More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Scheer

GET UPDATES FROM Robert Scheer
 

Thanks for What?

Posted: 11/24/11 04:19 AM ET

I love Thanksgiving for its illusion of abundance. It brings back early childhood memories of the one day each year during the Depression when the food on my family's table was not the leftover produce that my Uncle Leon could no longer sell at his stall, or the nearly spoiled organ meats that our local butcher offered at a steep discount.

But Thanksgiving day was quite the opposite, and while I obviously can't recall what was served in 1936, the year I was born, the holiday was soon seared into my childhood memory as the day when the good times looked upon us in the form of charity gift baskets from philanthropists of various religious and political orders, much like the needy will be served today in volunteer kitchens across America and just as soon will be forgotten.

It did not take long before I was old enough to realize that the largesse of Thanksgiving was the rare exception, and that "just getting by," as my mother's brave optimism would have it, was the norm. Getting by, thanks to Mom's piecework in the downtown sweatshops and my mechanic father's signing on to one of the New Deal's public jobs programs.

Then came the economic miracle of World War II, dismissed in its day by some Republicans as Franklin Roosevelt's treachery, and my parents and other relatives got their jobs back. The relevance of the wartime jobs to Thanksgiving in our family was that my Uncle Edward, the welder, was rewarded every year at his plant with one enormous turkey or two smaller ones.

The result was what I recall as an annual day of bloating, as if my extended family was frantically storing calories in preparation for a severe economic winter that was certain to return. But for us it didn't return. Not with the good union jobs that abounded in the postwar boom and the opportunities provided by the GI Bill and the spread of affordable college education that made upward mobility a truly plausible American goal.

Every time I need to be reminded of what was done for my generation in the way of generous government-funded programs, I reread the part of Colin Powell's inspiring autobiography where he writes about the educational opportunities and vigorous community support programs that postwar kids in the Bronx were afforded. Powell and I were engineering students in the same class at the City College of New York, though I didn't get to know him until he was famous and I spoke with him as a journalist. But the great opportunities available to us, as compared to what is available to the poor today, is a recognition we share.

I thought back to those buoyantly optimistic times at CCNY, the working-class Harvard as it was justifiably called, last week when students protesting onerous tuition hikes at the University of California got pepper-sprayed for their efforts to keep hope alive. The once excellent and very affordable UC system, like the publicly funded colleges of New York and elsewhere across the country, was the proud boast of moderate Republican and Democratic politicians who believed as did the nation's Founders that equal opportunity leading to a land of stakeholders was the essential bedrock of America's experiment in democracy.

No more. On this Thanksgiving we have been cheated of the bounty of that harvest as the stakes have been pulled up on the millions of Americans who have lost their homes or the many more who face that fate with half of US home mortgages now underwater. The housing crisis haunts a majority of Americans, even those who own their homes outright but have lost their jobs and must now sell in a downward-swirling housing market.

Good public education on every level, from preschool through college, is now a matter of inherited privilege reserved for those who can pick and choose affluent neighborhood settings for their children's schools. And the prospect of affording one of those settings is dim for most parents in a country where securing a good job is beyond the reach of so many highly motivated people.

How many folks from my generation are honestly sanguine about the economic future of their children and grandchildren? What I have heard constantly, and just this week from a former top investment banker addressing a college class I teach, is that our offspring probably will face a decade of lost opportunity. I thought back to my college days and how shocked any of us, even those from the most impoverished of circumstances, would have been to hear such a prediction.

As the New York Times editorialized this Thanksgiving, "One in three Americans -- 100 million people -- is either poor or perilously close to it."

A bummer of a message, I know, until I think of those pepper-sprayed college students linking arms, and of all the Americans, young, old and between, who have occupied their minds with a challenge -- that it doesn't have to be this way. For their brave spirit of resistance we should be most grateful this Thanksgiving.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 501
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
06:48 PM on 11/26/2011
It is getting perilously close to that point in time where, if things do not change, that Americans will be taking to the streets. Not as they are peacefully doing now but with the intent of tearing the corrupt institutions down. The time for America to change is now, later will be too late.
02:19 AM on 11/27/2011
Black Friday sales were at record highs; Americans are doing well and enjoying their holidays as they have for a near 70 year turn of incredible prosperity. Americans who cry poor are like people at a buffet who complain the oysters aren't quite chilled enough. Take to the streets? Only to chase down some sweet bargains!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SansCulottes08
08:15 AM on 11/28/2011
Ignorance is bliss, I suppose. The GOP figured this out about 40 years ago and it is now their total ideological, propaganda and electoral strategy.

Most items purchased by consumers on Black Friday were made overseas. Most purchases were made on credit. Those purchases add to the US trade deficit and US consumer debt. They weaken the US economy, not strengthen it.

The first thing everybody has got to do to break the hold of the global corporations and banks over American government and society is to STOP SHOPPING.
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
11:46 AM on 11/26/2011
"Most of the greatest evils that man has inflicted upon man have come through people feeling quite certain about something which, in fact, was false."
-- Bertrand Russell
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
11:45 AM on 11/26/2011
Bitter complaints about housing values going down, bitter complaints about housing price prices going up just a few years ago. Will complain about prices going up in a few years. Bet on it.
And all of, no doubt, due to machinations of ...fill the Chomsky Lite terminology.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
09:41 AM on 11/26/2011
True.

There is little thanksgiving in 2 party Crony Capitalism

Next stage is to cut Payroll tax in 1/2 cutting SSA Revenue and making entiltlements a reality.

Next is a WAR with Iran because we America can be the only country to Drop Atomic Bomb, Drones and have Unprovoked WAR, Occupation and ATTACK all others who try this. And all those who don't like Iran.

We are failing economically, democratically, and socially. No need for a Thanksgiving of delusion. We need leaders that are not following the Water Fall approach of the past Decade and the 3 Decade of Reaganomic that distroyed the New Deal for Hedge Fund profits and Multiply and Subdue the earth
07:51 AM on 11/26/2011
"Strange how it was always the spoiled who weakened and cried first, and it was the injured, the maimed, the blind, and the poor who fought on alone.”
― Louis L'Amour
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
anonymous67
02:29 AM on 11/26/2011
My thanks and a special prayer to the OWS protestors for snatching America's attention away from the litany of propaganda promoting unending corporate greed and callous abuse of that suffer its consequences.
frank1946
Tell the Truth
01:43 AM on 11/26/2011
Trillions in Public DEBT has accomplished very little !

Nobody wants to buy USA DEBT anymore, or Europe.

So, lamenting the decline in PORK seems absurd ?
12:47 AM on 11/26/2011
Either take care of illegals or pay your tuition- you can't have both.

http://chronicle.com/article/Californias-Public-Colleges/125910/
http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/immigrationnaturalizatio/a/caillegals.htm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
09:48 AM on 11/26/2011
Public spending on education when there are no JOB is stupid and throwing money down a rat hole

But then not giving Green Cards to all the illegals to identify them and let them stay as long as they have a job and have not broken the other laws and alow them to come and go as long as they have work is also stupid.

Only an idiot or self motive would deal with a problem with a solution of ignorance of the problems
12:52 AM on 11/27/2011
Check the links out. The state of California is spending over $10 billion a year on illegal immigrants while they cut $1.4 billion from the education system.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jf1936
09:02 PM on 11/25/2011
You can thank the failure of our government for all of this.

Public education is their responsibility, which they have failed all of our children consistently.
College education affordability? They have single-handedly turned the vast majority of our college graduates into indentured servants, backing and granting loans that the market would have most certainly rejected.

Housing is no longer affordable because the government strives day and night to keep prices artificially high so that the banks with large foreclosure holdings are not harmed by suffering massive loses in equity.

ALL of this can be traced back to government manipulation of the marketplace.

All I'm thankful for is the strong libertarian movement that has grown in this country in the last 4 years. In 2007 no one knew what a libertarian was, and today 1 in every 6 voters considers themselves libertarian.

Separation of church, CORPORATION and state, and we will get back to being a truly prosperous country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
09:56 AM on 11/26/2011
You seem to think Government is not a piece of Paper, the laws of the Land, the Constitution of the Unifted States of America

You seem to think Corporations are a person and not a Business Entity owned by Stock Traders who do not work for the Corporation, they don't sweat or give genious. They simply trade ownership and pay only 15%. The jobs creators don't exist as you are lied to. NYSE and ASE don't put cash into a corporation that is an IPO and 90% of all employment are corporations in NYSE and ASE. The only way to create jobs is TAX the Corporations, Dividend and Capital Gains forcing Corporations and Stock Traders to raise wages, hire and build corporate capacity which are deductions and lower these taxes.

Ron Paul is the only one I would vote. But I am convince I will write Paul and Kucinich end so I can be proud of not voting for either of these 2 parties of crony capitalism
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jf1936
12:41 PM on 11/27/2011
I don't think government is a piece of paper. It is an organization of people that make arbitrary rules for their own self interest, no different than an organized crime syndicate.

Corporations are not "people" but they are owned by people. Corporations are not owned by "traders", you strongly misunderstand the premise. They are owned by shareholders, who while not being employed by that corporation, have skin in the game because their money is at stake.

Investors are absolutely job creators. That is not a lie, because I am at the forefront of that argument. I own a small motorcycle shop, and without my investors I could have never afforded to expand and hire additional mechanics.

Taxing the corporations and raising wages? That makes no sense, all you are doing is more of the same- manipulating the marketplace with government policies.

If you want to create jobs, you remove taxes and regulatory burden, including minimum wage. Just let the market work.

I am happy to hear that you would vote for Paul. He is by far the best choice.
08:46 PM on 11/25/2011
Every underprivileged or disadvantaged American of today is a negative drag on the America of tomorrow. We may not always succeed, but we cannot stop trying to 'lift ALL boats'. We gain nothing through the Republican message of hate fear, greed, jealousy, bigotry, and division, or the conservative chant to cut back, roll, back, retrench, self flagellate, and surrender....................all that we get from that is self doubt, obsolescence, and a declining place in the world.

Like it or not Boehner, Cantor, McConnell, Kyl, Ryan, and their pay-to-play friends are bad for you!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
10:11 AM on 11/26/2011
You appear to be related to the Post, my dad use to talk about. The one that was part of the Fence clan.

The underprivilidged and disadvantage are probably MORE than the Rich Stock Trader and sure in the hell have less than their wealth and income. Since 20% own 90%. And if 80% with have10% that is the disadvantaged and underprivleged you just NAMED

So out of 305,000,000 people in AMERICA you seem to think 61,000,000 own the other 244,000,000 who are underprivilidge and disadvantaged. And this owning is the way it ought to be

Just 11 years ago Capital to Labor was in balance with the UNDERPRIVILEDGED AND DISADVANTAGE recieving 60% of the fruit of the labor for DOING ALL THE WORK.

A corporation and stock treader cannot make 1 thin DIME withut Labor. And you seem to think that doing no work and ADD NO VALUE to the economy is worth more than those who do all the work. if all the CASH is in the hands of these non worker or non job creators you don't have a democracy and you don't have capitalism. You have cronyt capitalism and an Oligopoly

Nice delusion, but a very unworkable situation that is mathematically heading to a very abrupt ending. That Justice could prevent and all including those with more would benefit rather than falling of the edge of humaity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
10:15 AM on 11/26/2011
Sorry, your first sentence sent me rolling down the hill? The rest I favored.

So you are not of the Fence Clan. That is Boehner, Cantor, McConnell, Kyl, Ryan, and Obama are
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shankapotomus
07:20 PM on 11/25/2011
Yea Robert why didn't you mention FDR made the Americans suffer 7 years longer than they should have by spending to much?
01:14 AM on 11/26/2011
Explain, please.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shankapotomus
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill Duckworth
It is a DOOZY
10:23 AM on 11/26/2011
Studying the FDR economics and history is not SWALLOWING the propaganda of the Tax Cutiting 2 Party Crony Capitalism

Thinki for yourself is why we are MORE THAN ONE.

If the DUST BOWL GREAT DEPRESSION, and WWII is not enough to convince you. Election to 4 Terms of Office and 12 years of service make you HIND SIGHT very silly.

What you would have him Cut Taxes on the RICH who don't even create JOBS in any great fasion. Our Congress use their Insider information to get rich while in office with new IPO's. These initial public offerings are a Primary Market. And no quarantee of a new job at all. How many IPO's don't create 1 more job.

The NYSE and ASE are the secondary stock market of EXISTING STOCK only. No initial investment or potential for JOB CREATION. And where $300 Billion is trader every year and where America is EMPLOYEED. The only job creation here is thought TAXATION. Corporation and their Stock Trader OWNERS will avoid TAX by Hiring, Raising Wages and purchases to expand the economy. As well as increasing the stock value by increasing the Asset to Price values. Another folly of your REAGANSOMICS
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
06:05 PM on 11/25/2011
No 1 can make you inferior without your consent,pal.
08:39 PM on 11/25/2011
Not so........ Republican policy can and has.........multiple times over the history of the country. The playing field has to be fair in order for winners to emerge. The fewer the playing fields, and the more that the fields are tilted, the fewer the hero's who have an opportunity to 'strut their stuff'.

Every under privileged person in America (self caused or not) is a negative drag on the opportunity that will ultimately be available to the next generation of American's. While, it is true that it may not matter to the ever increasing number of self serving, self righteous winners of today, it will limit the future for both them and their offspring.............that is, if they manage to find anytime outside of self worship to find time to procreate :-)
photo
tnkeating
Dyslexic agnostic insomniac
05:17 PM on 11/25/2011
So give up now or press on, I received no student loans as they were only available to some people back when I went to school so I put myself through college working at every opportunity, when I didn't have work I missed a semester (or two). It all comes down to how bad do you want it and what are you willing to do to get it. Were you raised to be a producer or a consumer.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
08:02 PM on 11/25/2011
That was true for me in the 1960s, but I am not sure how students can pay their own way in this new era.
08:51 PM on 11/25/2011
A huge percentage of the Americans made it through on the GI Bill. We should have a mandatory National Service Corp for all American's and ALL American's should be given the opportunity for either a college education or vocational training. In all cases, we also need a to instill the idea that education is a lifetime pursuit, people must constantly renew, upgrade, and enhance their skills throughout their lives. The idea that one skill set, and one job can serve a family for a full generation is long gone!
03:42 PM on 11/25/2011
When we abandoned unions, we abandoned the middle class. The proof is now here. The top of the food chain gets richer, and the rest loose more and more. Unions gave the workers a fair shake. Now there is nothing to put a check on greed from the top.
05:01 PM on 11/25/2011
Given that the bottom is anchored to zero and the top is unlimited, yeah the top of the food chain gets richer. The question is are you really losing just because you are not winning as much as the top.
01:18 AM on 11/26/2011
Interesting concept, the rubber band. If it stretches uniformly, I would agree with you. I expect not only is the end anchored but several waypoints are anchored as well.
01:41 PM on 11/26/2011
I'm not sure I get what you're saying. The bottom is stagnant. Their has been no gains. Flat. Nothing. So it is hard to measure zero.
08:54 PM on 11/25/2011
The net effect is that the both the number of playing fields, and the fairness of those playing fields has been rigged to reduce the opportunities that are available to Americans. THAT, in turn, will reduce the power, and the future prospects of America and for ALL Americans!
03:13 PM on 11/25/2011
This guy's articles are always moderated to death.........so you better agree with him.
05:03 PM on 11/25/2011
I have been disagreeing with the gist of the article and have not had my posts censored.
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
06:01 PM on 11/25/2011
Yep. i'ts the liberal concept of liberty: we're very nice as long as you toe the line.The party line.