iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Kuttner

Robert Kuttner

Posted: January 16, 2011 07:40 PM

On this, the commemoration of the 82nd anniversary of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s birth, we can take some solace from what Dr. King did in the face of forces far more annihilating than the ones that progressives face this cold January.

Impossibly enough, he built a movement.

He did so in an era when the consequences for challenging the racial order in the American South were swift and brutal. You lost your economic livelihood, or your life.

In 1955, when Dr. King led the Montgomery bus boycott, the chances of such a movement seizing the nation's conscience, and within less than a decade including the full moral authority of an American president, were just about inconceivable. He was a minor 26-year-old radical, hardly known outside his own circle.

In 1955, except for a recent Supreme Court decision on school segregation widely held to be unenforceable, there was no support from the government to end the racial order in the South. The Democratic Party was fatally dependent on the votes of Southern racists. The Republican Party of Lincoln was failing to lead even on something as rudimentary as a federal anti-lynching law.

Yet within a decade, the legal foundations of what Pulitzer Prize winning author Douglas Blackmon called "slavery by another name" had crumbled. Half a century later, public attitudes were continuing to evolve, glacially to be sure, but in the direction of Dr. King's arc of justice. Far sooner than he might have expected, our country elected an African American president.

I mention all this not just because this is the day to remember Dr. King, but because we progressives have been depressing the hell out of each other lately and wringing our hands about President Obama's missed opportunities.

It is all too easy to make a list of why all political possible avenues to a more progressive society are blocked. If you want to wallow in it, here is the list:

  • Wall Street capture of both parties.
  • An alliance between billionaires and disaffected common people.
  • The Citizens United case ushering in a new era of money overwhelming citizenship.
  • A grievously weakened labor movement.
  • President Obama spending his prestige seeking a nonexistent middle ground.
  • A right wing media machine/echo chamber with no counterpart on the liberal left.
  • An almost certain Republican takeover of both houses of Congress in 2012.
  • A prolonged era of deep recession that, weirdly, energizes the right rather than the left.
  • A new dark age of theocracy and denial of verifiable scientific truth
  • A national psychosis embracing guns as a basic civic right.
  • Public services hitting stall speed where citizens turn away from government remedy.


Okay -- depressed?

Well, the prospects that African Americans faced in 1955 were far worse. And, against all odds, unimaginably brave men and women, some honored and some still unknown, went out and built a movement.

And you could say the same of every other cause that has resulted in real social progress over the last century. A bottom-up social movement came first, presidential leadership came afterwards.

Organizing in the mines and mills proceeded long before Senator Robert Wagner imagined sponsoring a bill to legalize collective bargaining, or President Roosevelt embraced the labor movement.

Women's right to vote did not come from presidential leadership but from bottom-up struggle. Women's economic rights were added to the Civil Rights bill of 1964 by cynical reactionaries in the hope that it would kill the bill. Today, our daughters take for granted rights that their grandmothers doubted would ever come.

Homosexuals, as recently as half a generation ago, were the last group that an American could openly ridicule without being called a bigot. So gays and lesbians built a movement whose moral power could not be denied.

The disability rights movement was built from the bottom up, to the point where George H.W. Bush felt compelled to sign the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, which seemed to come out of nowhere. It didn't; it came from the bravery of unsung people.

I could go on.

As readers of The Huffington Post may recall, it drives me and many other progressives nuts that in a moment when heedless capitalism has disgraced itself, President Obama has not been more like the two presidents of the past century who helped lead radical, transformative change -- Franklin Roosevelt and the Lyndon Johnson of the civil rights era. But in both the 1930s and the 1960s, the movement came first, the likelihood of success was even slimmer, and mainstream political embrace followed.

At a time when the economic dreams of tens of millions of Americans are being crushed, I have no doubt that we shall see another progressive social movement, beginning with a tiny brave minority, and coming to have real transforming influence. Dr. King put it well: "Everything that we see is a shadow cast by that which we do not see."

Those who say it can't be done in an age of trivializing media, or the paradoxically fragmenting and disempowering role of the Internet, or the undertow of private amusement, or the hegemony of big money, are too cynical. The great social movements of the past were even more impossible.

Dr. King declared, "History will have to record that the greatest tragedy of this period of social transition was not the strident clamor of the bad people, but the appalling silence of the good people." He also said, "Change does not roll in on the wheels of inevitability, but comes through continuous struggle."

Robert Kuttner is co-editor of The American Prospect, and a senior fellow at Demos. His latest book is A Presidency in Peril.

 
 
 
On this, the commemoration of the 82nd anniversary of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s birth, we can take some solace from what Dr. King did in the face of forces far more annihilating than the ones that...
On this, the commemoration of the 82nd anniversary of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s birth, we can take some solace from what Dr. King did in the face of forces far more annihilating than the ones that...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 258
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kd45music
The truth is out there.
07:47 AM on 01/18/2011
Kuttner's words are inspiring and a reminder that the only way to lose a fight is to give up (or cave, Mr. President). Perhaps we could learn a thing or two from history - the North Vietnamese won the struggle against overwhelming odds and firepower because they refused to lose, the same with the Afgans (as we will soon realize) defeated the Russians with outdated weapons. As the poet, Delmore schwartz once wrote, "In dreams, reality begins." Thanks for the reminder, Bob.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cayuse
Soaring Eagle, soaring to Spirit from the ego self
07:14 AM on 01/18/2011
I do agree with a lot of what you say. But it is not Progressive or Liberal to fight for Fair, Equal and Just America. The first sentence of the Constitution says "Establish Justice". It is not talking about the Justice systems it explains later in the document, but exemplifying Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness of the Declaration of Independence. And punishment for those who take it away including not only Car Salesman, Predatory corporations, but politicians, and educators.

So KING was not a Progressive Liberal he was as Conservative as our Founding Fathers that equality is a birth right of not just of American Citizens, but ALL MANKIND. And the Constitution was the rock of the world for righteousness or "right action".

The 21st Century has been symbolized to me as IRONY. Where WORDS are being redefined to change policy, law and meaning to confuse, manipulate and control the honest, sincere and hard working for the GREED of the few.

To me we have a two party one is the GREEDY party, desiring to take others Happiness away enslaving their 100% Labor for 7% return for all the Labors SWEAT and GENIUS. Twisting the words and hence the LAW for their GREED. That is as much progressive away form our roots of America as you can get

Call me what you will, but you will never take away my right to life, liberty or Happiness

This is the spirit of Martin Luther King, Gandhi, Mendella, Jesus Christ
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PerryLogan
We don't want your guns; we just want your women.
07:04 AM on 01/18/2011
Dr. King is virtually the only progressive who has become part of the modern political pantheon. In our right-controlled government and media, this is an historic achievement--a small light in the darkness that progressives are confronting today. There is also the irony progressive side of the man is thoroughly suppressed in the celebrations, and we hear little about his awesomely progressive ideas--stuff you can't even talk about now, like a guaranteed income for all citizens.
09:04 AM on 01/18/2011
Right, April 4th 1967 is at least as significant as August 28th 1963. Indeed, one might say that the former is going global on the latter.

Empire is fundamentally incompatible with democracy. Actually, democracy ------- govt of, by and (most importantly) for the people -------- exists NOWHERE. The best which exists is mirage democracy, given the over emphasis on the political component and the under emphasis on the economic component with respect to "the people". Govt of, by and for the banksters and their various cohorts (including the elites of govt) appears to be a more accurate description of what exists.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
arkymorgan
Nobody knows the trouble I've been...
04:59 AM on 01/18/2011
Why are so many posts decrying te lack of a leader?

BE that leader!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cayuse
Soaring Eagle, soaring to Spirit from the ego self
07:35 AM on 01/18/2011
Be righteous, right acting. Leading is an opportunity if you have a good soul you will lead good given the opportunity. But leading and change is not itself what make you whole. It you are not whole how can you make others whole. Christ taught you to be whole, not you make others whole. Liiving whole is not a material job or material act, it is acting beyond material life for the things that are not material. Right Action is not measured by material accomplishment or saving the world. Help others by your actions and point out the truths of non material world, be it a leader or common folk.
04:09 AM on 01/18/2011
Martin Luther King Jr. confronted the US war making machine head on and warned this nation of the moral corruption that comes from supporting or acquiescing to jingoism.
During this national holiday there is the usual stillness about King’s public opposition to our violence in Vietnam. Every year it gets pushed further into the background. Kuttner ignores it. This kind of parallels the silence during the recent midterm elections about the two shooting wars in which our troops and drones are presently engaged
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patililac
heaven forbid!
01:44 AM on 01/18/2011
The best we can do is to always tell the truth!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Buffyboy
Here it comes, Senior
01:30 AM on 01/18/2011
Under threat of death, Martin Luther King started a movement that changed our country, but our Progressive legislators don't even have the courage to mention the insanity of assault rifles after this tragedy. Pathetic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cayuse
Soaring Eagle, soaring to Spirit from the ego self
07:46 AM on 01/18/2011
I am more concerned the make an Unfair Tax Code, Health Car, Salaries, jobs benefiting themselves and not the people they supposedly serve.

GUNS are not the problem. Create fairness and there will be less sick people, less violent activity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lendmeanear
01:20 AM on 01/18/2011
Each movement also had a great leader. I don't see that person out there.
TOOO
Warning: Rabid Monty Python fan!
01:13 AM on 01/18/2011
Even though I doubt we'll ever see another Dr. King, there is still hope, because there still are a few "troublemakers" out there willing to stand up to authority. Julian Assange - if he ever gets his act together - and WikiLeaks may be the next to start a revolution, although it will be a revolution of information. As we've seen in Tunisia (and before that, Iran) "traditional" journalism - and traditional media itself - is being challenged by Twitter and Facebook.

Change can come from the most unlikeliest of places.
photo
MadAs
Tuned-in science editor
11:54 PM on 01/17/2011
On this day of Doctor Martin Luther King's, I wonder, were he alive today to see and juxtapose the changes for justice he did bring about against today's unjust translocat­ion of America's jobs and our jobless left behind, I wonder if his speech today might go something like this: "I had a nightmare.­.."”
photo
WoodyCPM
Now what?
11:39 PM on 01/17/2011
King would be the first to acknowledge that he was in many important ways chosen by history and opportunity to lead. He did not single handedly build or certainly not create the civil rights movement. In some ways the movement of southern and later northern blacks for legal and social equality "invented" Dr. King, if in no other way than in inspiring his mission. History could not have done better. He was a brilliant man, an eloquent man, a moral man, a good man. We are all poorer for him having been taken from us so untimely.

One hopes that those who are in charge of keeping the histories of our American Experiment, will not dilute nor misrepresent the full measure of his work and his message over time. He was a moral leader, not only for the civil rights of black folk, he was also a moral leader for the poor, the downtrodden, the left out, the working class no matter what their color or their gender, and for a nation that had lost its way in war, as we so often do.
photo
MadAs
Tuned-in science editor
12:07 AM on 01/18/2011
Enjoyed you comment. One area of question: not so sure the "blacks for legal and social equality 'invented' Dr. King." My sense is that long times were waiting for Dr. King, the Messiah to lead us all out of a wilderness of insensitivity, ignorance, and vile hatred.

His words not only reached "the negro" but well beyond that into the core of all human beings sense of conscience, and if not all of us then, then more of us now.
photo
WoodyCPM
Now what?
12:41 AM on 01/18/2011
"My sense is that long times were waiting for Dr. King, the Messiah to lead us all out of a wilderness of insensitiv­ity, ignorance, and vile hatred."

Exactly. You said it better than I did. However, that is why I put quotation marks around "invented".

Sometimes I despair. We slowly, painfully make progress in some areas as I certainly know that we have in the areas of race and racial discrimination, and yet we walk backwards in other areas like economic justice and war.

Thanks for your comment.
11:26 PM on 01/17/2011
I've always found myself leaning more towards Malcom, rather than Martin!
But on this MLK Day, knowing what I KNOW about this Martyr, I'm simply in Awe!!
Sometimes I wonder, what the Man who Fought for Equal Rights, and Spoke Out against the WAR (Vietnam/Cambodia/Laos), would have to say about US in Afghanistan & Iraq!!!
Then again, I think I Know the answer....

Happy Birthday Martin..........................

Peace, Love & Respect.
10:40 PM on 01/17/2011
Amen!
10:23 PM on 01/17/2011
After the passage of the Civil Rights Act, Dr. King stated that with "the defeat of Barry Goldwater, there was widespread expectation that barriers would disintegrate with swift inevitability. This easy optimism could not survive the first test. In the hard-core states of the South, while some few were disposed to accommodate, the walls remained erect and reinforced. That was to be expected, for the basic institutions of government, commerce, industry and social patterns in the South all rest upon the embedded institution of segregation.”

The election of President Barack Obama directly addressed the deep psychological scars that our history has layered over with the remnants of America’s tragic past. King went on to say, “each accomplishment was the culmination of long years of ache and agony….quietly, without the blare of trumpets, without marching legions to excite the spirit..."

When President Obama took office in 2009, he urged those who applauded his ascension to Presidential leadership to keep the pressure on him. King noted, “The fluidity and instability of American public opinion on questions of social change is very marked.” The ebb and flow of the multitude of the critical issues facing our country today and that must be decided are momentous.

I believe President Obama is a fighter. Dr. King understood that..."No major program gets going unless someone is willing to wage an active and often fierce struggle in its behalf." I think Obama is poised to do this. 
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjc
Avoid printing any..
10:19 AM on 01/18/2011
Wish the poise would turn to action....sigh....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stpehennettles com
Shooting Straight about People,News and The World
09:23 PM on 01/17/2011
As a Southernor - I am sensitive to the use of the term racist. I am not one and I grew up in South Georgia in the 60/70's. My parents were not racists either. Matter of fact, if my parents even suspected that I wasn't acting appropriately they would have tore me a new one.

Mr. Kittner it's time you faced the reality that in the 60's/70's MOST OF AMERICA WAS RACIST. To be fair there were more racists and racial hate in the South but we didn't own it. It was everywhere.

I am sick and tired of the South being characterized the way you do, Mr. Kittner.
10:13 PM on 01/17/2011
I'm thankful for you and your wonderful parents. And while I understand your not liking generalizations, it's pretty well documented that racism had pretty deep roots in the south and continues to lag behind the rest of the nation, much to my sadness.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
GoldwaterKid
Vote Person, Not Party
10:33 PM on 01/17/2011
Also, a grandchild of grandparents who grew up in the South, and at that time and before, in history; I had wonderful conversations with them about the south in the 50's and the changes that were happening in the 60's in the news and Southern California. Racial hate, women s rights, gay rights, rights in general was the topic at dinner tables, who had both Democrats and Republicans sitting and talking. At that time, when JFK chose Texan Johnson, my grandparents thought he was a hateful racists. Times are changing, and have been doing so for over 100 years. We are a Blessed Country.
photo
WoodyCPM
Now what?
12:03 AM on 01/18/2011
I'm a southerner, grew up in the South in the from the 50's to the 80's, and after 20 years in NYC, live in the South again. My parents never spoke disparagingly of black people. However, that does not mean that racism wasn't present in the larger society. It was, and it was particularly ugly and brutal, not only in individual acts, but also in an accumulation of humiliations and marginalizations. Even today in the little southern town in which I grew up around, there is still present a racist attitude among many. It might be expressed less frequently, and in less gruesome terms, but make no mistake, it's still very much alive

But you're right, racism is not confined to the South. Heaven knows it's not unique to Southerners, or even Americans. Racism is a human problem the world over. In fact King believed that Southerners would overcome their racism before northerners would simply because of the shared history and culture, however brutal and exploitative it had been for blacks. The South has certainly gone a long way toward rectifying inequities and blocked opportunities. About 15 years ago, the NYTimes reported that three of the four most integrated communities in the country were in the South. We can as Southerners take some hope in the continuing opening up of southern society to full equality, but we mustn't ever pretend that history was not what it was.