just a “smoker’s disease” – we could be taking major steps to prevent and cure it, but seem to have an uphill battle ahead of us.
TM http://www.mesorc.com/
06:20 PM on 11/21/2010
Healthcare Town Hall » Actuarial study anticipates, supports recent findings on lung cancer screening. http://www.healthcaretownhall.com/?p=3248
09:45 AM on 11/21/2010
Barb & Rob,

Had no idea what you are going through. Have signed all the petitions, sent it to all my kids and everyone on my email list. Is there any fund you would prefer that we donate to - to help take any step towards curing this terrible disease? Our thoughts, prayers and hearts are with you!

Much love,

Peggy & Tom Hall
02:26 AM on 11/21/2010
I watched the woman I love die 2.5 years ago in her hospital bed from the effects of lung cancer. By this time it spread through out her body and caused a major tumor in her throat that blocked her airway. She did indeed smoke, but I don't see why that should matter. She was still a wonderful woman who touched many lives. I still remember sharing her thoughts on these issues. "Why is there so much awareness and support for breast cancer but nothing for lung cancer? Lung cancer kills more people and effects both genders rather than predominantly women." I knew the answer, but...and I'm sure she did too. Instead of giving her the answer I just gave answers that would make her laugh eventually. That's the best I could do for her then. Now in her passings, all I can do now is help make change. My only wish is she was here for it all. 37 years old is far too young to die. In closing, new studies are showing some traces of nicotine to a cause of breast cancer. Something to think about when this actually becomes official...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
momstudent
08:49 PM on 11/20/2010
We all know why lung cancer is not advocated like other cancers and or chronic illnesses. People attach smoking automatically, and therefor blame. Period. Regardless if the individual smoked or not. Though doctors, friends and sadly family may think silently to themselves-perhaps our loved one and or friend is not willing to admit she smoked. My mother was a smoker and passed away from lung cancer at the age of 58. Every single childhood friend whose mothers also smoked while we were children have also passed away from lung cancer too. Smoking is an addiction and I believe needs to be treated as one. Meaning detox and recovery just in the same manner as alcohol and other drugs, people forget tobacco is a drug. There is nothing more sad than to witness a individual smoke very well knowing it will kill them, just as any other addict. With the exception tobacco does not make the smoker impaired. So now, at the age of 47 I fear all of those years growing up in a household with two parents smoking, knowing I never smoked, I too am at risk of lung cancer. Best wishes to all whom have lost a loved one to lung cancer, and let us all pray the assigned shame will be removed.
07:38 PM on 11/20/2010
I know that club all too well. The GOOD news is, we're begunning to have a voice. I urge you to join us. The work that Bannie Addario is doing will blow your MIND! She's an amazing woman. The BJALCF is making noise and being heard. Pleas, anyone who is dealing with this...as a patient OR family member..as Bonnie says "we're in a HURRY, hurry with us" This is the BJALCF's Facebook link :
http://www.facebook.com/BJALCF?ref=ts
And another rising (and closely associated with BJALCF) is WTF, Where's The Funding for LC? support support support!!!
This is our Facebook link : http://www.causes.com/causes/402351-support-wtf-where-s-the-funding-for-lung-cancer-campaign?recruiter_id=59918814

I'll be a 3 yr. survivor this Feb. : ) Let's get LOUD.
04:41 PM on 11/20/2010
Done! Let's hope things change. Soon.

I heard about this from a friend of your wife's via email and have forwarded it to friends of mine. Let's spread the word!

My very best wishes to you and your wife. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
01:24 PM on 11/20/2010
Thanks ... My wife, Dianne, is in the same club as yours.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rob Densen
02:53 PM on 11/20/2010
Joe: Our thoughts and prayers are with your family as well. Here's hoping that if we can get something done with this bill that our wives would benefit. If you could share the article with your friends and families, urging them to sign the petition and/or pass the article along to their friends, that would be great. WIth a bunch of small, individual actions, maybe we can, together, move the world. All the best.
12:11 PM on 11/20/2010
You have said it all, and so thoroughly. As a 7 1/2 year lung cancer survivor, I understand fully the need to continue to speak out to eliminate the stigma of lung cancer and to increase funding for lung cancer research. I will continue to advocate for what the lung cancer community needs in any way that I am able, and to do my best in carrying on the voice of those who are no longer with us. I encourage other survivors and family members reading this to do the same. Thank you for your wonderful article and best of luck to your family!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rob Densen
03:02 PM on 11/20/2010
Debi: Thank you, thank you for your comment. I shared it with Barb and we were both tremendously encouraged. Seven and one half years -- you are truly an inspiration. If you wouldn't mind sharing the article with friends and family, asking them to sign the petition, that would be awesome. Maybe together we can have an impact of the fight against this crummy disease. May god bless you and your family, and may you have a wonderful Thanksgiving. I think both our famlies have a lot to be thankful for.
01:55 PM on 11/23/2010
Thanks Rob - and may you and Barb and family have a great holiday also. I had signed the petition already but I did post your article on my FB page - I tend to use that as a platform to get out as much info as I can about lung cancer; if you are my friend, you sort of buy the whole package. :) It's so important to educate people, not only to increase funding opportunities but to let them know that it can happen to them and those they love, and maybe they can be just a little more prepared than I was. Thanks again for covering everything so well!
08:52 PM on 11/19/2010
I signed the petition in my area. My prayers go out to you and your family. It amazes me how easy it is for one to judge another suffering or dying from lung cancer without even knowing how or why they have lung cancer. For me it does not matter if one smokes or not. It is a disease that needs to be addressed, as you so eloquently stated "We love and need our moms and dads, husbands and wives, sisters and brothers, grandpas and grandmas. " and "Some have never smoked, some stopped decades ago, some still smoke today, struggling desperately with their nicotine addiction just as some of us struggle with a desire for sugar, alcohol or one more hand at the poker table. " Who is anyone to judge another in such dire circumstances. God Bless your wife and your family.