More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Seth Shostak

GET UPDATES FROM Seth Shostak
 

Heroic Exploration: Well and Truly Dead?

Posted: 12/20/2011 3:52 pm

It's hard to believe, but only a century ago the heroic age of exploration was easing to a close. At the bottom of the world, Robert Scott and his four companions were wearily sledging across 800 miles of ice, destined to find the tent of their triumphant rival, Roald Amundsen, flapping in the wind at the South Pole. In Peru, Hiram Bingham had just clawed his way up a tangled mountain ridge, where he beheld a lost redoubt of the Incas, Machu Picchu.

The blank spots on the globe were evaporating. But more than that, exploration as a heroic endeavor -- lonely, dangerous, and dependent on personal grit -- was largely over. Future expeditions rode to their destinations on motorized transport, and could radio the cavalry if trouble threatened.

Yes, things still went wrong, and people occasionally died. But arguably it wasn't the same. Ask your best friend to name five illustrious explorers. Dollars to Dunkies, they were all afoot before the First World War. Everything thereafter is diluted by too much knowledge, and too much technical support. In the 1930s, the story of finding King Kong Island in a south sea fog already harkened to a lost past. Most people knew that such an island didn't exist.

Of course there is still unexplored terrestrial territory, but most of it is waterlogged. Submersed secret places, such as the Challenger Deep, which today lure hi-tech adventurers like Richard Branson and James Cameron, will undoubtedly provide welcome fodder for National Geographic. In the sky, the moon and Mars continue to beckon. But billionaires in hi-tech mini-subs or elaborately trained astronauts on choreographed missions smack of puppeteering, lacking the sheen of individual triumph.

So is it all over? Is heroic exploration -- which arguably began fifty thousand years ago when our hirsute ancestors wandered out of Africa -- now only past tense? Have geographic societies become mere dinner clubs for celebrating the easy, the quirky, and the small?

Possibly. But I suspect that the banality of a world lacking in secrets -- a globe whose every acre can be perused with the click of a mouse -- is only a temporary setback. Homo sapiens' long-term legacy of setting out for terra incognita will, I think, resurface.

I'm not speaking of a Star Trek future here. Sure, massive pan-planetary federations may eventually field enormous star ships to boldly go... somewhere. And while that would be interesting and worthwhile, it doesn't strike me as heroic.

Rather, I'm picturing an intermediate era -- a moment in future history between the infancy of the space age and its presumed maturation, a half-millennium hence. A time -- possibly towards the end of this century -- when the cost of access to space will be beaten down from its current $10 thousand a pound to one percent of that (think "space elevator"). When small spacecraft, perhaps driven by solar sails, will become as plentiful and affordable as Cessna's or private yachts. When people having a taste for adventure, acclaim, or merely making some money will enter the realms just beyond Mars. Here, millions of rock islands swarm in the main belt of the asteroids. Some are no bigger than a suburban mall, and others are as large as Texas. But one in six is made of valuable metals.

Mining asteroids is a well-oiled trope of science-fiction. But someday actually doing it will make economic sense. Many of the essential metals of our society, such as platinum, copper and zinc, are rapidly becoming scarce. The asteroids might offer a replacement supply, providing the materials our descendants will need for a high quality life.

But which asteroids are worth taking apart and hauling back to Earth? That's not easy to tell. Astronomers can examine many of the larger main belt targets telescopically, but the paucity of spectral lines for identifying the solid metals means that only close-up inspection can separate the valuable digs from the dross.

And that gives the nod to prospecting. Traditionally, prospecting has been a risky and highly individualistic precursor to commercial mining. But it might once again become an activity for small groups of entrepreneurs. And like prospecting in the 19th century, reconnaissance of the asteroids would of necessity take place in an arena where trouble is likely and help is distant. Heroic stories of individual triumph and failure, set on landscapes never seen by humankind, are in the cards.

Today, with GPS and cell phones as common as crickets, it's hard to believe that anyone could hope to emulate the exploits that filled the five centuries between Vasco da Gama and Robert Scott. But just you wait: any reports on the death of heroic exploration may be premature.

 
It's hard to believe, but only a century ago the heroic age of exploration was easing to a close. At the bottom of the world, Robert Scott and his four companions were wearily sledging across 800 mil...
It's hard to believe, but only a century ago the heroic age of exploration was easing to a close. At the bottom of the world, Robert Scott and his four companions were wearily sledging across 800 mil...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:35 PM on 12/31/2011
I think that within this century when oil and jet fuel runs out, or it becomes too expensive for personal transportation, the world is going to seem like a much bigger place. I.E. exploration on earth will be exciting, dangerous, and uncertain again. Apparently there are other ways to make it more exciting now: http://www.expedition360.com/. Call me a cynic, but I think we're going to see a lot of tragic endings with commercial space travel, while space telescopes and Seti searches will accomplish the next discoveries until they run out of electricity.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
R.W. Sanders
Numerous questions, too little expertise
02:24 AM on 12/26/2011
Think Han Solo and his space ship. Seriously though, I fear that in our turtle in a shell mentality, we will deny ourselves the profit and wonders of space exploration. Face it, someone will need to be supremely confident of extreme profit in order to bring private industry into the picture. Or private explorers, if you will. The costs of prospecting are just too prohibitive.

This is a very good illustration that there are some very beneficial things that only government can and will do. For the same reason that private business doesn't build toll roads, they won't go beyond earth orbit unless there is tremendous profit to be made. But the very people who would end up profiting the most, the one percent, continue to rail against government. That is, until they need the government for their own selfish needs.

If we'd just build a couple less nukes, we could go back to the moon and prospect.
04:42 PM on 12/21/2011
I suppose, thinking along your lines, you can't call a robot a hero, but we'll still set them up on display for adoration once humans themselves have caught up with their location in outer space
08:53 AM on 12/21/2011
Just watch. Some day soon the message sent by some alien somewhere calling us wimps will reach us, and we'll have to build interstellar ships to go show them who's boss.

Then we get there and it's just a trollface painted over the landscape of a planet.
07:44 AM on 12/21/2011
It all starts now. The European Particle Physicists are regrouping next year. Hopefully America will lead by regrouping sooner and denouncing that the speed of light is a Universal Speed Limit. With CERN having new evidence (even though not validated) that 1) That matter can travel faster than the speed of light and 2) The Higgs-Boson was found at a lower mass level than previously thought. This all points to my theory that relativistic mass can only be solved for acceleration and not velocity being valid. (Debated on Space.com’s FB wall. See below for link.) It seems like it would be logical for the astrophysicists to also regroup to see what this does to our understanding of the Universe and to take a good look at any theories that are based on 1 there being a speed limit and two that relativistic mass can explain things it shouldn’t be used for. http://jetsrock.wordpress.com
02:05 AM on 12/21/2011
Personally, I like the view that Jeremy Clarkson espoused on the Top Gear Polar Special, when he and cohost James May attempted to drive to the North Pole over the frozen Arctic in a heavily modified Toyota Hiluz pickup: [paraphrasing] "It's time to make exploration easy. Who can get to the top of Everest in the most comfort?"

Also, "[w]hen small spacecraft, perhaps driven by solar sails, will become as plentiful and affordable as Cessna's or private yachts..." I was unaware that Cessna's and private yachts were plentiful or affordable to the vast majority of the planet's citizens.
11:55 PM on 12/20/2011
'Heroic [Terrestrial] Exploration Well and Truely Dead'? Hardly. Google Reid Stowe and the 1000 Days at Sea project. Reid spent over 1,100 days, non-stop at sea sailing his 70' gaff-rigged schooner around the world. He originally set out with his girlfriend, Soanya, who had to depart near Australia when she found out she was pregnant after 350+ days at sea together. Reid then sailed the remainder of the voyage single-handedly. Most of us would have difficulty sailing a boat that large around NY Harbor alone, but Reid sailed her around Cape Horn. 1000 Days is roughly how long it will take a manned flight to get to Mars. Reid proved that humans can survive, even thrive, in confined, deadly environments for prolonged periods of time. Exploration is alive and well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aarontastic
"Mr. Cain instead decided to try to provide her wi
02:57 PM on 12/21/2011
I think that testifies more to Stowe's acumen with a schooner than whether or not exploration is dead. Nothing new was discovered, and no uncharted waters were touched: it was merely an extended pleasure cruise. The key element in exploration isn't adventure per se, but rather actually going someplace *new*--Cape Horn and the waters around Australia are hardly novel destinations.
12:14 AM on 12/22/2011
I'm sure Tenzing Norgay and Sir Edmund Hillary didn't climb to the top of Everest merely to arrive at a novel destination. They did it to see if the climb was possible. Same for Sir Francis Chicester, first to sail around the world alone, with a single stop, and Sir Robin Knox-Johnson, first to sail around the world solo, non-stop. They were not going anywhere *new* either, but they were knighted for doing something extrordinary no one had ever done before. I would suggest that exploration isn't limited to geography, but rather extending the bounds of what we know to be humanly possible.
08:43 PM on 12/20/2011
Have you been asleep? What about the LHC In Cern...When the square root of 2 was first presented to the Pythagoreans..I cant remember his name,but the existance of an incommensurable number,just didn't fit with their model of the world,so they threw him off a cliff into the sea....There will always be a problem unsolved,and a goal that seems unreachable,as long as we exist..Meanwhile...I'll keep looking under rocks..
11:06 AM on 12/21/2011
But I would be careful not to confuse adventurous exploits with exploration.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aarontastic
"Mr. Cain instead decided to try to provide her wi
02:59 PM on 12/21/2011
How does that qualify as "exploration"? You sir, are aptly named =]
photo
Small Axe
Well sharp.
08:20 PM on 12/20/2011
Can I suggest the cosmos on the "Inside".
photo
Dave24
Without God, life is everything.
02:13 AM on 12/21/2011
How about both.
06:40 PM on 12/20/2011
Yes. Yes it's dead. Deader than red landing party red shirts in ST:TOS. We tried space, didn't like it. Manned space flight will be over in 10 years for the next 150 years. In 20 years there won't be any space science. Space engineering to satellites in LEO. And that's it. We as a SPECIES (not a nation) are done with it. A Canticle for Liebowitz will wind up being a true story.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aarontastic
"Mr. Cain instead decided to try to provide her wi
03:09 PM on 12/21/2011
I'm not sure what information is inspiring those pessimistic platitudes and oversimplifications. We tried space, but didn't like it? Just how are you calculating our species' aggregate 'like' of space? I'm sure that the people at NASA and every other national space program around the world would disagree with that, not to mention most physicists, and a good portion of laymen too. It's not worth addressing those other presumptuously precise forecasts that you've made since you have no evidence to base them on. but it always bewilders me when people are so sure about things that they know so little about.