iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ron Kaplan

GET UPDATES FROM Ron Kaplan
 

If the Yankees Are Such a Class Organization, Why Do They Cheat?

Posted: 06/29/2012 5:46 pm

Two years ago it was Derek Jeter, who won an Academy Award for best fake hit by pitch.

Now it's Dewayne Wise, who got way too much benefit of the doubt when umpire Mike DiMuro credited him with catching a ball in foul territory that the Yankees outfielder did not catch.

The ESPN sports talk show Pardon the Interruption featured the incident, with Tony Kornheiser coming down on the side of truth and justice, while co-host Michael Wilbon merely opined this is the Major Leagues not Little League. The takeaway therefore, I suppose, is that sportsmanship and honesty are not longer in play, so to speak.

I love stories in other sports, such as golf and tennis, where an athlete fesses up, even at the risk of losing the event and prize money. Is it because baseball is a team sport that the offender is reluctant to come forward, because he doesn't want to let down the team?

Wise's cop-out: "It's not my fault" the umpire messed up.

Wise said, "Anybody in baseball would've done the same thing," which is probably true and the problem. "The umpire makes the out call -- you've got to go with it," he continued. "You can't just sit there and say, 'I didn't make the catch.'" Sure you can. Someone has got to go first.

(And don't you just love this rationale from Yankees catcher Chris Stewart who said yesterday, "You're trying to get your team to win. You're not really cheating, necessarily." It's that qualifier "necessarily" that does it for me.)

Wouldn't it be something if, just once, a team or player would say, "We don't have to win this way?" But with so much money at stake (imagine if this had cost the Yankees the game and they lost a post-season berth by that margin), you can be almost certain it will never happen.

So what are we teaching young athletes here? That it's all right to pull stunts like this, so you might as well get used to it and perfecting this aspect of your game? And if it's okay here, it's okay in other aspects of life too? Where would you start differentiating?

 
FOLLOW SPORTS
Two years ago it was Derek Jeter, who won an Academy Award for best fake hit by pitch. Now it's Dewayne Wise, who got way too much benefit of the doubt when umpire Mike DiMuro credited him with catc...
Two years ago it was Derek Jeter, who won an Academy Award for best fake hit by pitch. Now it's Dewayne Wise, who got way too much benefit of the doubt when umpire Mike DiMuro credited him with catc...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
PowerPridePinstripes
27 and Counting!
09:47 AM on 07/23/2012
Man Boooo!
photo
FDRliberal
Terminating teabag ideology with extreme prejudice
12:30 AM on 07/09/2012
The big Patriots NG Vince Wilfork admitted to the ref on the field he was not held on a key play AFTER the call. He laughed and said he was owed one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TC Ragstix
just a songwriter
01:42 AM on 07/03/2012
In the old days, with only ump, a player ran across the diamond from first to third while the ump was looking the other direction. "Safe at third!"
09:04 PM on 07/02/2012
Mr. Kaplan, I enjoyed your article. But... do you honestly think this happens ONLY on the Yankees? As I write this, there are about 15 major league baseball games being played. And I would bet that there is a blown call by an umpire in just about every one of those games. Do you expect the team that benfits from the blown call to tell the ump that he blew the call? If you don't like the Yankees, there are better ways to state your opinion. But at least be fair.
02:09 PM on 07/09/2012
Thank you. It may be unfair, but as the "class of the game," shouldn't they be held to a higher moral standard?
photo
PowerPridePinstripes
27 and Counting!
09:50 AM on 07/23/2012
Um, hey - each and every MLB team should have standards -- and at the end of the day, it's a game! We watch for entertainment and who doesn't like to see some drama here and there --- that's what playing is all about. I think folks that take this sort of cerebral approach and moral fortitude approach are just, well...um, zzzzzzzz...yeah, m'kay. Leave it alone ... leave the Yanks alone! Fitzgerry called it right... it's silly to believe that ONLY the yankees do things that will make someone with such high moral standards call foul! Really? Pluease...
05:24 PM on 07/02/2012
Down with the evil empire! http://www.squidoo.com/hate-the-yankees
02:48 PM on 07/02/2012
what stunt did wise pull? he didn't even act like he caught the ball.
11:44 AM on 07/02/2012
The fault lies with the umpire. Jeter's performance is done by other players as well. GO YANKS!!!!
photo
PowerPridePinstripes
27 and Counting!
09:51 AM on 07/23/2012
You sir, speak the truth!
09:32 PM on 07/23/2012
I kive my Yankees.  I'm a Rays season ticket holder and love baseball.  The Yankees run the best organization in sports.  Proud to be a fan.
09:37 PM on 07/23/2012
We've got Ichiro!!!! I wish we could have held on to Wise.  Rats.
photo
lonesometx
Please don't take me out with a drone, Pres. O
09:29 PM on 07/01/2012
"... imagine if this had cost the Yankees the game and they lost a post-season berth by that margin..."

And by the same token, imagine if this had caused the Yankees to win the game and they got a post-season berth by that margin.

Wrong either way.

But remember, this is the league that turned a blind eye to PEDs for years and years. The league, the players and the owners will stop the cheating soon.

They are just waiting for me to hit a game winning grand slam in the bottom of the ninth at PNC Park in the seventh game of the World Series.

(Despite the fact that I have been stepping in the bucket since I was seven years old...)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
adcan49
Lone Star Liberal
03:32 AM on 07/01/2012
Awesome! Mr. Kaplan, I, too, have often pondered about the "classyness" (is that a word?) of the Yankees. I admire Jeter, but the incident you mentioned was beneath him. Chris Stewart's comment about it being "necessary" seals the deal for me. The Yanks are dirty.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
garganto
10:41 PM on 07/05/2012
LOOK WHO'S TALKIN!!! What about that Nolan Ryan prank??
Goaheadmakemyday
Tennessee tuxedo will not fail
02:23 PM on 06/30/2012
Get real I am a Red Sox fan but really its the ump. that messed up not the player.
Soccer players dont call handballs on themselves, Tennis players dont argue a call for the other player.

You want people who call penitlys on themselves, well other then golf you are out of luck.

NASCAR has a joke, if you aint cheating you aint trying.
photo
PowerPridePinstripes
27 and Counting!
09:52 AM on 07/23/2012
Hey, F&F -- even if you're a Red Sox fan! (lol)!
jhNY
Mercy.
01:18 PM on 06/30/2012
"Sportsmanship and honesty are not longer in play'-- and in nearly all professional sports, for all time, never have been. Gamesmanship, however, and taking advantage of every situation whenever possible, has always been. Sorry to see this all seems to be news to the author, who must not have spent very much time actually watching actual professional sports.

Young athletes , if they are of professional caliber, will not be taught anything by such behavior as the author cites, as they have long ago internalized the actual doings of actual sports professionals throughout history and the world-- without being told.

But if we're really serious about explaining the questionable doings of adults to children, then try this one: chiseling on taxes, specious deductions and padded expenses. These lessons would be of great practical value to millions upon millions more as they negotiate through life, but I'm guessing, if the lesson is meant to be conveyed by example, the example will teach us, most often, a lot about: hypocrisy.
08:10 AM on 06/30/2012
This is so obvious. When you have not caught the ball, you tell the ump that you have not caught the ball. Simple stuff, really.
08:06 AM on 07/02/2012
You are so naive.......how did the Kool Aid taste by the way!!! Go Yanks.
photo
PowerPridePinstripes
27 and Counting!
09:54 AM on 07/23/2012
Exactly... some of these 'moral' couch umpires are hilarious!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JohnHopwood2
Happiness is a 9 letter word
01:24 AM on 06/30/2012
Every athlete cheats or gets an edge. It is part of sports and has nothing to do with the Yankees. Yankee haters really need to get a life.
11:13 AM on 06/30/2012
So, what Roger Clemens did to restore his fastball after people were lighting him up, that was ok? What Jason Giambi did to make himself an elite power hitter instead of a second tier power hitter which he naturally was, that is ok? What ARod, who was an elite player on all levels already, did so he could make a run at the most hallowed records in baseball and obtain the largest contract in history, that was ok?
09:50 AM on 07/01/2012
Clemens, Blue Jays; Giambi, A's; A-Rod, Rangers.

JohnHopwood is right, it has nothing to do with the Yankees.
photo
njo2351
how many super bowls?? i lost count
03:08 PM on 06/30/2012
" every athlete cheats or gets an edge. it's part of sports..."......you might want to think about that statement................
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JohnHopwood2
Happiness is a 9 letter word
09:40 PM on 06/30/2012
huh?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
adcan49
Lone Star Liberal
03:41 AM on 07/01/2012
Right on! Cheating is NEVER a part of sports. Or life. JohnHopwood 2 must be a republican ;)