More

Stephen C. Rose

Stephen C. Rose

Posted: August 9, 2009 10:03 AM

Is America A Joke?


It is time for some perspective. We have just elected a President who embodies what we might call true American values. These relate to fairness, opportunity, respect and allegiance to law and the Constitution. These values conflict with the following:

Racism.

Lawlessness.

The cultivation of hatred.

We elected the President because we knew we were emerging from a government that was skirting the laws and most certainly making a joke of our country.

Now we confront what is a precise big lie effort to bury the above in a stench-laden collection of nativist and palpably ignorant allegations.

Is America a joke?

No.

Is this big lie effort a joke? No.

Read the following:

(1) Repeal of all Naturalization Laws.


(2) None but Americans for office.

(3) A pure American Common School system.

(4) War to the hilt, on political Romanism.

(5) Opposition to the formation of Military Companies, composed of Foreigners.

(6) The advocacy of a sound, healthy and safe Nationality.

(7) Hostility to all Papal influences, when brought to bear against the Republic.

(8) American Constitutions & American sentiments.

(9) More stringent & effective Emigration Laws.

(10) The amplest protection to Protestant Interests.

(11) The doctrines of the revered Washington.

(12) The sending back of all foreign paupers.

(13) Formation of societies to protect American interests.

(14) Eternal enmity to all those who attempt to carry out the principles of a foreign Church or State.

(15) Our Country, our whole Country, and nothing but our Country.

(16) Finally,-American Laws, and American Legislation, and Death to all foreign influences, whether in high places or low

"Copied from the "Know Nothing" newspaper, for the special benefit of my honorable colleague, Miss R In haste----S"

It is a summary of the 1856 Know Nothing platform. SOURCE

It wasn't a joke then, either. (Ironicaly, the movement began as the Republican Party before it became the American Party.)

Almost always the extremist and absurd efforts of fringes, on either end of the spectrum, reflect serious conflicts that are allowed to flare up in what seems a confusing and depressing wall of noise, anger and sometimes outright violence.

The enemy then was Irish Catholic immigration. The enemy now is the impending dominance of a multi-racial state replacing a white-dominated state.

The Know Nothing conflict erupted in huge draft riots during the Civil War and perhaps ended with the election of JFK.

The present conflict has a longer arc. It began with the first slave ships and it will not end until our prison society is a distant memory and poverty is eliminated because it is no longer necessary with a technology that can produce abundance without requiring the subjugation of workers.

America is not a joke. It is as ever a bold experiment in moving humanity a bit more to the good side of the spectrum of life. It is a test of the possibilities of immanence and the staying power of proselytizing religion.

For thought in a similar vein: http://stephencrose.wordpress.com

Follow Stephen C. Rose on Twitter: www.twitter.com/stephencrose

 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:32 PM on 08/11/2009
Wow... Mr. Rose. Where to begin.

You covered a lot of ground there. Let me see if I got your bullet points.

1- The president embodies what is good and American.

2- The 'nativists' (whatever that means to you) are un-American. Which if I read you correctly are connected to the know nothing party somehow. At least, you seem to be trying to draw a connection here.

3- All will be solved when we can create abundance for everyone.

4- Oh and the juicy bit, nativists are Republicans? Therefore, Republicans are Un-American.

I have to admit, I find your way of thinking quite alarming. Even moreso that people actually agree with you.

If someone said that the president was the embodiment of good. The communists, socialists and social democrats were un-american, I would be alarmed. Oh wait, that did happen. It was a dark time in our countries history. Are you saying we should reactivate the House Un-American Activities Committee? Watch anyone who you define as a nativist?

Perhaps I am being a bit alarmist, but this way of thinking sounds very familiar. Please correct me if I missed your intent here.
01:19 PM on 08/09/2009
"Almost always the extremist and absurd efforts of fringes, on either end of the spectrum, reflect serious conflicts that are allowed to flare up in what seems a confusing and depressing wall of noise, anger and sometimes outright violence."

Well said, dad! ;)
03:39 PM on 08/09/2009
LOL!! He might be your dad since you have same last name.
04:30 PM on 08/09/2009
Ha yes, I was just being silly. But I believe his quote and will share with others. :)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Stephen C. Rose
Fulltime writer, blogger, thinker, activist.
01:09 PM on 08/09/2009
Well from the comments this far, one would conclude that the question is at least of interest. I am a supporter of the President -- both of his political realism and his measured allegiance to what is right. If he is a good politician and decent he outshines all recent presidents with one exception. He has indicated who he thinks that is. I do not agree but I understand.
01:05 PM on 08/09/2009
Sorry. In the second paragraph, I meant to say all of the sentiments that we....
01:04 PM on 08/09/2009
Perhaps to the international community we have become a joke. After years of championing the causes of "freedom and justice for all" around the globe, with less than honorable intentions in some cases, we are now projecting live and in living color all of sentiments that we, supposedly, were in opposition to.

Corruption at the highest levels of government...check.

Multinational corporations allowed to have an unprecedented influence over policies affecting the public...check.

Everyday working people unable to earn a living wage which covers their basic needs...check.

Widespread hunger and homelessness...check.

Educational system in shambles...check.

Manufacturing sector in this country almost non-existent due to outsourcing...check.

Culture and class warfare...check.

Millions without health care coverage, dying prematurely as a result...check.

Public officials indifferent to the consequences of their actions...check.

And on and on....

We are most probably viewed as a joke by other countries, but what's happening here is certainly not funny and will in all likelihood get worse as time progresses.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
propitiousmoment
the journey is the destination....
02:20 PM on 08/09/2009
All of those things also accurately describe this country before progressive politics made a dent in them back at the beginning of the last century. Remember the "robber barons"? Remember how the railroads and the manufacturing industries treated their workers, and how the slumlords treated their tenants, and the mentally ill were misunderstood and mistreated? Unfortunately, like women's rights, worker's (and everyone else's) rights are all too recent, too fragile, too easily deconstructed by the powerful. We created for a time a great place to live and work but the corporations were turned loose again and if we don't rein them in soon I fear for everything we have gained as a society.
02:40 PM on 08/11/2009
I think you misunderstand what Republican ideals are or their role in our country. You need to separate the party from the philosophy as the party seems to create a bias in peoples minds. Republican ideas are what led this countries early leaders to separate from the power of the Whigs and seek independence. Our early leaders werent perfect, but they fought for the idea of equality, and equal opportunity. At least some of them did. The word progressive and republicanism are not mutually exclusive terms. Just as republicanism and liberal are not mutually exclusive.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
propitiousmoment
the journey is the destination....
02:22 PM on 08/09/2009
Sorry I should have said, except for the non-existent manufacturing base.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kitkatborn
11:27 AM on 08/09/2009
Thank you for this post, Mr. Rose.
11:07 AM on 08/09/2009
America is still a utopian experiment. The human zoo is an animal kingdom made up of lords and serfs, the selfish and selfless, predators and prey. Therein lies its basest flaws, not in unnatural selection or homegenity. The idea of a polarized society thust together and expected to mix well despite issues of economics, culture, agenda, secret societies or elite nepotism vs. voiceless divestitute is sheer fantasy.

Humanity's foibles exist in a system of chaos. To suffer is to know the truth. Idealization of perfection is folly and cannot exist except among those who preach morality from economic security and safe gated communities. PC feel good policy that we can all get along has not been victim of crime or poverty and control freak elitists responsible for most of our problems are too wealthy, insolated or isolated to care.
10:44 AM on 08/09/2009
America became a joke when W was re-elected. An UK tabloid had a headline commenting on Americans returning W to office that I'm going to garble, "How can so many be so stupid?". America still is a laughing stock as Pres Obama continues to morph into W.
11:30 AM on 08/09/2009
America is not a joke to the rest of the world. Instead it looks like a criminal gand war in motion. Honesty and integrety seem to be missing in the American make up. Every man for himself. Huge corporations.........er....gangs bribing whole branches of government. Gangs ( drugs industry, HMOs) getting their own way by first corrupting government officials and then fomenting violence against law abiding citisens. America a joke? I think not. The world trembles as it watches a very powerful country taken over by criminal elements. It is no joke. America today is the worlds best example of democracy gone wrong. Corruption reins supreme. What could save America? A new civil war perhaps? A fresh start? But the entire mess has to be brought down and a new governent started from scratch' with strong laws that would be equally enforced across all classes of society. That might help. No death penalty for murderers, but the death penalty for fraude and corrupt government officials. They do much more harm than murders to society.