iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Steve Harmon

GET UPDATES FROM Steve Harmon
 

Which PC Should You Buy? Check Our Complaint Tally First

Posted: 08/23/2012 11:19 pm

Thinking about buying a PC or computing device? You may want to take a look at the company with the most complaints before forking out your money. Taleee's consensus engine looked at customer complaints from across the web and here's the exclusive scoop for Huffington Post readers:

The worst? DELL. Some 50% of the almost 25,000 complaints we tallied from across the Web are aimed at DELL. Here's the pie chart look of the percent of complaints against many well-known brands:

2012-08-23-complaints.jpg

When investors and the media look at why a company is winning or losing it's going to boil down to customer satisfaction. That's why my company Taleee tallies up customer opinion. Customer experience is king.

Among the top 3 PC/tablet makers Apple scored the best with the fewest complaints, 14% overall. Acer had 7% of complaints, owed in part to its smaller market share.

DELL started so strong. A guy (Michael Dell) in his dorm room making PCs and beating Tandy and IBM at their own game. I am a fan of the entrepreneur Michael Dell. No doubt he's built a great company. In its early days Dell stood out based on its custom configuration and direct ordering model, catalogs. Over the years I've owned every manufacturer's PC, from Apple to Zenith, and many Dell PCs.

Years ago I had a great DELL mini portable with no problems. But my latest two Dell laptops have had issues. One just conked out, couldn't handle video playing without freezing up/overheating. The newest one has problems with its display, the brightness dims and changes by itself no matter what the setting. What's changed? DELL, wherefore art thou?

The two Acers I have both work fine, little netbooks that work well in price/performance. The Apple iPad is fantastic. The HP I have is clunky and laborious with a fan that sounds like it's taken from a jet engine.

_________________________________________


An update in response to certain readers: In compiling the data for this post, I did indeed look at market share. In fact, given market share, the statistics make the insight even stronger. Here's the breakdown of market share. Apple and HP sold the most so you'd think their complaint totals would be higher. But they're not. That speaks to quality and making customers happy. (No PC makers are clients or customers of Taleee. This is pure research and insight for consumer benefit.)

2012-08-24-Screenshot20120824at1.15.57PM.png
Source: Gartner. Except Apple's market share includes tablet sales per Canalys and other research data.


How about you, what have your experiences been with your PC or tablet? Sound off in the comments.

 
FOLLOW TECH
Thinking about buying a PC or computing device? You may want to take a look at the company with the most complaints before forking out your money. Taleee's consensus engine looked at customer complain...
Thinking about buying a PC or computing device? You may want to take a look at the company with the most complaints before forking out your money. Taleee's consensus engine looked at customer complain...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 76
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
07:46 AM on 10/02/2012
I have just replaced my old Acer notebook PC with an HP ProBook. I wish I'd stuck with Acer! The first ProBook had a faulty touchpad. In spite of the fact that I bought it bundled with a 24 hour on-site service pack, it took nearly two weeks to get a replacement. The new PC works fine except for the touchpad being slightly less sensitive than I would have liked. However, three weeks after my original order and after umpteen emails, online chats and phone calls, I have finally got the Premium Care certificate and guess what: it is made out for the defective PC I returned to them three weeks ago and dated with the date of the original purchase. I am in France, but realise from reading all the complaints on the HP Forum that this is not a French service problem but that HP is just as bad for customer service in the US.

My experience with Acer customer service on a PC bought in the UK, but requiring repair under guarantee in France was very good indeed. They were fast, responsive and took responsibility for ensuring all was OK.
08:00 AM on 09/07/2012
So true ,dell xps laptop was worst laptop i have ever seen on earth it worked only 13 months for me! imagine that ,and they wanted me to pay almost a full price of a new one for repair my laptop! I hate dell
10:12 AM on 08/28/2012
Acer parts are the best if you're building a computer these days, and the computers themselves are pretty good. Dell is crap in a box, HP is run of the mill, and I hate Apple and its idealogy, so I can't offer an unbiased opinion. Cannot stand the company or the kind of person and attitudes they present and sell to.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dan Cheshire
Southern California
09:46 PM on 08/27/2012
I agree, Apple is the best but what happened to Toshiba? They used to always rate high in customer complaints. Are they making a better product now? I hope so.
photo
Anonymous Conservative
Cynical atheist.
02:06 PM on 08/27/2012
Apple is the best.
photo
AlButerol
It's all about me
12:19 AM on 08/27/2012
Since you would expect more sales to result in more complaints, I thought a more meaningful statistic would be number of complaints per market share %. Here they are, based on the author's numbers:
Dell: 1,040
HP: 409
Apple: 207
Acer: 157

I think these numbers make a better predictor of whether you will be one of those complainants if you buy a computer from one of the above vendors. Of course, these numbers don't negate any of the author's conclusions. It just makes an honest comparison easier. HP's complaints per share are significantly higher than Apple's and Acer's, but not astronomical like Dell's.

My personal experience with Acer is that my roommate bought an Acer laptop (on my recommendation) which had to be sent back to Acer twice for the same problem. Currently it is sitting in a corner unable to boot up. It makes a nice paperweight. So a low complaint per market share doesn't absolutely guarantee you won't be disappointed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:46 PM on 08/25/2012
I bought my first PC 3 months ago - an Acer laptop - just because it was the cheapest thing they had on sale - over $100 off. I was prepared to hate it, but figured it would be good enough for a starter. So far, though, I've been pleasantly surprised, it does everything I need it to.
11:41 PM on 08/25/2012
Presently using a Toshiba P755. Swapped out the HD for a SSD and replaced the battery for a larger one, more suitable for its i7. Lately, I've owned Sony's and HP. They didn't last; my Sony's are both dead. Some others might be 'cuter', but for reliability, useability and price/performance, my Toshiba's have been my best investments.
11:52 AM on 08/25/2012
- Desktop PC (Windows or Linux): never buy one, build it yourself, and if you can't, tell someone who can what you want to do with your new computer and give them $1000, even if they rip you off for a couple of hundred you'll probably still end up with a better system than you'd have gotten if you went to the store, plus you get warranty per component.

- Desktop Apple: never buy one, period, they're way too expensive for what you get in return. If you like their software then install it on a PC.

- Laptop: never buy an Apple, be very careful when buying a laptop in general, always consult someone who knows their way around computer hardware (and doesn't work for the store that you want to buy it in) first.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:15 PM on 08/25/2012
never buy an apple laptop? did you notice that the macbook pro was the laptop of choice of engineers and scientists at nasa/jet propulsion lab, and was everywhere in the control room during the landing of the mars rover?

if it's good enough for scientists, it should be good enough for the average consumer.
11:21 AM on 08/26/2012
"did you notice that the macbook pro was the laptop of choice of engineers and scientists at nasa/jet propulsion lab, and was everywhere in the control room during the landing of the mars rover?
if it's good enough for scientists, it should be good enough for the average consumer."
It's "good enough", but you can get the same performance for half the price from another brand: they use the exact same hardware.
11:37 AM on 08/25/2012
The number one failure with a PC is capacitor failure.

They are inexpensive components on a motherboard, but are subject to bootleg suppliers or improper chemical compounds being used in them. Back in the 2000's there were a series of fake capacitors that flooded the market. Dell was just one of many companies buying them. Most companies did build a few machines out of them before detecting the problem.

If you open your case, look for the 1/2 inch tall cylinders sticking up off of the mainboard with an X pattern on its silver top. That is there to help relieve pressure in a capacitor that is failing and to help identify failed ones. If they fail, the top will bulge slightly. Also, leakage at the bottom is not good.

Also, NEVER buy a laptop battery off the internet that is NOT from the manufacturer. Boing Boing did a report on all of the fake batteries being sold online that do not have quality or fire protection in them.
09:54 AM on 08/25/2012
Called Dell 10 days ago and took out the extended contract.
I was told if any problems they will send a tech over to repair. I called about the original problem I had and got a call back that a tech would contact me.
Still nothing!
01:56 AM on 08/25/2012
The wife and I have a Dell and an 06 HP. No major problems only minor hiccups that are usually software related. Can't say the same for my Sister-In-Law's 2 Dells, a laptop and a desktop. Major multiple meltdowns on both machines.
11:39 AM on 08/25/2012
PCs made between 2002 - 2009 were subject to supplies of bootleg capacitors. Most companies experienced outages from them and they were such good fakes that they could not be identified, other than flagging the whole part number... including the legitimate ones.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dc8s
The most attractive nuisance you've seen.
11:33 PM on 08/24/2012
Dell is terrible. I has a notebook once. Once. The thing constantly overheated, the hard drive crashed twice and oddball pieces would break off. I vowed never again. I had an Acer/Gateway too. The quality was a little better than Dell, but their service was the lowest of low. Absolutely horrendous. So ... My Toshibas have been fantastic.
09:11 PM on 08/24/2012
Well, I am typing on a Dell XPS 15z, I love it but it has had some issues since I bought it. First I had a fan that would make a buzzing sound when it came on and shut off, I called Dell and despite the negative reviews their customer service gets (I put off calling for the longest time) it was an easy and stress free experience. The guy who came by to fix the computer was awesome and we had a nice techie conversation. The other problem I had was with the SSD and its hibernation mode, the computer would not retain its memory through the hibernation, so I just turned the feature off. Now there are very few issues hardware-wise that I cannot fix myself, so I was not afraid of the risks involved with buying a Dell. I love this computer because its my computer and once I worked my magic it ran flawlessly. I have a Dell Studio XPS 7100 desktop and the only issue that thing has given me is the usb port is getting kind of beat up, but that is my fault.

Point is, if you know computers you don't typically complain to the vendor itself. I am betting the complaints themselves were from tech illiterates to poor to buy a higher quality machine and to computer illiterate to properly take care of their machines. I would love to hear what type of complaints the companies were getting.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Crim
“None but ourselves can free our minds.”
08:46 PM on 08/24/2012
The best bet is to build your own. You will get better quality parts for less money and avoid bloatware.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bertski
just a guy trying not to be part of the problem
12:29 PM on 08/27/2012
Is that really still the case? It seems that a lot of PC's are being sold for less than the sum of their parts, if you have to buy them separately. Once you factor in the operating system, the home-built system might actually cost more. Of course, you're getting exactly the components you prefer, and if you know what you're doing, you can control the build quality well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Crim
“None but ourselves can free our minds.”
04:29 PM on 08/27/2012
Most manufacturers don't use a high end motherboard, power supply, and video card.  They get away with this by putting a good processor, lots of ram and disk space.  In the rare cases that a manufactured PC is actually cheaper, its usually because of the preloaded software that you still have to purchase.