iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse

GET UPDATES FROM Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse
 

Take Social Security Cuts Off the Table

Posted: 07/08/11 12:20 PM ET

Yesterday's Washington Post headline says everything you need to know:

"In debt talks, Obama offers Social Security cuts"

We, as Democrats, must stand firm against any cuts to Social Security or Medicare benefits. Period.

So I'm introducing a Senate resolution to tell the President and congressional budget negotiators on both sides of the aisle in unambiguous terms: Cuts to Social Security and Medicare benefits should be off the table.

We must unequivocally reject any cuts to Social Security or Medicare benefits. Click here to be a citizen co-sponsor of my resolution.

If Democrats can't unite to defend these hugely popular and successful programs -- and unequivocally reject Republican plans to dismantle them -- what do we stand for?

We have to hold the line. We can't keep moving the goalposts.

Cutting Social Security and Medicare benefits is bad policy when so many people are still struggling in this tough economy.

So White House negotiators need to know that they may not get the Democratic votes they need to pass a final budget deal if they slash benefits for Social Security and Medicare. They should not assume Democrats in the House and Senate will just bite the bullet and accept whatever eleventh hour deal they reach with Republicans.

I can only hope that, as one administration official has stated, yesterday's Washington Post story covering the budget negotiations "overshoots the runway" and that the White House isn't seriously considering these cuts.

But until we come together, as Democrats, to declare that cuts to Social Security and Medicare benefits should be totally off the table, we must continue to apply pressure upon all those involved in the budget negotiations, including President Obama.

To become a citizen co-sponsor of my resolution today, and unequivocally reject any cuts to Social Security or Medicare benefits, click here.

 

Follow Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SenWhitehouse

 
 
  • Comments
  • 103
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:01 AM on 07/24/2011
I'm sick of people thinking Social Security and medicare/medicaid should be cut to balance the deficit when Social Security did not contribute one penny to the financial crisis we are having now! Why not have all the uproar towards the cost of wars OR is it going to be now every time our country gets in financial problems due to the cost of war and wasteful spending they can just hurt the middle class and poor to get the money back! There is no crisis now for Social Security and things can be done to keep there from being a crisis in the future without hurting the middle class and poor! Two years without cost of living raise might not had hurt everyone but there is those it has financially hurt. If you want to stop passing along the debt to our kids then target what has caused all of this. I'm a life long Republican but nothing like the way they are now and there is no excuse for hurting the poor and middle class while everyone is so afraid of making the wealthy pay their fair share when a lot of wealthy people have said they don’t hire more people with the savings they get from all the loop holes as they invest or spend the money! So many people think we are stupid!! The Budget can be balanced without harming the middle class and poor but too many people are too greedy to go that route.
Pauline Jaing
Artist, worker, mother
09:43 PM on 07/09/2011
So if the Democrats are not our political party, that means that the VAST majoirty of Americans, working Americans, HAVE no political party at all! So we have NOTHING, no ovice, we are totally put down.

Working Families Party?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
olerealist
retired trial attorney; former member of VA abd Wa
04:14 PM on 07/09/2011
RE SS and M-care.
I have read a lot of comments here on this topic and have made a few.

First I muset stipulate that I hate Rep;ub's. (except my best friend) and love Democrats.
HOWEVER, I fear that very many of my Dem friends are living in a make believe non existent ideal world.

My friends, I fervantly wish that you (and I) would read more articles by economists of varous pursuasions and really study FACTS and statistics. I am not holding my breath but I can at least pray. The status quo is not sustainable.on taxes, loopholes or anything else. God bless Obama.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
olerealist
retired trial attorney; former member of VA abd Wa
02:08 PM on 07/09/2011
After reading the comments on this SS topic, I feel contrained to reenforce a comment I made earler

Notwithstanding that my SS pension is a vital part of my current susteance, I do believe that the current formua for computing COLA is illogically slanted toward us beneficiaries. I wish we coud afford this but we cannot. And I uderstand that the financing of SS need reforming but without benefit reduction.
On a related issue: I had cursed the Repub's. for their dogmatic stance against the silighted increase in net "revenue" to the US Treasury. Some people did not understand that, in that context, "revenue" was meant to included TAXES and included terminating some tax "loopholes".
Javalation
Laughing in a Daydream
10:10 AM on 07/09/2011
Allow Republicans to cut the programs, an I promise the malaise of 2010 will be remembered as huge support for Democrats. Many of us will see no purpose for voting if the Democrats won't stand up for the people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Auntydee
10:06 AM on 07/09/2011
Here is a link to one of the reasons BO has social security on the table. During his Town Hall Tweet BO, said he wanted to make changes to the program to make it stronger, He has said he will not cut benefits just the fraud and waste. At this point the hue and cry is BO wants get rid of social security.
The question is how many more doctors are involved in the same type of criminal behavior.

http://blogs.sacbee.com/crime/archives/2011/07/federal-jury-fi.html
09:16 AM on 07/09/2011
Yes, this is the issue. To date the Democrats continue to practise GOP equivocation but in an inept manner that is equally corrosive to governance on behalf of the citizens.

"If Democrats can't unite to defend these hugely popular and successful programs -- and unequivocally reject Republican plans to dismantle them -- what do we stand for?"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:16 AM on 07/09/2011
"If Democrats can't unite to defend these hugely popular and successful programs -- and unequivocally reject Republican plans to dismantle them -- what do we stand for?"

Senator, I have been asking myself this question for over two years now. I don't have an answer.

Sitting out the election in 2012 may be my only option. However, if, when I vote for Democrats I get Republican policy..... what good does it do to vote?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
uinsane
03:56 AM on 07/09/2011
Any cut to SS, medicare and medicate this president will lose my vote in 2012, as simple as that..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Auntydee
11:23 AM on 07/09/2011
Uinsane,
BO wants to cut fraud and waste, not benefits. He spoke about this on his town Hall tweet. .
This is an example of what BO wants to get rid of.

http://blogs.sacbee.com/crime/archives/2011/07/federal-jury-fi.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yellowjay
Social without the -ism
10:48 PM on 07/08/2011
Tonight the news showed a Mr. Boehner who was ready to use the bad news about the job stagnation to bring home his negotiation points to the people: wasteful Government spending, that awful debt ceiling, too strict regulations. From our President, I heard hardly any specific counter points. The danger of that is, that when you are giving away parts of our social safety net and the consequences are going to show later, that your opponents can use the same arguments over and over again. If, however, Obama would explain to the people that he had to give away something to avoid a disaster and if he would openly point out the bad consequences of the decisions that you were forced to make, maybe more people would understand that the propaganda of the GOP is only that and not a comprehensive wise plan.
Rest assured that not investing in the poor and the middle class will have far reaching consequences, because they are the backbone of our consumer population in America. They are spending less and less, and that is what makes the companies reluctant to hire here in America. That brings us in the downward spiral. Average companies give nothing about the debt ceiling. They are only concerned about selling their products.

Senator Whitehouse, I fully agree with you, we have to stand united to safe America from going down. Thanks.
photo
abbienormal
What hump?
09:32 PM on 07/08/2011
I have signed. Good luck, sir. Keep up the good work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fgbouman
Curmudgeon & Designer
08:13 PM on 07/08/2011
The games played with the CPI have resulted in a reduction of Social Security benifits for retirees of about twenty-five percent in real terms since 2008. Holding the line is good political theatre but if CPI calculations aren't fixed, the decline in retiree real income will continue apace.
01:12 AM on 07/09/2011
They didn't play any "games".....they just did NOT give a COLA raise for two years.

Of course, the payment stayed the same and medicare payments, food, fuel, etc. went up in price....so people getting SS lost real income (buying power).

However, it looks like the politicians are talking about changing the COLA formula to one that gives less money to people on SS than the present day formula.
07:34 PM on 07/08/2011
When are you all going to stop talking about the "middle class"? There ain't no such animal any longer.
The poor and elderly have always been with us, but the middle class has now added to those ranks. For the first time since 1940, I missed an election. I could not bellieve in Obama and all the promises he made. People ask me if I would have been better under the Republicans. Well, now we know. It only took us a couple of years to learn. Obama has no guts, he caved into the opposition on the tax using the escuse that the unemployed would not get any more benefits. And he has been caving in since. He ain't a leader, he is a gutless wonder. We ought to go to the streets as other nations are doing to get justice. It is time for us to Trow de Bums out.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NAMI
The Divine Socialist
05:08 PM on 07/08/2011
Senator White House

i have often admired what you say , and perhaps your place is in the WHITE HOUSE.

People are furious about talks of CUTS to Social Security and only LIFTING the CAP would fix whatever problem there is in the future with it.

As for the BUSH TAX CUTS were passed at a time of SURPLUS

they were RELUCTANTLY passed ONLY for 10 years ............NOW we have DEFICITS and worse DEBT.............so IT IS OBVIOUS they should NOT be extended.

The INTRANSIGANCE of the GOP is a sign of DICTATORIAL intentions
NEXT time they will ask for abolishing the minimum wage as soon as in 2012 they win the SENATE and the White House ...........you will see that i predicted right.
photo
snowballinhell
Humans have a 100% chance of extinction
05:22 AM on 07/09/2011
But Democrats are the dogs drooling to do the same if only we give them the chance. There is no iota of difference between these corrupt parities; just hubris.
04:47 PM on 07/08/2011
If you notice, Pelosi says that Social Security "reform", which means "cuts, should not be on the same table as reducing the deficit. She says it should be on a different table. They pointed out on Morning Joe this morning as to why do you think these secret meeting are going on behind closed doors? They said its because they are going against the Will of the people. They also pointed out that our politicians do not listen to the people anymore.
So just know if they appear to be backing off from cutting SS its because the democrats have said that more of them are up for re-election in 2012 and they are fearful if they go along with it, that they will lose.
I look for Obama to include it in on an agreement as they've aleady said that this will just be an agreement for cuts to come next year or after the elections and they will do it on a "separate table" to say it wasn't done to reduce the deficit.
Our politicians, at least most of them do not have the majority of the people's best interest at heart. Their main concern is if they get re-elected and whose going to line their pockets!
I voted for Obama but will not vote for him again. I feel if he can do this to the American people in his first term, what on earth is he going to do if he gets re-elected?