More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Shane Claiborne

GET UPDATES FROM Shane Claiborne
 

Bombs, Cookies And The Cross: A Christian View On Military Spending

Posted: 10/29/10 10:03 PM ET

There's some interesting talk stirring about how it may be necessary to cut defense expenditures to decrease the deficit. Even though the $533 billion budget is the elephant in the room and the $200,000 spent every minute on the endless war on terror is the gushing, bleeding wound of America, this has been the taboo secret, the idolatrous sacred cow. But folks are beginning to whisper.

Maybe people have grown tired of militarism and war. After all, war hasn't gotten the best press over the past few years. Maybe the recession has created a desperation that has led us to rethink the status quo, where nearly half of every tax dollar goes to militarism. Maybe we are starting to realize if we don't stop spending all our money on a defense shield soon we won't have much left to need to defend. Or maybe it's all the above, the perfect storm for peace.

As a Christian, I am convinced in the power of non-violence by the greatest nonviolent act in human history: Jesus dying on the cross, even for his enemies. You'd think we Christians would be the hardest folks in the world to convince that violence is necessary, but that hasn't always been the case. In fact, much of the world seems confused by Christians who are so quick to abandon the cross of Christ and pick up the sword of Rome.

I'm reminded of a dinner conversation I had recently with Ben Cohen, founder of Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream, who has become a friend I deeply admire (and not just because he makes good ice cream). We talked about how this moment in history may very well be perfectly poised for Christians and non-Christians to work together for peace, and to eat some ice cream together with the money we may have spent on guns. And it is Ben who put together one of the coolest demos about the federal budget, using cookies as measuring units to show us how the dollars stack up. Check it out:

Martin Luther King said more than 40 years ago that every time a bomb goes off overseas, we can feel the second impact of that bomb as we watch our schools crumble and our health care system go up in flames. As Dr. King said, "A nation that continues year after year to spend more money on military defense than on programs of social uplift is approaching spiritual death."

So let us hold up our glasses of milk and toast to another world -- Christians and non-Christians, Muslims and Jews, all who would rather see ice cream dropped from planes than bombs -- and let us put our hands together and build a world where the schools have enough money and the militaries have to sell cookies for their uniforms.

 
There's some interesting talk stirring about how it may be necessary to cut defense expenditures to decrease the deficit. Even though the $533 billion budget is the elephant in the room and the $200...
There's some interesting talk stirring about how it may be necessary to cut defense expenditures to decrease the deficit. Even though the $533 billion budget is the elephant in the room and the $200...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 201
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Houston
British and a London resident
12:59 PM on 11/06/2010
Orwell summed it up nicely in his book "1984" the perpetual war was designed to consume the wealth and keep the nation in poverty and subdued.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:18 AM on 11/06/2010
I figure South Park would love to satirize this... but if they did, would it look any different?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Wood
A.T.C.G...(sigh)
12:41 PM on 11/05/2010
All wars are a stain on humanity. There never are winners except those that make the stuff that kill and maim people, destroy property...are used up and re-ordered. Names like GE, Boing, Ratheon, Haliburton...come to mind. Otherwise, humanity loses...always. Christianity is no worse than any other religion that asks God to bless their war...and no more helpful. That people should believe that any God would bless any war is sad. Based on available evidence, there probably isn't a god. We should consider trying to treat our fellow humans...humanely...with compassion...with reason...(sigh)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Gareth Harris
12:11 PM on 11/05/2010
Actually a military leader summarized the problem well:
Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed. This world in arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children. This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud of threatening war, it is humanity hanging from a cross of iron. -- Ike
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chipchuck
Rethink that...
12:09 PM on 11/02/2010
Here's where I get mad.

Let's look at Wal-Mart. It goes to a vendor of shoelaces and says, "Hey there, we're going to buy 100 million cases of your shoelaces and we're going to pay 10 cents each." The vendor usually sells for 20 cents each, but since Wal-Mart is buying 100 million cases, it means big profit for the shoelace company so they go with it. Wal-Mart sells the shoestrings for 20 cents and they make profit too.

Now the DoD, buys the same 100 million cases of shoestrings, but it's the other way around. The vendor says, "We got 100 million cases at 20 cents," and the invoice is signed and paid.

I think the bulk purchasing power of the DoD should be able to demand deals on the hardware.

DoD to Boewing: "We need 500 F-22's. I know ya'll list them at 2.5 Million each, but we're going to pay 1 million each. What's that you say? Profit? Okay, how bout this, We'll pay 2.5 Million, minus a 1.5 million surcharge for keeping your corporation safe from enemy invasion. Oh, you'll sell to the enemy? Okay, well our friends over at the tarriff department would like to let you know that there is now a 6 million dollar tarriff on sales to that country."

Yeah, I know, free market folks are gonna rail. Free market is tyranny; thank God we've never had it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SilentSolidarity
So what do you need? Besides a miracle.
10:36 PM on 11/03/2010
Exactly. Free market is nothing but a call for anomie capitalism. It really is nothing but tyranny.

Friedrich engels, one of the foudners of the communsit ideology was the son of one of the very few people who had a factory at this time. He saw the exploitation, how the rich were getting richer while the poor were getting poorer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Wood
A.T.C.G...(sigh)
12:54 PM on 11/05/2010
There is a natural inequality of ability and a general equality of greed. (Greed, for better or worse is a natural human instinct). Both capitalism and communism end up with a few very rich folks at the top and a bunch of poor folks at the bottom. Perhaps I'm uninformed, but I don't recall there ever being a successful communist country...or one where you and I could even have this conversation without one of us being in jail...or worse....probably me...(sigh)
01:14 AM on 11/02/2010
Can you make fun of God around here? Or doesn´t God have a sense of humor or gets a chance to laugh at Him self like Don McClean said about ¨Satan laughing with delight¨? Cause personally I agree with the Three Stooges and the Blessed Virgin and Mary Magdalen that a crucifixion and sucker punches and pre-emptive strikes and suicide bombers and weapons of mass destruction goes way beyond slap stick comedy. Think about it really...if we had world peace what the hell would we need any religion for then to tell us what to pray for in the Eden that would simply come into existence as a result of it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chipchuck
Rethink that...
11:57 AM on 11/02/2010
Yes, you can make fun of God around here. People do far worse than make fun.

I think God has an awesome sense of humor. Look at me for God's sake, or the platapus, or that dumb expression we get as we try to tell someone to look out. O.o

If we had world peace, I would give prayers of thanks and ask God to help us maintain it.

Those are my three cents.
photo
alterego55
"Always intended to be a factual statement"
05:12 PM on 11/01/2010
War hero and Republican President Dwight D. Eisenhower had this figured out in 1961.

"In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the militaryindustrial complex."
03:33 PM on 11/02/2010
Sage wisdom, indeed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:33 PM on 11/01/2010
I like Ben's idea of using Cookies as our currancy. The "Cookie Standard". That way when we are at last broke and bankrupt. We at least can eat the cookies.
03:04 PM on 11/01/2010
is it possible that America will destroy itself at the very same time we seek to protect ourselves militarily? I think Dr. King had it right. The only time we took from the Defense budget was during Clinton's term and he was able to balance the budget and create a surplus.

How sad that we as a nation prefer war and therefore our own death.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cayuse
Soaring Eagle, soaring to Spirit from the ego self
02:35 PM on 11/01/2010
Nice. I agree with the military perspective.

Just leaving a university where departments have become department, vice president and president and each make 5 time more than the professors do.

I think throwing money is the problem. How long does it take to teach reading, writing and arithmetic. 3 bone head course teach these in 15 credit hours.

Baby sitting, Getto cleaning or preferential treatment and advantage are problems that not an educational problem.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:46 PM on 11/01/2010
There will always be a business cycle and there will always be another crisis. If we don't plan our income and outlays with that in mind, the debt will continue to rise.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gentleman Agitator
"...morality is, in fact, hidden in everything.."
01:44 PM on 11/01/2010
This article is a bit murky to me. As a Christian, I understand what he is saying. However, making a case against war like he does, I doubt would change the mind of a Christian who holds a conservative political stand. One frightening outgrowth of far-right politics mixing with Christianity has been the idolatry of the military. God warns in many places in the Bible against putting other gods or ideas on level or above him. Yet, we have seen the our military lauded as if supporting the troops is akin to worshipping our Lord. That is not to say that I do not respect and give thanks for the dangerous job each and every member of the armed services does in defending my freedom. I do. However, they are not to be worshipped as supermen and superwomen, demigods or superpatriots who must be constantly bumper sticker praised in order for me to be considered patriotic and a Christian. Love of warfare might be less if we stop seeing the warriors not as a holy order, but as fellow ordinary Americans called to risk their lives for the rest of us ordinary Americans.

P.S.: Have you thanked a vet or active member today? They do not want your worship, but they might like a "thanks for your service."
03:06 PM on 11/01/2010
I do not think that even one militarily minded conservative "christian" gets into Heaven. You cant pretend to love Jesus Christ and still want/demand a military such as ours that frankly can destroy everyone 100 times over.

I served in the AF and am a Christian and the waste in the DoD surpasses any welfare or entitlement program ever could. Our corporate welfare to defense contractors needs to be brought under control.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:40 PM on 11/01/2010
I thank everyone of them I run into. They usually just want a job.
photo
DavidBlackburn
Recovering Republican since 1995.
02:24 AM on 11/01/2010
Amen brother. When 9/11 hit, we forgot about turning the other cheek. Could you imagine what would have happened had we just spent half that war money on eliminating oil from our economy and closing up our military bases to protect oil in the Middle East?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
gsj612
10:04 AM on 11/03/2010
Amen.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:11 PM on 11/04/2010
On half a trillion could go a long way huh? Sad what our government decides is more important, WAR or hope.
02:12 AM on 11/01/2010
The U.S. is the leader of the "free" world, its protector and benefactor. Sure it costs a lot, but the rewards, at least for the upper income classes, are far greater than the costs. Those who reap few apparent rewards from the military dominance of the world by the U.S. think that somehow the military budget could be slashed and we would just go on reaping the benefits of the empire without enforcing our will on the rest of the world.

If we were to quit being the enforcer the order would unravel and there would be a contest between the nations for a new way to enforce order. Our most feared and favored economic status would disintegrate along with the banking system that favors the U.S. and we would experience an abrupt decline as did the USSR after their losing the cold war.

The supposed lack of money to support the social safety net, education and health care come from our selfishness that spends 100's of billions on entertainments and luxuries while ignoring the basic needs of the poor. It would take a deep commitment on the part of the upper/ruling/leader classes to erase the gross income inequalities both domestic and international.

A lessening of income/power inequality would lessen the need for underclass violence and the counter force of imperialistic armed force worldwide. Only then would it be safe to reduce military spending and economic reliance on arms production in the U.S.
11:12 AM on 11/01/2010
There are ways to reduce defense spending without reducing it efficacy. Stop giving some companies no-bid, competitionless contracts, stop having multiple companies build virtually identical items (in the name of diversity and competition-especially when the military has said they do not need or want another version), actually hold contractors to the budget they offer (companies habitually low-ball the cost so that by the time the project goes way over budget the gov won't have time or resources to start over with a new vendor), etc. We could cut a lost of wastefull, ineffective spending without hurting the international power of the fighting force.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:48 PM on 11/01/2010
It's nice to be the King. But if we don't pay for the title then it's just borrowed prestige. Putting "king of the hill" on the credit card is not a long-term strategy.
03:53 AM on 11/06/2010
The Asians pay the west tribute - such as is due a King - borrowing is only a euphemism that saves them face. The reality is that they enslave their own so that their upper classes can live like the westerners in the movies. The U.S. of course does the same to its under class but due to its superior military steals the lions share of the worlds wealth and can afford to buy the poor off so as to remain relatively at peace domesticly without resorting to the overt oppression found in China.
02:08 AM on 11/01/2010
Defense has been seen as a sacred cow. With all this talk about "taxed enough already" the waste in defense spending goes on.