iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Shannon Bradley-Colleary

GET UPDATES FROM Shannon Bradley-Colleary
 

Am I Really Fat?

Posted: 01/29/2012 11:07 am

I've been the same weight for approximately five years. 140 lbs. Sometimes I'm up to 143, sometimes down to 137, but almost always exactly at 140. I am 5 foot 6 1/2 inches tall. I'm 46. So let's shark about the internet and find out if I'm really fat ...

1. The National Heart Lung and Blood Institute says a normal BMI is 18.5 - 24.9. When I calculate my BMI I come out at 22.3 which is well within the normal, healthy range.

2. Am-i-fat.com says that if I were a female in the U.S. Army my healthy weight would be between 143-147 lbs. Hoo-ahh!

3. Myoptumhealth.com says a women my height should weigh between 118-156 lbs.
Clearly I'm in a healthy weight range. So I've decided to do something radical.

I'm not going to lose weight.

Say what? That's it. I've relinquished 130. Would I like 130? Yes. Do I need it? No. I've been nit-picking myself about those ten pounds for five years. I've been wanting to get back to my pre-child, pre-40s size. Well I'm done with it and this is why.

The unretouched girl below is 25-years old and weighs 125 lbs. She's a size 4. She doesn't like her body. She's broken it down into parts as if it were a car. Some parts are acceptable, others she hates. She thinks she has cellulite on her bum:

She thinks she needs liposuction on her thighs:

She thinks her breasts are too small:

She is me. 21 years ago. With a media-induced case of Body Dysmorphic Disorder. Deceased Hollywood headshot photographer Helmut Lipschitz took these for a gallery show he was producing. I allowed him to do so as a woman trying to see my real body. Not the inadequate one I thought I had.

I look at this girl now and wonder, "Why did she even wear any clothes? She could've just walked around naked all the time!" Whenever I get the chance I show everyone my nudes. Henry just sighs and says, "I see you've managed to get your nudes out again." My mom's group is sick of my nudes. The Jehovah's Witnesses have stopped coming by. Even the neighborhood realtors don't leave their flyers in our gate anymore for fear I'll chase them down the street with my photo album shrieking,"Look at my nudes! Wasn't I gorgeous?!"

(And of course I won't be running for public office anytime soon ... wonder if they'd let me put my nudes up in the Oval Office?)

Here are Henry and I two summers ago. (We don't do nudes anymore) I call this our Angie and Brad shot (he's Angie):

I don't have the same body I had in my nudes. But ... not bad. (Henry's since lost 10 lbs. Does he have a second family somewhere? Anyone? Anyone?)

In 21 years from now I'll look back at this photo and think -- I looked great. Why did I worry so much about sucking in my soft round belly? It barely showed! And my kids loved to snuggle on it, my husband too. Why didn't I enjoy the way I looked and especially the way I felt, which was extravagantly healthy? Why didn't I carpe the freakin' diem?

Any woman worth her salt knows all about the photo-shopping and air brushing that runs rampant in the advertising industry, accosting us relentlessly with fake perfection. If you haven't you might enjoy seeing photoshopping in action:

WATCH:

We all know that advertisers make it their business to manipulate us into hating ourselves so we'll buy their products. Still an image is worth a thousand words. As a society we are brainwashed into the perpetual quest for perfection and it's just NOT POSSIBLE.

So I won't be losing weight. What I'll be doing is:

Developing a healthier relationship with food.

And maintaining a healthy weight.

I don't have the nerve (yet) to make my own "Muffinlicious" video, but here is one brave woman who has pulled a Jamie Lee Curtis and shown us how to celebrate our imperfections:

WATCH:

What are you struggling to accept?

This post originally appeared on The Woman Formerly Known As Beautiful.

 
 
 

Follow Shannon Bradley-Colleary on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@shannoncollear

I've been the same weight for approximately five years. 140 lbs. Sometimes I'm up to 143, sometimes down to 137, but almost always exactly at 140. I am 5 foot 6 1/2 inches tall. I'm 46. So let's sha...
I've been the same weight for approximately five years. 140 lbs. Sometimes I'm up to 143, sometimes down to 137, but almost always exactly at 140. I am 5 foot 6 1/2 inches tall. I'm 46. So let's sha...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 530
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (12 total)
12:27 AM on 02/17/2012
As a former Weight Watcher speaker and yo-yo dieter, like you 7lbs up, 7lbs down but never happy! I loved your post I was not lucky enough to have great nudes, although now I wish I did, as I think back why was I never satisfied with my body? Now in my sixties and still in pretty good shape I am finally beginning to appreciate what your body is really here for! Not just an ornament but vehicle to keep you up and running until the last possible moment. Why is it so hard for us as women to understand that? I am thankful to G-d, that I did not do any damage to myself with any of the crazy "diets" we indulged in years ago. Please keep writing, your style is terrific and this is so important for young women of today to learn!
gclafontaine
Sand is a small price to pay for sandlessness.
11:55 PM on 02/16/2012
Nice writing style.
07:29 PM on 02/16/2012
love it... thank you for this. I'm 71 and about 25-30 lbs. overweight...need to work out more, eat better but this article helps me.. I hate that hating how I look thing... I just want to be healthier..and I am pretty healthy, just would like to get around with more agility...and have it for sex too. We women need to be real about this...isn't that one of the good things about getting older?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thoreau101
05:07 AM on 02/17/2012
you are risking serious illness by being so over weight. Gross too.
12:29 PM on 02/20/2012
you're so sweet and helpful. your friends must adore you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Al Vaught
Socialist who speaks the truth
05:02 PM on 02/16/2012
Good job Shannon the hottie.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jen Grisanti
is an author (Story Line: Finding Gold In Your LIf
01:01 PM on 02/16/2012
I love this blog topic. I applaud you for exploring this. I think that the bottom line is seeing the beauty in what is no matter what phase of life we are in. You are beautiful. We need to stop looking back at what was with appreciation and instead to look at what is with tremendous gratitude and appreciation. We know that we couldn't see what was when we had it. We have the wisdom now to see it and be in it and rather than wait 10-20 years to look back at it.

I am 45. I say this as I am on the Quantum Wellness Cleanse by Kathy Freston and doing Tracy Anderson's fitness video. I have to work harder now but I am more conscious of my health and I do love and appreciate what is, imperfections and all.

I think that it is important for women our age to help younger women appreciate their bodies by complimenting them and helping them see what is.

Thanks for sharing your perspective on this and being so open.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nohopepope2187
Honest † Impartial † Enlightening † Centrist
10:02 AM on 02/03/2012
When I joined the Military at 20yo, I weighed 165lbs. I left training at 185lbs and maintained 190-195 lbs throughout my deployment. Now I'm 25yo, 6'3" and weight 200-205 lbs. I know that some people are worse off, but I get mad when I show the slightest hint of bellyfat. I'm not obsessed, but when I feel that way i change my workout routine to twice a day with more running.

We all have our issues.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shannon Bradley-Colleary
Aging Vaintress, Mom Butler, Wife Dominatrix
12:14 PM on 02/06/2012
Wait. Is that you in the picture? Because you look quite yummy. I wouldn't worry if I were you. Sounds like you're right where you need to be. Oh how we torture ourselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nohopepope2187
Honest † Impartial † Enlightening † Centrist
05:52 PM on 02/06/2012
Yeah, that's me - post-shower in my barracks bathroom. I just hope my metabolism never slows down.
photo
abhorson
in favor of legalized bar fighting
11:46 AM on 02/02/2012
Shannon - "wife dominatrix" ??? heee, is there another kind ?
02:58 PM on 02/02/2012
No. There is no other kind.
01:02 AM on 02/02/2012
I don't like my thighs, but it is not for the reasons you would expect from an American female. I was an olympic-styled weightlifter that could deadlift (which is a powerlift) 310 lbs at 150, 5'10 tall.
I am now atrophied at 125 pounds, 120 on a bad day, 130 on an equally bad day. I had so much muscle that my thighs were bulked up due to the muscle, and not the fat. When the muscle started to go, I now see how thin I truly was, but the muscle on my thighs seems to be leaving the slowest to my critical eyes. But everyone else thinks they look great so whatever. (they are wrong.)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nate35
05:42 PM on 02/01/2012
Meh, if there wasn't the media making us feel inadequate it would be the slightly better looking neighbor or co-worker. Disliking your imperfections is natural. Obsessing over them is not.
06:28 PM on 02/01/2012
I love that word Meh. Of course it's natural to like your imperfections, but there's no way I'm letting the media off the hook. There's a fantastic you tube video called Killing us softy here:
http://youtu.be/PTlmho_RovY
04:16 PM on 02/01/2012
You are hilarious and dead on. I looked at photos of myself from a few years ago and was like "whaaaaaaaaaaaaaat?? I thought I was fat???" Seize the day is right!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
anoise
My micro bio is too small to fit here....
03:22 PM on 02/01/2012
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!
My new mantra: you are never more beautiful than you are NOW. The past is gone, and when you look back you will realize how beautiful you were when then was now. So love your now because you will never be more beautiful than you are now.

I look back at photos when I was in my 20s 110 lbs, 18% body fat and I HATED the way I looked. I thought I was fat, my boobs were too big, my tummy too soft...

As much as I critisize myself now, I try and go back to my mantra. Woman need to stop looking to media to judge their beauty. And stop letting beauty define their selfworth. And realize they really are beautiful.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Annemarie Dooling
HuffPost Community Editor. Loves cats & airports
11:01 AM on 02/03/2012
That's a fantastic mantra!
12:56 AM on 02/01/2012
You were beautiful then and you're beautiful now! You're healthy, you're happy....self-acceptance is a wonderful thing...thanks for the inspiration, keep on keeping on!
07:01 PM on 01/31/2012
Every female should read this.
03:58 PM on 01/31/2012
I want to like this article, but I struggle with one aspect of it. The author shows her nudes as an example of when she feels she looked her best. Nothing wrong with being proud of that. But how is this empowering for women who NEVER looked that way? As a man, I don't know the reaction women would have, but I would love to see women who don't look like models (or never did) talking about how it is "okay" to have an "average" body.

I should qualify "look like models"...since most models today are NOT my ideal woman, nor healthy looking. I am uncomfortable that the second shot (of her back) is being shown as a possible "ideal"...lots of rib bones showing there, and I hate to think young women will strive for that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
cynicalme
your microbio is empty...and shall remain that way
09:22 PM on 01/31/2012
i understand what she's saying. i can only speak as female, but i feel the same way. i've spent the majority of my 37 years being unhappy with my body. most of that time, i realize now, i looked awesome. i look back at photos and do exactly the same thing. wonder what i was thinking and why i was hating on myself so much. now, after having a baby, it's a whole different ball game. i do , in fact, need to lose weight and get into shape, but i hope to remember along the way that i don't need to be airbrushed perfect and that i will never look like i did at 18. ever. again. i should have enjoyed it more then. oh well.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Kingpleasure
Live for Pleasure
11:33 PM on 01/31/2012
HudsonSpeaks:"I want to like this article, but I struggle with one aspect of it. The author shows her nudes as an example of when she feels she looked her best. Nothing wrong with being proud of that. But how is this empowering for women who NEVER looked that way? "

Great Comment Hudson, I was looking at her photos when she was 25 and I thought wow,, she's skinny, I can see every bone in her back and all of her ribs... How is that attractive? Maybe it's cultural but some women and men would find her to be too skinny and some men actually like women with meat on their bones.
03:50 PM on 02/01/2012
Hi Hudson, cyn and king -- I find all of your points of view very interesting. I was definitely a very skinny person pretty much into my 30s and it was a metabolic thing. They used to call me the girl with the hollow leg. I was very self-consious about my skinniness, especially when it came to having smaller breasts than I thought I was supposed to have. I read way too many Harlequin Romances where the lust object had pendulous ivory orbs so felt I was lacking.

Where I got into trouble thinking I had cellulite and needed liposuction was criticism from my first lover. We were together five years and throughout that time he'd pinch my thighs and bottom and show me the dimpled flesh telling me I had cellulite. At the time I didn't even know what cellulite was! I became so self-consious I didn't wear skirts or shorts for years. Thank goodness I got my act together and got out of that relationship. I was shocked to discover my next boyfriend thought my legs and bum were fantastic.

I guess what I'm trying to say in this article is to appreciate the body you're in. Now. Whether it's skinny, fat, tall, short, curvy or straight. Love you body now. It's the conduit for so many wonderful things. And in my case two beautiful daughters.
03:16 PM on 01/31/2012
As a personal trainer I've noticed that many women just accept what they have and just live with it and I hear all the usual things like I've been working out and haven't seen any results or I don't have time for the gym and I really enjoy eating food. Now all these are excuses most women that I've met that say they workout I've watched them do what they think is working out and sorry ladies getting on the treadmill for 60 minutes walking while reading a magazine is not working out now that might come from a lot of fitness and health experts not actually caring about getting their client in great shape but it also comes from people who give an half-ass attempt getting in shape is not easy but life is not supposed to be easy but I want to change the state of fitness and health industry and actually help all those who really want to change their lives and get that body they've always wanted and get them on a healthier lifestyle.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
anoise
My micro bio is too small to fit here....
03:30 PM on 02/01/2012
I just joined a gym to get healthier - I've accepted that at almost 50 I will never have the body I had at 20.
Sometimes women have unrealistic ideas of what working out can do.
06:29 PM on 02/01/2012
Yea its true that women can sometimes have unrealistic ideas about that but it's good to have a high goals in life its a way of pushing yourself past the your own limits and bettering yourself.
01:39 AM on 02/02/2012
No, you are NOT going to be able to do this here, Mr. Better-Than-You-Bc-I-Take-Probiotics. Nice try. I have had, been around and have dated personal trainers since I was 13 years old. I had private personal training three days a week at 13-22 yrs old.

Getting on the treadmill with a magazine for 60 minutes IS WORKING OUT. But for a personal trainer like Michael, that simplicity of work in his field done by regular-day people-which are his main clientel-Will Not Make Money For Him. Have you ever heard a personal trainer say "get on the treadmill and walk for 60 minutes?" I have, because I have been with dozens of trainers nationwide, from world class to garage-gyms. If you control your nutrition, muscle matters simply to health concerns with women. You can look great as a glo-worm without muscle, like that actress from the Twilight movies.

Trainers are not there for your benefit. Nobody will tell you what I am about to say. Trainers are there to prove their self-regard and esteem for their work and job, which happens to address to "working" you out. Never never never listen to personal trainers before you listen to yourself. You think something will bulk you up: You Are Right-It WILL. I KNOW. I went 4 hours, 2 hrs, am/2 hrs, pm every day but Sunday, doing olympic-style weightlifts. Now I don't. I look Completely different.