More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Greenwald

Robert Greenwald

Posted: March 21, 2011 11:07 AM

Why Do Politicians Want to Cut Jobs? Budget Cuts Equal Job Cuts


We are in a painful recession. Too often it seems like D.C. hears more about the concern of billionaires who don't want to lose their tax cuts, and too little about the parent of two who works long hours and barely is getting by. And yet Congress votes on whether the billionaire will have more, and whether the working class parent will lose his or her job. These are the votes presently occurring, and which are being treated like a drawn out political game.


The proposed federal budget cuts are turning into another political sideshow. The process of the budget is being treated as a chess game, a battle over politics and procedure, and one that may go on for a long time still, narrated by talking heads throughout.

If you are an American in need of a job, or one afraid that your job will be cut in the budget proposals, it isn't just a D.C. soap opera. The reverberations of the proposed cuts are drastic and personal. States and cities throughout the country feel the impact of the cuts through the stories of those waiting with every news cycle to hear whether their job, or hope of a job, will be slashed.

The City of Los Angeles is a perfect example of this harm. Los Angeles is already affected by the recession with a whopping 14.5% unemployment.

The proposed federal budget cuts are not abstract to Los Angeles. They would eliminate funding for job creation projects, projects needed to help Vets find work, and they could wipe out training services for youth hoping to find skills, or the homeless, hoping to break the cycle of poverty.

In Los Angeles, the community is not sitting back and letting these proposed cuts happen without a fight. Next Wednesday, March 23rd, Angelenos will rally at the Federal Building in Downtown Los Angeles to say no to such cuts. Cutting jobs is not the answer to recession budgeting. It's time that our government prioritized working people over billionaires.

If democracy is to work, we have to hope that Wisconsin and Los Angeles, and the other communities that have had enough, send messages strong enough to penetrate the walls of Capitol Hill. It's time our government support those struggling to get by, and not just those with the money to access power in private backrooms. It's time we make it known: budget cuts equal job cuts. And America simply can't afford to cut anymore jobs.

 
 
 

Follow Robert Greenwald on Twitter: www.twitter.com/robertgreenwald

 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rtx47
05:31 PM on 03/21/2011
Japan was the beacon of economic stability and productivity. With their astronomical debt questions are raised how they'll pay for this natural catastrophy.

US debt:GDP is not far behind Japan. Our federal debt (14T) is 80% of our GDP. Yet this doesn't include state and local debt (2.4T); unfunded pension obligations (3.5T); and personal debt (13.4T). Perhaps someone can tell us how much is total corporate debt?

I question the true economic stability of the US and it frightens me. Those who think federal debt (plus 1.5T every year) is no problem should think again.

Basing our economic activity largely on artificial and inflated consumer demand; and stimulating that demand with 'easy-money' (credit card, buy-now and pay-later schemes, easy line of credit; borrow money against a borrowed asset etc) is a sure way to see cycles of boom and busts; and finally ending in an implosion. Such an implosion will impact even those who played by the rules and led a conservative economic life style.

Unemployment is here to stay. Technolgy (robots and computers) eliminated assembly line (blue collar) workers and mid-level managers (white collar). Since WW II, women have doubled the work-force. Yet while we have unemployment and under-employment we have Head Start programs which are govt-paid baby-sitting services for pre-KG kids. Third of healthcare budget of 2 trillion is for the indigent care becase there's no one at home to care for the elderly and sick.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
02:01 PM on 03/22/2011
We don't get out of our economic problems by budget cuts. Jobs and other programs that put people to work are the best way, including Head Start--it is NOT just babysitting. When people work, they pay taxes, which decreases the deficit. They buy things, which puts other people to work making things and selling things. Cuts put people out of work, which puts a further load on government services they wouldn't need if they were working so it's a double whammy since they also stop paying both income and sales taxes since they can't afford to buy as many taxable goods.

If you had a house for sale, you would not strip it of all the nice things about it, stop maintaining it, and let it go to wrack and ruin if you wanted the best price. In fact, you might even have to borrow to fix it up, make it as nice as possible so it will sell for more, at which time you can then pay back what you borrowed, and everyone benefits. Conservatives are always saying how they want to run this country like a business, which it is NOT, but they don't actually do that. Businesses would never survive if they applied their so-called principles to their businesses: paying CEOs at the top HUGE salaries thus taking money OUT of the business, paying workers poor wages so they're resentful and unproductive, and instead paying off company debts? Terrible business model, terrible for the country.
04:22 PM on 03/21/2011
Funny how just the title of this article is enough to prove the point. The GOP wants to cut budgets that will cost jobs and yet have no jobs bill in the works to stimulate small business growth or the entreprenuership they keep going on about. Though to be fair, they are sucking all of the money from corporate america that they can to provide jobs for right-leaning lobbyists and organizers.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
02:03 PM on 03/22/2011
Apparently, they think lobbying is an honorable way to make a living, more than teachers and fire fighters and policemen. At least if you look at the salary structure for the various jobs, lobbyists are certainly valued higher than all these other workers. F&F
03:28 PM on 03/21/2011
Try increasing revenue. Why give billionaires and millionaires, corporations and capital gains recipients tax breaks while gutting programs which help the poor, the disabled, the sick and the elderly? Individual responsibility without social responsibility is irresponsible. The poor are not lazy, not without discipline, and are not spiritually weak. They are poor, usually from circumstances beyond their control. Take your paternalistic attitude and your misguided morality elsewhere.

The lack of money to fund the government is a result of thirty years of conservative policies, and the national debt is being used as an excuse to cut programs. (Where were conservatives when Bush almost doubled the national debt? Oh, deficits weren't a problem then?) Conservatives are slashing regulations, gutting Federal agencies with oversight responsibilities, shipping jobs overseas with free trade instead of fair trade, attacking public unions, attacking health care reform, and attacking the EPA, IRS, SEC, HUD, the Department of Education, the Labor department, as well as other agencies.

By the way, Social Security is funded from payroll taxes. It is not an entitlement program. It has 2.6 trillion in reserves (U.S. Treasury Bonds), and is fully funded for the next 26 years. Cutting benefits or freezing cost of living adjustments does not help the deficit one dime.

Slash heating assistance for the poor while big companies pay zero in Federal taxes? How stupid do you think we are?
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
02:04 PM on 03/22/2011
Welcome to HuffPo! You definitely need more than 2 fans. :) F&F Excellent post.
MrStat1
I believe in the rule of law
02:49 PM on 03/21/2011
It isn't a matter of want to, it's a matter of have to because of the lack of money to fund the government. When expenses exceed revenues you have to cut from the budget, and that means jobs. That's just the way it is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tekkdude
Battling Republican lies one post at a time.
03:52 PM on 03/21/2011
It is not true now and it has never been true that the government cannot afford to spend more than it earns. That is not how government economics works. The problem is demand not taxes or a lack of money. But leaving that aside, I hope that your side wins this debate and destroys this country's economy once and for all. For too long, we have been able to cobble together compromises that keep things going just a little longer. Never letting Republican conservative economics completely destroy anything. Bush almost did it, but we managed to pull the economy back from the brink. This time, I say, let's just let your team have the ball and run with it. When there is 25% unemployment and the top 400 people hold 75% of the country's wealth and the rest of us are living in abject poverty maybe then Americans will realize once and for all what conservative Republican economic policy is all about and we can get back to some sensible economic policy again. Because until then, I think that the American people are too easily confused by economists on both sides arguing about who is right. I think we will have to let Americans see what a true Republican America looks like. A fundamentalist Christian, anti-immigrant, anti-gay, anti-anyone who isn't white and rich America where only the most ruthless survive - everyone else is left to fight for scraps. Because that is the America that Republicans believe in.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
02:08 PM on 03/22/2011
Scary proposition, but I get your point. I can't help but hope it doesn't actually get to that point though. Perhaps soon most Americans, after seeing what Republicans are really trying to bring this country down to, will come to their senses and come to the more reasonable and humane economic principles. F&F
01:37 PM on 03/21/2011
The Republicans ran on JOBS, JOBS, JOBS, yet when they get in they say CUT, CUT, and CUT. They are attacking the American people coming and going. People need to wake up and realize that they don’t care about you unless you are in the top 2% and contribute millions to their campaign. Blindly slicing the budget will not create jobs or make our country stronger.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
03:12 PM on 03/22/2011
Ain't THAT the truth!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Vasquez
A Unapologetic liberal
01:31 PM on 03/21/2011
This is yet another blatant example of republican hypocrisy. After 8 long years of bush&Co. stating that deficits don't matter in wartime and the subsequent bloating of the budget deficit, now suddenly
they mean everything. Go figure.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
03:16 PM on 03/22/2011
It's all part of the plan. Give tax cuts to the rich keeping huge amounts of money out of circulation, create a huge budget deficit, which then leads to program cuts for the poor, which the middle class is rapidly becoming. Meanwhile, maintain a constant barrage of propaganda on fright-wing radio and Faux "news" convincing ordinary Americans that conservatives are the only ones who know how to make the country better, actual evidence to the contrary but who's paying attention to that?, and voila! You have the government going belly up, valuable programs disappeared, and everything privatized so the money goes even more to the ultra-rich. Sounds like a great plan, doesn't it? Banana Republicans are what they should be called.
01:10 PM on 03/21/2011
I agree with you, but I don't think Washington is listening. We need to end the two party system because it doesn't work. Look at our politicians. Most of them come from wealth. They don't know what it's like to scrape by to make a living. They're in bed with the banks and other corporations. They're all golfing together on Sundays. This country is becoming a nation of Haves and Have Nots, and they want it that way. There are other ways to cut spending other than cutting education and social programs. One way to save a few trillion dollars would be to end the wars. Real simple! We could use that money to rebuild our country, but the political will isn't there. Wake up folks. It's time for a revolution.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
UberdanSounds
I make music(al), funnies.
01:05 PM on 03/21/2011
I solved the budget & I didn't cut one social program or raise taxes on the middle class.

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/11/13/weekinreview/deficits-graphic.html?choices=vmt245lt
photo
FirstGame72
The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters
01:03 PM on 03/21/2011
I can answer for Republican politicians because the answer is a simple one:
GOP pols could care less how many or how few of their constituents have jobs, homes, healthcare or enough to eat. GOP politicians work for the 5% wealthiest Americans only, ever, zero exceptions, to the detriment of all else, including their own political careers if need be (see scott walker).
The real tough, almost unanswerable question then becomes why do millions of people who suffer under GOP rule (see the people of WI - and MI, OH, & FL) continue to hand the GOP power through their votes?
03:28 PM on 03/21/2011
TO FIRST GAME 72 YOU ARE RIGHT ON. THAT IS WHY WE HAVE INSUFFICIENT REVENUE
CAREFUL TAX ON THOSE WHO EARN $1MIL OR MORE A YEAR -$800 BILBRING THE MEN AND WOMEN HOME FROM WAR-$120 BIL A YEAR-CUT THE TAX HAVENS IN PLACES LIKETHE CAYMANS. BANK OF AMERICA PAYED NOTHING LAST YEAR. ANOTHER $100 BIL.. WHO SAYS WE ARE BROKE ? I AM BROKE AND ANGRY!!!!!!
photo
FirstGame72
The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters
04:20 PM on 03/21/2011
As Mr. Michael Moore has said, this country is not broke, there's plenty of money. The problem is that it's all in the hands of the top half of 1% richest people leaving the rest of us to fight for the crumbs.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
03:20 PM on 03/22/2011
How about pushing that caps lock key on the left just once, okay? :) Thanks!
12:38 PM on 03/21/2011
Maybe if California wasn't so keen on pissing away as much money as possible there would be some state money to help those find jobs. Budget cuts are necessary when we spend 1.5 trillion more than we take in theis year alone. Its too bad our president doesn't want to lead on this but its typical for politicians to try and make political hay instead of doing the job they were hired to do.
02:39 PM on 03/21/2011
"Budget cuts are necessary when we spend 1.5 trillion more than we take in theis year alone."

That only because they keep cutting taxes for corporations (either directly or by giving them deductions). We may have the highest corporate tax RATE on paper, but we take in far less than countries whose corporate tax rate is 1/3 of ours. Bank of America and Exon each had profits in the billions, but paid zero income tax. Exon even got money back in 2009.

The population is growing and infrastructure has to be kept up. Taxes are at historic lows. Yes there is some spending that could (and should) be cut, but it is not the only answer. In fact, on its own its the worst answer. Most companies (very small businesses not so much) are quite flush with money. They are not hiring because no one is buying. Increase the number of unemployed (or reduce peoples wages) and people will not buy anything but the absolute necessities.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
03:30 PM on 03/22/2011
In fact, I don't think they should make ANY cuts right now. Not unless they determine a program is completely wasting the taxpayers' money should they cut anything. The programs they want to trim are valuable. Like Head Start and the National Endowment for the Arts with its annual Poetry Out Loud contest (we just had that yesterday in California) that is so inspiring to high school kids. Any programs for the poor should not be cut at all and should probably be increased. Research and development in scientific endeavors and disease cures should never be cut. Our government has a constitutionally mandated purpose of promoting the general welfare of the people, and that can't be done by cutting every government program that does just that. Conservatives may be so selfish they don't want the government to do that, but then they can't claim to love our Constitution in which promoting the general welfare is mentioned twice. Cutting programs eliminates jobs, and we can't afford that right now, and as you say, it's not good for demand of other goods and services when people are out of work. It's extremely odd to me that conservatives can't seem to get this rather simple concept--if you don't have a job, you can't afford to buy anything, and the economy doesn't get stimulated. They don't need to be rocket scientists to figure this out.
12:31 PM on 03/21/2011
By cutting the budget in areas that affect the middle class--for example the freeze on federal salaries--Congress and the President are reducing consumer demand even more. This will, in turn, hurt retailers--except those that can make a handsome profit in foreign consumer markets...like Walmart (Walmart has posted increased profits even as their U.S. sales have declined).

If middle class Americans do not get serious about gaining ground that they've lost over the last three decades, they will eventually find themselves in a position where they are no longer needed. Wealthy investors can make a profit just as well from foreign sales. Americans need to seriously think through where our corporate-subservient policies are leading us. Trickle-down economics--if it works at all--cannot possibly work when investors are increasingly focused on other countries' workers and consumers.

www.wpatoday.org
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tekkdude
Battling Republican lies one post at a time.
03:57 PM on 03/21/2011
The untold secret of today is that American middle class consumers are no longer needed. That is why corporations are sitting on record amounts of cash but not creating jobs. I guarantee if they were not still making record profits from their overseas operations, they would be creating jobs to stimulate demand for their products. But they have figured out during this recession they can do just fine without the American market.
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
03:32 PM on 03/22/2011
Which means, of course, that corporations have no conscience, which makes you wonder how the Supreme Court could ever come up with the notion that corporations are people. Perhaps because they have no conscience?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Appleblossom
12:20 PM on 03/21/2011
Here is an idea-apparently over in the United Kingdom Rupert Murdoch's empire has been caught red handed hacking into private communication of politicians and apparently used the information gleaned to blackmail those politicians.

If he did it there, who is to say he did not do it here?
photo
You Are My Density
Independent--it's just ONE country.
03:33 PM on 03/22/2011
Why isn't that man in jail?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Appleblossom
10:12 PM on 03/22/2011
They got the coppers to cover it up.

Seriously-it is quite horrifying.