iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sayu Bhojwani

GET UPDATES FROM Sayu Bhojwani
 

5 Questions on Immigration We Wish Jim Lehrer Would Ask

Posted: 10/01/2012 3:42 pm

On Oct. 3, President Obama is set to take the stage with Governor Romney to engage in the first presidential debate. While pundits are busily inflating the debates' importance and predicting which of the candidates will "win," we at The New American Leaders Project are wondering why immigration is not on the agenda, particularly when the debate in held in Colorado, a swing state where Latino voters could well decide the outcome. Like all voters, Asians and Latinos consistently place the economy on top of their list of concerns and the economy is rightfully the focus of the debate. Nevertheless, immigration is a top concern for immigrant communities and is inextricably tied to the economy. In recognition of this, we're proposing five immigration questions that Jim Lehrer, Wednesday's debate moderator, probably won't ask, but should:

1. Our current immigration system is broken. We have record numbers of undocumented immigrants living in the shadows. We have an antiquated visa system that makes it nearly impossible for smart, hard-working immigrants to come to the U.S., and all but sends foreign-born graduates from top American universities home or to a competitor country. Please outline the top three immigration policy changes you believe we need today to ensure a vibrant, competitive future for our economy.

2. President Obama, you have deported more immigrants during your tenure in office than any president before you. Governor Romney, you have advocated attrition through enforcement and "self-deportation" as effective methods of removing undocumented immigrants from this country. Yet both of you elevate the family as a keystone American institution. How can you break apart families by deporting children or parents of mixed-status families? Would you endorse a more humane policy solution that keeps families together?

3. President Obama, your administration has overseen an expansion of secure communities, which has been widely criticized as harming the safety of immigrant communities. Governor Romney, during the primary campaign you came out in support of Arizona's SB1070 and the rights of states to enforce immigration laws and coordinate with federal agencies to deport undocumented immigrants. Do you both believe that local law enforcement should enforce the country's immigration laws despite the fact that the Supreme Court severely curtailed states' rights to establish immigration law in their ruling this year?

4. Studies have shown that negative media and elite frames of immigrants focus overwhelmingly on crime and illegality and drive negative and damaging stereotypes of many immigrant groups in the country. Widely known undocumented journalist Jose Antonio Vargas has begun a campaign to stop major media outlets from using the word 'illegal' to refer to immigrants because it criminalizes people, rather than their actions. What are your thoughts on the use of this word and would you be willing to use the more accurate "unauthorized" or "undocumented" to describe immigrants who are in this country without proper documentation?

5. President Obama, you promised to pass comprehensive immigration reform in your first year in office and you failed on that promise. Governor Romney, you said during your recent Univision interview that you would offer a "permanent solution" to a broken immigration system. Yet after the failure of comprehensive reform in 2006 and 2007, Congress remains a huge obstacle. What can you do to ensure that Congress fixes the current broken immigration system when you're elected to office?

As in past years, the presidential debates on Wednesday are not designed to provide concrete or detailed policy proposals. But, at the least, we want to see more from our two presidential candidates than pandering to voters with baseline moral arguments around fairness and justice. We want leadership on immigration, not simply because it is of concern to immigrant communities but also because it is intertwined with almost every social, economic, and political issue and is key to America's future. Furthermore, a sensible immigration system uplifts a core American value of respect for diversity and holds together families, which both candidates and their parties agree is important. This October, we hope Jim Lehrer, Candy Crowley, or Bob Schieffer will hold firm on an issue that is core to our economic success and our long term viability in an increasingly competitive world.

 

Follow Sayu Bhojwani on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@SayuBhojwani

FOLLOW POLITICS
On Oct. 3, President Obama is set to take the stage with Governor Romney to engage in the first presidential debate. While pundits are busily inflating the debates' importance and predicting which of ...
On Oct. 3, President Obama is set to take the stage with Governor Romney to engage in the first presidential debate. While pundits are busily inflating the debates' importance and predicting which of ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 86
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
12:21 AM on 10/04/2012
Work Visa - imperial visas
The Work Visa is the most common visa for foreign nationals in order to live and work in the UK. In 2008, all work permit applications were classed under UK Work Visa
Keywords: -
Work Visa
Contact Us:-
Location: 2nd Floor Cygnet House,
12-14 Sydenham Road Croydon
Surrey CR0 2EE
Telephone: +44 0203 627 4777
Email: info@imperialvisas.com
http://imperialvisas.com/work-visa.html
photo
Hoodooman
Non-Aggression Principle
04:29 PM on 10/02/2012
We have more than two presidential candidates.

"

1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Simplify Legal Immigration

LEGAL IMMIGRATION STRENGTHENS AMERICA'S ECONOMY AND THE social fabric. It will also strengthen our relationship with our southern neighbor Mexico.

It should be easier for a potential immigrant to get a work visa. Potential immigrants should pass a background check, and then be issued a Social Security card, which would allow them to pay income, payroll, and all other taxes workers pay.
There should be a two-year grace period for illegal immigrants to attain work visas so they can continue contributing to America and begin taking part in American society openly.
Immigrants with temporary work visas should have access to the normal procedures for gaining permanent status and citizenship, and should be able to bring their families to the U.S. after demonstrating ability to support them financially.

2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tackle Illegal Immigration

REAL BORDER SECURITY MEANS KNOWING WHO IS coming here and why.

Legalizing marijuana will reduce border violence and illegal immigration significantly, decreasing the U.S.-Mexican drug trade by 70 percent. Without a monopoly on the marijuana trade, Mexican drug cartels will have vastly diminished incentives to violate U.S. law and risk capture.
Streamline the legal immigration process to reduce illegal immigration and allow the U.S. to know who enters the country and for what reasons.
Enforce a 'one strike, you're out' rule for immigrants who circumvent the streamlined work visa process." - Gary Johnson
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BeasTT
01:15 PM on 10/02/2012
The system is not broken Sayu, I went through it myself, and it worked out just fine. I paid the fees, waited patiently, and was rewarded with citizenship.

Stop whining like a baby, every country has immigration laws, what is more telling is the measure of the person who is willing (or not) to go through it legally.

It's a test, it's supposed to be tough...because the tough is what makes it great.

If it were easy, the reward would not be as sweet.
05:46 PM on 10/02/2012
Well said BeasTT. Wishing you all the best.
photo
iuriggs6
Sure thing. Shoot, Timmy.
09:11 PM on 10/02/2012
Well done.
photo
Liberals Are Intolerant
fiscal conservative, social libertarian
12:48 PM on 10/02/2012
What Obama needs to be asked is: How is it constitutional for you to decree the mass legalization of millions of illegal immigrants, without the authorization of Congress?
10:56 AM on 10/02/2012
Seriously, #4 is a question to be posed to the leader of the free world. I'm sure the candidates could be asked much more serious questions - such as. Do you pronounce it Tomaytoe or Tomahtoe?

Illegal is illegal. Seriously - what a Sarah Palin type of question.
12:52 PM on 10/02/2012
You don't understand, she doesn't think anyone is illegal, she thinks everyone in the world has the right to immigration here.
07:58 AM on 10/02/2012
There are answers but nobody in power will ever talk about them or support what the American People want. At least Obama has stood fast on enforcement.

If you can't shut the door why bother talking about reform ? Their flooding the streets as we type. If you can't shut the door reform of any kind is amnesty.

Immigration limits are set for a reason. An American We The People reason. I'm sorry you were born in a sh***y country. If the US Government decided to invade and take temporary control over the economy and law enforcement, I'd support it. But until then you gotta grow some hair on your pair and fix your home.
12:54 PM on 10/02/2012
"Stood fast on enforcement"?? What?? ICE agents are suing Obama because of his illegal amnesty and NON-enforcement!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rothomaha
The Truth will out
07:52 AM on 10/02/2012
And why are they NOT designed for hard answers? At the minimum, we should be granted the respect to hear each analyze the current situation around a particular issue and identify causes. Without such an analysis, who can tell whether a proposed solution is rational? This should be done without finger-pointing and accusation, and if it isn't achieved, the moderator must clearly and unequivocally say so, and go on to the opponent. These men are not products of virgin births and do not walk on water - they are human beings, with flaws like all the rest of us. That said, let's hear from each how they think a "bad situation" came about, in the context of historical background and world events, not "you didn't do this, or you didn't do that"! That is BS and pap for the masses.
photo
franchise2m
I'm platinum mad!
05:14 PM on 10/02/2012
The ironic thing is that the USA has always called itself the "Land of Opportunity"...so is it any wonder that so many people would want to immigrate here?

The real problems come from the immigrants countries of origin...In the case of Mexico we are a relatively prosperous country next to a country full of drug violence, corruption, income disparity, and poor economic opportunity...

A much more effective road to "Immigration Reform" would be to for the nations the people emmigrated from to reform themselves...Maybe this is really a foreign policy issue as well as a domestic one
06:57 AM on 10/02/2012
The only important question on immigration is:

There are more than 100 million third world residents who want to immigrant to the U.S. How many of them would you keep out?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alitoo
10:53 AM on 10/02/2012
Actually, 5 BILLION people live in countries poorer than Mexico and most would come here if they could. How many of THEM should we admit? And on what basis? After all, someone with no skills is basically fungible with every other person with no skills.
12:56 PM on 10/02/2012
Actually it's more like 2 billion:
http://www.gallup.com/poll/124028/700-Million-Worldwide-Desire-Migrate-Permanently.aspx
700 million adults plus their children.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Black Rhino
03:30 AM on 10/02/2012
A ridiculous list of questions from a clear supporter of illegal migration, into the US. Pathetic.

This is why there's no real debate on immigration - both sides live in fantasy land.
photo
Snake1994
Snakebite!
01:44 AM on 10/02/2012
The only reason our immigration system is broken is because illegal aliens have broken it. And that's the bottom line.
12:28 AM on 10/02/2012
You missed a question:
6. How can you get millions of unemployed Americans back to work if you are importing millions of new foreign workers, aka, immigrants each year?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alitoo
10:55 AM on 10/02/2012
And 7. How can you decrease poverty in this country if you keep importing millions of unskilled uneducated people who will never pay enough in taxes to cover the cost of the services they use? Importing even millions of such people, moreover, wouldn't even put a dent in poverty in the rest of the world but would make the Americans who subsidize these immigrants far poorer. It already has.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Latikia
Wear the mask long enough and it becomes the face.
12:21 AM on 10/02/2012
"...we at The New American Leaders Project are wondering why immigration is not on the agenda..."

Probably because neither candidate (or Party for that matter) wants to address immigration in any substantial way, shape or form...but then neither candidate (or Party) particularly wants to alienate (forgive the pun) a huge block of potential voters (with the possible exception of Romney/Ryan).

pity the moderators have already signed non-disclosure type contracts with the debate sponsors.
12:03 AM on 10/02/2012
Five Illegal Immigration questions for Jim Lehr:

1) Our current immigration system is not being adequately enforced. Why? Would bringing all the troops back from Afghanistan and Korea help in any way?

2) President Obama, since you took office your administration has repatriated over a million unauthorized foreign nationals back to their homelands. Don't you think you could double or triple that number? Why play small ball, Mr. President?

3) President Obama and Governor Romney - when will Secure Communities be fully operational in every town, city and suburb? Will you make a pledge tonight to deny federal funds to any and all cities that fail or refuse to comply with this humane and extremely popular tool in stopping illegal immigration?

4) President Obama, why is it that unlawfully present foreign nationals who are calling for the dismantling of our immigration system aren't being apprehended and repatriated to their homelands? Jose Antonio Vargas is laughing at you right now. How does that make you feel?

5) President Obama, you promised so-called Comprehensive Immigration Reform when you last ran for office. Why would you put the needs and wants of foreign nationals who break our laws everyday over the needs of American citizens who are unemployed and seeing their life savings reduced to zero? What does that say about your loyalty to this nation? Do you even believe in the concept of national sovereignty at all?
02:44 PM on 10/02/2012
If only the media would ask the hard questions. Sadly the entire election process is an illusion to make us think were are in control.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
inthedesert
Those who never question will fall for anything.
06:56 PM on 10/03/2012
SO faved.
photo
Fotstain
Partying like it's 1999 since 1976
12:00 AM on 10/02/2012
#1 Why did you decide to come here illegally and think you could live here indefinably?
#2 Why are you in a foreign county where you are not welcome?
#3 Why don't you go back to your country of origin and than apply for a visa to enter the USA legally
#4Why don't you take the same boat that took you here illegally and go back to your country of origin.
#5 Get the f- out of my country
11:06 PM on 10/01/2012
This is a bunch of hogwash! Here's a better plan: 1. Have manadatory e-verify for current and future employees. Have an speedy appeals process so that anyone who doesn't pass e-verify has the right to appeal that and get any incorrect results corrected. 2. Have strick and sure sanctions against any and all employers whose employees don't pass e-verify of at least $20,000 per employee per day. This will work to keep the illegals from stealing jobs and government benefits and committing crimes. They will have no choice but to self-deport and get to their home countries the same way that they got to the US--plane, train, automobile, walking, running, swimming, etc. Problem solved.

PS. When you commit a crime, you go to jail and you separate your family from you. When you are an illegal immigrant, you are free to take your family with you when you are deported and you separate your family (if that be the case) by your bad/illegal/criminal behavior! (Which behavior, by the way, includes stealing jobs, resources and opportunities from Americans!)