iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rose Marie Berger

GET UPDATES FROM Rose Marie Berger
 

Todd Akin, There's a Christian Seminary That Wants Its Diploma Back

Posted: 08/23/2012 8:40 am

Every time I hear references to Rep. Todd Akin's crazy talk related to violence against women, I get nauseous. It's a visceral physical response. And I don't think I'm alone in this.

One in every six of my sisters and one in 33 of my brothers in the U.S. have been the victims of an attempted or completed aggressive forced violent sexual act.

And gaining insight into the background of Rep. Akin's muddled pseudo-science, such as is explored in "The Roots of Rep. Todd Akin's "Legitimate" Rape Remarks" by Tim Townsend and Blythe Bernhard doesn't help me. It actually makes it worse. It risks reinforcing a set of propaganda under the guise of exposing it.

I have a hard time understanding how Akin, who is the son of a Presbyterian minister, has a Master of Divinity from a prominent Christian seminary and is an active member of a Presyterian Church of America congregation, could debase himself in such a way that he has no qualms about putting his political agenda ahead of the truth and well being of women. As Christians, don't we hold ourselves to a higher standard?

No doubt he doesn't see it that way.

No doubt he is profoundly uncomfortable with the moral gray areas that some women must navigate when it comes to rape, pregancy, abortion, STDs, morning-after pills, permenant gynecological damage, psychological trauma, spiritual desperation, loss of control, complete loss of safety, trust, intimacy and all the others dangerous and shifting decisions that a rape victim must make. No doubt he believes that what is best for him is best for all. We may have to agree to disagree. But one thing that's perfectly clear is: Mr. Akin should end his career as a public servant.

At least 51 percent of the voting public deserve much better than what he has to offer.

In 1984, Sojourners magazine ran a provocative set of articles on violence against women. In "Our Lives At Stake," Ginny Soley writes about cultures the promote violence:

[University of Pennsylvania anthropologist Peggy Reeves Sanday] is one of the first researchers to ever study the phenomenon of rape within cultures. Using reliable cross-cultural information, she found material relevant to the study of rape in 95 cultures. Of the 95 studied, 47 perent were virtually rape-free, 17 percent were rape-prone (displaying a high incidence of rape), and the remaining 36 percent indicated some incidence of rape.

Her research suggests that the incidence of rape in a society depends on the status of women, the values that govern relationships, and the attitudes and behaviors taught to children. She concludes that rape is not a biological drive within men, but stems from a conditioned response taught within social environments.

Sanday's findings indicate that in societies with little or no rape, women are respected and influential in all areas of life -- public and private. The religions in those cultures emphasize the importance of women and include female deities, and women take an active role in religious life and ritual. The people tend to live together in cooperative structures, with both women and men involved in decision making. Fertility, nurturance, and children are regarded highly within these cultures, and little distinction is made between men's and women's work.

On the other hand, Sanday's research indicates that in societies that have a high incidence of rape, women take little or no part in decision making or religious rituals, and men have private political and religious gatherings that exclude women. Men tend to stay aloof from child rearing in these cultures and demean what is considered women's work. Boys and girls are segregated early on into different forms of play; boys are encouraged to be tough, competitive, and aggressive.

Among the groups with a high incidence of rape, a belief in a male supreme being as the source of life is usually found. And sexual conquest is a ritualized part of courtship and marriage.


Sadly, we still live in a society that is toxic for women and girls. Even more sadly, there are still Christians who sacralize misogyny and maintain a criminal ignorance about women's reproductive health and the levels of sexual violence in the United States.

I was gratified to see that Mr. Akin's alma mater Covenant Theological Seminary issued a disclaimer:

Covenant Theological Seminary has never taught, and in no way affirms, that the female body is capable of preventing pregnancy caused by rape. Covenant Theological Seminary affirms that rape, in all its forms, is wicked. In regard to rape against women, men, and children, we believe that the Gospel calls us to show love, compassion, and support for the victims and their families. In all circumstances surrounding the trauma, we must name the evil, seek justice, and care for those affected by such horrendous acts. In instances of rape against women that result in pregnancy, this includes caring for the unborn child as well.

No doubt they'd be glad for Mr. Akins to turn in his diploma.

As a pro-life Catholic feminist, I hold all life as sacred. Most Americans can agree to "make abortion rare," to make it the exception, rather than the rule. Let's stop fighting about it.

What if we called a voluntary moratorium on the public use of the word "abortion" for the remainder of the year? Would any wisdom arise from our silence?

Rose Marie Berger, author of ' Who Killed Donte Manning?' is a Catholic peace activist and poet. She blogs at rosemarieberger.com.

 
 
 

Follow Rose Marie Berger on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RMBerger

FOLLOW RELIGION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pl1224
lifelonglefty
01:28 AM on 08/28/2012
An interesting article--gives the reader much to think about. I wonder if anyone has ever researched the correlation between a society's incidence of rape and its economic system--that is, between a system of laissez-faire capitalism which values individualism, competition, and domination over a more cooperative, communitarian economic model. I suspect women are much more valued in the latter, rather than the former for a variety of reasons, some fairly obvious, others not so much. I guess it's also worth noting that the most competitively capitalistic systems are also predominantly Christian. Kind of makes one wonder if Christians in highly capitalistic societies ever bother to read the New Testament. (Way deep into irony here . . . .)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:56 PM on 08/27/2012
I wish wisdom would arise from it - we are so caught in the rhetoric and the narrow vision that engaging in actual dialogue, with the welfare of all as the goal. Great commentary.
04:17 PM on 08/27/2012
I liked everything about this article except for the last line. Abortion is not a dirty word to make secret an act that is (still) legal in the United States. It would be wonderful if it never had to be implemented, but it is sometimes necessary for the health and medical welfare of a woman who finds herself with a pregnancy SHE has decided she cannot go through with. In consultation with her doctor and a clergy person if she wishes, she should have access to safe methods of ending the pregnancy. Akin and his like are not doctors. They should not be making laws on the medical wellbeing of people in the first place! I don't care what his religious beliefs are, but they should NOT be infringing on the rights of anyone else, especially a right that is legal. A pregnant woman's rights trump his (and the fetus) everytime.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cindbird
Using my head for something other than a hat rack.
12:16 AM on 08/28/2012
I don't think her suggestion was to make the word abortion a dirty or secret word. I think the idea is that if we stop talking about abortion, and start talking about the VICTIM then the victim doesn't get lost in the rhetoric.
11:20 AM on 08/27/2012
Why would anybody be surprised that a person whose education apparently primarily is religious embraces non-sense and pseudo-science left and right? I'm pretty sure the religious, of every stripe, basically have to accept all kinds of hogwash on no evidence to maintain their "faith." Why should issues of women's reproductive health be any different?
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
11:16 AM on 08/27/2012
A Master of Divinity degree seems to hold the same value as the Ph.D. obtained by Marcus Bachmann in his correspondence course.
photo
farmilyman
everything is illusion
11:00 AM on 08/27/2012
Any religion that has become republicanized is no longer valid.
09:02 AM on 08/27/2012
One of the reasons of the mainline denominational decline is that many of their seminaries have adopted a theology that goes against the basic teachings of the Bible. Creation, salvation, physical resurrection of Jesus, virgin birth, miracles, even the Ten Commandments are no longer held to be true in many seminaries. No wonder that many churches are going to independent, Bible teaching seminaries to find pastors. Even the basic creeds are are not followed. The students at these seminaries should have their tuition refunded.
11:22 AM on 08/27/2012
I agree with your last sentence. Anybody who pays to be stupified with the non-sense sold to them in any seminary "school" has been taken for a ride and deserves to have their money refunded to them. Why not pay for an education in things that are real and become something?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cindbird
Using my head for something other than a hat rack.
12:20 AM on 08/28/2012
No, the decline of the mainline denominations is that they no longer even pretend to be places that follow the teachings of Jesus. They have become more about what's on your back than what's in your heart. They are more about how much you put in the collection plate than what you put into the heart and soul. When you call for help, and they refuse to help, when you have a need they refuse to fill, when you look for acceptance and find only rejection, what do you expect to happen?
10:54 AM on 08/29/2012
Todd Akin's denomination, the Presbyterian Church in America, broke off from the mainline Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) over, among other issues, the ordination of women.