iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Stephen Ducat

Stephen Ducat

Posted: October 26, 2008 01:04 PM

Why They Hate Obama: Miscegenation and Other Nightmares of the Racist Political Imagination


The frank comments of unapologetic anti-Obama racists across the country have recently gained a wide national audience. As Ricky Thompson, a pipe fitter from Mobile, Alabama, told a New York Times reporter, "He's neither-nor. He's other. It's in the Bible. Come as one. Don't create other breeds." Another denizen of the GOP's "real America" shared his spiritual insights with the same interviewer. Glenn Reynolds, of Martinsville, Virginia pointed out, "God taught the children of Israel not to intermarry." Such shameless declarations of prejudice reveal something obvious but easily overlooked: It is not Obama's blackness that disturbs these pious bigots, but his grayness.

Ideas that now seem like crackpot notions of race were, not long ago, regarded as common sense, and found themselves codified in law. The "one-drop rule" asserted that a single drop of black blood in an otherwise white citizen rendered that person black. Blackness was widely viewed as a contaminant that sullied white purity. (In antebellum America, white slave owners got around this problem by either denying the ordinary practice of raping and impregnating black women, or by justifying this predation as a racial improvement of the population of black slaves.) The rule was adopted by numerous state legislators in the first third of the 20th century, and used as the basis for Jim Crow laws.

In 1924 Dr. Walter Plecker, a public health advocate who worked for Virginia's Vital Statistics Department, said, "Two races as materially divergent as the White and Negro, in morals, mental powers, and cultural fitness, cannot live in close contact without injury to the higher." It wasn't until 1967 that the U.S. Supreme Court proclaimed Plecker's Virginia Racial Integrity Act and the one-drop rule unconstitutional. This decision, which eliminated the ban on interracial marriage, bore the wonderfully apt title of Loving v. Virginia.

Sadly but not surprisingly, such legal victories have not kept Plecker's sentiments from being embraced by contemporary guardians of racial boundaries. And, Barack Obama, the child of a black African father and a white American mother, is for these folks the very embodiment of what must not be brought together.

As psychoanalyst Adam Phillips has succinctly observed, "We hold ourselves together by keeping things apart." While legally sanctioned racial segregation in public life may be moldering in history's dustbin, a corresponding segregation in our inner lives continues to structure our thoughts and emotions.

Some people consciously, most unconsciously, hold on for dear life to the pure and invariant categories of "good" and "bad." Keeping them apart and unambiguously distinct helps us retain a reassuring infantile fantasy of safety, order and certainty. "Race" lends itself well to this process of splitting. Imagined as fundamentally unlike us, the racialized other becomes the perfect receptacle into which we are free to project all the wishes, impulses, and longings that we cannot bear to see in our ethnic group or ourselves. In other words, racism allows us to be all-good because there is someplace outside of us to put the bad.

Of course, this ruse we perpetrate on ourselves only works if we can sustain the delusion of absolute difference. Those who are more consciously racist rely on what Erik Erickson called "pseudo-speciation," viewing other racial groups as separate species. "Inter-breeding" thereby becomes a psychological, as well as a theological abomination.

Speaking of spiritual matters, we should not be too surprised that most openly racist people are religious fundamentalists. This is not just because so many Biblical fairy tales endorse slavery, ethnic warfare and genocide, and inveigh against "race mixing," but because the structure of fundamentalist theology and racism are the same - they both rely on splitting. A recent example of this symmetry is the fundamentalist Christian Bob Jones University, which didn't overturn its ban on interracial dating until 2000. (This was done with considerable reluctance, and primarily to save George W. Bush from political embarrassment after having given a campaign stump speech in their chapel.) Such racist thumpers of holy books literally as well as metaphorically think in black and white terms.

Thus, the very visibility of Barack Obama - let alone his candidacy for the most powerful and, before Bush, the most esteemed job in the world - creates a category crisis of epic proportions. He not only mouths a rhetoric of transcending division, but is himself a seamless genetic integration of what should be immiscible. The decent, God-fearing racist must be plagued by unanswerable questions: What is this incomprehensible hybrid of badness and goodness? How can the same person contain that with which I identify and which I despise? What does that make me?

In the course of the presidential campaign, we have heard Republican ads and seen GOP viral emails that pose more rational-seeming derivatives of these questions: Who is Barack Obama? Do we actually know him? Doesn't he sound kind of uppity and elitist? Is he a Christian or a Muslim? Is he really like us? Didn't he grow up in one of those anti-American parts of America, like Hawaii?

By way of concluding, I want to emphasize that most Americans are not consciously racist, and would abhor the prejudice and ignorance manifested by the good white Christians cited above. But as Drew Westen and other researchers have shown, the majority of people - black as well as white - harbor an unconscious negative bias against anyone perceived as black. At a deep level, most of us make use of racial categories to navigate the world, manage its vague and unseen threats, and define our worth.

And why should we expect otherwise? Every person in this country is embedded in a culture and history founded on racist beliefs, practices, and emotions. There is no place to stand outside this psychological and social reality. It saturates our national sense of self and structures our neural networks.

What is possible, however, is to acknowledge and remain mindful of this ugly and disturbing legacy so that we can minimize its influence on how we treat others, and how we elect leaders to public office. And, as the enthusiastic throngs of citizens, here and abroad, attest, it is even possible to move beyond "tolerance" - to embrace and celebrate the fluidity of categories, cultures, and identities that Obama's candidacy has come to symbolize.

The frank comments of unapologetic anti-Obama racists across the country have recently gained a wide national audience. As Ricky Thompson, a pipe fitter from Mobile, Alabama, told a New York Times rep...
The frank comments of unapologetic anti-Obama racists across the country have recently gained a wide national audience. As Ricky Thompson, a pipe fitter from Mobile, Alabama, told a New York Times rep...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 198
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
08:56 PM on 10/27/2008
41 years ago, the movie "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner" brought this issue to the forefront of American culture. I watched it again today and I am so proud of how far we have come in this country on the road to tolerance & acceptance. There are far fewer bigots than there were, and people can change their hearts and minds. Spencer Tracey said in the film: "There'll be 100 million people right here in this country who will be shocked and offended and appalled and the two of you will just have to ride that out, maybe every day for the rest of your lives. You could try to ignore those people, or you could feel sorry for them and for their prejudice and their bigotry and their blind hatred and stupid fears, but where necessary you'll just have to cling tight to each other and say "screw all those people"! Anybody could make a case, a hell of a good case, against your getting married. The arguments are so obvious that nobody has to make them. But you're two wonderful people who happened to fall in love and happened to have a pigmentation problem, and I think that now, no matter what kind of a case some bastard could make against your getting married, there would be only one thing worse, and that would be if - knowing what you two are and knowing what you two have and knowing what you two feel - you didn't get
06:26 PM on 10/27/2008
Psychoanalyst Philips observed that “We hold ourselves together by keeping things apart.” It should be pointed out that this only goes for the weak minded. Those people who are weak inside their own personality and therefore afraid of anything that is “different”. And although research shows that most people unconsciously hold a negative bias against people perceived as “black” it should be pointed out that only the weak minded actually act on such a bias.

And these weak characters are to be found in any country. The right political system is structured in such a way that these people do not get into a position where they gain enough political influence to make a difference. The sad thing is that Republicans routinely call upon the sentiments of these weak characters to get their numbers right. On the upside, the country is demographically moving into the right direction and no Republican can stop that trend.

To speak with Blue Mink: “What we need is a melting pot” and Barack Obama, his parents and many others, including myself, have contributed actively to this trend. And remember folks, once you’ve made your melting pot contribution no one can take it away from you, not even in the 10th generation.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
veggiequeenmo
Blueneck in a redneck state!
05:17 PM on 10/27/2008
racists make me sick
05:07 PM on 10/27/2008
The GOP has abandoned all code word and are getting straight to the point.

Watch the Crowd Yell the N-Word at a Palin Event
http://newsone.blackplanet.com/nation/crowd-yells-the-n-word-at-palin-rally/
04:28 PM on 10/27/2008
Assassination plot targeting Obama disrupted

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The ATF says it has broken up a plot to assassinate Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama and shoot or decapitate 102 black people in a Tennessee murder spree.

In court records unsealed Monday, agents said they disrupted plans to rob a gun store and target an unnamed by predominantly African-American high school by two neo-Nazi skinheads.

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/S/SKINHEAD_PLOT?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2008-10-27-16-23-21
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
amcg50
04:20 PM on 10/27/2008
The really sick part of this is that the McCain people are encouraging this and pretend that they have no control; they are counting on it!
03:31 PM on 10/27/2008
This is not really about racism per se. It has much more to do with our desire (need) to reduce our reality to an “either or” mentality. Black White. Him Her.
During the feel good fog of the Reagan years we were fed daily doses of the "Evil Empire", the OTHER. We can't live without an " OTHER ". We MUST despise the OTHER. They are evil and WE are GOOD.

When our current president, the Dim Reaper, said on tee wee "Yur eether with us or against us" we all sighed and thought to ourselves, "here's a guy in control. He’ll take care of that evil OTHER".

This all goes to the heart of why the Conservative Masters have waged all out war on intellect, education, science, and all forms of critical thinking. The do not want thinkers in the electorate to think except in the most zombie like assigned group think.

The point is we have to understand our need to see life as an either or proposition. We need to understand our proclivity embrace a hatred of the OTHER and learn to live with it and keep it in check. If we don’t we may find ourselves voluntarily voting and acting against our own best interests.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Meah
03:12 PM on 10/27/2008
i have read the author's thread and the comments. Interesting how there seems to be a short circuit when it comes to the subject matter. People are going every which way except to talk about "miscegenation". As a white wife of an African American man, the love of my life, I can tell you that I am feeling that you are coming to conclusions that are based on rather shallow insights, and it does not really reflect what is happening today politically. Many persons who are older and may not believe in the races mixing because of the way they were brought up, which was not necessarily biblical in origin, are voting for Obama because they can see that he is the most competent and will probably be better for the country. Others are not voting for him because they are Dixiecrats, but are considering a Democratic vote because of what has happened to the country. Others are dyed in the red Republicans who would not be caught dead voting for a Democrat. And there are those who do not want to vote for Obama for the reasons the author states. And on an on. The country is changing. Tiger Woods has shocked the world of white male golfers. And they know he is good. That is how it is. We have found that every person is different, and those you think are bigots may not be, and those you think are not, are.
12:37 PM on 10/27/2008
I wouldn’t assume that those harboring the racist viewpoints are illustrative of those who will vote against Obama. Of course, I could be wrong, and it might be appropriate to find anyone who has said something ridiculous, and suggest that everyone else on their side believes the same thing. But that’s not my way. After all, following the pick of Sarah Palin, for almost a week the MSM interviewed people who stated that Palin, like any woman with children, has no business running for this office - cuz women are the natural child bearers and nurterers don’t you know. I realize that those were just politically inept attacks before a clear attack strategy could be figured out. But, if we are going to suggest that the words of some equate to the words of all, then I will admit those voting against Obama are racist, just like I will also assume those voting against Palin/McCain believe a woman’s place is in the home. After all, it wasn’t just some random person talking about Palin, but key individuals on the sets of the MSM - and that has to mean a whole lot more.
11:54 AM on 10/27/2008
Christian fundamentalists are fringe, they are not even real Christians but if you aren't even a Christian then probably everyone is a fundamentalist?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
anniegirl9
Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tom
11:41 AM on 10/27/2008
Continued…

The world is changing, and so are the neo-cons even if they don’t see it. Sure, they will dig their heels in the ground, kicking and screaming the whole time, but they will be unaware of their own migration. Unfortunately, we will also move consistently left and will still be baffled at the rights inability to look to progress.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
anniegirl9
Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tom
11:41 AM on 10/27/2008
We say people are left of center, right of center or moderate (meaning center). But what we do not recognize is that center is not a set point. Center has, since the very beginning of our country, slowly but consistently moved left. There have been brief points when we may have swayed right slightly, but not for long. We are more liberal than we were 20 years ago, and 20 years from now, we will be even more liberal. That is why the better term for liberal is progressive. Environmentalism and Feminism were openly mocked such a short time ago, but they are now moderate positions, with even the Republican ticket claiming to be for climate protection or even feminism (although one can argue how well they actually represent either). Remember Dan Quail's criticism of Murphy Brown. Now they have a VP nominee with an unwed pregnant teen daughter. That is not a slam on Palin or her daughter; it is an excellent example that the right is moving left.

I say with confidence that in my lifetime I will see constitutional protections for Homosexuals. We will look back on this period in time as a dark mark against our country for withholding civil rights to these individuals, much as most of the country now looks at segregation as a black mark.

Continued...
11:25 AM on 10/27/2008
I've gotta take up for the racists. First of all, you act like they're not voting for Obama. There are quite a few exceptions and we're seeing more every day. I know a woman in Oklahoma who still isn't comfortable with black and white people marrying each other, let alone gay people..... and she's voting for Obama. Now of course, that's not the way she said it. lol She said it in a strange racist-turning-not-racist way.... you know where the N word was said with pride. I know that doesn't sound like it makes any sense, but you should have been there. You would have heard it too. And she's not the only racist I know who's voting for Obama.

You people fail to realize, this is a one issue race and that issue is competence. Competence trumps race, gender, age, religious and sexual preference. We're voting for our jobs, our homes, our retirements and college funding for our kids.... and nothing trumps survival.

Scariest words this halloween "President Palin."

I'm voting a straight democrat ticket for the first time in my life. We've had enough republican gridlock.
12:07 PM on 10/27/2008
Cool! Thank you for sharing this experience.
12:10 PM on 10/27/2008
I wish I could agree with you, but I can't. Understanding the concept of competence requires objective thinking, and rationally examining evidence. Racism is founded on cultural indoctrination and conditioning. It isn't about thinking at all. You may peel off a veneer of racists, but not that many. If your brought up in a racist environment, it's hard to shake the indoctrination.
05:15 PM on 10/27/2008
Well... yes and no. It is hard to rid yourself of all of its evil. But a LOT of people were raised in racist environments but have kept themselves from actively being racist. It is the difference from regular use of the N-word, belief that "White Pride" means they are superior, and therefore all those who are not White are inferior, and those people who believe Black people could achieve just as much as Whites if they only tried harder, got off welfare, put down the basket ball and the 40, and picked up a book.

Neither of those groups is without racism but one is a very active and hateful version and the other is ignorance without malice. Thankfully each generation racism gets scrubbed a little bit more out of our national subconscious.
10:10 AM on 10/27/2008
what you are doing is calling people racist if they are white and don't support obama. that's pathetic.
voting for someone because of their race is just as bad as voting against someone because you don't like their race.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
returnofthejedi
Trolls have no chance!
10:44 AM on 10/27/2008
A serious question please dont take it as an offense or calling you racist. Where did the author of the thread imply that a white person (and i'm assuming you are) not voting for Obama is racist.
Could you honestly tell me where you get that? ( Im black by the way)

So do you also feel the black people that did not vote for Allen Keyes over Obama where they racist? Or did they feel Obama was a better candidate? What about the white people that are voting for Obama are they reverse racist?......................Could you please elaborate.
11:08 AM on 10/27/2008
Dear child,
Is that really what you got out of this story? What kind of glasses do you wear, that would distort your interpretation like this? Read it again. Read it slowly. . It says that some people (some) are against Obama because he comes from an inter racial relationship. It doesn't say nor even imply that anyone who votes for McCain is ra ci st.
Read this again, slowly, and then post exactly where in the article it says that anyone who votes for McCain is a ra cist.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
robotfog
Victim of Technology
10:08 AM on 10/27/2008
What if the haters were not voters or if they weren't haters? What would McCain's crowds look like. Instead of 4,000, they might be 200 people. If many people (not all I hope) are voting out of racism and you removed them from the equation (because in a better world, McCain would have been honorable), then there is nearly nobody who would vote republican. Just people who are scared of socialists. And if those people were rational, you could count the number of real McCain issues voters on one hand.

crazy.
11:32 AM on 10/27/2008
Hate isn't the opposite of love, it's an unhealthy side effect of love. You can love without hating but there's no such thing as hate that doesn't come out of love. The one thing that Obama haters have in common with Palin haters are that each group starts with love of country and seeing the other as a terrible threat to the country we love. I'd quit worrying about racists. They were all going to vote republican when this started no matter what color the democrat candidate was. Now every day more of them are voting for Obama, because their survival is more important than his color.

Relax people, rather than be afraid of racists we need to be afraid of complacency in our own voters. Get out the vote.

Who are you taking with you? Call your friends, make a party out of it. Let's enjoy saving our country and our world.

Obama/Biden '08 & '12

and NOT

President Palin '08 destroying the USA.