iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Creamer

GET UPDATES FROM Robert Creamer
 

Last Friday the GOP Had a Really Bad Day

Posted: 02/ 5/2012 10:57 pm

Last Friday the GOP had a really bad day. It didn't come in the form of new polling results -- or some new political scandal. It was delivered to them by the economic statistics:

  • Private sector jobs up 243,000 -- almost 100,000 more than expected.
  • Unemployment rate down to 8.3 percent.
  • Twenty-three straight months of private sector jobs growth.

But you say, this is not bad news -- this is good news. Not for the GOP and its chances of ousting President Obama, seizing control of the Senate or maintaining its majority in the House.

As Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell made ever so clear early last year, the Republican Leadership -- and their backers on Wall Street -- have one and only one goal: to defeat President Obama next fall. To do that, the GOP is betting against the American economy.

For the last two years they have done everything in their power to slow America's recovery from the greatest economic meltdown since the Great Depression.

They have opposed virtually every element of the president's American Jobs Act.

They brought the economy to the brink by threatening that they wouldn't allow America to pay its bills during the debt ceiling standoff last year.

They tried their best to prevent extension of the payroll tax holiday and unemployment benefits that are so critical to maintaining buying power momentum as the economy begins to pick up speed.

And, of course, they advocate returning to the regulatory and fiscal policies that caused the Great Recession in the first place.

But the most significant thing they have done to stall the economic recovery has been their refusal to continue federal aid to state and local government.

In the last 23 months, the economy has created 3.7 million new private sector jobs. But during the same period, it has created only 3.165 net total jobs. That is because government -- mainly state and local government -- laid off a net of about 535,000 people.

If the Republicans in Congress had not refused to continue providing aid to state and local governments, it is likely that unemployment would be in the mid 7 percent range and the economy as a whole would have at least another half million jobs.

And we would also be more likely to have more private sector jobs as well, since the additional teachers and firefighters and policemen who the Republicans basically fired, would have had money to spend on the products and services produced by private businesses.

As much as they like to pretend they don't agree with "Keynesian" economics, many Republicans completely understand that by refusing to provide aid to state and local government, they are hurting the economic recovery -- and that is exactly what they are trying to do.

They have been perfectly willing to allow our kids to have fewer teachers and bigger class sizes, and to allow our cities to have fewer policemen and firefighters all to advance their political goal of slowing the economic recovery.

But despite their efforts to the contrary, the economy is beginning to gain traction. That is very important to the prospects of everyday Americans -- and it is critically important politically.

Anyone who has ever tried to move a car that is stuck in the snow -- or in the mud -- knows what I mean. As long as the car just keeps spinning its wheels, there seems to be no hope. But after you've shaken and pushed, and put sand under the tires and the car finally begins to get the smallest amount of traction -- everyone's spirits change. Suddenly there is hope that you're finally going to get the car moving again.

That's what's beginning to happen to the economy -- and it will have an enormous effect on the attitudes of voters. It begins to give them hope that the president's policies are, in fact, moving the economy in the right direction -- that it actually is beginning to build up steam -- that there is hope that middle class Americans are actually going to see their prospects begin to improve.

And it gives lie to the ridiculous statements of Mitt Romney, who continued to claim as late as last Friday that Barack Obama has made the economy "worse."

The definition of "worse" is "not as good as it was before." The economic disaster that was caused by the policies of the Bush administration -- the same policies that Romney wants to bring back to the White House -- caused the destruction of 8 million jobs. In fact, George Bush was the first president in modern American history to preside over net zero private sector job growth.

As soon as President Obama took office he put into place policies that reversed those jobs losses. Monthly private sector job losses declined continuously and finally turned positive -- and the economy has added private sector jobs continuously for the last 23 months. In the last two months alone, the economy has added 446,000 new jobs. That is not worse. In fact, that is commonly known as better. And that is a huge problem for the GOP political narrative this fall.

In the next several weeks, Congress will rejoin the battle over the extension of the payroll tax holiday and unemployment benefits for those who are out of work for no fault of their own. Recall that this was the fight that involved the complete surrender of GOP opposition in the week leading to the Christmas holidays. Then, they agreed to a two month extension that guaranteed that the battle would be renewed -- a fight that will once more highlight just how, when it comes to jobs, President Obama and the Democrats are doing battle with a "do nothing Republican Congress."

There will likely be ups and downs in the jobs numbers over the next eight months. But as long as the economy continues to gain traction -- and as long as Democrats continue to battle for jobs legislation in Congress -- there will be many more bad days ahead for the GOP's strategy of making themselves look better by trying to make the economy worse.

Robert Creamer is a long-time political organizer and strategist, and author of the book: Stand Up Straight: How Progressives Can Win, available on Amazon.com. He is a partner in Democracy Partners and a Senior Strategist for Americans United for Change. Follow him on Twitter @rbcreamer.

 
 
 

Follow Robert Creamer on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rbcreamer

 
 
  • Comments
  • 207
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
03:18 PM on 02/06/2012
"A poll by WashingtonPost and ABC News finds the Republican frontrunner clearly losing to Obama for the first time. Obama's approval rating came in at 50 percent—the highest since the killing of Osama bin Laden—and he is beating Romney 52 percent to 43 percent in a general-election matchup. Voters said they disapprove of things the GOP primary candidates have said during the race, and by more than 2 to 1, voters said that the more they learned about Romney, the less they like him."
03:03 PM on 02/06/2012
I guess that last $450,000,000,000 stimulus BHO was screaming for was just BS, huh. In order for you to believe this is bad news for Republicans, you would have to believe all the "obstruction" they are "guilty of" was of no consequence whatsoever. Quite the contrary, if they had not obstructed most of the Progressive agenda for the past year, I seriously doubt the current highly suspect unemployment number would be as low as it is. I guess keeping the Bush tax cuts worked after all.
02:42 PM on 02/06/2012
Unfortunately those Republicans blatantly fighting against the U.S. will never be brought up on charges of treason, or even Congressional rules. But that's okay, because I know someday the Repubs will blatantly fight the U.S. while simultaneously having an illicit affair that they deny (ala Monica Lewinski), and THEN they'll be in trouble!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thismachinekillsfascists
Exposing the GOP Lie-machine
02:13 PM on 02/06/2012
Let's flush the GOP down the drain of history this November!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gtobynj
If it's really funny, it's bound to offend someone
02:07 PM on 02/06/2012
The Republicans insist that government doesn't work. Then they get into office and prove it. Case in point, since they retook the House they have gone to war on everything leading the country to the brink of effective bankruptcy. Yet despite Republican inaction, the economy is gradually improving and almost certainly thanks in part, to the measures taken prior to that. What blows my mind is that anyone could want these people back in office.
photo
unitron
Reverse Chron Order never stays checked
02:04 PM on 02/06/2012
New generic Democratic campaign ad:

"When you step into that voting booth, remember, a bad day for the Republicans is a good day for America!"
photo
thejazz
I'll burn that bridge when I come to it.
02:00 PM on 02/06/2012
Great post, but you are missing the American prime directive. The credit for good news goes to whatever branch of government the GOP is in charge of. In this case the congress. Bad news gets credited to whatever branch of government the Dems are in charge of.
photo
maspring
Causing trouble: One post at a time.
01:43 PM on 02/06/2012
This is mostly true.

There is one caveat: As the economy improves, many people who were on the sidelines will be coaxed back into looking for work. These people will then be counted as part of the country's unemployed.

The result is that the unemployment statistics will probably trend upward even as the economy improves.

Look for the Republicans to play this up as much as humanly possible.
01:34 PM on 02/06/2012
Keep telling it like it is, Robert (and was). You never know, maybe even the entrenched, don't care about facts crowd will even catch on.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mcqball
01:23 PM on 02/06/2012
Mr. Cantor and Mr. Boehner stood there and said 'we can do better.' But they won't do better;
in fact, they refuse to do better. They came to office over a year ago and won't pass a jobs
bill. They continually try to obstruct progress in improving the economy hoping it will project poorly on the President. I feel when their faces are projected on the screen, there should be a caption beneath
them which says 'unclear on the concept.'
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CSDofNM
I speak lolcat
01:10 PM on 02/06/2012
Mr. Creamer is right, this is bad news for the GOP.

First, with the foreign policy successes (including Bin Laden) under his belt, Obama is strongest in the traditionally weakest Democratic area.

Second, with domestic policy failures and flubs being handed to the GOP right and left (Wisconsin, anyone?) all the GOP could hope for was a bad economy. Remember McConnell repeating the "Don't hire anyone until Obama is gone" line? Now - oops - the economy is still not good, but getting better.

When Obama finally gets around to asking - "Imagine where we could be if we actually TRIED", then all the obstruction and destruction caused by the GOP will come home to roost.

Don't expect the GOP to be able to field a baseball team from their caucus in 2013.
photo
DoubleYellowLines
Left of the Right, and Right of the Left
02:00 PM on 02/06/2012
Well, to go with the baseball analogy, every team will win 40 games and lose 40 games. Coaches and players will make the difference in all the rest. The same is true with the seats in the House and Senate - unless something truly dramatic happens, the GOP will control about 1/3 of the seats no matter how bad the narrative is. The question really is, how much change can/will occur? If Obama continues to be successful, if the economy continues to trend upward (shades of Reagan, right?), Obama gets reelected AND gets more help in the process. Which could very well lead to another Democrat President in 2016.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
beckjr2000
been there done that & tired of it
12:56 PM on 02/06/2012
Yes 243,000 new jobs created in the month of January and 345,000 NEW applications for unemployment insurance in the previous WEEK alone. How can over a million people sign up every month for unemployment insurance for the first time and all we hear about is the supposed job creation? There are still more than 5 million people unemployed today than in Jan 2010.

/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
libwithaclue
GOPers taste like chicken and smell like......
01:08 PM on 02/06/2012
Thank George W Bush for that. He lost 6 million American job from 2001 - 2008, many of which he happily let leave for China and India.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Awake-and-Sing
named after a great play written by Clifford Odets
03:31 PM on 02/06/2012
That while misleading the nation into war in Iraq under false pretenses while giving the superwealthy immoral wartime tax cuts they didn't need.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William1950
everything I say could be wrong.
12:44 PM on 02/06/2012
might be off subject... liberals in general are much more in favor of individual liberty and freedom.. liberals in general are much more business friendly.. they are in favor of equality, they are in favor of educating all children and in favor of continuing education.. they are in favor of a better world... and yeah, conservatives are against all of the above when their policies are looked at.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
M Grey
07 Saluting our armed forces
01:19 PM on 02/06/2012
Was that sarcasm?

"they are in favor of equality" - equality of outcome, not equality of opportunity. Conservatives aren't for giving people special rights, liberals are for it to make up for perceived inequalities.
"liberals in general are much more business friendly" - what planet? It's a talking point you have no support for, unless you call it for certain businesses like Green businesses. Did you really write that with a straight face?
" they are in favor of educating all children and in favor of continuing education" - And conservatives are against education and college? Really? Next you'll say you hate stereotypes and dumb bible banging rich oil/farmer conservative hicks.

"everything I say could be wrong"
You could be right with that one.
12:30 PM on 02/06/2012
Polls out today show a growing lead of Obama over Romney - one poll had him 9% ahead. Obama's favorability ratings are going up and Romney's are going down. I think the electorate is starting to understand that Romney is a patterned liar considering his past statements. He can lie or misrepresent maybe a couple of times and get a pass but when it gets beyond that it becomes a pattern. If Romney can't be truthful now, why should we trust him not to lie in the WH.
12:23 PM on 02/06/2012
Same old same old liberal stuff..A lot of pieces of the story missing to ensure to paint the worst picture of anyone who dares to criticize the Messiah.Sure, reasonable people would say that the jobless rate dropping is a good thing. If different principles were applied then you have likely seen larger decreases. I think he would have written the same arcticle no matter what happened. If unemployment went up...it's the GOP's fault...if it stays the same....it's the GOP's fault. Any "Success" is automatically attributed to the "brilliance" of Obama. If only each and everyone of us simply cried "All Hail the King" and let him do everything he wants then we would all be happy.
12:30 PM on 02/06/2012
Then list out some of those missing pieces. Your post is meanlingless.

And how exactly are facts (Things that actually happened) the "same of same of liberal stuff"?
01:05 PM on 02/06/2012
Because reality has a well known liberal bias
01:05 PM on 02/06/2012
The sourness of his grapes speaks volumes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
libwithaclue
GOPers taste like chicken and smell like......
01:11 PM on 02/06/2012
What is ONE thing the GOPer congress has done to increase American employment? JUST NME ME ONE THING!! I'll give you all day to think about it. Hint: This is a trick question, because they have done NOTHING!!!