Huff Post Review: Up (2009)

Up
2009
102 minutes
Rated PG

by Scott Mendelson

It is one of the bitter realities of our existence; that all of our relationships must end with the pain and sadness that comes with death. All of my relationships, friends and family alike, will end on the same bitter note. No matter how good of a father I am to my child, I cannot escape the fact that the final memories that she will have of me will be the circumstances and feelings associated with watching me die. And no matter how long my marriage lasts, in all likelihood the last thing we will do for each other is hold each other's hands as the first one of us passes on to leave the other behind to pick up the pieces. I can only hope that the lasting impressions made while still on this Earth are strong enough to overpower the more painful memories forged right at the end in the minds of the people who must eventually bury me.

Up is the best animated film since Meet the Robinsons. Both films are unabashedly sentimental fables about the broad strokes of life. Meet the Robinsons dealt with a young orphan boy who learns to accept the hardships that early life can bring, so that he can 'keep moving forward'. Up is about a man at the end of his life, with seemingly nothing to live for except to look backwards with fondness and regret. At the risk of scaring off would-be viewers, it is the most achingly sad romantic fable since Sarah Polley's Away From Her. And while I wouldn't recommend it as a casual date movie, and I'm not sure how it will play as a family film (since the kids might wonder why mommy and daddy are crying), it is a gloriously beautiful adventure film that will likely remain the finest film of 2009.

A token amount of plot - Elderly Carl (Ed Asner) has just buried Elle: his wife, his childhood sweetheart and his best friend. Waking up without any purpose to his life, he simply sits on his couch, mourning both his loss and the one adventure that his wife and he never got around to taking (life kept getting in the way). After circumstances put both his house and his freedom in jeopardy, Carl decides to live out Elle's childhood dream (traveling to South America and living in a house on the mountaintop next to the theoretical Paradise Falls). Using leftover balloons from his days as a balloon peddler, Carl sets sail as his entire home floats into the sky. As he embarks on one final adventure to keep a promise, he soon discovers that a young 'wilderness explorer scout' has accidentally stowed himself away on the front porch.

That's all you get. I wouldn't dream of revealing what Carl encounters on his journey. It offers up its visual pleasures without explanation and without apology, knowing that it has earned the right to its own imagination. The film is surprisingly simple, with a relatively straight-ahead narrative that takes only a few twists along the way. As Carl and the young boy bond through their mutual grief (young Russell is mourning the apparent divorce of his parents and the absence of his father), Carl desperately tries to get his house to the falls before the helium runs out. Despite the melancholy undertone, this is, similar to the last Indiana Jones picture, an often rousing story about a man nearing the end of his days discovering that he still has a life left to live.

While the film is basically about death and the fragility of life, Up is every bit as funny and exciting as any other Pixar film. The 'talking dog' (via electronic collar) revealed in the previews is just the beginning of the glorious discoveries that are in store. The animation is, of course, astonishing, with rich bright colors and vivid details around every corner. The score by Michael Giacchino is every bit as rousing as his work on The Incredibles. And the vocal work (mostly filled with actual voice over artists, save for Delroy Lindo and Christopher Plummer) is splendidly low-key and naturalistic and always at the service of the story (Ed Asner is wonderful per usual, although most of Carl's best moments are silent ones). Even if kids don't get the heavy dramatics at play, there are plenty of laugh-out-loud gags and gee-whiz action scenes to keep them enthralled.

Up is a wonderfully touching, openly dark, and surprisingly surreal adventure story. To call the picture 'sentimental' would be an understatement, as it is often an ode to sentimentality. It uses wordless montage and the power of silence every bit as effectively as Wall-E and it's often just as action-packed as The Incredibles. It is a beautiful tale, gloriously told with rich and vivid characters, eye-popping visual splendor and it acknowledges the complete despairs and utter joys of life in one fell swoop. It is the finest film of 2009 and one of the finest animated films I've seen in my lifetime. Up is just that good.

Grade: A+

Comments

[gavottes]

How can you say that Carl was sitting on his couch?

There was no couch. It was chair, Scott!!

The most memorable two chairs ever in film.

(Don't listen to Scott and his couch.)

[jsgaetano]

"Up" was one of the best films I've seen in a long time. Every emotially touching.

And I recommend seeing it while you can see it in 3d. It's really interesting, I can see why so many directors are working in 3d now.

[Winning09]

I saw it on Saturday.

It's really a sweet, wonderful little movie.

[rob2007]

I remember a thousand years ago when "finest film" accolades went to actual humans performing in actual films instead of animated subjects created digitally.

[CanuckInLyon]

"one of the finest animated films I've seen in my lifetime"

Here "in my lifetime" is redundant, while the sentence as a whole strongly conveys a sense that the reviewer should deepen his experience of the long, rich history of animated films.

[trprincess]

I adore animated movies and have watched a large number of the greatest animated movies ever made. I saw "Up" on Friday, and it ranks right up there with the best I've seen. It's imaginative, funny, warm and smart. Perhaps you should try seeing the movie yourself before suggesting the critic in question isn't allowed to believe it's wonderful because he just can't have seen all the other wonderful animated movies, as if that has anything to do with the quality of this one.

[Scott Mendelson - Huffpost Blogger]

I'm not as completely caught up on Hayao Miyazaki as I should be (I'll wait until my daughter is old enough to enjoy them and then go on a crash course), but I've seen more than enough animation in my relatively short life. But yes, the sentence was a bit redundant, I just wanted to write something other than 'one of the best animated movies of all time/EVER'.

[oz4009]

Just saw the movie with my 17 yo daughter and my 48 yo friend. We balled, we laughed, we clapped, we sighed and we applauded. This was the first time that I was not the only one in the theater that was audible. The couple sitting next to us, also in their 40s, were there without a kid in tow and I could hear us express emotion almost on cue. BEST movie of the year.

[ubeman]

This Post is the BEST post of 2009. No need to read any others for the remaining 7 months, as it has been settled.

[bluguy8]

no , not the best of this year. probably that best from last year too . An amazing piece of art & film making

[EvieEve]

I loved this movie. Bawled like a baby.

[HekmabaJuzimax]

I did not watch this movie, so I will not be posting a comment.

[llisa]

Snort (ooops, tea up my nose)

[SaddieMcCall]

I saw it today with my husband. He was reluctant to see a cartoon, but quickly changed his tune during the movie. We both LOVED it!

[Ponderus]

PIXAR is technologically advanced and dramatically p'e'd'e's't'r'i'a'n. They n,e,v,e,r take chances with their stories or characters, because they don't want to offend the American b'o'u'r'g'e'o'i's'i'e, those folks who see nothing v,u,l,g,a,r or s,h,a,l,l,o,w about SUVs, shopping malls, the D'i's'n'e'y channel, D'a'n'c'i'n'g with the Stars, American I,d,o,l, F'o'x' News, H,a,r,r,y P'o't't'e'r or the g'h'o'u'l p'o'r'n offered by the B,r'u,c'k,h'e,i'm,'e,r TV empire.

[WhatTheHolyHeck]

Yes, I imagine it would be infinitely preferable for all of us to be pretentious snobs.

Thank you, Prometheus, for bringing us light.

[Ponderus]

The pretense is all PIXAR'S: Webster's: "1 an attempt to make something that is not the case appear true."

Human beings are not as cut and dried, cliched and predictable as P presents them. Many films for children and fantasies have presented complex characters. Try "White Mane" or "Dreamchild" -- imagination AND depth. PIXAR cannot allow complexity. Complexity challenges convention. PIXAR is aesthetically conventional, middlebrow, and bland.

So you dig all the other things on the list?

And any time I can bring a little sunshine into your humdrum life, WTHH, you just let me know.

Must run -- time to feed the eagle.

[z78pb45]

I saw this with my 10 year old nephew and we both agreed that Cars and Wall-E were a cut above (and according my nephew, Bolt the best of all). It's standard Pixar so if you love what they usually do, you'll love this. The artists, animators, and sound technicians are incredibly talented people. The plot and voice-overs are predictable but at least they don't overshadow the production.

[Go5000K]

I saw Up today....

Deep.

[Herbert Ragan]

Sawit for the second time today, this time in 2D... and I highly recomend seeing it that way, the colors just jump out atyou in 2D, more so then when watching it in 3D, with those stupid sunglasses.

A glorious film no matter how you see it. But so much better in 2D.

[JoeGdr]

Good point. I have yet to see the movie and I was debating whether I should go the 2D or the 3D route. I'll watch it in 3D if I like the movie the first time around.