iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Greenwald

Robert Greenwald

Posted: April 30, 2010 10:07 PM

Do I Look "Illegal?"

What's Your Reaction:

I have a question for you: Do I look "illegal?"

I'm probably not going to get pulled over and questioned about my citizenship while driving in Arizona. I'm probably not going to have to carry my birth certificate in my car to prove I was born in the United States. And let's be honest: The only reason this is true is because I am not a Latino.

It's disgraceful that Latinos have to worry about this in any state in the union in 2010.

Boycott Arizona video graphic

Brave New's Cuéntame project has been at the forefront of the fight against Arizona's racist anti-immigrant law, which allows the targeting of anyone a police officer "reasonably suspects" is in the country without documentation. (Reasonableness in the state that just threatened the jobs of teachers with accents is, of course, in the eye of the beholder.) We've tracked this issue in a series of short videos and launched a Facebook drive for an economic boycott targeting this unjust law.

A couple of days ago, though, we had a real breakthrough in our activism online. We let our supporters on Facebook vote for a slogan for a t-shirt to protest the racist law, and we got an avalanche of comments. "Do I Look 'Illegal?'" came out on top, and within hours we had hundreds of orders for t-shirts bearing this slogan. Shortly after, the phrase was in use on the major Latino groups on Facebook.

Clearly, there's a hunger out there for ways to push back against the racism insinuating itself into state policies and the wider national discourse.

I have a second question for you: Do you look "illegal?"

Join our "Do I Look 'Illegal?'" campaign on Facebook and send a strong message that Americans won't tolerate racist public policy in 2010.

 
 
 

Follow Robert Greenwald on Twitter: www.twitter.com/robertgreenwald

 
 
  • Comments
  • 421
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edwin Boyette
03:07 PM on 05/03/2010
So the descendants of the people who went to Europe and crushed the Nazis, and came back and made the United States apparently the most desirable place to live in the Americas are Nazis? So poor Central and South Americans are clamoring, and striving, and breaking the law out of deseperation to come live and work with Nazis? What sort of mental convultions do you have to go through to excrete some nonsense.



A people who built a place and reside in that place have the right to determine how they will live. The paralells that I see and the history ignored is the similarities between a distant Government (Washington/England) telling remote States (Arizona/Colonial America) how they will conduct their lives.
There is no parallel with Nazi Germany there is a distinct parallel with Colonial Pre-revolution America.
01:24 PM on 05/03/2010
Dear Robert Greenwald,

Please cease desist from writing any more articles....you're making yourself look very foolish.

Thanks, signed anyone with common sense.
01:20 PM on 05/03/2010
The author insinuates the people will have to carry birth ceritficate. As ordered by President Franklin Roosevelt legal immigrants must carry appropriate papers at all times, but the Arizona authorities have repeatedly said that they will accept a drivers license. How the request to see a driver's license imposes on anyone's civil rights is beyond me, I have had to show mine since I was 15 and now I am 56.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
ianmcc
Those who you let anger you conquer you
12:14 PM on 05/03/2010
A part of me does not feel sorry for the latinos current plight, as when the law that took effect in AZ latino groups then started to trot out the nazi, "First they came for latinos..." memo. Well guess what? Conservative right wingers have relied quite a bit on the latino voting base to vote against EQUAL rights for gay, lesbian, and transgendered Americans for quite some time now. Prop. 8 in CA is an excellent example.

So maybe if these same said conservative latinos had actually paid attention to that old nazi chestnut, they should have been voting to HELP LGBT Americans attain EQUAL rights. Since we have been attacked for some time now, the right wingers feel empowered to now go after other non-white and/or heterosexual groups, and that means latinos are now being targeted.

Sometimes irony can really bite you in the @$$.
12:58 PM on 05/03/2010
Oh please, stop with the Nazi references. This is about enforcing the laws, no more, no less.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
ianmcc
Those who you let anger you conquer you
01:03 PM on 05/03/2010
Total agreement here, I was merely parlaying what has already been said by others. I think to use such language is highly over inflated to the situation.
01:34 PM on 05/03/2010
I find it interesting that you post about Gay Rights with the Arizona law. I really don't see what one has to do with the other. The conservative latinos that should have anything to say about their representatives voting for or against Gay Rights are legal citizens of the United States. This law is to help with the illegal immigrants that have decided to make the Unites States their home. I think that if anyone wants to come to the USA legally, we should welcome them with open arms, if not then something should be done about it.

Not all conservatives "go after" non-white and/or non-heterosexual groups. Wow, that is not very open minded of you to think that way. In my opinion, all LEGAL citzens of the USA deserve equal rights.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
ianmcc
Those who you let anger you conquer you
02:59 PM on 05/03/2010
It's what's called an historically relevant and apt analogy.
12:09 PM on 05/03/2010
You know, as a white 40ish (American) woman who speaks spanish, I plan to take a whole mess of my "like complexion" friends to Arizona where we can speak Spanish to anyone who will listen. I am sure I won't be asked for my "papers" but, i sure hope I am. I think I could borrow one of my murdered Russian relatives Jewish stars too-- am I the only one who sees this being eerily and frighteningly similar?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
sonoffestus
Got smart & got out!
12:19 PM on 05/03/2010
You are exactly right. It is scary and way too familiar to anybody who pays attention to history.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TankGirlz
Lyrical Combat
12:58 PM on 05/03/2010
nope, you aren't too bad more people don't though.
11:28 AM on 05/03/2010
I live in Tucson at least once a week someone is shot or there's a home invasion by drug runners or human smugglers. Just a half hour south over the border they kill police and behead anyone in there way.things are getting worse here everyday something has to be done and if the federel goverment doesn't do anything what else are we suppose to do?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
damilitantone
Fed up with politicians
10:31 AM on 05/03/2010
Are those who are against the crackdown on illegal immigrants sending extra funds to the U.S. Treasury and their state and local governments to help defray the cost of providing public assistance to these folks? If not, who should pay the cost of supporting these folks? Should the American taxpayer foot the bill, the illegal immigrants' country of origin, or their supporters within the U.S.?
08:42 AM on 05/03/2010
MR Greenwald

Do you beleive it is ok for a police officer to require to see my driver's license if I happen to fail to signal a left hand turn while at a stop sign?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:38 AM on 05/03/2010
Chris , Do you believe it is alright to make a portion of the population carry an extra piece of paper to prove they have the right to be standing in a state of this country? Why is it alright for you to go around without having to carry your birth certificate upon your person?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
damilitantone
Fed up with politicians
10:25 AM on 05/03/2010
It's just the illegal part right? Are you willing to pay extra taxes to take care of the illegal folks that apply for public assistance? If as a taxpayer, I want my government to crackdown on the number of illegal immigrants that I am supporting through my taxes, then shouldn't I be allowed to voice my opinion? Have you sent the government extra tax funds to support the illegal immigrants that don't have jobs and who are costing the rest of us many millions in additional taxes?
10:48 AM on 05/03/2010
If you were legal, you dont have to worry about carrying around papers. Most countries, you have to keep your passport on you when there. But lets just be honest, this all about trying to secure a voting block. By the way, go take a look at FDR's immigration policy, now you want to talk about cracking down.
08:10 AM on 05/03/2010
Those inciting the public through misinformation should be held responsible for any harm that comes as a result of that.
This bill does also cover employers of illegals.
If you really care to know the truth read the bill
http://www.azleg.gov/legtext/49leg/2r/bills/sb1070s.pdf and a simple explanation
Center for Immigration Studies
http://cis.org/Announcement/AZ-Immigration-SB1070

"Before asking a person about immigration status, law enforcement officials are required by the law to have “reasonable suspicion” that a person is an illegal immigrant. The concept of “reasonable suspicion” is well established by court rulings. Since Arizona does not issue driver's licenses to illegal immigrants, having a valid license creates a presumption of legal status. Examples of reasonable suspicion include:

• A driver stopped for a traffic violation has no license, or record of a driver's license or other form of federal or state identification.
• A police officer observes someone buying fraudulent identity documents or crossing the border illegally.
• A police officer recognizes a gang member back on the street who he knows has been previously deported by the federal government.

The law specifically states that police, “may not solely consider race, color or national origin” when implementing SB 1070.

When Arizona’s governor signed the new law, she also issued an executive order requiring the Arizona Peace Officer Standards and Training Board to provide local police with additional training on what does and what does not constitute “reasonable suspicion.”
07:40 AM on 05/03/2010
Robert,
What is truly disgraceful is that you and those who seemingly support the status quo on boarder enforcement want to continue empowering the human traffickers, murders, rapists, and violent criminal illegals that victimize Latinos.
Authorities say the boy called 911 early Tuesday saying his 44-year-old mother might be dead. The teen and his mother were illegal border crossers and the boy says Mexican smugglers had kicked them out of a vehicle because she was sick.

Deputies found three illegal immigrants in the desert about 50 miles west of here Wednesday, a day after authorities discovered as many as 100 immigrants abandoned by smugglers in temperatures that exceeded 110 degrees.

Suspected Illegal Immigrant Charged With Rape, Impregnating 10-Year-Old Girl

Suspect in 2 Rapes Is Charged; Courts: Jose Zavala, an illegal immigrant from Mexico... He is accused of raping a 64-year-old woman who lives in the Thunderbird Oaks.

A Salvadoran man who was in the United States illegally has been charged with sexually assaulting a 10-year-old Manassas girl

Rape Charges: The suspect, an illegal immigrant, has a criminal record, has used aliases and has been deported twice after serving jail time.
A 17-year-old charged with raping an 8-year-old girl and leaving her for dead at an abandoned landfill is in the United States illegally.
An illegal alien from Ecuador has been charged with raping a 6-year-old girl with Down syndrome, authorities said.

Robert you should be ashamed!
11:55 AM on 05/03/2010
Come on Tunes59, they are only here to experience the American way of life.
Why are you being so hard on them???
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edwin Boyette
05:20 AM on 05/03/2010
Do I look racist? I'm southern born of Anglo-Irish ancestry. Despite the last name we have a sliver of French in us at best.

From our geneaology as best as I can my ancestors have served in the Armed forces in every generation back to colonial times with some branches of the family a bit late off the boat.

In the debate about immigration I keep hearing an overt anglo-phobia. Now I'll be the first to admit we conquered this land and displaced other people to obtain it. Slavery is a blight on our history too. But the same European-Americans who allowed slavery fought and perished to end it (I realize that the reasons for the Civil war are vast and debatable). Until recently the United States has been a nation of European-American people.

So while we may take most of the blame for the failures of our nation the same must go with the credit. That's not to minimalize anyone's contribution, it just a sheer matter of numbers. The European-American for the most part founded and built this country, along with the at first enslaved but now equal African Americans. As my African-Americans brothers are proud to celebrate their rich heritage so do I celebrate my European-American forebearers, their culture and custom.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Edwin Boyette
05:35 AM on 05/03/2010
I think we have some rightful claim what effect a mass immigration will have on traditional European-American cultural practices. Just as everyone else who loves their culture and attempts to preserve it so do I. If that makes me racist than I can only assume that every African-American, every Asian-American who has contemplated their history and culture with a sense of pride and connection must by definition be racist also.

I'm not reassured by the protests, I see that the immigrant right advocates have used more American Flags this time which is a positive step but I still see the divisions of MeCha, and LaRaza, and the chanting in Spanish. It seems it is the immigrants who want to cling to the other to that which separates us. As a European-American it almost seems as my culture and heritage is to be diminished. What a strange situation that my people could create a Nation that so many are so desperate to come to but so contemptous and sickened by the culture that created it. It's a paradox that I have not been able to satisfactorily unravel.
01:42 PM on 05/03/2010
Yes you are correct Edwin and since "La Raza" means "The Race" I assume it must be an organization fixated and race and certainly not Anglo-European culture. However, as Irish-Americans if we try to focus on our culture we are called "racists" and "bigots". Actually, all we have to do is disagree with Obama in any way and we are called "racist"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mottazuma
01:40 AM on 05/03/2010
Another right-wing immigration talking point bites the dust. Republicans will tell you that border violence is up, however, the facts do not agree...

http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/2010/05/02/20100502arizona-border-violence-mexico.html
10:26 PM on 05/02/2010
If you fall under the classification of "illegal alien", you are breaking the law. I am not against immigration, but I do feel that people who want to come here should do it legally. Illegals cost this country billions every year in public assistance in one form or another, which is one reason the border states, mainly California, are bankrupt or soon to be bankrupt. A lot of people are turning this into a humanitarian/refugee/civil rights type situation, it can't be that way, there are simply too many people in the world who live in dire conditions and we simply can't help them all. If our laws are so draconian, why aren't the same people who are making noise boycott every other country in the world? They all have immigration laws, and 99% of those countries hold true to their law, especially Mexico.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BoyInBOYCOTT
12:28 AM on 05/03/2010
Only when there is economic hardship, does America blame undocumented workers...in good times they neglect to mention the Social security deductions taken from checks of Undocumented workers with bogus SS#'s and which the worker knows they could never collect benefits on....those pay for our current senior's benefits. The additional production in Agri Businesses is due to cheap labor, the additional profits hotels make on the backs of their laundry employees, housekeepers, catering and banquet staff is due to cheap labor, the roofing and landscaping bids and contracts which comes in under budget, is due to cheap labor, and the Anglo women who can earn a substantial second household income on the backs of Latin@ nannies all contribute to making those finacial good times. You might say Mucho Gracias, and not rip their families apart.
01:31 AM on 05/03/2010
I REALLY THINK THA TO ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF "illegal aliens" WITHOUT TALKING ABOUT THE PEOPLE WHO HIRE THEM IS BOTH DISENGENUOSE AND DISHONEST. DONT GET ME WRONG I AM BE ANY STRECH OF THE IMAGINATION SUPPORTING ILLEGAL IMIGRATION,I MEAN AS A BLACK MAN IN AMERICA WHO IS WORKING CLASS,I KNOW MORE THAN MOST THE EFFECTS OF AN INFLUX OF CHEAP LABOR TO THE LOCAL COMMUNITIES.BUT AT THE SAME TIME,I BLAME THE PEOPLE WHO HIRE THEM WITH ONLY GREED AND PERSONAL GAIN AS THEIR MOTIVE.YES I THINK THE HARSHES AND STIFEST PUNISHMENT SHOULD BE RESERVED FOR THEM,BECOUSE IF THERE WAS NO ONE TO HIRE ILLEGALS THEY WOULD NOT COME HERE.I SERIUOSLT DOUBT IF THEY ARE COMING HERE JUST TO ENJOY THE LIFE OF LEISURE THAT IS WELFRE COME ON MAN USE YOUR BRAIN AND STOP LETTING fox news THINK FOR YOU
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
TRex86
Enjoying life in West Ohio
04:02 PM on 05/02/2010
Driving While Pigmented (DWP): Twelve years ago I drove my '73 El Dorado to Phoenix. Cruising at about 75-80 mph (like everyone else) I was pulled over by a state trooper, who did a doubletake when he saw a white guy at the wheel. My crime was driving while seeming to be black. In LA I've committed the same crime, getting pulled over for a "flickering" tail light. Again, big surprise to see a white guy at the wheel. Having chatted with Hispanic and African-American friends I doubt that my experiences are unusual. In fact they predict how the Arizona law will be enforced.

So let's put it in perspective. Whether they do racial profiling or not law enforcement does a lot of racial stereotyping. Moreover, they tend to be right wing politically. Contrary to the civil manner in which gun toting tea baggers get treated my experience at left wing demonstrations has been uniformly bad since the 60's. The cops look for any excuse to break things up and toss lefties in jail. It's all about law enforcement politics. Of course, the police will cook up any story that suits them to claim "reasonable suspicion" for stopping pigmented people. This law will accomplish nothing towards dealing with illegal immigration because it attacks the wrong end of the problem. Until we start jailing the employers of illegal immigrants we won't see real change. But are we ready for the economic consequences?
01:02 PM on 05/03/2010
Oh stop. Did you ever think that you were pulled over because you were speeding and your tail light was broken?
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
TRex86
Enjoying life in West Ohio
01:08 PM on 05/03/2010
My tail light wasn't flickering, and I was driving about 20 mph on that occasion. If you don't believe there is such a thing as DWB you must live in Sweden.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BoyInBOYCOTT
02:26 PM on 05/02/2010
Maybe a more cutting phrase would be

"Do I Look Like I Hire Illegals?
04:49 PM on 05/02/2010
Maybe a more cutting phrase would be

"Am I in the country illegally?"