iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Steve Lombardo

Steve Lombardo

Posted: October 12, 2010 04:50 PM

During the last 14 days the White House and President Obama have gone on the attack, and their strategy is pretty simple: "Let's acknowledge the voter anger and make sure it gets funneled toward something else." Thus we have seen political attacks on just about everyone -- and everything -- out there. The problem, though, is that voters aren't angry with Karl Rove, John Boehner, the Chamber of Commerce or even the "undisclosed financing" of elections. Voters are angry about the economy and they have two devastating perceptions of this administration: voters think it is incompetent and that it has overreached over the past two years.

An even bigger problem for the White House is that voters may have already tuned the President out; virtually every possible metric used to evaluate the outcome of the midterm elections suggest a massive GOP victory. So let's just come out and say it: there is no reason to think that Republicans will do any worse than 1994 (when they picked up 54 seats) and there is plenty of data to suggest that it will, in fact, be a better year for the GOP. Our projection -- based on all current available data -- is that the GOP will gain between 60 and 70 House seats in November.

The White House and Democrats want this election to be a "choice," but midterms are rarely ever "choice" elections -- that's what Presidential elections are for. Instead, midterms are a referendum on the President and the party in power. So let's look at the key metrics that we use to evaluate voter perceptions of the President and Congress:

  • President Obama's approval rating is hurting Democrats across the country. According to Real Clear Politics' average of public polls, Obama's approval rating now stands at approximately 45%. Our analysis of national surveys suggests that Obama's approval rating is closer to 42-43% with likely voters. More importantly, the President's approval rating in key swing states that Obama and fellow Democrats won in 2008 is faltering. In Colorado, for example, Obama won 54% of the vote but no recent poll shows his approval rating higher than 45% with likely voters. That is one of the reasons that incumbent Democratic Senator Michael Bennet is in serious trouble. Or take Pennsylvania, where an average of the last five polls has Obama's approval rating at 40%: Republican Pat Toomey leads Democratic Rep. Joe Sestak by six points. The pattern is consistent: almost every state where Obama's approval rating is at or below 45% the GOP candidate is leading by 3-10 points.
  • The GOP lead on the generic Congressional ballot is unprecedented. Republicans now lead on the generic Congressional ballot by seven points (48% to 41%) according to RCP. Our analysis of likely voter surveys taken over the last 30 days has the GOP lead at +9. As we have said before, Republicans rarely--if ever--lead on the GCB. According to Gallup, in 1994 the two parties were tied on the GCB the week before the election. Republicans picked up 54 seats that year.
  • Congressional approval is catastrophically low and Democrats--not Republicans--will pay the price. Congressional approval is at 20% (according to the last Pew Poll). The last WSJ/NBC poll also had it at 20% (with 75% disapproval).
  • In terms of election "engagement," Republicans far outpace Democrats this year. According to last month's Pew study, 79% of Republican candidate supporters say they definitely will vote for their preferred candidate, while only 66 percent of Democratic candidate supporters say the same. Just as importantly, the same poll tells us that 64% of Republicans are "giving a lot of thought" to this election, compared with only 40% of Democrats. This gives the GOP a +24 margin. To give you some perspective, in 1994 the GOP had a +9 lead on this measure (51% to 49%).
  • Anger about the economy and the lack of jobs remains this election's defining element. The LCG Anger Index is increasing as we move closer to election day. The current index stands at 261. It was 246 in May of this year, and in 1994 it was 245.



Election Projections

We are in agreement with several recent analyses suggesting that there are approximately 35-40 house seats that should be rated in the "toss-up" category. To simplify things we will refer to the RCP assessment that has 39 "toss-up" seats. They have identified 185 seats as either likely or lean Democrat and 211 as either likely or lean GOP. In each of the remaining 39 "toss-up" races the Republicans and Democrats have been polling within points of each other--many are within the margin of error. So let's assume that these 39 races split 50/50, giving the GOP a 20-set pick up. That gives the GOP a 53-seat pick up and control of the House. But a more realistic analysis suggests that in this current environment--keeping in mind the above voting metrics and the GOP turnout advantage--the GOP will win approximately 70% of the toss-up seats. That would mean a total pickup of 60 seats. And then let's also assume that Republicans pick up a few of the "lean Democrat" seats. Our sense is that in a true "wave" election the party with the lead, the enthusiasm and the turnout advantage will take 70-80% of the toss-up seats in addition to some of the seats that "lean" toward the other party. Using this formula, at this point in time it is our sense that the GOP will pick up a total of around 65 seats, giving the GOP control of the House (with 242 seats to the Democrats' 185).

The Senate is easier to visualize but, in some respects, more problematic to project. We continue to believe that it will come down to the West Coast, with the races in California (Boxer and Fiorina) and Washington (Murray and Rossi) holding the key to a Republican takeover. We've put Connecticut in the Democrat column and have put the following in the GOP column: KY, MO, NH, PA and WI. The other four true toss-up states are West Virginia, Colorado, Nevada and Illinois, although there are signs that all four are trending GOP at this time. Assuming Republicans win all four of these toss-up states, that leaves the aforementioned two West Coast races. The GOP would have to win one of those "away games" to get to 51 seats in the Senate.

Thanks again to John Zirinsky and Peter Ventimiglia for their insights and contributions. For real-time reactions to events and more thoughts on the public opinion environment, please follow us on Twitter @lcgpolling.

 

Follow Steve Lombardo on Twitter: www.twitter.com/lcgpolling

During the last 14 days the White House and President Obama have gone on the attack, and their strategy is pretty simple: "Let's acknowledge the voter anger and make sure it gets funneled toward somet...
During the last 14 days the White House and President Obama have gone on the attack, and their strategy is pretty simple: "Let's acknowledge the voter anger and make sure it gets funneled toward somet...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 859
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (12 total)
04:35 PM on 10/25/2010
RCP averages now have GOP leaning/likely at +47 seats with an additional 36 seats as tossups. This is another 7 seats that have tilted GOP in the past week. -60 seats for the Dems is beginning to look like a somewhat conservative estimate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spiegelp
04:16 PM on 10/20/2010
The admistration should have swung faster and hit harder. Being "nice" to congress backfired and the oil spill kept the admistration's focus too long. The bail outs worked, Healthcare is on the way for everyone and the economy is improving, albeit slower than some expect. The reparty is too extremem for many republicans, and that will keep many of them from even voting. Who wants to be assosciated with those nutjobs, like Angle, ODonnell, Paul, Cantor and Boener!? What an embarrassment!
06:56 PM on 10/20/2010
Who wants to be associated with these GOP candidates? Far more people than want anything to do with Obama and his agenda. Obama is the reason the Dems will lose about 60 House seats and 8 Senate seats. Losing Ted Kennedy's seat was a strong message, and due to arrogance, the Dems just didn't get it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vere15
Vero nihil verious (nothing truer than truth)
10:38 PM on 10/19/2010
wrong wrong wrong - the voters feel that the administration UNDER reached
06:50 PM on 10/20/2010
Yes, under reach is what the 20% occupying the true left believe. The other 80% believe that he has overreached. What does this leave Obama? Very little more than the 91% approval rating of black voters. If he really wants a 2nd term, he'd better hope that Hillary does not run against him in the primary, and that the GOP also overreaches on a perceived mandate.
10:01 PM on 10/19/2010
RCP averages now have GOP likely/leaning +38 seats. 43 seats are now tossups. This is trending GOP. My over/under remains at 60 seats. Place your bets! :-)
QuietLightTraveler
Scientist, Teacher, Naturalist, Photographer
12:10 PM on 10/18/2010
This is Obama's fault and no one else's. When he was elected he was in the drivers seat. He had a majority in both houses and the wind in his sails. But as a leader he was too cautious, not bold enough, succumbed to a delusion of working with the Republicans, sucked up to the corporate types and failed to hear the voice of his progressive base. He was a man mired in half measures so as to try and please everyone, and thereby pleased no one. Hey, the man was told the error of his ways enough times but ignored it. You can lead a fool to water but you can't make him drink. We need a progressive with some testosterone behind his democratic principles, not some soft spoken Harvard dandy who wastes his time trying to prove to Republicans that he is not a tax and spend liberal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
h23154
12:09 PM on 10/20/2010
Baloney. It's Reid's fault, if anyone's with Pelosi a close second. Reid's chamber is where bills went to die and he was rolling over like an over exuberant terrier for the GOP. McConnell owned him. Negotiating with Grassley over health care? Pelosi's problem is that she forgot the whole country is not San Francisco. It's nice to be ideologically pure and may make one feel good, but if you want to hold on to power you have to realize that the base is only about 35% of the electorate and if you lose independents you are a minority. Politicians are a lot like generals. The are always fighting the last war. The cycle will continue, The Dems lose now, then they win. Trouble is the GOP knows how to do trench warfare better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dave Harpe
Was young, now old.
01:28 AM on 10/18/2010
During the last 2 years we did not get far enough away from Republican "supply side" economics, because the Democrats have less power than their numbers. Too many of them voted with the Republicans. Too many of them helped to stall any of the real changes that need to be made. So now the public will be angry at all Democrats and vote back in the people who caused the problem in the first place? Smart! If this happens, the United States is doomed. It would be like throwing gasoline on a burning house.
04:10 PM on 10/15/2010
So lets see....We have a Republican Strategist go onto Huffingtonpost to talk up doom and gloom. I would think if this was really true the last thing you would want to do is broadcast this to the opposition.

Trying some psych-ops to demoralize the liberal base. Unfortunately for this tool, will probably have the opposite effect. How many people with have a brain would want Michelle Bachman or Steven King heading any congressional committee.
03:48 PM on 10/16/2010
RCP averages have GOP at +39 seats with an additional 40 seats as tossups. Do the math. -60 is not a doom and gloom projection. It's a middle of the road projection.
03:54 PM on 10/16/2010
Correction, should be +37 seats.
Dogmudgeon
Saepe in Errore, Nunquam in Dubito
03:50 PM on 10/15/2010
Sorry, I'm just too hip to be bothered to vote. Besides, the two parties are the same. If I voted, my almost-equally-hip friends might think I was selling out.

Yes, I *AM* a white guy. Why do you ask?
02:59 PM on 10/15/2010
Let's not stop at 60-70 let's get rid of everyone and start over repub and dem. No tea party or green party. Let's go get people who have no desire to be in politics and elect them. School teachers, nurses, dock workers, truckers. I mean real American people. How can they do worse? Now let the elitists roar.
11:45 AM on 10/18/2010
well if someone needed surgery, I would doubt they would vote for the least experienced surgeon. All the republicans have done is reinvented themselves after they got clobbered in the last election. You can fool some of the people some of the time, but I will wait till after election day. Americans are not as stupid as people think.
QuietLightTraveler
Scientist, Teacher, Naturalist, Photographer
12:14 PM on 10/18/2010
There are a lot of people in those red states that are in fact pretty dumb.
Mark from atlanta
Unity through Diversity.
02:57 PM on 10/15/2010
There are factors involved in social events that go beyond scientific polling.

All sustainable mass movements have several characteristics in common:

1. Grassroots origin (not astroturf).

2. No ideological contradictions (sorry, teabaggers).

3. Not based on hatred and cynicism (again - sorry teabaggers).

The current reactionary wave is not sustainable. The only question is whether it will fizzle before this election or the next.

In the meantime: Vote, volunteer, organize and don't give in to pundant provided pessimism.
02:34 PM on 10/15/2010
that's what the Democrats deserve after:
1) Selling out to health insurance companies
2) selling out to Wall Street
3) selling out to the military-industrial complex

Why would any liberal continue to vote for those clowns if they're not going to do their job?
02:02 PM on 10/19/2010
And you think the Repubs will be better? The reason most of the things you mention were done was to appease the corporatist Republicans to get enough votes to break their fillibuster.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
12:46 PM on 10/15/2010
Voters are angry about the economy and they have two devastating perceptions of this administration: voters think it is incompetent and that it has overreached over the past two years.

Well the D party did it self, they announce a "great reform for the people" then let R's and money define and write laws for same. Sorry D's but you sold out, and are simply incompetent to defend what you did, as some good came out of tiny bit. When D's ran from Obama, they proved to public they have not loyalty, had a R done that to Bush, the R party would have dropped them on spot.

D's were warned when they lost MA seat, but blissfully went on with half way measures. That is the truths they do not want to admit, Nadar was right, D';s taking same money as R's is end of the D party", now the proof is something no D wants to admit, from WH on down. This is final end of the Mid Class unless something really changes, the "40 year plan" is about to be culminated, RIP USA
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:41 PM on 10/15/2010
This dire predictions are not reflective of recent polls. The authors mention West Virginia "trending" Republican. Yet there are polls out today showing Manchin moving into a double-digit lead. Finegold is in a virtual tie now in WI.
04:08 PM on 10/15/2010
Lib Hope vs Reality . . . usually fun to watch. Feingold has not led in a poll since July. He's down by an average of 7.3%. Goodbye, Russ!

+60 seats for the GOP is a reasonable estimate. RCP averages have GOP leaning/likely +37 seats. They have 39 seats as tossups, and 38 of those seats are currently held by Dems. If the GOP takes 54% of the tossups, it's 60 seat gain for the GOP.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MrUniteUs
12:36 PM on 10/15/2010
Republicans have no history of fiscal responsibility
Reagan, Bush I, and Bush II, all ran up the deficit. Bush II inherited a 236 million dollar surplus,
and turned it into a 1.4 trillion dollar deficit.

Dick Cheney said,
Deficits Reagan proved deficits don't matter.

President Obama inherited, an economy losing with American losing 700,000 jobs and their
health care a month, a free falling stock market (now up over 70%), and the largest deficit in history
the budget shrank this by $125 billion.

Free you mind from the right wing matrix.
Visit the Professional Left Network on Facebook.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
12:48 PM on 10/15/2010
Good try but the facts and reality pretty much prove there is but one party left in USA, the $$$$ party.
12:34 PM on 10/15/2010
i do all of my comments pending i`ve been part of huff post since 2006?