Best and Worst of the GOP Presidential Debate

On the campus of the University of North Florida, four men gathered for one last push in the Sunshine State hoping to win the key tiebreaker primary to be held in 4 days. As the UNFL Chamber Singers left the stage after the national anthem, the stage was set for what is surely one of the most decisive debates of the campaign season. A re-established Romney looked for another strong campaign performance in order to solidify his new lead in Florida, while Gingrich's goal was to win a decisive victory in order to re-launch his South Carolinian election. So, who were the winners and losers, and what were the best and worst moments?

Winners:

Mitt Romney

Mitt just needed to not slip up in order to keep his lead in the polls. He managed to fend off Gingrich's blows with ease, such as when Gingrich accused him of owning stock in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Romney was ready, pointing out that he personally does not make his investments, and turning the criticism right back on Gingrich, indicating that Gingrich owns the same stock that he does. He also managed to land a few punches of his own with regards to Gingrich's advertising campaign, which called Romney "the most anti-immigrant candidate," saying that it was distortion and slander.

Rick Santorum

Yup, Santorum managed to make himself heard at this debate. Don't expect him to win (or even take second) in the caucus, but do expect his poll numbers to rise. The most defining moment of the debate for Santorum was when he argued that Romney and Gingrich's attacks on each other had gone too far. He claimed that there was nothing wrong with Gingrich's consulting work for Freddie Mac and that there was nothing wrong with Mitt Romney being wealthy. He scored big points with an audience tired of the same old debate.

Marco Rubio

When asked a question about which Hispanic-Americans the candidates might appoint to their cabinet, each one mentioned Rubio. Gingrich even hinted at a Vice President run for Rubio.

Losers:

Newt Gingrich

Without defining moments to rail against the news media (and his one chance shot down by Romney), Gingrich couldn't seem to get anything started at the debate. His blows were easily parried by Romney, and he took criticism from all sides. Needing a big debate, Gingrich couldn't deliver and that could be the end of his presidential aspirations.

CNN Moderator Wolf Blitzer

Wolf and CNN didn't look good, as the candidates talked about whatever they wanted for however long they wanted. Wolf's inability to control the debates direction was not his only problem. Once again, the debate focused on the two frontrunners -- largely ignoring Rick Santorum and Ron Paul at some points. Wolf even received boos and heckles from the crowed as he would attempt to put the debate back on track, sometimes attempting to prevent candidates from responding to direct attacks against them.

The Candidates Best and Worst

Mitt Romney:

Best: Mitt had a rather average debate performance, not riding as much of a roller coaster as some of the other candidates. His high moment, however, would be his attack against Gingrich's ad campaign. He highlighted exactly what many Americans hate about the political process- the divisive rhetoric

Worst: Santorum managed to pin Romney down on "Romneycare," pointing out that it was incredibly similar to "Obamacare." Mitt's regular excuses would not throw Santorum off and Romney will have to come up with some new answers to the same questions about his time as Governor of Massachusetts

Newt Gingrich:

Best: Gingrich was a big loser at the debate, but he did have some good moments. His plans for space, while drawing some criticism, show that he is still a grandiose candidate who thinks grandiose thoughts. His allusions to JFK and Reagan could serve him well, but probably won't be enough.

Worst: The rest of the debate. Gingrich did not have a strong showing at all, getting trounced by Paul, Romney AND Santorum. Gingrich has learned once again what it means to be a frontrunner in a national election.

Rick Santorum:

Best: Rick's pins on Gingrich and Romney showed that he has the strength to debate as well. Santorum comes out of this debate looking like one of the most reasonable politicians around, especially after his answers regarding human space flight, even in the face of Space Coast voters, and his accusations of flip-flops to the two frontrunners.

Worst: Santorum could have used some more speech time, something he didn't really control. His worst moments were the ones where he was wasting his speech time stumbling over words or repeating himself. If he can clean up his presentation skills, he could transform into a very strong candidate, but probably a little too late.

Ron Paul:

Best: Paul had a better debate than he has previously. He stood aloof from the name calling and attacking, while excellently touting his own ideas. His best moment would have to be when he claimed he could care less about Romney v. Gingrich.

Worst: Paul didn't make many mistakes in this debate. His main problem is not making a huge impact on the debate. Banking on being the only one campaigning in Nevada and Colorado, he distanced himself from the crowd in Florida, meaning he didn't get as strong reactions from the crowd.

These debates, of course, have no technical winners or losers. Each voter decides their own winner and we can see those results at the polls come January 31st. The winner of Florida could easily be the winner of the national primary race and win the chance to face a formidable Barak Obama.

 

Comments

[bobbing4apples47]

03:14 PM on 01/28/2012

Very insightful. Keep up the great work Simon.

[brokensheild]

03:39 PM on 01/27/2012

I posted some time ago that Herman Cain's platform of the 9 9 9 tax plan would eventually be his undoing in the republican party. Not because it was perfect, but because it suggested some leveling of the tax-payer playing field. While it was claims of sexual harassment which represented the final straw, we must be aware that these claims may have been orchestrated by big money interest who, at all cost, want to protect the financial interests of the people with big money.

Ironically, Newt and Mitt are going at it over issues surrounding big money. With the current economic situation in this country and the fact that many tax-paying Americans are paying twice the tax rate of Mitt Romney, it is not surprising that the current President is looking better and better to most Americans.

While Newt claims he was not a lobbyist for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, a lobbyist by any other name is still a lobbyist. For his efforts, he was enriched while the tax payers experienced one more molestation.

Somehow, the republican party is going to have to figure out a way to establish a platform which, at least, appears to be in the interest of most Americans. Failing this, they will suffer an historic defeat in the upcoming elections.

[BMLT]

01:34 PM on 01/27/2012

Great job kid...can't believe YOU are a junior in HIGH SCHOOL. You sound so mature and very astute in your review. A future HuffPo journalist:)

[None of the Above 0]

12:22 PM on 01/27/2012

Are you kidding? A high school junior? Incredible writing, young sir! Very insightful analysis that exceeds many of the better known writers in the blogosphere. I can tell that you have a nuanced understanding of the candidates and the texture of the last few months of campaigning.

I would love to see you do an article breaking down the issues of each of the candidates. Keep up the great work!

[Halsey]

08:52 AM on 01/27/2012

Simon, Hard to believe you are a HS junior! I was so curious to read your take as you are the future and we've left you a bit of a mess (as a boomer, I apologize for the 70's and 80's!). You write as well, if not better than more tenured, professional essayists, journalists, etc. You, regardless of your politics, which you wisely did not reveal, give me hope. I will assume that in spite of what Santorum said about Obama being way off expecting all kids should go to college (while his own wife has had two, college educated careers), will ultimately, shortly pick a Univeristy or college that will be fortunate to have you. I see you running THEIR newspaper, if that is your dream.
Major kudos for a very well-written piece. Thank you.