More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sen. Russ Feingold

Sen. Russ Feingold

Posted: April 14, 2010 01:14 PM

A Timetable for Afghanistan is Key to a Broader Security Strategy

What's Your Reaction:

Today I introduced bipartisan legislation, along with Representatives Jim McGovern (D-MA) and Walter Jones (R-NC), requiring a timetable to draw down U.S. troops from Afghanistan. The legislation is one component of a comprehensive national security strategy to defeat al Qaeda and its affiliates around the world. Below are several key elements of the strategy, which include improving our intelligence capacity, pursuing al Qaeda's global network, improving the reach of our diplomats and addressing the conditions that enable al Qaeda to thrive.

Pursuing al Qaeda's Global Network

The U.S. cannot continue to jump from one perceived "central front in the war on terror" to the next, nor should we invest our resources this way. Al Qaeda, its affiliates and sympathizers will continue to look for new safe havens in places like Yemen, Somalia, North Africa and elsewhere around the globe. Rather than investing a disproportionate amount of our resources into Afghanistan, where al Qaeda now has a limited presence, we should transition to a more sustainable counter-terrorism approach for the region and shift resources to more aggressively pursue al Qaeda's global network. Ending al Qaeda's safe haven in Pakistan remains a top priority, but a massive military presence in Afghanistan won't accomplish this, and could actually contribute to further destabilization of Pakistan.

Rather than spending $100 billion in Afghanistan in one year, primarily on military operations, we should provide assistance to the people of Afghanistan to fight corruption and support the emergence of more responsive and capable government institutions that can address socioeconomic and political issues feeding instability. And we must retain a capability for targeted counterterrorism efforts, consistent with a strategy to fight al Qaeda around the world.

Improving Our Intelligence Capacity

We need better intelligence about al Qaeda and its affiliates. Conditions around the world that allow al Qaeda to operate are often apparent to State Department and other officials who gather information openly, and do not necessarily require clandestine collection of intelligence. But the information that these officials collect is not being fully integrated with the work done by the intelligence community. Unless we reform how our government collects, reports and analyzes information from around the world, we will remain a step behind al Qaeda's global network.

Improving the Reach of our Diplomats

Where U.S. diplomats have limited presence, we will we never truly understand what is going on in a country or region, and we won't be able to build relationships with the local population. We need to increase our diplomatic access to important countries and regions by, for example, establishing new embassy posts, such as in northern Nigeria.

Addressing Conditions that Enable Al Qaeda and Its Affiliates to Recruit and Operate

I support initiatives and policies to address local conditions in places like Yemen that continue to enable al Qaeda affiliates and sympathizers to recruit and operate. Congress has passed legislation I authored to develop a comprehensive stabilization and reconstruction strategy for Somalia, a nation where al Shebaab, a terrorist group with ties to al Qaeda, has grown and strengthened. Instead of seeing the fight against al Qaeda as a largely military operation, we must recognize the importance of a comprehensive, global counterterrorism strategy that emphasizes security sector reform, human rights, economic development, transparency, good governance, accountability, and the rule of law.

Cross-posted from The Hill

 

Follow Sen. Russ Feingold on Twitter: www.twitter.com/U.S. Senator fr

Today I introduced bipartisan legislation, along with Representatives Jim McGovern (D-MA) and Walter Jones (R-NC), requiring a timetable to draw down U.S. troops from Afghanistan. The legislation is o...
Today I introduced bipartisan legislation, along with Representatives Jim McGovern (D-MA) and Walter Jones (R-NC), requiring a timetable to draw down U.S. troops from Afghanistan. The legislation is o...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 87
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
01:17 PM on 04/15/2010
Al Qaeda has a limited presence in Afghanistan precisely because we invested resources there to kick them out. We must continue working to prevent their return.
We resisted the influence of theSoviet Union around the world for 40 years, waiting for it to collapse, which it eventually did. We must be willing to do the same against Islamofascism until that particular fever breaks.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:34 PM on 04/15/2010
One thing we must never do is have a real conversation as to how Al-Qaeda got started, and what forces nourished it. And, by the way, what is it exactly? The failure to de-mythologize the situation plays right into the hands of many kinds of fascists, including Christofascists, and just plain greedy fascists.
11:07 AM on 04/16/2010
Al-Qaeda means the base. Probably was established in remote parts of Afghanistan by US help to fight USSR.

Al-Qaeda was started to oppose US because of US military base in Saudi Arabia, the holly land from Bin Laden point of view.

Saudi Arabia was also Bin Laden's homeland and US military base their might have touched his nationalism ego to some extend as well.

This is the reason he stated when he first attacked world trade center unsuccessfully in 1993 and again in 2001.
11:38 AM on 04/15/2010
Afghanistan is beyond merely containing 'al qaida' now and is an effort at stabilizing Afghanistan as a whole. That's what you need to address to get us out of there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
timm0
It's impossible to have too many malasadas.
01:16 PM on 04/15/2010
Easier said than done. Who was the last government to stabilize an appreciable amount of Afghanistan? Genghis Khan?

Maybe we just need to make a reasonably effort in a certain time frame and get out.
photo
JoeBlough
The Horror. . .The Horror. . .
11:28 AM on 04/15/2010
Apparently, Afghanistan is not a war. It’s a jobs program for unemployed civilians. It was reported yesterday that there are more U.S. civilians in Afghanistan than there are soldiers. And each civilian earns 4X the amount of a soldier’s salary, all taxpayers’ money. What’s that about? Look’s like the scope of our commitment has runaway! We will be there forever.
10:55 AM on 04/15/2010
Say, that last one's still a LONG way off, Senator Feingold, as the last 4 years or so have shown us just how 'discriminatory', 'conditional' and 'selectively applied' any Rule of Law actually is in OUR country, and seems likely to remain. The wealthy and plenty running OUR country in all three branches of government believe the law doesn't apply to them

Please propose a law, sir, to criminalize campaign contribution 'bundling' - thereby making lobbyists' jobs as 'bribery middle-men' ...obsolete.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dragucci
Caustic1
10:50 AM on 04/15/2010
I,m just sick and tired of the world expecting us to fix what is now a world problem.the senator is right we need to focus on where these looneies are hidingbut,with the help and resources of every capable country in the world.they will attack everywhere even in china someday so,it behooves all targets of this menace to support a global approach to stop them.then and only then will these clowns begin to be brought down.
10:29 AM on 04/15/2010
You libs love the word timetable nearly as much as gravitas. Yes, let's announce when we will leave. That would be a real 'game changer'.
photo
unionave
Old Codger
10:23 AM on 04/15/2010
Any effort to get Europe and North America out of Afghanistan and Iraq and at the same time end the hassle with Iran should start with a big push to eliminate the need for oil and natural gas .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vippy
Carpe Diem!
11:36 AM on 04/15/2010
As the current wars draw down the war drums with Iran are getting louder! Read in the Army Times that we will have wars until 2028, and from that I gather that it does not matter who is president.
09:41 AM on 04/15/2010
We look at wars with a star and an end, often forgetting years of very little fighting. The Iraq war had a bloodbath, millions fled as the society Sunni’s and Shea ethnically divided. Israel killed many in the latest inclusion. Massive deaths may still be occurring in African wars. General McChrystal brags of few civilian deaths, but actually Afghan President Karzai and Mullah Omar go out of their way to avoid civilian deaths. Google NY Times, with Taliban code of ethics, to get a lot of sites. Power sharing with once goon Gulbuddin Hekmatyar may not look good, but if we in the West want women in downtown Kabul the only place freedom not to wear the burka doesn’t mean free to be raped, or beaten for refusing to marry a powerful warlord, to be able not to have to wear burkas, maybe Mullah Omar will allow Hong Kong status if the US agrees to pay rent. Just ending funds set for a future date, may give al Qaeda an opportunity for revenge killings.
Karzai was arrested in a peace attempt in 1994, the Taliban’s usual response to later attempts was that they wouldn’t negotiate with a traitor. Let’s cheer, not fear, recent peace talks and the upcoming May 2, giant peace gathering. Google Western Peace Activists Ignore Real Afghan Peace Efforts.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LBA7895
08:16 AM on 04/15/2010
Two ways to eliminate the deficit:

1. Get out of Afghanistan and Iraq

2. A 1% sales tax for 5 years - call it the Bush/Cheney tax, placing the blame where it belongs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vippy
Carpe Diem!
11:37 AM on 04/15/2010
and take the cap of social security and have all pay in to the system.
08:06 AM on 04/15/2010
The US is part of the problem in Afghanistan. It should withdraw its troops and leave the future to the Afghan people. Resistance to foreign occupation is legitimate.
photo
JoeBlough
The Horror. . .The Horror. . .
12:06 PM on 04/15/2010
But it's OUR occupation and they were suppose to give us flowers. Dick said so.
07:34 AM on 04/15/2010
I'm not afraid of Al Qaeda; I'm afraid of those who would use Al Qaeda to promote their totalitarian policies.
guajiro
posted 5 minutes ago
04:17 AM on 04/15/2010
I agree with Mr. Feingold. All of his ideas are based on improving conditions with the population and this is by far the best way to steal/reduce the impact Al Qaida has. Right now in my neighborhood in Texas I see Immigration helicopters, DEA helicopters, Black ops helicopters, Coast Guard planes and helicopters, all flying 300-400 feet above the ground and a number of other military equipment meant to do who knows what in the fight against the Drug Cartels that are executing tons of people on both sides of the border, 26,000 in the last few years by one account. They are spending millions flying these helicopters day and night and are having no effect on the drug traffickers. Money would be better spent infiltrating these groups with hundreds of undercover agents who could find out from where and from whom the drugs come from. Instead we have the occasional raid complete with humvees, hovering helicopters, and assorted military equipment that I'm sure impresses those in charge of the cavalry but does nothing to those moving drugs through the area. Additionally, Mr. Feingold is right to address the socioeconomic factor. Providing the populace with jobs, machinery to farm, manufacturing equipment, etc., would go a lot further than the current method. Way to go Russ.
photo
sammyscout
Speak truth to [GOP] Ignorance
12:09 AM on 04/15/2010
I agree with Sen. Feingold, more money to the military is not the answer in Afghanistan. The Marines over there already know this and are (were under Petraues) doing great work of building partnerships with the the local leaders and community.
12:05 AM on 04/15/2010
Serious suggestion - and it will cost way less money plus win hearts and minds! (And keep them busy...)

Forget about 3 cups of tea. Let's capitulate, give them exactly what they want, and end up winning!

Let's give every single Muslim family on the planet an HDTV and their choice of Wii, Xbox, or Playstation.

That's what success ultimately looks like, so let's short circuit the whole war nation building exhausting ordeal and be done with it.

(Note to big deal think tanks and planners - use this scenario in your next asymmetric gaming exercises...)
11:37 PM on 04/14/2010
BRAVO OBAMA, he DID give us a date certain, Senator, and he'll have to stick to it if he wants re-election. Our mediocre generals call it "counter-insurgency." But like Vietnam, it ain't counterINSURGENCY, it's counterREVOLUTION. Taliban revolution fought corrupt warlords since 1997 while McCrystal is still puckered from his public kissing of Karzai's corrupt seat of authority. Afterall, Petraeus dumped Gen. McKiernnan-- replacing him with McChrystal-- because latter is his 2012 Presidential Campaign manager-- Petraeus is running a COIN presidential campaign at taxpayer's expense trying to produce another phony "surge" victory. Only one group had the cohones to declare "PETRAEUS BETRAYED US!" Dems in Congress let our mom and dad soldiers die needlessly because, like American public, they suffer from "ain't my kid dying in Petraeus surges" disconnect syndrome but can't stand defeat so are ready SEND NEIGHBOR’S SON to die trying to produce victory that promises more gas to fill-er up cheap their SUVs. Our generals' only crime is incompetence and, especially in McChrystal's case, BSing. It is the American people who are war-criminals for allowing to be done with neighbor's kid what they would never allow be done with their own kid.
03:47 AM on 04/15/2010
Well said. Your wisdom is a common sense which may never have been common, and so hence is beyond the comprehension of the American - and to a lesser extent - human psyche.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
grn1
11:07 AM on 04/15/2010
I spent nights awake plotting how to keep my son-in-law out of the war, a broken bone, a car accident, tying him up in the attic. I was an activist before bush was appointed to push this country and its military into the middle-east occupation for greed. I lost my job and friends over the madness which I expressed daily but not so freely. I know many Israeli's who do not sympathize with the aggression of their state. It was only 70% of the American people who wanted this aggression, yet nearly 100% of our representatives. They alone have the power to commit these crimes. Accountability is essential to good governance, but most still hold office and collect pay for these crimes.