csavage's Comments (1129)
The Soviet Occupation of Afghanistan Through CIA Eyes: Lessons for the United States Today
Commented Nov 24, 2009 at 16:34:50 in World
“And what makes you think the DoD has any interest in removing their overseas bases? Fifty years after WW2 and 20 years after the fall of the USSR, we maintain military bases in Germany.
The only nation that has successfully rid itself of our military is the Philippines and that was only after Mt. Pinatubo destroyed Clark AB and Subic Bay”
The only nation that has successfully rid itself of our military is the Philippines and that was only after Mt. Pinatubo destroyed Clark AB and Subic Bay”
The Soviet Occupation of Afghanistan Through CIA Eyes: Lessons for the United States Today
Commented Nov 24, 2009 at 16:31:59 in World
“We are an empire now....Our number one export is the defense industry. You are an absolutist and you've decided that the example of an empire is the USSR. What about Great Britain, or France, or the Romans?”
The Soviet Occupation of Afghanistan Through CIA Eyes: Lessons for the United States Today
Commented Nov 24, 2009 at 16:29:17 in World
“Hmmmm...the US is populated by infidels who have a penchant for drugs, music, dancing, sex, and exploitative business practices. I see plenty of values antithetical to the Afghan people....Our American Exceptionalism rears it's ugly head again...”
Third-Quarter GDP Number Revised Down
Commented Nov 24, 2009 at 16:01:03 in Business
“You aren't likely to get it. Last year, I was attending a board certification review in Dallas about the time Hank Paulson was saying he needed $1 Trillion by Thursday and no questions asked. The topic on NPR that morning was the sad state of finance/economic journalism and how Columbia was cancelling classes due to low demand. If we can't have trained journalists reporting the issues to laymen, how is the public going to know or understand. And, for those dissing Krugman, economics is a soft science and open to lots of interpretation. For every Keynes, you have a Friedman...”
Daniel Webb Dead: Obese SC Man Died After 8 Months In Home Recliner, Didn't Have Health Insurance
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 16:12:50 in Home
“How has the government made my life better? Well, since 46% of my patients are on Medicare, the government funds a large percentage of my practice. Medicare also is responsible for funding a majority of hospitals in the country, so, if you were in a hospital, or in an ER, thank your government for providing the backbone of funding that allows the health care system we have in this country to function. I drove on a highway to get to my job and that highway's construction was funded by a statewide funding system driven by taxes imposed on each gallon of gas. At my job, I used an excellent education provided by the University of Texas-a state run institution-and paid for by the US government in exchange for my service to the country. I prescribed many drugs today and those drugs were discovered through funding by the National Institutes of Health. Some of my patients have the flu and I was able to tell them that using guidelines provided to me by the CDC.
My government does alot for me and you, except I'm cognizant enough to connect the dots and you, in your intellectual laziness, buy everything someone tells you.”
My government does alot for me and you, except I'm cognizant enough to connect the dots and you, in your intellectual laziness, buy everything someone tells you.”
BubbaNH replied on Nov 20, 2009 at 16:45:20
“kudos, doc...”
Next On Bravo... The Woman From Wasilla
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 15:18:59 in Politics
“We have a serious problem in this country-our campaign financing. TV covers candidates directly commiserate with their ability to sell ads, so, an attractive candidate gets more coverage that someone not so photogenic. We are shown a cast of possible presidential candidates that are differentially promoted. Ever wonder, after years and years of mediocre choices and general voter dissatisfaction, why our choices never seem to improve? Why candidates not plugged into the entertainment-military-industrial complex don't get highlighted-like Ron Paul or Dennis Kucinich.
Does the media really think we want someone who we can have a beer with to be president? I'd prefer to have someone intelligent run the country. But alot of people are entranced by "the girl next door" quality Sarah brings. If they vote for her for president, though, it will be obvious that our slide to a banana republic is complete.”
Does the media really think we want someone who we can have a beer with to be president? I'd prefer to have someone intelligent run the country. But alot of people are entranced by "the girl next door" quality Sarah brings. If they vote for her for president, though, it will be obvious that our slide to a banana republic is complete.”
d'Armond Speers: Dad Spoke Only Klingon To Son For Three Years
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 13:06:18 in Technology
“His hypothesis doesn't make sense. All languages are invented and evolve over time. If he wanted to see how his son would do learning two languages phonetically dissimilar, he should have taught him English and Mandarin”
bluexero replied on Nov 20, 2009 at 13:42:17
“Mandarin is a crazy hard language...My wife is Chinese and she can speak both English and Mandarin brilliantly. When I listen to her speak with her family, its really hard to pickup on what they are talking about sometimes because the Mandarin words sound so similar.”
Gang Killed People For Their Fat: Peruvian Police
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 12:59:45 in World
“This is straight outta "Fight Club"...and you know what the first rule of Fight Club is, don't you?”
audadvnc replied on Nov 20, 2009 at 13:26:33
“Yeah, but I'm about to tell you...”
Gang Killed People For Their Fat: Peruvian Police
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 12:58:56 in World
“We're down to #14 of the top 50 fattest states...”
Gang Killed People For Their Fat: Peruvian Police
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 12:58:16 in World
“He's the chief buyer for McDonald's Corp.”
Pem3 replied on Nov 20, 2009 at 13:02:17
“Well that explains my greasy quarter pounder last night.”
Gang Killed People For Their Fat: Peruvian Police
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 12:57:23 in World
“I'll listen for this storyline to get picked up by Beck, et al.”
Pem3 replied on Nov 20, 2009 at 13:01:14
“He would be nervous have you seen his waist line!!!!!”
Doctors Answer Mammogram Concerns
Commented Nov 20, 2009 at 09:48:10 in Living
“The ACP has long recommended mammograms not start until age 50, so one of my internists friends who told me she wasn't going to get one until she was 50 is completely justified now. As for pap smears, it makes little sense for me, as a 46 year old woman, HPV negative, in a monogamous relationship, to get one every year. Ovarian cancer is another thing, and one not screened for with a pap smear-and, one with no good screening protocol in 2009. As for mammograms, I've had one every year for the last 6 years and I'll discuss it with my OB/gyn. As for mammograms catching everything, one of my nurse friends was diagnosed with Stage 3 B breast cancer after having a screening mammogram yearly. She took all the previously read "normal" mammograms with her to MD Anderson and the radiologists there saw her cancer in every one of them. A mammogram reading depends on the competency of the radiologist, too.”
Poll: Majority Of Republicans Don't Think Obama Won 2008 Election
Commented Nov 19, 2009 at 16:59:14 in Politics
“No one here should forget that the Repubs are the party of "screw you, I got mine". They think that everyone thinks like they do. They cannot comprehend that someone would choose to vote Democratic on principle. ACORN and SEIU are their 'Boogeymen" and that we were deluded by those agencies' propaganda. They do not think that Bush lost the popular vote in 2000-they think that Florida result was inconsequential to the election. They really believe the government was only going to wiretap terrorists with the Patriot Act, although the law didn't define what a terrorist was. They think the international reputation that the US should have is "international strongman" not global participant. They really believe that their ideas lead to less government despite the fact that the only president who saw the government shrink in terms of GDP was Clinton. They think their party is the party of privacy, despite the fact their hero Hamilton didn't think the US needed the Bill of Rights to limit government. They believe the race and gender roles of the 50s should return-no wonder they're stunned to find out white people voted for Obama. The wingnut media has successfully merged the concept that Democrat/liberal means "minority"”
Virginia Tech Survivor With Hidden Camera Films Dangerous Gun Sales at Gun Shows
Commented Nov 19, 2009 at 09:42:50 in Politics
“This gun owner is. I have a .243 and a 9 mm I use to hunt deer. My plan for any home invasion is to get my kids and run out of the house. Semi-automatic weapons are just designed to kill people, not game. Competitive shooters shoot guns that would never be carried at these gun shows. Those feelings are the same as 85% of the gun owners in this country. Only a wingnut would connect "the dots" between the Fort Hood shooting, Columbine, the shooting in Florida and 9/11 to say that we are being overrun by Muslim extremists. Sensible people see unchecked access to guns as uniting 3 of the 4 events. I've been to these guns shows-it's actually sad. You pass table after table of vendors plying on fears to sell their products-fear of blacks, immigrants, Muslims, "criminals" (ironic considereing the source). These gun dealers are the ones promoting the drug war in Mexico. Ninety percent of cars driving into Mexico from the US aren't searched and a fair number of them are driven by gun runners. It's just a matter of time that the Mexican drug war becomes the American drug war...”
OdinsEye replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 15:23:48
“"Semi-automatic weapons are just designed to kill people, not game. "
Really? I guess that you are not aware that semi-auto hunting firearms have been sold in the US for more than 100 years and are quite popular.
"Competitive shooters shoot guns that would never be carried at these gun shows. "
Also quite incorrect.
"Those feelings are the same as 85% of the gun owners in this country. "
LOL... you are funny!”
Really? I guess that you are not aware that semi-auto hunting firearms have been sold in the US for more than 100 years and are quite popular.
"Competitive shooters shoot guns that would never be carried at these gun shows. "
Also quite incorrect.
"Those feelings are the same as 85% of the gun owners in this country. "
LOL... you are funny!”
InYourWorld replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 13:14:13
“Any one familiar with ballistics of a 9mm would agree that it is not a humane round for shooting deer unless you are less than 25 feet away.”
mike102 replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 10:59:14
“We eagerky await your response to BenEzra, who really IS a competetive shooter, and who contradicts your entire post.”
mithras93 replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 10:55:42
“Competitive shooters shoot semi-automatic weapons, including assault rifles.
People like you seem to think that because some folks abuse our constitutional rights, those rights should be restricted for everyone. WRONG!”
People like you seem to think that because some folks abuse our constitutional rights, those rights should be restricted for everyone. WRONG!”
benEzra replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 10:11:57
“I *am* a competitive shooter (IPSC/USPSA) and both the guns I shoot competitively (a 9mm Smith & Wesson and a 7.62x39mm SAR-1) are semiautomatic.
http://www.commongroundcommonsense.org/forums/uploads/1168567538/gallery_260_23_29637.jpg
If your 9mm isn't a revolver, it's a semiautomatic, and certainly one doesn't hunt deer with a 9mm. Of course, only 1 in 5 U.S. gun owners hunts, so "legitimate gun owner = hunter" is quite mistaken.”
http://www.commongroundcommonsense.org/forums/uploads/1168567538/gallery_260_23_29637.jpg
If your 9mm isn't a revolver, it's a semiautomatic, and certainly one doesn't hunt deer with a 9mm. Of course, only 1 in 5 U.S. gun owners hunts, so "legitimate gun owner = hunter" is quite mistaken.”
Dimensio replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 09:59:58
“" Semi-automatic weapons are just designed to kill people, not game."
Please justify this assertion. Explain why none of my semi-automatic firearms have been used to commit homicide; are my firearms defective, or have I misused them? Explain why the AR-15 is the most popular centerfire semi-automatic rifle in the United States yet is rarely used in criminal acts at all.
" Competitive shooters shoot guns that would never be carried at these gun shows."
Your assertion is demonstrably false. Many competitive shooters use AR-15 rifles and Glock handguns, both of which are frequently sold in such venues.”
Please justify this assertion. Explain why none of my semi-automatic firearms have been used to commit homicide; are my firearms defective, or have I misused them? Explain why the AR-15 is the most popular centerfire semi-automatic rifle in the United States yet is rarely used in criminal acts at all.
" Competitive shooters shoot guns that would never be carried at these gun shows."
Your assertion is demonstrably false. Many competitive shooters use AR-15 rifles and Glock handguns, both of which are frequently sold in such venues.”
Glocksf21 replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 09:57:00
“9mm to hunt deer? and a 9mm is a semiautomatic round, i have never seen a single shot 9mm or a bolt action 9mm.”
Jon Stewart Explains To Conservative Pundits Why He Doesn't Like Sarah Palin (VIDEO)
Commented Nov 19, 2009 at 09:30:37 in Comedy
“So you think it was appropriate for the RNC to push Palin as a VP candidate based on the fact they considered her "f*ckable"? Is that the image you want the US to portray to it's enemies? Boy, you guys really do hate America”
shella2177 replied on Nov 19, 2009 at 09:35:40
“what is YOUR issue with FEMALES?????”
Conservatives Terrified of Bringing Terrorists to Justice
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 16:10:23 in Politics
“Gee, I remember it being GEORGE WALKER BUSH who was willing to detain them indefinitely. Obama sought to close Gitmo and transfer them to prisons here and the neo-confederates were so incensed and claimed that, somehow despite the fact we are able to imprison pedophiles, rapists and murderers, we could never house them here-they essentially made it impossible to get other countries to take them, too. You may fault obama for admitting that we may have to house them indefinitely, but never forget it was people like you who poisoned that pot to begin with”
Conservatives Terrified of Bringing Terrorists to Justice
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 14:56:41 in Politics
“I agree....the boogie man's going to be found out to be on the CIA's payroll and it scares the bejeesus out of his former employers.
I don't necessarily pin in on Bush. I pin it on our foreign policy for the last 30 years-ever since the Soviets invaded Afghanistan. The American public, in their concrete thinking majesty, will see al-Queda for what they are/were-the mujahideen that we armed and trained in 1979....
Oh, that and the fact that the Bushes and Bin Laden family are business associates...”
I don't necessarily pin in on Bush. I pin it on our foreign policy for the last 30 years-ever since the Soviets invaded Afghanistan. The American public, in their concrete thinking majesty, will see al-Queda for what they are/were-the mujahideen that we armed and trained in 1979....
Oh, that and the fact that the Bushes and Bin Laden family are business associates...”
The Inevitable Fluke That Is Sarah Palin
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 13:25:53 in Media
“It also describes most "Tea Partiers"”
Safest Cars 2010: Ford, Subaru, VW Win Insurance Industry Picks
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 11:40:48 in Business
“I agree-Toyota owners have their own cult. They handle like boxes with wheels attached and their interior looks trashed within 3 years. Lexus owners are even more deluded-they're buying a Toyota with an inflated price tag.
I'll stick with my BMW any day.”
I'll stick with my BMW any day.”
saveyour replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 12:53:14
“i've owned a 7 series bmw before selling it to buy a lexus gs430. i loved to drive the bmw, particularly on road trips, up and down the mountains etc. but it was expensive to maintain and fix all of the nagging problems it constantly had, particularly electrical issues.
the lexus isn't quite as much fun to drive--it's close though. and definitely worth the trade-off given that the only issue i've had is having to replace the halogen fog lights that were stolen one night when the car was parked.
look at resale value for high-end bmw versus lexus---no comparison ( although, i live on the west coast where lexus and infiniti hold their values much better than bmw/mercedes/audi and i think the reverse made be true on the east coast)
and as far as the lexus being a 'toyota with an inflated price tag', ummm okay.
i guess given that analogy, filet mignon is beef tongue with an inflated price tag as they both come from cows...”
the lexus isn't quite as much fun to drive--it's close though. and definitely worth the trade-off given that the only issue i've had is having to replace the halogen fog lights that were stolen one night when the car was parked.
look at resale value for high-end bmw versus lexus---no comparison ( although, i live on the west coast where lexus and infiniti hold their values much better than bmw/mercedes/audi and i think the reverse made be true on the east coast)
and as far as the lexus being a 'toyota with an inflated price tag', ummm okay.
i guess given that analogy, filet mignon is beef tongue with an inflated price tag as they both come from cows...”
Safest Cars 2010: Ford, Subaru, VW Win Insurance Industry Picks
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 11:36:53 in Business
“Coloradoans love their Subarus. Actually, I got stuck in our cabin with the big snow of 2003. I couldn't get my Expedition out but I watched a Sabaru driver start driving forward until he couldn't go any further in a snow bank, back up, pick up some speed and push the snow bank a little further and repeat this for 2 hours until he cleared out the road. If they pulled 5000 lbs trailers, I'd get one!”
Pilate replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 12:36:54
“A few years back we went Christmas tree cutting with a bunch of friends. Two guys had Silverado 4x4's, one had a Suburban, and I had a Baja. After the requisite ribbing about my toy truck, we and our wives set out. The Suburban was the first to drop out; it was so long that it was whacking the rear bumper every time the back wheels bottomed in a dip. When we got to the narrow part, which was also rocky, rutted, and with trees close on either side, one of the Chevy's slued and whacked one. After we sorted that out, it was the other Silverado and the Subaru, each with four adults. When we made it to our cutting area the last Chevy owner had had enough and parked it. I continued along the "trail" to roughly the middle of our spot in about a foot and a half of snow, everybody cut trees, threw them in my truck, and we dropped them off to each owner on our way out. Merry Christmas after all.
Not bad for a "toy" truck that gets 18 mpg city, 27 highway when averaging 70 mph, and is WAY more fun to drive than a Suburban.”
Not bad for a "toy" truck that gets 18 mpg city, 27 highway when averaging 70 mph, and is WAY more fun to drive than a Suburban.”
Integrative Mental Health: A New Model For Depression Relief
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 10:21:48 in Living
“I have an even better suggestion. Depression is a learned behavior, we'd be far better off examining the circumstances that led to a person learning that behavior. Another of my fav models of depression (developed by Overmier and Seligman) fits completely with my experience as a doc with depressed people in my practice. Most people seek care for their depression with their primary care doctors. I agree that SSRIs do not "cure" depression but people expect a drug, based on their overwhelming exposure to TV and print ads. The one bit of advice I find myself giving patients is both the Serenity Prayer and the statement that we cannot control someone else's behavior, we can only control our response to that behavior. As a counselling, the insurance companies do not pay for counselling, they pay only for med checks-so you can see where the bias lies...”
db0255 replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 19:49:28
“"Depression is a learned behavior"
I loled at that one, but I'm not sure I should have. Depression is not a learned behavior, no more than cancer is a learned disease.”
I loled at that one, but I'm not sure I should have. Depression is not a learned behavior, no more than cancer is a learned disease.”
Kathryn Maver replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 12:56:01
“Oh my word! With all due respect, you apparently are not anywhere near current on the research regarding depression. While there are no doubt behaviors around depression that may be learned, and circumstances can act as triggers, this is not simply a learned behavior. There are real neurochemicals involved (did your medical school teach you anything about serotonin?). The Serenity Prayer is not all that helpful. Please do your patients a favor and refer them to someone qualified to deal with mental health issues.”
teresa1960 replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 12:38:22
“That's just pure rubbish.”
Natalie Willoughby replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 12:05:45
“Depression is not a learned behavior, and I'm insulted that you could say so. That reminds me of Doctors of old saying that people with depression should just "Get over it", and that it's not a true illness, it's mostly just in peoples heads. That does lead to a worsening of the situation and the mental condition of the patient, who would most likely go home after that and think "What's wrong with me? Why can't I get over this like my doctor says?"
There is a HUGE difference between "depressed people" and people with depression. We all get depressed. It's part of the human emotional range. I have depression, so does my dad. But that doesn't mean I learned it from him. And it's insulting to even consider, in my opinion. Just a cop-out and dismissal.
I do agree that those with depression need a combination of medication, therapy and other treatments (acupuncture, yoga, excerise, etc.) to become whole again. But to just focus on "circumstances that led to a person learning that behavior" is just downright inconsiderate.”
There is a HUGE difference between "depressed people" and people with depression. We all get depressed. It's part of the human emotional range. I have depression, so does my dad. But that doesn't mean I learned it from him. And it's insulting to even consider, in my opinion. Just a cop-out and dismissal.
I do agree that those with depression need a combination of medication, therapy and other treatments (acupuncture, yoga, excerise, etc.) to become whole again. But to just focus on "circumstances that led to a person learning that behavior" is just downright inconsiderate.”
vim876 replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 11:47:58
“Clearly you haven't dealt with many truly severely depressed patients. This sort of advice is the kind that makes people think there's no hope. As someone with heavily biologically based depression, I was perfectly aware that my thinking is irrational, as well as what rational thinking looks like. It didn't matter. Drugs and ECT saved my life. Please give your severely depressed patients the same chance.”
MarcoDante replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 11:41:16
“That is only partially true. While some aspects of depression (some behaviors) are learned, it is primarily a disorder that is biochemical/genetic in nature. Meds and therapy can help, but there is an over-ridding brain chemistry in many of us that laughs in the face of such therapies. If 30+ years of counseling and pharmaceuticals hasn't "cured" me, I doubt that the Lords prayer will either. Marco http://bipolarized.wordpress.com”
Biden On The Bailout: 'Socialism For The Rich And Capitalism For The Poor' (VIDEO)
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 10:11:45 in Politics
“That started off as wingnut fearmongering-or do you not remember Hank Paulson telling Congress they had 4 days to approve TARP in Oct 2008 or the whole financial sector would collapse? No?”
Kalie replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 12:38:45
“Yes Hank Paulson. I wish he would go do some census work in the backwoods of Kentucky. My bad.”
Biden On The Bailout: 'Socialism For The Rich And Capitalism For The Poor' (VIDEO)
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 10:09:56 in Politics
“Take the money out of the campaigns....”
sdsuprof replied on Nov 18, 2009 at 13:01:44
“Campaign money is the root of all evil.”
Biden On The Bailout: 'Socialism For The Rich And Capitalism For The Poor' (VIDEO)
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 10:09:26 in Politics
“Don't worry, we're not "out of the woods" yet...”
Biden On The Bailout: 'Socialism For The Rich And Capitalism For The Poor' (VIDEO)
Commented Nov 18, 2009 at 10:03:36 in Politics
“I was going to say, I've been saying "Privatize the profits, socialize the risks" for a long while now...”


