iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Koehler

GET UPDATES FROM Robert Koehler
 

Captives to the Logic of Violence

Posted: 09/08/11 11:18 AM ET

A decade later. The abyss keeps deepening, the wars keep squandering our blood and treasure beyond all logic except the logic of violence.

What ended on Sept. 11, 2001, it sometimes seems, was human evolution.

Suddenly, an irreparable schism opened between those in power and the rest of humankind, and a decision fell into place that war for profit would never end -- and there was nothing to be done about it, as the corporate media conveyed to the world with a knowing shrug. What fell into place was armed insanity as perpetual background noise, and any reach toward global community, understanding and forgiveness went on permanent hold.

"Peace, of course, is not just absent from video games. It has faded from any debate in Washington surrounding the wars."

Thus spake the Washington Post the other day, in a dazzlingly superficial reflection on the tenth anniversary of whatever happened that day, oh yeah, terror, evil, biff, bop, pow: "A Decade After the 9/11 Attacks, Americans Live in an Era of Endless War." I can't remember the last time I read something so glaringly lacking in moral intelligence. It must have been intentional.

Reporter Greg Jaffe uncritically informs us, for instance, that "radical religious ideologies, new technologies and cheap, powerful weapons have catapulted the world into (what a Pentagon report called) 'a period of persistent conflict... No one should harbor the illusion that the developed world can win this conflict in the near future.'...

"By this logic," Jaffe goes on to tell us, "America's wars are unending and any talk of peace is quixotic or naive."

Pondering the profound changes this has wrought in American society, Jaffe visits video game culture, specifically a game called Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, which, he reports, portrays "a very different kind of war" -- full of good old slaughter, just like the World War II games, but without any kind of ending, no victory banner or grandly hoisted American flag, just dead bodies. "Victory is unattainable."

This is it, sucker, get used to it. Jaffe adds: "'Peace,' meanwhile, has become something of a dirty word in Washington foreign-policy circles. Earlier this year, the House voted to cut all funding for the congressionally funded U.S. Institute of Peace." The funding was later restored, but... you get the idea.

All this is a warning: The powers that be and their scribes have had it up to here with "peace consciousness" and are trying to imprison it in the dark cell of their contempt. A decade after 9/11, the agenda couldn't be more stunningly clear. The enemy is Evil Itself, and we're taking it out with drones, but Evil regroups. This is going to take forever. We'll keep you informed just enough to stay terrified.

This, of course, is absolutely nuts. The mainstream media, beholden to power and corporate interests, have given up challenging their agenda and want the rest of us to as well.

It is in this context that we must take our stand. "Be a hero for peace!" is the cry of a group called The Raven Foundation, which is launching an effort to reclaim the meaning of 9/11, making it a day of reverence, connection and forgiveness.

"Be a hero for peace!" This is the cry of empowerment -- the cry of those who insist on a future that is not the endless playing out of the cycle of violence. And it is the cry of those who believe, with passion and a life's commitment, that we will end not simply the current bloody, pointless wars in Central Asia and the Middle East, but war itself, and the addictive logic that fools us into thinking that the violence we perpetrate is the good kind, because it takes out evil.

"We know everything about war," says Raven Foundation's Suzanne Ross in a video on the organization's website. "Why is it that everyone knows where the Pentagon is and what the Department of Defense is, but (almost) no one knows about... the United States Institute of Peace?... Why is the USIP budget a fraction of the Pentagon budget? And what would happen if the funding ratio were reversed? These are questions we have not asked because we are captives to the logic of violence."

Heroes for peace are beyond number, but one of them is named Rais Bhuiyan, a South Asian immigrant living in Texas who was shot in the face at close range shortly after 9/11 by a self-described "Arab slayer" named Mark Stroman. Two immigrants were killed in Stroman's rampage and Bhuiyan, blinded in one eye, spent years in recovery. Afterward, he took on a startling project: He campaigned diligently to save the life of his would-be killer, who was on death row.

"I've had many years to grow spiritually," Bhuiyan told MSNBC reporter Kari Huus. "I'm trying to do my best not to allow the loss of another human life. I'll knock on every door possible."

Though Stroman was executed in July -- this was Texas, after all -- Bhuiyan has written on his website: "Our work doesn't end here. We need to educate people about the healing power of forgiveness."

Forgiveness, think of it, in the name and spirit of 9/11. Happy anniversary.

- - -
Robert Koehler is an award-winning, Chicago-based journalist, contributor to One World, Many Peaces and nationally syndicated writer. His new book, Courage Grows Strong at the Wound (Xenos Press) is now available. Contact him at koehlercw@gmail.com or visit his website at commonwonders.com.

© 2011 TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.

 
A decade later. The abyss keeps deepening, the wars keep squandering our blood and treasure beyond all logic except the logic of violence. What ended on Sept. 11, 2001, it sometimes seems, was human...
A decade later. The abyss keeps deepening, the wars keep squandering our blood and treasure beyond all logic except the logic of violence. What ended on Sept. 11, 2001, it sometimes seems, was human...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paris215
Be the change you want to see
02:46 PM on 09/09/2011
Robert I appreciate your article.. Forgiveness is not a word we hear often in the 9/11 discourse.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
09:48 PM on 09/08/2011
Consensus isn't the solution, it's the problem.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:41 PM on 09/08/2011
"Jaffe visits video game culture, specifically a game called Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, which, he reports, portrays "a very different kind of war" -- full of good old slaughter, just like the World War II games, but without any kind of ending, no victory banner or grandly hoisted American flag, just dead bodies. "Victory is unattainable.""

I guess he didn't beat MW2, as the 75th make very clear their shared desire to return Russia's favor of invading the mainland United States. By the way, if the guy is making his arguments based on a video game partially inspired by Red Dawn, I doubt he's really the most reliable source.
09:33 PM on 09/08/2011
"Forgiveness," a sweet word, and not that difficult to enunciate. But that word is not the same as reality, particularly for people who were intimately associated with the grotesque, horrifying tragedy of 9/11. These words, like "forgiveness," might be easy for some to script out in a journalistic article that has a logic not well connected to the event or those who were involved in this horrifying event. Nor is forgiveness a giant square hole in the ground with water running down it like water down a giant drain ( the 9/11 "memorial"). It would be easy to forgive the French monarchy for all of the suffering they caused because we are over 200 years away from the devastation it had on the French people. How easy it is to forgive people you never knew or were not personally involved with. When it comes to words, I think it would fit more into the word, "fantasy," to think that people who directly experienced 9/11 might be as cavalier about it all as this article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brothers3
Mankind In Its Vanity Keeps Us From Our Sanity
06:26 PM on 09/08/2011
I posted this comment earlier, and it was in the first comment pending. I'll try again:

"A decade later. The abyss keeps deepening, the wars keep squandering our blood and treasure beyond all logic except the logic of violence. "

Using the author's opening statement, I can only offer the following observation:

We will continue to squander our blood and treasure as long as we continue to demand products and services dependent on non-renewable energy sources.

For those who have allowed themselves to believe we are fighting any of our current wars for moral reasons - helping "them" become "Democratic" - forget about it.

For those who have allowed themselves to believe we are fighting any of our current wars to fight against "terror", forget about it.

We are involved in a global contest to control access to the earth's diminishing energy reserves. As long as we continue to demand products and services dependent on non-renewable energy sources, we can expect to see our military involved in actions wherever those resources are still available.

And because those resources are essential for keeping the machinery of war well-oiled, our involvement in assuring our share of those resources is every bit as vital to National Security as defending any actions of perceived "terrorist" organizations.

It's that simple.

I am an anti-war, liberal, progressive Independent. But because I am anti-war does not mean I do not acknowledge the valid reasons for its existence in today's fossil-fueled world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brothers3
Mankind In Its Vanity Keeps Us From Our Sanity
07:51 PM on 09/08/2011
P.S. Because my comments were exactly at 250, I'm adding these links for those of you who might wish some support for my comments elsewhere, as well as some interesting perspective regarding our perpetual involvement in wars.

~~ Cheers!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brothers3
Mankind In Its Vanity Keeps Us From Our Sanity
07:51 PM on 09/08/2011
Woops! Long day! Here are the links:

Iraq & Afghanistan - The Hidden Truth
http://tinyurl.com/4ftz2gc

U.S. Interests and Central Asia Energy Security
http://tinyurl.com/3p72sm7
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William50
04:05 PM on 09/08/2011
Spin, fear, government needs to expand with the military and no one saying that the attack was a failure because of the strength of the US people. Instead we had chicken little running the show, the military complex seeing its chance to expand and the democratic slaves to the protect me giving up more of their power over a failed attack.
Lets say that every plane had hit. The outcome would still be a strong USA. The government would not have crumbled, the military was ready to act and react, trains and food would have been supplied, water and power worked, in fact if they had done as much damage as they wanted, nothing would have changed. They failed because their thinking was small. They failed because the people are stronger then the government.
But the changes from this failed attack are a million times greater then they should be. Today 9-11 succeeded because America allowed them too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christine Shackleton
03:05 PM on 09/08/2011
Understanding history is important. This is the second episode of "new York The centre of the earth". It is excellent but the first episode which shows Rockefeller and the Port Authority chief building a building no New Yorker evidently wanted in this thesis-- it drained the real estate from a broke NY hub -- and then on opening the Caesar of the the building did not turn up but Rockefeller did and had to fill the building with government offices. [[Later theses would attest to the gradual acceptance of the parks and association of- by NY ers - to the Towers -- But here is episode 2 of that history . The link is New York TYhe Centre of the World -- and the thesis applies here
It is by a top NY associated TV company
http://www.sbs.com.au/documentary/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gerald Serlin
Retired lawyer. Perserverantia Vincit
02:37 PM on 09/08/2011
I wrote what I thought was arespectful and interesting comment about an hour or two ago, but it has not been posted. What's up?
02:22 PM on 09/08/2011
The Dionysian impulse to initiate war is as archetypal as Cain and Able. Since all men and women are brothers and sisters, with far more positive common needs than differences, we must emphasize the former and steer clear of the latter, which always tend to objectify and then demonize the "enemy." See Mark Twain's "War Prayer" for the quintessential absurdity of fighting. Buddha observed that "No one ever wins a fight." Observe also how much time, money, energy and sincere sentiment we inject into funerals for service men and women. Yet when the opportunity to start yet one more war comes along, there is never a dearth of takers. Vegetius, the Roman philosopher observed that "War is always most attractive to those who know the least about it." We do need to study and learn from history instead of mindlessly repeating it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gerald Serlin
Retired lawyer. Perserverantia Vincit
12:53 PM on 09/08/2011
There is a U.S. Institute of Peace? What does it do? It certainly did not talk to our war President when he raised the stakes in Iraq, Afghanistan, Yemen and Libya. Or maybe it did and he refused to listen.

We are not only more involved in wars, we are more involved in wars that cannot be won. AND, WE HAVE NO INTENTION OF WINNING THEM, going in. We just fight them because our President thinks he is "lord of the world", that this country is his to run all by himself and because Congress does not care if they have no voice, even though the Constitution says it is their job and their job alone to declare war.

This is a story of a discouraged electorate. Discouraged because the President and Congress do whatever they want, without regard to the Constitution. If we followed the dictates of the Constitution, we would be war-free, debt-free and the true leaders of the world again.