iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Greenwald

Robert Greenwald

Posted: February 17, 2011 11:03 AM

Americans of all ideological persuasions are fed up with the Afghanistan War. We're fed up with a $5.7 billion-per-month military campaign that's gone nowhere over the past 12 months. We're fed up with being told we'll have to do without vital public services because of the sorry state of our national finances, while at the same time our politicians are spending $2 billion a year to police a dusty Afghan town called Marjah. But most of all, we're tired of the song-and-dance from officials who think they can spin a year full of ugly setbacks as "progress."  We know better.

We're so fed up, in fact, that over the past week, with the help of Brave New Foundation's Rethink Afghanistan campaign, several hundred ordinary Americans pooled their resources in an online fundraising drive and picked three everyday people to star in the first-ever anti-Afghanistan-War TV ad. The ad has run all this week in Washington, D.C. on CNN to get make sure politicians know we want our troops brought home--because it's time.

For months, public opinion polls have been very clear on Americans' opposition to the Afghanistan War. This past week, Gallup's latest poll showed that 72 percent of Americans want Congress to act this year to speed up troop withdrawals from Afghanistan. This support cuts across ideological lines, with strong majorities of Republicans, Democrats and independents wanting Congress to rein in the war. And yet, somehow, President Obama and Congress persist in requesting and approving funds to keep this war going long past a time period acceptable to most of their constituents.

What will it take to get policy-makers' attention to the fact that the war isn't making us safer and isn't worth the cost? The worst year for U.S. troop deaths ever so far in the war? Check. The worst year for civilian casualties? Check. The highest annual cost of the war so far? Check. We could throw in 9 percent unemployment at home, an economic crisis, and deficit hysteria at home as well. There's simply no justification for continuing to spend almost $6 billion a month on a futile, brutal war while cutting programs that keep people from freezing in the winter

Take, for example, one of the hardest hit cities in the new economy: Detroit, Michigan. The Detroit metropolitan area has an unemployment rate of more than 11 percent. But this year alone, taxpayers in Detroit will pay $180.4 million for the war. WIth that same amount of money, Detroit could have hired 2,523 elementary school teachers, 3,435 firefighters, or 2,815 cops for a year. Our communities here in the U.S. are suffering in a terrible economic vise. When do we stop wasting money on this futile war and start getting serious about getting American back on its feet?

Some Members of Congress, thankfully, do hear the voices of their constituents. Today, U.S. Rep. Barbara Lee (D-Calif.) and a bipartisan set of cosponsors introduced the Responsible End to the War in Afghanistan Act, a bill designed to force the withdrawal of U.S. forces from Afghanistan. And, many of these elected officials spent the week working to restrict funding for war during the debate over the continuing resolution to fund the government. They face an uphill fight in a Capitol awash with war industry lobbying dollars, but every time they take a vote, they're building on the last roll call, expanding the number of people willing to stand up and say, "enough." 

That's why we helped run the first-ever anti-Afghanistan-War ad on TV in Washington, D.C. this week: to support the efforts of public servants willing to cast the tough votes, and to tell our politicians we want our troops brought home--because it's time.

If you're fed-up with this war that's not making us safer and that's not worth the costs, join Rethink Afghanistan on Facebook and Twitter.

UPDATE: Several Members of Congress have posted blog pieces today at The Huffington Post on this issue. Take a look:

 
 
 

Follow Robert Greenwald on Twitter: www.twitter.com/robertgreenwald

 
 
  • Comments
  • 145
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
02:36 AM on 02/22/2011
I am really sorry to have to say that it's a pretty lame commercial. It could have been so much more effective. Maybe the next one.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dana Nicole
Geaux Saints!
07:09 AM on 02/21/2011
As usual, the early detractors from this nonsensical war will be vilified, until it becomes "popular" to want a responsible end to an irresponsible war...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
R.W. Sanders
Numerous questions, too little expertise
03:29 AM on 02/20/2011
The democrats proposed 30 billion in cuts and the republicans increased it to 60, if my info is correct. If we are spending 6 per month on the war, we could wipe out the republican cuts and have 12 left. Folks could get their social security checks and the troops would get paid. Shut down the government and nothing gets paid, including the rent. Besides. don't we have enough sophisticated spy robots to keep an eye on Osama? I saw a program on the news featuring a fake hummingbird. It actually flaps it's wings when it flies. It has a 360 degree camera view and can fly for ten minutes on one AAA battery. Since we live in a society where privacy is but a memory, why not increase taxes on the wealthy and use the money to educate the kids. They could invent even more robots, cyborgs and even androids. Our best troops will be excellent video gamers. Imagine, a UAV drops off a hummingbird that flies into Osama's window and blows up. Now, that would discourage terrorism.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
susanjones
10:08 AM on 02/19/2011
The military industrial complex we were warned about is here. We seem to have perpetual wars and make enemys all over the world. Americans do not want to be in Iraq (the big lie) or Afganistan (the bigger lie). Neither country wants us there; we spend billions in dollars and endless young lives for nothing. It's Vietnam all over again. What in the devil will it take to get out of both? The President, Senate and House want war. The only way I see to get out is to get rid of every damned one in Washington.
06:48 AM on 02/19/2011
How many more American lives have to be ruined before Washington reacts? Americans know two things for sure, the war is not winable, and we don't belong over there. We have to develop a system of controls that prevent us from going to war on the words of liars. These two wars have violated every principle the United States stands for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pecosdog
this sht writes itself
12:18 AM on 02/19/2011
When obama gets the clue that this is going to cost him and his party dearly in 2012, this war will end. If he doesn't end it the end of 2011, he deserves the boot.
06:41 AM on 02/18/2011
I'm about as anit-war as it gets, but I think the US needs to be in Afghanistan right now, and needs to stay there for a long time yet.
Obama's surge seems to be working - let's give it some time.
01:33 PM on 02/18/2011
That is not as anti-war as it gets. That is not ''about as anti-war as it gets.'' That is pro-war for now and a long time yet. Get out of denial. You favor the war.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
JonRaymond
General threat to uncivilaztion as we know it
05:18 PM on 02/18/2011
Yup. You got his number. Say one thing. Do another.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Martha Rayburn
04:24 PM on 02/21/2011
I can't see one logical reason why we "need" to be in Afghanistan right now. Our presence there is doing nothing to stop Bin Laden from doing anything he wants to do. It's not stopping terrorism in any way. We are investing billions and billions of dollars in both Iraq in Afghanistan for the purposes of "nation building", meanwhile our nation is crumbling around our ears. We need to get completely out of both countries now and start putting our dollars where they will do some good to Americans.
07:45 PM on 02/17/2011
Declare victory, bring the troops home, throw a huge parade to celebrate! That's how you finish a war.
05:52 PM on 02/17/2011
A bit slow on the uptake those Americans, aren't they? I mean, after Vietnam and other unfortunate adventures. Besides they've never won a war in the recent past after all, so what keeps up the hope of doing so one day? Maybe the weapons manufacturers and Pentagon warlords who need a proving ground? You'd think the US government doesn't have sufficient problems at home to spend the billions on. Of course it's not their own money they're "p*ss*ng" away.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William50
05:28 PM on 02/17/2011
It is true, when we leave Afghanistan, and I will work to make it soon. we will have to fight them again. We will either again join to over throw the religious government or be fighting a united Arab military. But we can do that in a manor we can win and not be wasting billions to win the minds and hearts of the people while those who run the country laugh at us!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
schneckenschmecker
Equal Opportinity Offender and Lover of All
05:09 PM on 02/17/2011
This advertisement does provide a little bit of hope that we as Americans might wake-up before it's too late. What I have a hard time comprehending is the lack of interest from the college-aged crowd. Given that they are the generation that is looking at a future that is far more bleak than the preceding generations, precisely BECAUSE of these disasterous military occupations, one would think that they'd be a little more iterested.
I see this generation as "the obediant consumers". Give them a hundred thousand or more (in debt) for a college "education", some "snookilisceous" mind-numbing "entertainment", a smartphone and a five dollar latte, and "it's all good, it's all chill". So sad!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blueline2
We'll always have Paris
03:25 PM on 02/19/2011
Reinstate the draft for both sexes, and watch the college-aged crowd suddenly get interested in these wars. The draft is what helped end Viet Nam-much more than the VC. Today, the college crowd, which will be the mainstream population in the future doesn't worry about the war. It's fought by other people-minorities, immigrants, and the kids of people who can't afford to send them to college. Sounds a lot like the Roman empire. Any way, want resistance from youth? Re-instate the draft and sit back and watch the demonstrations in the streets.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
R.W. Sanders
Numerous questions, too little expertise
03:33 AM on 02/20/2011
My old draft number was in the 150's. How's that for average?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Martha Rayburn
04:31 PM on 02/21/2011
The lack of a draft is one of the main reasons the military industrial complex has been able to get away with these continuous wars one after another. You are very correct that as long as young people see war as something that's fought by minorities and poorer people (disposable people) they have no interest in it. It isn't seen as something that touches their lives. Unfortunately, I think a lot of older people view it that way also. Even people who have lost loved ones in the wars often see it as having lost them in a noble cause fighting for their country, and not as what is, just more fodder for the military industrial complex to make more billions.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frank
My last name is FRANK so thats what I am..
04:31 PM on 02/17/2011
this video is long past due..it should air across the country in every station daily until they get the message
04:25 PM on 02/17/2011
I am for getting out of there as well - but this is weak

Sending our grandkids to kill their grandkids.... come on.

Unfortunately it is hard to forget that this began with them sending some of their grandkids over here to hijack a few planes - fly them into buildings and thereby killing some of our grandkids.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StillMadMatt
Offending the right people is its own virtue.
05:23 AM on 02/20/2011
Umm 19 out of the 23 hijackers were from Saudia Arabia. So what your point again???
photo
NHGranite
Killer Koala escapes diner, eats shoots & leaves
05:43 PM on 02/20/2011
My coworker's daughter was on Flight 11 from Boston. Died leaving behind her husband and new baby. We killed 100000 innocent Iraqis - wrong war. We've been in Afghanistan for too long and how many citizens killed. Not including our own troops. Be thoughtful
04:24 PM on 02/17/2011
We can't really leave; their infrastructure has been destroyed. What would happen if we leave without helping establish a government?
04:47 PM on 02/17/2011
What infrastructure did they have exactly that we destroyed other than poppies? You need to ask yourself if a majority of Afghans even want us to stay. I think that's a better question than whether we are obligated to just "buy" it because we "broke" it without even asking the "shopkeepers" what they want us to do...
07:50 PM on 02/17/2011
So we need to stay forever? F that. If the price of rubble goes up, they'll be fine.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
phoenixx1
Get up, Stand up
04:22 PM on 02/17/2011
In the era of Vietnam protests there were elements that are certainly missing at this point in time. Unity & solidarity were formed out of the belief that our participation in that war was wrong. There were many iconic symbols born in that time, but the one I remember wearing means the same thing today.
If you are not part of the solution
You are part of the problem

Out of Afghanistan NOW!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
susanjones
10:10 AM on 02/19/2011
The reason we had protests was because of the draft. No it's a volunteer army and no one is paying attention.