iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Santhosh Mathew, PhD

GET UPDATES FROM Santhosh Mathew, PhD
 

"Sorry Aliens," We Have a Big Deficit

Posted: 08/04/11 01:50 PM ET

Our longstanding desire to become part of a galactic empire by establishing contact with alien kingdoms received a setback. The reason is, as one might expect, not the lack of aliens or their potential habitats in the universe but the cash crunch.

With all due respect, I choose to say that we must avoid broadcasting the news about our budget shortfall (print is fine but no radio telecasting).The extraterrestrials might pick up these signals and would lose any interest on this planet. Who on the universe would come to a planet that has no money for even intergalactic communication and whose resources are being depleted by the members of the same primary gene pool?

Last April,the SETI Institute (the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence), announced "Federal and state funding cutbacks for operations of U.C. Berkeley's Hat Creek Radio Observatory (HCRO) force hibernation of Allen Telescope Array."

The Allen Telescope Array
(ATA) opened in 2007, which is named after the Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen for his donations to the project has been a dream come true for the SETI researchers. The Hat Creek facility needs 1.5 million a year for its operations and another million for other costs. The radio telescopes at this facility scan the signals from potential alien civilizations.

Two of my friends had an informal chat over coffee on the same topic. One of them, a social democrat, grumbled that this amount is not even a small fraction of the money we spent every year for pet pampering in this country. The other one, a Biologist, retorted by paraphrasing Charles Darwin, "The alien hunters are like blind men in the dark room looking for a black cat which is not there." (Originally, this was Darwin's comment on Mathematicians)

Why, when it comes to SETI, everyone has either simple solutions or serious criticism,though this research has some ardent supporters? SETI astronomers had to do lot of public relations work in the past to keep going with their investigation. Even the U.S. congress has slashed all the funding for SETI back in 1993, though it was lifted recently.

The goal of SETI is not to look for any primitive life forms, which might be plenty even in our galactic neighborhood. SETI looks for developed civilizations, at least comparable to us or further advanced, that can communicate with radio signals the way we do.

In contrast to other branches of scientific researches, alien hunt is subjected to a lot of scrutiny and ridiculous comments. Some cynics even say we should accelerate the alien hunt, not for scientific reasons, to begin a tie-up simply for financial reasons. The aliens might be a better credit-rated crowd than the earthlings, and probably, we could borrow at a lower rate and increase our debt ceiling, all assuming they are recession proof.

Generally, people tempt to think research efforts such as the particle hunt, definitely much more expensive, is something we cannot ignore and must be continued. However, one must admit that most of these experiments pursue particles that may not even exist, including the God particle (Higgs Boson). While these scientific pursuits are easily accepted and admired, the SETI, strangely, has a lower ranking in public perception.

Whether it is alien hunt or particle hunt, I have no doubt in my mind that serious science is generated in these efforts, and the spin-off benefits from these experiments fine-tune the technology we use now and would enable us to master new science.

A section of our populace, it appears, has developed some sort of resistance to any basic science research. Too many alien movies and popular UFOlogists have, perhaps, contributed to this indifferent attitude, and these folks, possibly, are doing their best to discredit the serious scientific pursuits. It is time to reach out to other countries ,and engage them on collaborative large-scale alien search experiments similar to LHC (Large Hadrons Collidern) experiment, for economic and other reasons. This might ease our financial responsibility for such ventures.

Searching extraterrestrial beings is, perhaps, just the culmination of human imagination and ingenuity. But, as the late Carl Sagan, a strong advocate of this scientific search said, "Imagination will often carry us to worlds that never were. But without it we go nowhere."

 
Our longstanding desire to become part of a galactic empire by establishing contact with alien kingdoms received a setback. The reason is, as one might expect, not the lack of aliens or their potentia...
Our longstanding desire to become part of a galactic empire by establishing contact with alien kingdoms received a setback. The reason is, as one might expect, not the lack of aliens or their potentia...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Dredd
Our government is a wartocracy.
02:06 PM on 08/16/2011
More and more scientists are following in the footsteps of Jastrow, who rejected biological evolution as the origin of humans, choosing instead microbes from space being deposited here by comets and the like, then evolving into humans.

We are composed of non-human microbe cells over human cells by a factor of 10. Plus 99% of our genes are microbes, not human cells.

Who are the aliens?

http://blogdredd.blogspot.com/2011/08/tiniest-scientists-are-very-old-2.html
photo
Dredd
Our government is a wartocracy.
11:47 AM on 08/06/2011
The Dawn mission has "dug up" some monumental evidence. Space exploration is a must.

http://blogdredd.blogspot.com/2011/08/weekend-rebel-science-excursion-7.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CarlIII
Liberal Virginian living in Remlap Alabama
11:38 AM on 08/06/2011
If it had a 1% chance of picking up a radio signal from another planet. Then they could raise the funding from private sources. The odds are really astronomical {pardon the pun}. My wife and I were members of the Planetary Society and followed SETI very closely. After all these years {40 or so} we have found nothing ..Nada. I'm surprised it didn't happen already. The Bush wars and tax cuts have bankrupted our country. NASA is lucky to still even exist.
photo
WILLIEMOJORISIN
USN 1978-1984 God willin and the crick don't rise.
02:08 PM on 08/07/2011
Are you refering to the Bush tax cuts to the rich that Obama just extended ? how about the 30,000 more troops he sent to Afgan ? and now we're involved in Lybia , we are almost bankrupt because politicians (on both sides) sent all our jobs overseas.
02:32 PM on 08/05/2011
Having imagination may lead to a conclusion that everyone has imagination. However, it is becoming clearer every day that imagination is no more common than common sense.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:04 PM on 08/04/2011
The most amazing part of the Alan Telescope debacle is the number of SETI stations that remain in operation in the US.

How many do you think are still listening?

20?
50?
150?
1,500?

The answer is *much* worse that you think.

There is exactly ONE station still on the air in the US. I know because that station is my own.
www.SETI.Net The only SETI station in the US and only one of three ON EARTH.

One station and its run by one old guy that build it himself. If that isn't the dimmest damn thing for a civilization to do I don't know what it would be!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeff Rosenbury
I love all people -- in the abstract
09:51 AM on 08/16/2011
Thanks for doing your part to make the world a smarter place. How are things in San Diego?
photo
RevSpaminator
Life is too short to drink light beer!
03:30 PM on 08/04/2011
How years have we been broadcasting radio signals into space? Have any of those lousy freeloader aliens signed up for a subscription? Have any of them come down here and bought any laundry detergent or automobiles? Have they even bothered to pick up a radio transmitter and say hello back? No wonder congress pulled the plug on SETI, it doesn't contribute to the welfare of their wealthy corporate donors.
photo
straightuptalker
What ever happened to common sense?
05:54 AM on 08/13/2011
Cool response, laughable but true. It doesn't contribute to the welfare of anybody, but why are we so hell-bent on pursuing this type of science-fiction?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeff Rosenbury
I love all people -- in the abstract
09:58 AM on 08/16/2011
It was the same in the days of Lot. People were eating and drinking, buying and selling, planting and building. But the day Lot left Sodom, fire and sulfur rained down from heaven and destroyed them all.

It will be just like this on the day the Son of Man is revealed. On that day no one who is on the housetop, with possessions inside, should go down to get them. -- Jesus Christ.

There's more to life than buying and selling.