iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rob Shuter

Rob Shuter

Posted: December 17, 2009 02:45 PM

Tiger Dumped Because He's Black?

What's Your Reaction:

Tiger can't be happy about losing his lucrative endorsement deals, however I'm sure he WILL be happy to see he has been dumped by most of the weekly celebrity magazines already. Even if the reason why is very disturbing.

Sources with access to weekly sales numbers tell me that figures for last week's issues of In Touch, OK! and US Weekly, which all featured Tiger on their covers, were well below average. Only People, whose cover featured a sad looking Mrs. Woods, sold well.

In the magazine business once a celebrity has a bad week they are banished to a far away land. Which in Jennifer Lopez's case was New Jersey.

At first glance this would explain why you wont be seeing Tiger grinning at you from the checkout at the supermarket this weekend (with the exception of cheeky Star magazine, whose genius photo department found a shot of the golfer with his arm around that old cover favorite: Jessica Simpson).

But the bigger question is why didn't Tiger sell better on the newsstands in the first place? Why didn't his troubles become the new Kate and Jon Gosselin, who set a record for being on the cover of US Weekly seven weeks in a row?

Dan Wakeford, Editor-in-Chief of Life and Style, the only magazine smart enough not to jump into the Tiger story as its main cover, told me, "Readers were involved in the whole Gosselin family and invested in the world they'd invited us into, but with Tiger they barely know any personal details about him and his family."

Excellent points Mr. Wakeford but could there be another reason for Tiger's poor sales?

Richard Spencer, Editor-in-Chief of the powerhouse weekly In Touch, agrees. "The reason why Tiger isn't a Jon and Kate for the weeklies is because Jon and Kate were seen on TV weekly. Readers tire quickly of cheating just as they did with Jon's alleged affairs too."

And while I agree with both editors, another editor, who asked to remain anonymous, told me something much more alarming: "With the exception of Oprah, no African-American sells magazine covers. Period. If Tiger were a white dude with this crazy messed-up, never-ending drama, the tabloids would be in heaven. They couldn't print magazines fast enough to keep up with demand."

This reminds me of a similar debate that occurred last year when Jay-Z was noticeably absent from all covers when he married Beyonce. At the time, US magazine's then editor-in-chief Janice Min confessed, "typically, you will hear that discussion [African American celebrities not selling magazines] among a group of all-white editors." A group that now sits at the top of every single weekly masthead.

I hope I'm wrong. I hope Star's playful editor Candace Trunzo is right when she says, "Kate and Jon who? The same thing will happen with Tiger." It just seemed to happen awfully fast to me.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 77
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
04:39 PM on 12/23/2009
For being black? That's news to Tiger.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ChelleAgain
It's Chelle ... again.
06:20 PM on 12/22/2009
The Tiger Woods thing is embarrassing -- I think a lot of people are looking the other way out of disappointment. It's not fun to gloat over this one, because the guy was -- if not a hero -- seemingly admirable in many ways.
04:47 PM on 12/22/2009
People are way over-thinking this with the assumption that race and ethnicity could somehow be causing a slump in magazine sales when Tiger Woods is on the cover.

Blame it on the incessant news coverage of this story! We're all so sick of the 24/7 coverage that we get through tv, radio, Internet, Twitter, Google that by the time the magazines came out on the stands, we were so over it. What sleazy detail is left to know?!

When news of the first mistresses leaked, it was intriguing. But now, it no longer matters whether there are 10 or 20 or 30 of them. We get the picture! Athlete lets success go to his head, makes risky and foolish choices, and it costs him everything: family, friends, career, business connections and reputation.
11:06 AM on 12/23/2009
I kinda think so too. When there actually were real news stories out there, the 24-hour-news channels still put Tiger Woods at the top of their list, and also more people now than ever get their news and gossip online. I don't actually know anybody personally who even buys celebrity magazines anymore, because you can get the same stories online and that story was on tv constantly anyway (plus those magazines are always going to be in the hair salon/doctor's office/whatever anyway for you to read later).
11:58 PM on 12/21/2009
This is pretty thin logic

Couldn't it have been because he was asian?
After all there are far fewer asian celebrities than blacks.
Quick, name a prominent asian american.
I bet its not as easy as naming a prominent african american
keith1963
10-year Army veteran
04:17 PM on 12/21/2009
I do believe so in part. White celebs have been busted in Hollywood for years and it usually goes away within an eye blink. I've stomached Nancy Grace last week for a couple of days and you would think this was OJ all over again. That woman makes me sick to the highest level when it comes to any black person. When that first security guard got arrested in the Aruba case the man's face was shown every 20-30 seconds on her show. When he was released Nancy was damn near a mime for days. Faux Noise was the same but they haven't played this out like Nancy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MakersMark
Blame me..I voted for him twice & would again!
02:51 PM on 12/21/2009
Could it be that it's mostly whites buying these magazines, therefore people like to see and identify with people that look just like them?

In my house, we recycle mags, and we, being African American tend to love the covers with blacks on them more than whites. When we have a stack and they're all read, we pass them along.
photo
jukesgrrl
Hands off SS, Medicare & Medicaid
01:42 PM on 12/21/2009
"...could there be another reason for Tiger's poor sales?" I'm usually the first one to shout prejudice. I still disagree strongly with those who say the teabag movement is not racist. But in this case, I don't see it.

I live in a very sports-oriented family and community and I know many rabid Tiger Woods fans. I doubt most of them have ever heard of US, OK, or In Touch. Flop down in front of the TV and watch Larry King talk about Tiger Woods, absolutely. Buy a tab? Maybe People, at the airport, but the others, not likely. The specific readership demographic for celebrity magazines does not define a golfer -- even the most famous golfer in the world -- as one of their "celebrities," black, white, or in between.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
78Thomas
04:33 AM on 12/21/2009
Do articles given a racially triggered titles actually mean they are newsworthy?

First of all, he's half asian. He's only a quarter black.

So what does that say?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mountainweb
Conservative Commonsense
02:01 PM on 12/20/2009
Get a clue, he is not on the cover because he has established a high water mark for being DUMB. When you have staff of people whose job it is to manage your mistresses (16+) like he does, it shows a pretty low level of respect for women. NOT something that sells magazines. Disrespect is color blind!
10:33 PM on 12/19/2009
There is always an element of race in the equation, somewhere.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Snafu
I don't trust Peppermint Butler
10:29 PM on 12/19/2009
I think your average American could really care less about golf. Most people think it's boring. Pretty simple.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shzron1946
09:41 PM on 12/19/2009
I don't care why it is happening, I am just glad that it is happening. I mean for goodness sake, a great sportsman who happened to be married turned out to be a dog around the ladies.

What else is new?
08:31 PM on 12/19/2009
It's not because he is about 40% black. It's because the mob doesn't really enjoy his downfall. They would rather see other celebrities go down in flames...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
bnyb
sky-gazer
11:43 AM on 12/21/2009
Thank you! That's my reason for not quite 'enjoying' the story as we're, you know, 'supposed to'.

I still think he's a brilliant sportsman, talented and has done extrememly well for himself as a self-made man. I remember seeing him play Adam Scott in Troon, Scotland - Woods' focus and game was impeccable.

His penchant for women who are not his wife, is frankly his own business.
04:53 PM on 12/19/2009
This is really not a secret. Traditionally, magazines with black womeno n the cover haven't sold well, one of the reasons you usually see whites on the covers. Thankfully, that has changed a little in recent years, yet even when you see beautiful Halle Berry on the cover, there are so many lights shining on her, that her skin looks several shades lighter - so they can cover their butts and say "hey, look, we've got color on the cover!" Yet still make her look pale enough to satisfy the mainstream. Michelle Obama is the only black woman I have not seen photoshopped to whiteness on a cover.

Think about it- have you EVER seen a black woman on the cover of a bridal magazine? It's so lily-white, you'd think blacks don't even get married, they are so poorly represented. Therein lies the reason people of different groups want their own publications, and channels, etc. If the mainstream does not include them, there is no other option.

I'm not sure how it plays for a sports figure, though, since so many are considered mainstream already. That could play a part in why mags with Tiger's wife sold, and others didn't, or it might not. Or it could be that people prefer to read stories about the victim - his wife, and the mistresses. Oh wait, they are all white too.
01:08 PM on 12/19/2009
I think it is very simple. Tiger is boring. A rich and famous athlete cheating on his wife. Don't they all?
10:17 PM on 12/20/2009
If you find and prove a married man, white, black or green, hasn't cheated--then that's NEWS.
11:43 PM on 12/20/2009
I'm pretty sure a lot of them don't, but a lot of them do. It's kind of like when expectant parents say they want their child's sex to be a surprise--there are only two normal options. If your kid is neither a boy nor a girl, THAT would be a surprise. But a guy cheating, or not, is just life.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:37 AM on 12/21/2009
I must be news!!