THE BLOG
05/22/2014 03:54 pm ET Updated Jul 22, 2014

An Energetic Yet Emotionally Empty Motown the Musical

Twice a day, on the way to and from work, I pass the Oriental Theatre, where the national tour of Motown the Musical is running through August 9. Of all the shows that have played at the Oriental, this one is unique in that I constantly see couples, groups and families pausing when seeing the show's marquee, grouping together and posing for a selfie. Clearly, Motown isn't so much a record production label as it's an icon of change and music revolution that taps into something resonant -- an era gone by.

Arriving on the tidal wave of its hit Broadway run, Motown the Musical is pretty much what you'd expect from a vehicle designed to showcase a library of chart-toppers: a slick cavalcade of toe-tapping, hip-swaying tunes stitched together with a sketch of a storyline. What makes Motown the Musical a distinct challenge from most other Jukebox musicals are two factors. First, the massive catalog of material -- Motown founder Berry Gordy, Jr., who wrote the musical's book, had hundreds of top 10 hits to choose from, with artists such as Smokey Robinson, The Jackson Five, The Supremes, Diana Ross and Stevie Wonder at his disposal. Where do you start? Second, Motown was instrumental in changing the sound of the airwaves during a seminal time in our country's history. The story behind the music is just as, if not more, compelling than the music itself.

Whittling all this down for a three-hour show was surly no small feat -- and what we've arrived at is frantic fractions of iconic musical performances jam-packed together (though, faithfully reproduced by a hard-working ensemble who play countless roles) into a condensed explosion of sound and light projected against the dimly lit backdrop of social change.

2014-05-22-motown.jpg
The National Tour cast of "Motown the Musical"

That said, the audience around me seemed to be loving their Motown experience -- the louder and brighter, the better. Which tasks the leads, played by Clifton Oliver as Barry Gordon and Allison Semmes as Diana Ross, with projecting their surprisingly grounded performances (despite the paint-by-numbers book scenes) across the multiple LED lights and overworked sound system. The statuesque Semmes, in particular, knows how to work a crowd, and in a delightful moment near late act two, she gets to break the fourth wall to interact with the audience in full-on diva Ross mode.

If more real, connecting moments like this could have been found within this story, Motown the Musical could be more than just a glossy hit parade of fabulous songs backed by a smattering of a history lesson. Yes, the powerballads are there, but the potential is hardly tapped.

"Motown the Musical" plays through August 9 at the Oriental Theatre. More info here.