More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Martha and Scott: A Gender Blender in the New Internet Order

What's Your Reaction:

What happened Martha? You were so close. Who could ever have imagined that you weren't going to casually waltz into Teddy's seat for the great Commonwealth of Massachusetts? We can't help but wonder: would everything have been different if you had posed nude for Playboy in your youth?

We bring this up only because, just like you were the last woman in Massachusetts to know that Curt Schilling played for the Red Sox, we were the last to see Scott's sexy Cosmo-in-the-buff-pix.

2010-01-20-ScottBrownnew3.jpg

We have become serious Facebook stalkers, fascinated by its power ever since the fan page for our new book exploded from 500 nearly a month ago to nearly 30,000 today. We've been following Scott Brown's relentless status updates and tweets driving the voters of the great Commonwealth to meet and greet him in the flesh.

Anyway, it was during our stalking that we found Scott's photo spread right there in all its attractive glory on his Fan page. (If Martha had posed for Playboy, and if she did have a robust fan page, we wonder: what would have happened had she posted her pix?)

And that is the problem. Why didn't Martha have a robust fan page? Where was her noisy twitter campaign? The power of the Internet to create community, stimulate demand and drive action was proved by the Obama campaign. Why did the Coakley camp completely miss this line of action?

Bring on the finger pointing, the Democratic soul searching, Republican rejoicing. We wonder--could something besides anger, frustration, job loss, and healthy care rebellion be going on here? How is it possible that Massachusetts, despite its liberal legacy, cannot find a way to elect a woman?

Gender bending in politics and business is nothing new. It's no easy feat for a woman to make it to the top in either arena. It's a paradox inside a paradox. Women who want to compete in politics and business often find the need to 'out man' the men, to hide the softer side: warmth, kindness, vulnerability. Voters want candidates whom they imagine would join them for tea, who are "real," down-to-earth. Yet paradoxically, a woman who shows too much vulnerability or warmth isn't seen as being up for the job (unless of course she packs a gun and skins her own kill).

Brown trotted out his kids (including the American Idol runner-up local celeb Ayla), he drove around in an old truck, wore a zippered jacket. He bared more than his flesh-- he bared his humanity. In the end, Martha Coakley never was able to peddle the relatability and warmth that Scott Brown mustered for his campaign.

The other paradox of our times played out in this election: the loneliness and alienation of an ever-connected but isolated world. The huge growth of social networking is fueled by this desire to connect. But the Democratic candidate missed the point online and in person--she failed to realize that voters want to reach out and touch someone..

Read more at www.bitchesonabudget.com

 
 
 

Follow Rosalyn Hoffman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BitchesonBudget

 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:38 PM on 01/24/2010
Elections are binary - A or B; yes or no. Each voter makes a choice based on many factors- which one he or she cares about can't be surmised by adding up the totals. That said, I submit that this election had nothing to do with gender, and very little to do with the strengths, history or skills of the candidates. It was all about the direction the country has been drifting towards over the past year, and the binary choice of let it proceed or make it stop.
12:43 AM on 01/22/2010
There is such a double standard in this country and it really pisses me off. Do you think a woman who had posed nude would have EVER been elected to a political office? Hell no, she would've been torn to shreds and discredited at every turn. Vanessa Williams lost her Miss America crown when her nude photos went public, yet Scott Brown gets a Senate seat--something infinitely more important than a beauty pageant crown--after he posed nude. Where the hell were his "conservative" values then, huh? The injustice of this double standard stinks!
06:50 PM on 01/20/2010
If the woman candidate had a photoshoot like this in her past, the Democrats would have stepped in and told her not to run. Did the Republicans even bat an eyelash about a man's nude shoot? For all the talk about what this election meant, I do hope there is more attention focused on the gender inequalities. Hope this article is seen and distributed far and wide. It sure does give everyone something to think about.
08:02 PM on 01/20/2010
This is to the point. And, it is so hard for a woman to strike the right pose. Too tough and she's mean spirited, too warm not tough enough. Men can pose in the nude and no one thinks twice. God forbid a woman shows too much skin, let alone too much emotion!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
J Jill
03:33 PM on 01/20/2010
This was a stealth win. I think it's amazing that he was able to have this cheesecake spread on his Fan page and there was no outrage! If a woman had a photo shoot like that in her past she would have never been elected dog catcher. It does speak to the bad campaign not only Coakley ran but the Democrats. This is a WAKE UP CALL to the Obama administration. If uber-liberal Massachusetts can elect the ilk of Scott Brown what does it say about the midterm elections.

Oh and by the way. Wake up world social media and Facebook are taking over.
03:18 PM on 01/20/2010
I completely agree with your analysis and the general sentiment that the race was Coakley's to lose and she did. A little voice in the back of my mind wonders whether a man with the exact same profile as Coakley in every other way would have lost.
11:53 AM on 01/20/2010
Excellent piece. Disappointed in Mass.
12:41 AM on 01/20/2010
Very true about the challenges women face as candidates. Amazing pics of the newly elected Senator. Let's hope he understands that he did not win by a landslide - that he needs to work in a bipartisan manner. As he said, this is the people's seat - he needs to represent the people of Massachusetts and not the extremists that dominate the Republican Party in Washington.
12:09 AM on 01/20/2010
Great commentary--right on the money!

Coakley croaked her own campaign by being out-of-touch with both her own humanity and the pulse of the public. Yes, they want a senator they can believe in but they also want someone who they can relate to on some level. She was a strident advocate of an orthodox Democratic party line in a state that is unpredicable at best and a distant, cold candidate followng Teddy K. Brown saw that, and we heard the voices of his daughters (who really knows Ayla from Idol anyway?) speaking about their dad, his presence online and a resonating message about fundamental American worries about money and security. Pay attention, Mr. President!