More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sasa Milosevic

GET UPDATES FROM Sasa Milosevic

Should Women be Allowed on Holy Mount Athos?

Posted: 07/12/11 02:41 PM ET

Tradition holds Mount Athos, a spiritual oasis on the Grecian peninsula of Halkidiki, was a gift of God to the Virgin Mary. Her picture is present throughout the Holy Mount, but she is the only woman the 1,700 Athonian monks living in 20 monasteries will see on the land.

For more than 1,000 years, in respect of a monastic tradition separating the sexes to allow them to focus on their spiritual tasks, women have been banned from Mount Athos. Time may no longer be on their side.

A growing number of Orthodox women are protesting the ban, asserting what they say is their theological and political rights to share in the mystical fruits of this symbol of Orthodox spirituality.

From Facebook groups to political lobbying, they and allies for women's rights have been seeking to overturn the ban. Social conditions, including a growing movement in Western Christianity for sexual equality in churches, have changed dramatically since 1046 when Byzantine Emperor Constantine Monomahos issued a "Chryssobull," or edict, prohibiting all females from entering the peninsula, advocates say.

"Catholic and Orthodox churches still refuse to recognize that men and women are of equal value and deserve equal respect and equal rights," says Anna Karamanou, a member of the Facebook group Allow Women to Visit Mount Athos.

Nausicaa M. Jackson, another group member says all the faithful should have access to the spiritual gifts of Mount Athos.

"Mount Athos is a place for every believer, and women have a very special and privileged place by God through the Virgin Mary, so what Mount Athos is today, is an anti-Christian place!"

For the monks, however, the ban on woman is an issue of faith, not sexism.

Dositej Hilandarac, a monk from the Athonian monastery Hilandar, explains that it's not a problem with women per se, but the fact that Athos monasteries function in accordance with Avaton rule (meaning literally: entry is prohibited), which strictly forbids females from entering the Holy Mount.

Throughout Christian history, many religious communities of men and women have chosen to live apart to focus their lives on their spiritual mission. The monks' lives of devotion to God include the practices of scarcity and asceticism as well as virginity, seeking to remove any barriers, including sexual desire, to their pursuit of spiritual peace and holiness.

The all-male monasteries enable the monks to engage in the continuous practice of prayer and repentance that helps purify their souls of worldly desires, and focus on growing in faith, says Monk Seraphim.

Those seeking to overturn the ban have won important victories.

A European Parliament Resolution in 2003 condemned the ban as a violation of sexual equality and citizens' freedom of movement.

Professor Eleni Chontodolou, a Greek feminist, says it is a civil as well as a religious issue

"I pay taxes for these monasteries and their restorations, and I am equally human being as you (men) and I do not see reason of not being allowed to get in Mount Athos," she says.

But the "Avaton" prohibition ratified by the Greek Parliament in 1926 remains in place. Some government officials say the monks have legal rights as an autonomous region of Greece, often comparing it to the Vatican as an identical state with autonomous status.

Modern women are permitted to enjoy the "womanless land" only if they take tour boats. Even then, they are limited to approaching no more than 500 meters from the Athos coast.

Mt. Athos has opened its doors to women (and children) in wars and epidemics. In 1347, Serbian Queen Jelena Kantakuzin sought refuge there from the Great Plague. Serbian princess Mara Brankovic got permission to visit some monasteries in gratitude for her donation.

There is one way even the monks agree the ban could be overturned. That is when creation is restored to the paradise of the Garden of Eden before Adam and Eve defied God, said one Orthodox leader on the Holy Mount.

The prohibition "could be abolished if human beings could be as simple as they were before the original sin," said Athonian Father Christos Mitsios. "If this was the case, not even God could enforce an Avaton."

Follow Sasa Milosevic on Twitter @journalist92.

 

Follow Sasa Milosevic on Twitter: www.twitter.com/journalist92

Tradition holds Mount Athos, a spiritual oasis on the Grecian peninsula of Halkidiki, was a gift of God to the Virgin Mary. Her picture is present throughout the Holy Mount, but she is the only woman ...
Tradition holds Mount Athos, a spiritual oasis on the Grecian peninsula of Halkidiki, was a gift of God to the Virgin Mary. Her picture is present throughout the Holy Mount, but she is the only woman ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 266
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
06:30 PM on 07/19/2011
Nobody here understands the issue except one person I've seen. Mary is the holiest of all women and no other woman is allowed there to show respect to her. They aren't allowed there to show respect to a WOMAN, not a man. It isn't about women being less or "sinners" or something. The Bible clearly states that all people all equal so let's stop the notion that Christianity is unfair somehow to women. And the taxpayer funding isn't even an issue. My tax dollars go to women-only women's shelters, why isn't that wrong? I fund loans for that only blacks can take advantage of, why isn't that wrong? There are plenty examples of government money being spent where there isn't equal access. That's a bad and false argument. Lets see you libs get upset over some of that? Again we see the anti-religion agenda. I'm horrified to see other Christians who don't know the history of their own faith. Maybe 1 out of a 100 American Protestants could explain how Christianity developed to where it currently is. That's sad and it shows in their understanding of today's world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sasa Milosevic
Impression without expression is depression
07:07 AM on 07/24/2011
You are indeed one of the rare people who understood the the essence of question of woman on Mt. Athos. The monks' rules are very rigorous, but I am sure they do not want to make any sexual discrimination, but to express highest respect to Virgin Mary. And I observe that Mt. Athos is "female Holy place" because everythinm that exist there keep memories on woman - Virgin Mary....
08:32 PM on 07/17/2011
"We were driven underground by the zeal of many to overturn tradition. Our houses of worship closed, we prayed during the midnight watch in our cells in darkness waiting for another time. And the faithful, old women and some aged men, perilously entered our remaining sanctuaries to pray and honor our saints. Some of us fled to the wilderness to live in caves hidden by white birch trees witnessing salvation through nature. It is there where we wait in hope that our hallowed traditions will once again resurrect in the hearts of the young who will seek us and bring us back to the houses of worship where they may learn our ancient ways.

How did this deluge begin? You might ask. From what source did this scourge upon our institutions and way of life emerge? It commenced with the misplaced notion that equality is borne at the expense of tradition.

But even here in the forests, our lives are acts of penance. One day we will climb out of this darkness forgiving those who have sent us here and cast our burdens to the seas of time as we rebuild our lives in the example of our desert fathers."

Service in Seclusion: Living Quietly with Hope
Starets Pachomius of Ushetikov
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cliffhammond
Onward through the fog!
02:05 AM on 07/17/2011
If we let them win this one, pretty soon they'll be demanding to vote and smoke cigarettes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:10 PM on 07/16/2011
I fully support equal rights for women. However, Christian women must choose between exercising their equal right to live in Mount Athos, or their belief in the Bible, which clearly says that men are superior to women.

(I love how the religious tie themselves up into knots.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cliffhammond
Onward through the fog!
02:35 AM on 07/17/2011
"If anyone demands of thee your cloak, give unto them your tunic as well. And if they demand your Athos, give unto them Prime Minister Papandreou and his minister of finance."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:42 AM on 07/17/2011
Heh!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Willie12345
10:04 AM on 07/15/2011
Women won't like it there at all. There isn't a woman's rest room anywhere and there is no plans to build any. Sorry, girls.
photo
pphhrogg
domestic clown goddess
10:57 PM on 07/14/2011
Women should be allowed everywhere MEN are allowed. 'Nuff said.
photo
Down in FL
It's all about the density of states
10:26 PM on 07/15/2011
Men's bathrooms?
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
10:39 PM on 07/14/2011
I believe in equality, but if men are not allowed entry into a convent, then why do women have to enter a monastery? Or a monastic peninsula?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cliffhammond
Onward through the fog!
02:11 AM on 07/17/2011
Well, somebody has to cook and make the beds.
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
09:25 AM on 07/22/2011
I cook simple stuff like noodles and leave my bed as it is. The monks can do the same.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
elblanc0
Whatever good things we build end up building us.
08:14 PM on 07/14/2011
Is this really a question we should be asking in the 21st century? Should a woman be allowed to set foot on some peninsula in Macedonia? Sihce when did the tradition of some sexist monks trump basic human rights and common decency? I think Lilith Fair should book a reunion festival at the top of Mount Athos. I'll bring my daughters.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
02:31 AM on 07/15/2011
You do not understand the purpose of monastic life to make the proposal you do.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
elblanc0
Whatever good things we build end up building us.
11:11 AM on 07/16/2011
Even if I had a complete knowledge of the purpose and traditions of what it means to be a monk on Mt. Athos, it would not change my opinion. The exclusion of any group from anywhere based on archaic superstitious tradition should not be tolerated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Untainted Love
03:19 AM on 07/16/2011
The ladies have their own versions of this... My church's music group once performed for some cloistered nuns in Orange County. These women weren't even allowed to make eye contact with our group, so they sat behind these huge screens the whole time.

According to my uncle (who's been a RCC priest for 60 years) the celebacy requirement has nothing to do with spiritual development (is anything worse than a horny celibate?) and everything to do with the church's unwillingness to financially support the wives and families of married priests. There are also inheritance and other issues, all dealing with MONEY.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
09:37 AM on 07/16/2011
Monastic asceticism has practiced celibacy since the foundations of monasticism. Go read the life of the 4th century St. Anthony of the Desert if you don't believe me. There has long been the order of virgins, which was a type of monasticism. And there is a long tradition in the monastic literature of how to healthily live as a celibate person. One of the important ways of doing this was to engage in ascetic fasting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
04:53 PM on 07/16/2011
I don't know why your response didn't post. It was a completely reasonable point.

Anyone who becomes a monastic, does so free willingly. Of course they realize that it is a life of asceticism, which includes celibacy. --that is the path they have chosen. No one is forcing it on them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tiare75
09:51 AM on 07/14/2011
From what I understand about the monks on Mt. Athos they are not just living apart from women. Many never leave the island once they get there. They live apart from their extended family. Many take vows of silence. They are essentially living apart from everyone, not just women. If this is what it takes for them to communicate with God, let them have it. I don't feel the need to live apart from the world to be closer to God...but if this is what they need I'm OK with it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sasa Milosevic
Impression without expression is depression
10:47 AM on 07/14/2011
Yes, Tiare, you understand well. You would be great monk because you fulfil one of the basic monastic rules in Orthodoxy: do not condemn anyone. First see in your soul...."
photo
Jericho the Red
moderate before it was called liberal.
07:36 PM on 07/14/2011
except the gift was to Mary,, not men
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
joynerz
Commentor # 297,597,634
07:21 AM on 07/14/2011
The fact that religious documents have shown men are right in their leadership, and women should submit, shows the insecurities of men. It's the need for a man to feel power over the woman. Show's who really wrote the religious documents of this world: insecure men, as are many. No, I'm a man and feel a woman has every right a man does. How dare we men feel so insecure as to demand to feel superior to anyone or anything. The fact that we have the appendage and they have the receptacle is meaningless in who is more and who is less.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
03:15 PM on 07/14/2011
You have never read anything of the lives of Orthodox saints to believe that religious writings show men to be the only ones who have acquired holiness or who have been leaders in their pursuit of God.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
joynerz
Commentor # 297,597,634
07:14 AM on 07/14/2011
Men have always dictated the rights of women. Always will. It's called EGO.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sasa Milosevic
Impression without expression is depression
03:57 AM on 07/14/2011
The vast majority of those who commented the article felt insulted primarily due to money they giving as tax-payers.... According to them the money is the crucial reason why women should allow to enter the Holy Mount... I do not think so... There are more important things than taxes....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
03:17 PM on 07/14/2011
As an Orthodox woman, the goal of my journey as an Orthodox is not a travel destination. Rather, it is the acquisition of the holiness of God.
photo
AntithiChrist
Rhymes with Grist
01:47 AM on 07/14/2011
"The prohibition "could be abolished if human beings could be as simple as they were before the original sin," said Athonian Father Christos Mitsios."

Never met an adamant Fox News viewer, I take it.
photo
AntithiChrist
Rhymes with Grist
01:45 AM on 07/14/2011
"There is one way even the monks agree the ban could be overturned. That is when creation is restored to the paradise of the Garden of Eden before Adam and Eve defied God, said one Orthodox leader on the Holy Mount."

Never been to Disneyland, evidently.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cliffhammond
Onward through the fog!
02:29 AM on 07/17/2011
You apparently do not realize that, now that we've taken it from the Iraqis, the Garden of Eden will soon be reopened to the select few to be determined in the 2012 Minnesota primaries.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dadw5boys
Disabled Vietnam Vet
12:23 AM on 07/14/2011
Your using American Tax Dollars to pay for Welfare, the digging and Weapons for Israel !

American Woman darn well better be able to vist if they choose !

Don't like it ? Stop taking the money and pay back all the Billions you already took.

Refuse anymore FEDERAL RESERVE FINACING OF BUILDINGS on the West Bank !!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
03:35 PM on 07/14/2011
Mount Athos is an autonomous state and does not receive American Tax dollars. You might have your Orthodox mixed up here.