More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Scott Mendelson

GET UPDATES FROM Scott Mendelson

Weekend Box Office: Summer 2011 Ends With a Hurricane, Kneecapping Three New Releases (Colombiana, Don't Be Afraid of the Dark, Our Idiot Brother) and All Holdovers

Posted: 08/28/11 06:13 PM ET

It's a tough thing to accurately gauge how well a movie would have done if not for an unforeseen variable, such as in this case a massive hurricane that threatened much of the East Coast of the country and shut down hundreds of movie theaters over the weekend.  As such, it feels a little unfair to pick on movies that didn't open all-that well, since who is to say how they would have performed under normal conditions.  So, for the sake of not kicking people while they are down, this summary will be focused on the positive developments over the weekend.

While it was not number one this weekend, Sony's EuroCorp pick-up Colombiana opened with $10.3 million for a solid second place.  The Luc Besson-produced vehicle (which I'll hopefully be seeing tonight) would likely have opened between $12-15 million without the storm issues.  But even that smaller number is worth noting.  Point being, the film confirms the genuine bank-ability of Zoe Saldana, who co-starred in Avatar and Star Trek in 2009 and had supporting roles in The Losers, Takers, and Death at a Funeral in 2010.  Saldana's face was pretty much the entire poster, and the marketing campaign centered entirely around her.  This is the biggest opening weekend I can recall for a female-led pure action picture (as opposed to sci-fi/horror) that isn't based on a comic book or a video game. Even with the diminished numbers, this is still a larger opening weekend than the far-more high-profile Conan the Barbarian, Fright Night, and One Day from last weekend.  Point being, there is indeed a market for action pictures starring minorities and/or women. Maybe the market isn't big enough to support $100 million+ productions, but as long as the budget is reasonable (in this case, $40 million), we damn-sure should be seeing more of this kind of thing.  The film earned an A- from Cinemascore and played 65 percent over-25 and 57 percent female.

The actual first place finisher was once again The Help, which dropped just 30 percent even in the face of weather issues and some... negative publicity (Why said criticisms are not about the movie itself -- HERE).  The picture is tracking ahead of even Bridesmaids, which had $85 million after its third weekend compared to the current $96 million cumulative for The Help.  It is already poised to be one of the biggest-grossing pure-dramas released in any summer season ever, and $150 million is currently all-but guaranteed, with $170-$190 million possible depending on how long it can hold onto theaters.  Of note, this weekend marks the first time that I can recall that the top two films of the weekend box office both centered around minority actors, let alone women of color (feel free to point out if I'm forgetting something... ).

Anyway, the other two openers were small performers that were probably never going to break out.  Don't Be Afraid of the Dark was a small-budget remake of a 1970s TV movie that had no real stars (Guy Pierce and Katie Holmes are not exactly box office dynamos).  The film's main selling point, the fact that Guillermo del Toro was producing, didn't count for much, and it's just another reason why Universal was right to cancel the $150 million R-rated In the Mountain Of Madness earlier this year.  The film had the double-edged sword of being a film intended for a PG-13 that nonetheless got stuck with an R purely for intensity.  So you lose the younger audiences who flock to PG-13 horror, and you lose the gore-hounds who knew there would be little onscreen violence and/or graphic bloodshed.  As such, $8.6 million for the $25 million production was not a rousing figure, but it could have been a lot worse.
The last major opener was Our Idiot Brother, the Weinstein Company comedy starring Paul Rudd, Elizabeth Banks, Zooey Deschanel, Emily Mortimer, and Rashida Jones.  Kudos for the Weintsteins for giving this apparently somewhat arty comedy a mainstream release, as this is just the kind of star vehicle that has inexplicably been regulated to the arthouse over the last few years (I'm probably seeing it tomorrow).  And even though the film opened with just $6.8 million, it has already nearly-outgrossed Ceder Rapids and Cyrus (two such victims of the above trend) in just three days, meaning that you really can make a profit for a semi-wide release in cases such as this.  In holdover news, all of last weekend's releases dropped like stones, as did Final Destination 5 (-68 percent, $37 million cumulative) which would have happened without the storm.  Rise of the Planet of the Apes now has $148 million, which means it will soon be Fox's first $150 million domestic performer since Avatar. Bad Teacher may fail to hit $100 million stateside, but it has crossed $200 million worldwide, which is uber-impressive.  With all the talk about the death of star power, Cameron Diaz powered this one all-by herself.  In the realm of 'bad news here, good news overseas', the two big animated films of summer are firing on all cylinders overseas.  Kung Fu Panda 2 sits with $625 million worldwide, meaning it will surpass the first film's $630 million worldwide gross.  Cars 2 may be the first Pixar film to not cross $200 million domestic since A Bug's Life in 1998, but the film has $709 million thus far worldwide, meaning it will soon pass the $731 million worldwide gross of Up to become Pixar's third-biggest worldwide grosser, behind Finding Nemo ($867 million) and Toy Story 3 ($1 billion).

That's it for this weekend and for summer 2011.  The Fall season starts on Wednesday with the release of The Debt, and continues this Friday with the absolutely moronic head-to-head scheduling that is Shark Night 3D vs. Apollo 18.  Anyway, check out the first of a few summer recap articles (Part I: The Moments That Mattered)  HERE and look out for more in the coming week.
 

Follow Scott Mendelson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ScottMendelson

It's a tough thing to accurately gauge how well a movie would have done if not for an unforeseen variable, such as in thi...
It's a tough thing to accurately gauge how well a movie would have done if not for an unforeseen variable, such as in thi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:26 PM on 08/29/2011
Am i the only person in America who doesn't go to see a movie based solely on who directed it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skantea
A Resource Based Economy
07:06 AM on 08/30/2011
Nope, you're still part of the majority on that one.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:57 AM on 08/30/2011
I would think the only director whose name alone opens a movie is Steven Spielberg.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
02:29 PM on 08/29/2011
I caught THE GUARD on Saturday just before the rain kicked in. It could've been better. Waiting on BURKE & HARE as well as MONEYBALL.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Scott Mendelson
Film critic/pundit for Mendelson's Memos, Valley S
05:32 PM on 08/29/2011
Been meaning to catch The Guard, but it's not playing close enough for a casual 'drive to a theater while the new baby is napping' viewing. May have to wait for DVD on that one, but as long as I can see it by year's end (for theoretical inclusion in the year-end wrap-up stuff), I shall be happy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank day
Republican = FAIL
01:47 PM on 08/29/2011
I'm looking forward to Don't be Afraid when it comes to DVD.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robjh1
That Job Just Isn't Into You!
11:51 AM on 08/29/2011
Zoe Saldana is a beautiful actress!
photo
Halsey
"There is a price to pay for speaking the truth. T
11:20 AM on 08/29/2011
Colombiana is not my genre of choice, yet, of course I'll be happy when another woman can lead and carry an action film(as Scott corrected himself..kudos by the way for willingness to self-correct!) with Salt. As a fairly aware person, while the Colombian cartels are still dangerous and deadly, the Mexican cartels that moved in after Escobar died make Colombina look like pikers. I'd prefer, if one is making a violent revenge movie, something that dealt with say the death of the many women near the Texas border. I mean, frankly, Colombian cartels doen't even make the news these days; not with heads hanging over the pristine streets of Cuernavaca. Wasn't Zoe in Drumline?
I believe the woman can act and DO hope she moves back to meaty drama. I MUST toss in Jovanich (sp is way off) but she has a following with her many, even direct to DVD, action films.
I can't remember how The Color Purple did do but know it did not start a trend.
Thanks for good article Scott! Always enjoy them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sethj8888
The GOP Motto: Vote For Us And Nobody Gets Hurt
09:33 AM on 08/29/2011
I'm torn about Columbiana ...on the one hand, yes, it's nice to see a film headlined by a woman of color without the obligatory White Male Partner / Bad Guy Who Gets Equal Billing.

On the other hand, from what I've seen, it's just another loud, idiotic, revenge flick that should hardly rate a straight-to-DVD release. Didn't we already see this in that movie with The Rock last year, and with "Machete"??

I guess it's nice to see that a black/latino woman can succeed with My-Guns-Provide-All-The-Plotting-This-Movie-Needs genre picture as well as Nic Cage or Jason Statham. Hopefully she's headlining better films in the future.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Scott Mendelson
Film critic/pundit for Mendelson's Memos, Valley S
05:35 PM on 08/29/2011
It's not loud (as a result of the cutting, seemingly muted sound effects for the PG-13) and it's only occasionally idiotic. I wouldn't blame anyone waiting for DVD, but I did enjoy the film more than I expected to. As for Machete, that film was at least a fiery political polemic using the classic exploitation film template. And if you're referring to The Rock's Faster, that's actually much more of a character drama than an action thriller. It's pretty decent, with fine work by Dwayne Johnson and Billy Bob Thornton. Again, there is some action, but it's more a drama with violence.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Frustrated in PA
I am not frustrated, I am NOW disgusted
09:31 AM on 08/29/2011
Luc Besson makes watchable, entertaining action movies. Columbiana, similiar to Taken, seems to be low-key, doesn't need the huge marketing push and relies on charisma of Saldana, like Taken relied on Liam Neeson. While I love Neeson, he is not a HUGE action powerhouse before Taken. He always delivered good performances but was an "Actor" not action star. Even his turn Ra's al Ghul wasn't a "huge" action move. Nolan's 1st Batman relied on acting.

The dialogue may be a bit cheesy and the story a bit hokey.....it is the way the actor delivers it that makes it worth watching. Like Neeson with Taken, I believe Saldana can do the same.

And women should go see Columbiana instead of that silly Help movie.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjredder
08:18 AM on 08/29/2011
Kill Bill, Vol. 1, 2003.
01:42 AM on 08/29/2011
I'm confused about the marketing for Colombiana...the trailerand advertising looked totally generic without trumpeting Saldana as the star of Avatar (or even her supporting role in Star Trek) so unless you are a film nerd up on your genre casting the legions of Avatar fans who loved Saldana in these breakout roles would likely be clueless why this woman was even getting her own feature film
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
12:57 AM on 08/29/2011
As for yours truly, I saw "Sarah's Key", starring Kristin Scott Thomas as a woman looking for a Holocaust survivor.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Scott Mendelson
Film critic/pundit for Mendelson's Memos, Valley S
05:34 PM on 08/28/2011
Apologies that my paragrahph spacing was not 'honored' during publication. But the omission of Angelina Jolie's Salt as the biggest opening weekend for an original female action picture is my error.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Scott Mendelson
Film critic/pundit for Mendelson's Memos, Valley S
07:52 PM on 08/28/2011
Also, the page I checked no longer lists Cars 2 as $709 million worldwide, but rather $521 million worldwide. I do not know if the error was theirs or mine, but I will assume it is mine and note the error accordingly. Also, updated figures - Kung Fu Panda 2 has surpassed Kung Fu Panda, grossing $637 million worldwide. If Huff Post would let me edit my own work like they used to, I could just quietly update this stuff...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ekstatik
Granfalloon-free!
08:17 AM on 08/29/2011
"this is just the kind of star vehicle that has inexplicably been regulated to the arthouse over the last few years" Of course you mean "relegated" not "regulated".

Regulation is BAD.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jcwtts1
Elections have consequences
10:37 PM on 08/28/2011
Hollywood, like many industries, chases successful formulas in future biz. That's why Bridesmaids will spawn R rated female comedies... but other than Tyler Perry, do minority success stories spawn other minority movies? Or do they get co-opted, appropriated, and exploited by the traditional Hollywood machine?

What I mean is that while you love The Help, other's don't. But it is bankable. So do we get another generation of blacksplotation movies where the only characters are mammies, maids, hookers, and pimps? Or, because of other successful movies, Columbiana, Jumping the Broom at 6.6. cost 37 mil domestic, do we see a branching out of the Hollywood standard minority film. See, and this is why people can't just take The Help as a stand alone movie, the bankablity of it makes it more dangerous than if it were a flop. Movies chase trends as often as they create them. What I expect to see is an uptick of movies that are condescending, "surpemicist porn," like the help where well meaning white people save black people or empower them. All, of course, well meaning, but with little historical accuracy, deep thought, or true connection to the african american experience. Do yourself a favor and read the opening passage of the help, and begin to see why people are rejecting it even as white america rushes to love it.

J
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jabbaciv
So it goes.
02:08 AM on 08/29/2011
"What I expect to see is an uptick of movies that are condescend­ing, "surpemici­st porn," like the help where well meaning white people save black people or empower them."

Like "The Blind Side". Ugh.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Scott Mendelson
Film critic/pundit for Mendelson's Memos, Valley S
08:59 AM on 08/29/2011
I didn't love The Help, I liked The Help and felt that some of the criticisms against it were unrelated to its quality (or lack thereof) as a movie. And I specifically said that we should take note when Jumping the Broom does well, or when Precious does well, etc etc. I hope Colombiana's relative success (it will likely do well overseas) means we will see more of its ilk. But, Hollywood has a way of writing off any success that doesn't fit in the 'white guys or geeky boys' genre as 'flukes'.