In a stunning development, country music radio stations have started to refuse to air anything said by President George W. Bush, following his unprecedented attack on an American citizen and presidential candidate while overseas.
It called to mind when country music stations similarly stopped playing the Dixie Chicks music after its lead singer made critical comments about Mr. Bush while in concert in London.
"We never objected to the Chicks criticizing George Bush," said Charlie Benson, program director of WUSU 106.1-FM in Jackson. "That's America, that's Freedom of Speech. Two-thirds of the country is criticizing George Bush today. But there's an unwritten rule about criticizing American foreign policy when you leave our shores, and the Dixie Chicks broke that. Now, President Bush has, as well."
Mr. Bush was giving a speech in Israel's parliament, the Knesset. He likened Americans who wanted to negotiate with terrorists the same as former British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain appeasing Adolf Hitler before World War II.
A spokesman for the White House said that Mr. Bush wasn't referring to Barack Obama, but country radio programmers weren't buying it.
"Who else was he talking about?," asked an incredulous Larry Mittlehorn, VP of Programming for the Mighty Airspace Group, a syndicator to 38 country music stations, which has now instituted its Bush ban. "Please. The President of the United States doesn't go to the Israeli parliament and complain about some unknown guys in a bar [moaning] about foreign policy. Our listeners are smarter than that. They understand who he was trying to blast. That dog won't even think about hunting."
Echoing those thoughts was Belinda Ransel, who heads up Station Relations for Mighty Airspace. 'What we're hearing in our conversations with stations is that some think this is much worse than what the Dixie Chicks did. That was just an opinion during a concert, part of an entertainment. But the President was speaking in the general assembly of a foreign government before politicians discussing actual policy. It just rankles our stations. It just feels wrong, feels really bad to them. 'Scary' and "Big Brother" are the words we're hearing. It's not the America they and their listeners love and salute. That's not our flag."
Currently, 147 country music stations have instituted the ban, a number which has been growing by the hour. Clear Channel, a major syndicator to all radio formats across America, is considering the ban, which would increase the numbers significantly and be a major blow to the White House. Several Clear Channel stations have independently instituted their own ban.
The problem might be even worse for the Bush Administration, however, as a second issue has surprisingly cropped up in the controversy, which is reaching epidemic proportions. Country stations are not only concerned with the precedent of the U.S. leader criticizing the presidential candidate of an opposing party while overseas in a foreign parliament - but the accuracy of the criticism, as well.
Jerry Calderon is editor of Country Radio Today, one of the leading industry magazines. He's been in close contact with program directors across the nation ever since President Bush's speech made the news, and has noticed a trend.
"Even those who don't support Barack Obama are upset because they understand this is a complete distortion of what Barack Obama has ever said." Calderon noted that quite a few PD's [program directors] have been very angry at the distortion which they see as deliberate. "These are people who talk for a living. They understand that simply talking to other countries - even if enemies - is how nations avoid war. That's totally different from negotiating with terrorists. And it has nothing to do with appeasement, which is when Neville Chamberlain literally signed away the country of Czechoslovakia to Hitler."
One program director was even more blunt.
"I voted for George Bush twice. In fact, I voted for George Bushes four times," said J.J. Nelson of WAM 98 in Columbus. "But this is offensive. This insults me. And my listeners. It implies that we don't know history and don't understand what 'appeasement' actually is and what Neville Chamberlain actually did. Our listeners support America and support the troops. But they, but we don't support being disrespected this way. We're better than this. Shame on George Bush."
Nelson added, "And I can say that because I'm a proud American. And I'm proudly in America - not overseas, in the Israeli Knesset."
In response to the ban, White House spokesman Dana Perino said that the President may have been referring to a different appeasement, and said she believed that Neville Chamberlain's "Munich Agreement" was related to the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Update: The White House Communications Department corrected Ms. Perino's comments and released the following statement. "The Munich Agreement and Cuban Missile Crisis have nothing in common and occurred 30 years apart on different continents about completely different issues."
Update II: Upon further research, it turns out that nothing in the above article is true. Though it should be. The author apologizes for any confusion.
Posted May 16, 2008 | 02:37 PM (EST)