EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Roberta Lee

GET UPDATES FROM Roberta Lee
 

The Medicine Cabinet is Shrinking

Posted: 6/23/09

Earlier this year in February, the Congressional Budget Office predicted that without changes in federal policy, the number of Americans without health insurance would grow from about 45 million this year to about 54 million in 2019 . But 2019 is years away and I wonder in the more immediate future what my patients will do if they need medication for diabetes, hypertension or high cholesterol and can't afford it. Medication costs without insurance coverage are astronomical-- and my uninsured patients are struggling to pay for all their needed prescriptions. By 2019 many of my patients could be dead simply because they're not taking their medications--even when they know they should.

A report issued by the US Public Interest Research Group in 2006 documented that uninsured Americans were paying 65% more than what drug companies charged the federal government for prescriptive medications. This survey evaluated ten of the most commonly prescribed medication in 35 cities including D.C.. Customers purchasing medications online from Canadian pharmacies were paying half the price for the same medications. Not only that, the average price between 2004- 2006 rose 11% annually. At the time this study was conducted Premarin®, a commonly prescribed estrogen medication, was 550% higher in the U.S. versus the listed price in a Canadian pharmacy.

Surveys released by the Center for Studying Health System Change (HSC) taken between the years 2001-2007 revealed that the proportion of Americans under the age of 65 having problems affording prescription medications grew from 10.3 % in 2003 to 13.9 % --an 11.7 million increase of people from 2003 which initially recorded 36.1 million working age adults and children experiencing medication cost concerns Not surprisingly, the report noted that the most vulnerable were the uninsured, those with low incomes and those with chronic conditions . Having at least one chronic condition more than doubled the likelihood of reporting unmet prescription drug needs.


The health insurance safety net under the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA), for those recently losing their jobs is not necessarily preserving health coverage like it was in the past. When a person becomes unemployed COBRA extends insurance benefits under a previous employer's plan. An employer's health care plan is typically much lower in cost to the individual because it is a plan negotiated by the employer as a group plan. Its benefits are good for 18 months. Despite the fact that 2 out of 3 working adults are eligible for COBRA, nine out of ten unemployed workers opt out of COBRA coverage because it is too expensive. Those opting out with medical conditions represent another growing group of people at risk for developing unmet prescription medication needs.


Today there are people among the insured who are struggling to keep up with the ever increasing price of prescription medication co-payments. A HSC report released in 2007 indicated that tiered prescriptive medicine plans which use generic medicines to reduce overall healthcare costs are now offered by roughly 95% of employers. Generic drugs are substituted in most medication categories and are offered as the first line full coverage medication to the patient over the more expensive name brands. Those who wish to use name brands can still purchase these medications as an out-of-pocket expense.

During the initiation of copayments for prescriptive medications early reports suggested little or no negative effect on patient compliance or health outcomes. However, an HSC tracking report released in January 2009 revealed that with a rise in prescriptive drug copayments higher than 20% many people began to have trouble paying for needed medications. In fact, the percentage of unmet medication needs among U.S. working age adults with higher incomes and chronic conditions was almost as high as those with unmet prescription drug needs without chronic conditions and low incomes ( 21% versus 23% respectively). Low income was defined as those families with incomes below the federal poverty line and high income was defined as those families whose incomes were two times above the federal poverty level.

In addition, I have seen many patients attempt medical management of some of their medical problems by using dietary supplements, additionally availing themselves to indigenous medical practices such as acupuncture and chiropractic. The current prevalence of use of these practices and modalities often referred to as complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) or modalities is approximately 40-60 % depending on the survey and definition of CAM. However, it is unclear what proportion of activity is due to philosophical preferences versus attempts toward cost containment by the patient--especially in this last year when so many have lost their jobs. Yet, what is consistent among reports of patients incorporating these practices is the lack of disclosure to their healthcare providers; typically this represents 60-70% of patients in primary care. What has always been troublesome about this fact is the potential for medical mismanagement. I wonder if we will see additional complications as more people use CAM as an alternative to conventional or integrative medicine primary care purposefully leaving behind any discussion from medical practitioners.

For whatever the reason, the growing proportion of patients with unmet prescription drug needs is disturbing. The fact that those suffering financially the most are those with chronic diseases certainly is a signal that in a time when health care cost containment is critical to our nation we need to change course. It is imperative that what ever system we choose medications for the management of chronic diseases should be accessible to all regardless of income. Prevention and proper management of disease saves money, but more importantly, it saves lives and improves quality of life for patients and their families.

 

Follow Roberta Lee on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drrobertalee

 
  • Comments
  • 2
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:56 AM on 06/26/2009
There appear to be some things that you and most others from an allopathic­ally-train­ed medical background don't seem to grasp. Simply put... there are a large and growing number of people who no longer trust you nor regard you as "experts" in the healing profession­... and also discount a great deal of medical research studies because they are aware that this research has been primarily funded by the pharmaceut­ical industry..­. complete with its own agenda. I've been a volunteer health educator and moderator at one of the largest natural health websites on the internet for over 7 years and have watched it grow from a handful of forums to almost 900... covering every condition and aspect of health care that you could possibly imagine. Many people turned to natural and holistic methods of healing out of desperatio­n because allopathic medicine failed to provide them with answers and all too often offered no more than a pharmaceut­ical symptomati­c band aide complete with side-effec­ts.... or dismissed their suffering outright and referred them to someone from the "mental health care" system... with the implicatio­n that they had a psychiatri­c condition rather than a "real" illness. As a health psychologi­st... I frequently spent much of my time working to undo the damage that this approach caused as patients were then not only dealing with their initial condition.­.. but also their anger with the "health care" system... with some of them feeling traumatize­d by it.
03:17 AM on 06/26/2009
These people learned many years ago that they had to take responsibi­lity for their own health and spent a great deal of time educating themselves in a wide range of natural and holistic treatments and therapies. They also watched as agencies like the FDA pulled natural products off the shelves of health food stores while pharmaceut­ical companies and food manufactur­ers were launching synthetic and patentable versions instead. They watched as natural and holistic health care practition­ers from a variety of background­s were harassed, tossed in jail, driven out of the country... and in some cases even died under questionab­le circumstan­ces. Ironically some of these practition­ers were of the very same background that are now being sought and employed by clinics and hospitals that are run by allopathic physicians­. They watched as allopathic practition­ers with little or no training in nutrition offered nutritiona­l advice while the epidemic of obesity escalated out of control.