iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Naiman

Robert Naiman

GET UPDATES FROM Robert Naiman

Egypt Blocks Americans From Gaza March, Stops Aid Convoy

Posted: 12/28/09 11:49 AM ET

Cairo - The government of Egypt is taking a spectacularly hard line against international solidarity efforts in support of civilians in Gaza on the one-year anniversary of the Israeli invasion, blocking peace marchers from the U.S., Canada, and Europe from even approaching the Egyptian border with Gaza and blocking an aid convoy that has the support of the Turkish government from entering Egypt at Nuweiba. Even a peaceful protest at UN offices in Cairo was largely walled off from public view by Egyptian police.

It seems that any pretense of Egyptian government concern for the suffering of Palestinian civilians has been dropped, along with the pretense that there is anything less than 100% cooperation from Egypt and its US and European patrons with Israel's program of punishing Gaza's population for the political crime of having provided majority support to the Hamas movement in a legislative election.

Meanwhile, there is largely a U.S. press blackout of these striking developments. A search of the New York Times and the Washington Post only turns up a tiny AP story on the websites of the Times and the Post.

As has frequently been the case, Agence France-Presse (AFP) pays more attention to these developments. On Monday, AFP reports that Hedy Epstein and other members of the Gaza Freedom March have begun a hunger strike to press the Egyptian government to allow them to enter Gaza:

An 85-year-old Holocaust survivor was among a group of grandmothers who began a hunger strike in Cairo on Monday to protest against Egypt's refusal to allow a Gaza solidarity march to proceed.


American activist Hedy Epstein and other grandmothers participating in the Gaza Freedom March began a hunger strike at 1000 GMT.

"I've never done this before, I don't know how my body will react, but I'll do whatever it takes," Epstein told AFP, sitting on a chair surrounded by hundreds of protesters outside the United Nations building in Cairo.

On Sunday, AFP reported on the efforts of the Viva Palestina aid convoy to enter Egypt with the support of the Turkish government:

An aid convoy trying to reach the blockaded Gaza Strip through Egypt was still stranded in Jordan on Sunday amid Cairo's refusal to let it cross through its territory.


Members of the convoy, which is led by British MP George Galloway, were however hoping for a solution thanks to mediation by Turkey to enter Gaza through the Red Sea port of Nuweiba, the most direct route.

The British-initiated aid convoy has at least been mentioned by the BBC, but NPR has not reported on the U.S.-initiated Gaza Freedom March.

Wouldn't you be a little bit curious to know what explanations the New York Times, the Washington Post, and NPR would provide for ignoring these developments? Why not ask the Public Editor at the New York Times, ask the Ombudsman at the Washington Post, and ask the Ombudsman at NPR to give it their best shot?

 

Follow Robert Naiman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/naiman

 
 
  • Comments
  • 109
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marignymitch
E pluribus unum percent
12:56 PM on 12/30/2009
So Israel now is calling the shots in Egypt, in addition to the US?
02:32 PM on 12/30/2009
We Jews are so amazingly powerful. We rule the world!! Didn't you know that?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:46 AM on 01/01/2010
We know that you are trying, will willingly assert that you "influence" Egyptian behavior in situations like this, and never miss an opportunity to display your "power".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eileenflemingWAWA
http://www.wearewideawake.org/
09:14 PM on 12/29/2009
Screw the MSM and WAKE UP to Reality for The Truth is All Over The WWW,

Heddy Epstein said: "It is important to let the besieged Gazan people know they are not alone. I want to tell the people I meet in Gaza that I am a representative of many people in my city and in other places in the US who are outraged at what the US, Israeli and European governments are doing to the Palestinians and that our numbers are growing.”

The United States directly supported Israel’s deadly assault on the Gaza Strip for Israel used weapons paid for and supplied by the United States during “Operation Cast Lead.”

U.S. F- 16s, hellfire missiles, and ammunition used by the Israeli military devastated the Gaza Strip for 22 days and U.S.A. corporations also directly profited from “Operation Cast Lead.”

Caterpillar and Motorola equipment were used by the Israeli military during its assault on the occupied Gaza Strip. American made Caterpillar bulldozers demolished the civilian infrastructure throughout the Gaza Strip.

Amnesty International and the U.N. Fact Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict/The Goldstone Report documented that Motorola components were also used in the bombs that Israel dropped.

Human Rights Watch reported that shrapnel with Motorola serial numbers were found at the site of bombed civilian infrastructures in Gaza City.

The Rest @

http://wearewideawake.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1533&Itemid=227
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
10:38 AM on 12/30/2009
Keep up the good work.
Have a cigar.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
11:08 AM on 12/30/2009
Eileen, I'd have A LOT more sympathy for these folks if in the course of wanting to tell Gazans that thay are "outraged at what the US, Israeli and European governments are doing to the Palestinians", they also wanted to tell the Israelis that they are outraged by what the Palestinian armed factions have been doing to the Israelis (and the Palestinians as well) and that the two state solution is the only path to peace. That, after all, would be a statement that would further the peace offerts, as opposed to ignoring or even supporting the intransigence of people who reject that solution, which does not.
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
11:54 AM on 12/30/2009
If it was the Palestinians who had invaded and imprisoned the Israeli's, there would indeed be more sympathy for the Israeli side.

Your comment displays an elementary lack of understanding of Oppressor/Oppressed dynamics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
michael098762001
06:05 PM on 12/29/2009
http://zombietime.com/epstein/ casts a lot of doubt on the personal narrative and politics of Ms. Epstein. Reminds me of many elderly "progressives" who joined the Stalinist CPUSA during the 30's, who I've met over the decades. Well intentioned but, awfully naive.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ira7
09:18 AM on 12/29/2009
I don't think there's much coverage of it in the U.S. media because most Americans just don't care--like me. We side with Israel against Hamas terror, and believe Israel's incursion into Gaza was an act of self-defense.

But if you don't believe that and want to read some other distorted view of the realities there, you can always go to Al Jazeera's web site.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wisdo
semantics shamantics
11:23 AM on 12/29/2009
"...most Americans just don't care..."

Most Americans couldnt point to america on a map, let alone Gaza. You think US citizens are better informed about the middle east than all other people on earth? Or people who LIVE in the ME? Keep sucking on Fox's teat.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rachel Brownlee
12:00 AM on 12/30/2009
The only distorted view of reality is coming from the US media. WMD's anyone?
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
10:39 AM on 12/30/2009
He thinks it is the only teat.
04:10 PM on 12/30/2009
I don't know why you think that Israel's incursion into Gaza was an act of self-defense. Of course Israel has spent huge amounts of funds in its propaganda campaign. A lot of which is constantly repeated outright lies but some is just the standard biased obfuscations, deflections and orwellian use of language.

Most of the people in Gaza are refugees from Israeli terror. Israeli troops and their precursers conducted a fair number of massacres, ordering people out of their houses, lining them up and gunning them down in mass. Then they used loudspeakers in other places, telling people to leave their homes or be slaughtered "like they were at Deir Yassein" All part of the plan to get rid of the Arabs of Palestine to make room for Israel, to "cleanse" (term used by Israel's founders) the land of its native inhabitants.

Current propaganda by Israel is focussing on both deflecting the many human rights reports of deliberate murders by Israeli troops in Gaza Dec. 2008/Jan 2009, denying the independent, unbiased data they collected, e.g. about the children they burned to death with white phospherous, the deliberate squeezing of the Gazan economy, denial of adequate clean water, nutrition, building materials sufficient to bring shelter to those whose homes were destroyed by Israel, medical supplies, not to mention jobs. All in order to achieve a political outcome favorable to Israel.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CarlyHope
01:22 PM on 12/31/2009
One word Lyn

ROCKETS.

Hamas shot them deeper and deeper and deeper into Israel.
08:28 AM on 12/29/2009
The government of Egypt is taking a spectacularly hard line against international solidarity which is opposed to any contact with Hamas until it meets the Quartet's demands and recognizes Israel's right to exist and stops the terrorist attacks on Israeli civlians (not to mention its violent attacks on Fatah members in Gaza).
For those who think Israel or the US have any influence over Egypt's decisions regarding the terrorist Hamas government, remember that Egypt is scared of the Muslim Brotherhood, the parent organization of Hamas. The Muslim Brotherhood is oppressed in Egypt. You can't expect the Egyptians to have any sympathy for their allies in Gaza.
06:26 PM on 12/29/2009
Exactly. Egypt is a pretty repressive place, and perhaps could use some activists demonstrating against Egyptian actions, but I am mystified why these people think that they can just waltz into Egypt and stir up what, in the eyes of the Egyptian authorities, is trouble. The conflicts in the Middle East cannot simply be reduced to Israelis vs. the Palestinians, something that many anti-Israeli posters on this site seem to not consider.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:19 AM on 12/31/2009
They didn't plan to waltz into Egypt, they wanted to march through to get to Gaza. It is well known that Mazarak is in deep political trouble and is dependent upon the US and Israel to keep him in power. The aid he receives from the US is tied to his playing nice with both countries. Too bad Israeli aid isn't tied to that as well.
07:05 AM on 12/29/2009
Solution? 1. The Palestinian Arabs need to renounce Hamas and Fatah and set up an interim government that explicitly recognizes Israel's right to exist as a Jewish State inside the 1967 borders, with minor modifications to both Israel and Palestine (West Bank/Gaza). 2. Israeli "settlers" in the West Bank may either become Palestinian citizens or go back into pre-1967 Israel's borders. 3. Jerusalem will become a shared capital, with Israel retaining rights to the Western Wall/Temple Mount and Palestine retaining control of the mosques on the Mount. 4. The Arab world will assist in the resettlement of the Palestinian Arab refugees, with some allowed to go to the new Palestinian state, others to places of their choice in the Arab world or beyond. Britain and France, largely responsible for the mess due to their colonial policies, will play a major role. 5. Palestine, demilitarised except for a police force, will receive generous investment and aid from the world and develop a modern infrastructure and economy, working in partership with the Arab world and (sooner or later) Israel, where Palestinians can prosper and find opportunity and dignity. 6. Israel, Palestine, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria will work together on vital issues such as water, for the benefit of all. 7. Anti-Semitic and racist incitement in the region will cease, and all parties will cooperate for the common good.
Now--I wonder what is so wrong with those modest suggestions? Let the games begin...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ira7
09:20 AM on 12/29/2009
Well said.
10:15 AM on 12/29/2009
I like your suggestions but I wonder about point #2; if we have Israeli Arabs why would all the Jews on the Palestinian side of the border have to leave? Why couldn't they have Palestinian citizenship just like the Arab Israelis have Israeli citizenship?
01:01 PM on 12/29/2009
Please re-read my point 2. Israeli Jews who wish to become citizens of Palestine and reside in a Palestinian state may do so, with full rights as Palestinians--just as Arab Israelis reside in Israel a citizens with full rights as Israelis. My point is that no "transfer of population" need take place.
04:29 AM on 12/29/2009
"It seems that any pretense of Egyptian government concern for the suffering of Palestinian civilians has been dropped, "

ISpeaking of dropping pretenses.
It is highly revealing that those who are vociferously claming support for Palestinian suffering only support those Palestinian who suffer at the hands of Israelis.
Today, right now hundreds of thousands Palestinains are deprived of basic medical care, human rights, education rights, work rights, and freedom ofo movement and even a right to -rebuild their own houses.... In Lebanon.

WHERE ARE THE ALLEGED PALESTINIAN SUPPORTERS?

I've to read even SINGLE post by alleged supporters of Palestinian suffering about 500,000 Palestinian
ethnically cleansed from the Kuwait not that long ago. Why not?

Those Palestinains who suffer at the hands of Lebanese, Syrians, Kuwaitis are completely and totally ignored. Shame.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:40 AM on 12/30/2009
Your croc tears are ridiculous, as anyone who's familiar with your neo-antisemitic racism from elsewhere at HuffPost knows full well. People also know that while Palestinian arabs have indeed suffered at the hands of others besides Israel, all roads lead back to the Israeli government in Tel Aviv.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:57 AM on 01/01/2010
Doesn't the newest myth place the capital of Israel in Jerusalem? Tel Aviv is so yesterday.
09:11 PM on 12/28/2009
Of course they did, they're our ally.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
RobertNaiman
Policy Director at Just Foreign Policy
07:29 PM on 12/28/2009
UPDATE: Al Jazeera reports that Turkey has brokered a deal between Egypt and the Viva Palestina convoy, which will now change course:

Gaza aid convoy to change course
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2009/12/200912281583520582.html
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
RobertNaiman
Policy Director at Just Foreign Policy
06:08 PM on 12/28/2009
UPDATE: JFP sent an alert asking folks to contact NYT and WaPo. There is a photo at the link of Hedy Epstein at the UN protest, showing humanitarian aid she intended to take with her into Gaza.

http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/act/gaza-march-press
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
03:43 PM on 12/28/2009
Few people have much sympathy for people launching rockets at, and engaging in many other forms of violent attack, against civilians, or, it turns out, for the people that committed the "crime of having provided majority support" for them. Once upon a time, people, on "the left" like me, looked in favor upon the two-state solution, and stood against people, whether Israeli or Palestinian, that rejected that idea, and "we" certainly stood against people who used violence, especially attacks targeting civilians, as a strategy. When people on "the left" jumped the shark and began supporting, and making excuses for, those sorts of people, they lost the intellectual honesty that once distiguished them and put moral force behind their arguments.
04:04 PM on 12/28/2009
Yup. That's why I'm no longer on the Left.
05:04 PM on 12/28/2009
By contrast, a whole lot of people have sympathy who a state which has been in consistent contempt of international law since its inception, routinely violating the Geneva convention, numerous UN resolutions, World Court opinion, etc.

Indeed, the US public does support such a state but I suspect the cause is not a function of the reasoned moral assessment of the acts of Palestinians vs. those of Israel because such a reasoned assessment would have generated a posture similar to that of international legality which tends to look unfavorably at not just the rock attacks of the Palestinians but the root causes (occupation, settlement, refusal of Palestinian right of return or compensation, denial of Palestinian suffering caused by Israel's founding, refusal to recognize the Palestinian "right of self-determination, etc.) It is a function of ignorance resulting from slanted media coverage as suggested in the article above.

It is entirely unconvincing to use US public opinion as an explanation for the lack of sympathy for Palestinians & the corresponding sympathy for a state which has the most egregious record of violations of UN resolutions (not mentioning those which were vetoed by the US).

The causal arrow is in the opposite direction: public opinion is the result not the cause of media coverage
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
05:42 PM on 12/28/2009
Your argument is a fine example for the illustration of my point. Your argument dwells upon fine-sounding myths like "the rock attacks of the Palestinians" and "a state which has been in consistent contempt of international law since its inception", as if Palestinians attacked only with rocks, as if the estence of Israel were contrary to international law, and entirely ignores the role of the Palestinians in this conflict, including thier (and by "their" I mean their armed factions') much repeated and almost routinely ignored desire but to end the exitence of Israel, which is both in violation of international law and inherently incompatible with the 2 state solution. While there is much to criticise in Israeli policy, about which her critics, including countless Israelis and suppporters of Israel, spend rediculous amounts of time addressing to Israel's right wing, it is a curious fact about this issue that those on "the left", the vantage point from which I view the world, remain determined to be blind to Palestinian intasignence, violence (even that which amounts to crimes against humanity) and human rights depradations that cause this dance of death to continue as much if not more than the existence of all the Israeli settlements.
03:26 PM on 12/28/2009
The 85-year old Holocaust survivor Hedy Epstein was interviewed on Amy Goodman's "Democracy Now" a few days ago. It is a national disgrace that our corporate media (broadcast, cable & print) so distorts the public discourse on Palestine by ignoring the political views, humanitarian efforts of so many sincere individuals like Hedy Epstein. Thankfully, the alternative sources for "real news" do exist on satellite TV & online, but the MSM will need to understand & acknowledge that internationally the citizen groups of so many diverse nationalities, the BDS movements here in the USA & abroad, will continue to erode the old narratives about the region by insisting that their voices be heard.
04:08 PM on 12/28/2009
The pro-palestinian anti-Israel bias of the MSM over the last three decades has been well-documented. Hedy Epstein "survived" the holocaust in England. The description "Holocaust Survior" should be reserved for the survivors of the death camps.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wisdo
semantics shamantics
04:29 PM on 12/28/2009
Yes, Hedy Epstein is a well known anti-semite probably. Like the virulent anti-semite Judge Goldstone must be.
06:24 PM on 12/28/2009
Ms Epstein lived away from bombings, in US. Now she has a form of what is known as Sockholm syndrome (kind of distortion that made the abducted to support their own abductors).
This Stockholm syndrome is not that rare as one may think.
09:52 PM on 12/28/2009
Did you go to Amy Goodman's "Democracy Now" website? I suggest you do & listen to what Hedy Epstein has to say. Whether you (or anyone else) agrees or disagrees with her is beside the point. Her voice deserves to be heard in the MSM also. Thankfully, the international satellite channels & the alternative media are giving this story airtime. Let the public judge for themselves whether it is credible, instead of filtering the news as is business as usual in the corporate media.
02:49 PM on 12/28/2009
Let's be honest there is no conspiracy to hide this story in the US Newspapers. The bottom line there is little or no interest in the plight of the people of Gaza. Even if the folks on a hunger strike move on to the afterlife for their convictions, not many here in the US will even notice. Americans by and large have lost empathy for the Palestinians long ago. So many opportunities have been squandered by a stubborn near suicidal refusal to believe that Israel is here to stay. Sure the Palestinian people can continue this way for a hundred or two hundred years waiting for Israel to collapse. What a colossal waste of their children.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wisdo
semantics shamantics
04:24 PM on 12/28/2009
" Americans by and large have lost empathy for the Palestinians long ago."

haha. WHat a comedian. WHEN did Americans have "empathy for" the Palestinians, EVER?
photo
CigarGod
What is your process?
10:57 AM on 12/30/2009
Understood.
But, there has always been a small faction that did understand and advocate for the Palestinian's. Einstein happens to be one.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:12 PM on 12/28/2009
I have much more interest in the plight of the Palestinians than I have in the latest ravings of the indenpendent freshman Senator from Connecticut; nevertheless, he always seems to get the attention of the press. Think it is the "mooning"?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
michael098762001
01:46 PM on 12/28/2009
Why the silence on the killings in Iran/
The debate Naiman had with a Iranian-American Professor recently, carried by The Real News, organized by chicago leftists was revealing.